High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/2547/2013dismissed

Kavita Devi v. Managat Ram And ORS

2015-07-23Mr. Justice S.C. Datta4 pages

!"# #$%&% '( ) )

) !"# #$%&% '( ) )

) *!+%"!#+% *!+%"!#+% *!+%"!#+% *!+%"!#+% )))#"%"% '#,) )))#"%"% '#,) )))#"%"% '#,) )))#"%"% '#,) -#,&.& -#,&.& -#,&.& -#,&.& /"!"# !,0!'!!'1 "2#,& /"!"# !,0!'!!'1 "2#,& /"!"# !,0!'!!'1 "2#,& /"!"# !,0!'!!'1 "2#,& )))#&3 '1#'"&) )))#&3 '1#'"&) )))#&3 '1#'"&) )))#&3 '1#'"&) (45)// (45)// (45)// (45)//

62#"2#,#3 ,"#,& "2#7 $!73!3#,&8!09#!77 :#1" &##"2#;.1<8#'"=) 9#,# #,,#1" "2##3 ,"#,& ,' "=)

62#"2#,"2#;.1<8#'"&2 .719#,#3 ,"#1%'"2#%<#&"= ,#&#'"( ,)2!'1#,2!& !1!+>1+ $!"# ,"2#3#"%"% '#,) ???

!,!8;##"/%'<2>) !,!8;##"/%'<2>) !,!8;##"/%'<2>) !,!8;##"/%'<2>) 2!77#'<#%'"2#3,#&#'"$,%8%'!7,#+%&% '%&" ;.1<8#'" 1!"#1 )

)

3!&&#1907#!,'#111%"% '!7/#&&% '&.1<#>2!;;!, :2#,#90;.1<8#'"1!"#1@)

3!&&#190"2#7#!,'#1.1%$%!7 !<%&",!"#&"7!&&>2!;;!,2!&9##'.32#71!'1!$$.&#1,#&3 '1#'"& 2!+#9##'!$B.%""#1 "2#$2!,<#&7#+#77#1!<!%'&""2#8) '9,%# >"2# !$"&,#7#+!'" ,1%&3 &!7 %'&"!'",#+%&% '

!,#" "2##

#$""2!""2#%'&"!'"$!&#:!&,#<%&"#,#1 '!:,%""#' $ 837!%'"C)6 D $ 837!%'!'"*!+%"!#+%7#+#77%'<!77#<!"% '& !<!%'&"!77"2# !8%708#89#,& 2#,%'7!:& ,1#8!'1 1 :,0 !,"%$7#& !'1 , $ 88%""%'< $,.#7"0) " :!& !7& !77#<#1 %' "2# $ 837!%'""2!""2#02!18!1#!1#8!'1 1 :,0>3 .,#1E#, &#'# %7 +#,2#,!'1&.11#'702#,9, "2#,>'!8#70>#;!8!7 '<:%"28#1 /%'<2#2!7:!'$!8#" 2#, !'1&2#:#'"!:!0:%"2"2#8" 2#, 3!,#'"!7 2 .&# !" +%77!<# #21.:!& '

) )

) 2#,#!

"#, '

)

"2# 8!""#, :!& $ 83, 8%&#1 9# ,# "2# #3."0

/.3#,%'"#'1#'" 7%$#!'1&2#$!8#9!$E" 2#,%'7!:&2 .&# '

A) )

)<!%'&2#:!&9#!"#'.3!'1"2, :' ." 2#,%'7!:& 2 .&#:%"2!1%,#$"% '" 9,%'<8 '#03#,"!%'%'<" 2#,&2!,#%'"2# !<,%$.7".,!77!'1 2#,3!,#'"&) '"2# 9!&%& 2#,&"!"#8#'"> )A1!"#1@) )

:!& ,#<%&"#,#1) '+#&"%<!"% ':!&&#"%'" 8 "% ')2#!$$.&#1:#,#!,,#&"#1) "#,$ 837#"% ' %'+#&"%<!"% '> $2!77!'!<!%'&""2#!$$.&#13#,& '&:!&3,#&#'"#19# ,#"2# .,") ' &.33 ," %"& $!&#> "2# 3, &#$."% ' #C!8%'#1 $ 837!%'!'"*!+%"!#+%!&6 >!82!7!&6>!7#7/%'<2 #"1) '&3) !&6 >#;!8!&6!'1!,!8/!, 3!&6)2#,#! "#,> 3, &#$."% '$7 &#1%"&#+%1#'$#) /"!"#8#'"& !$$.&#1 .'1#, /#$"% '

,))) :#,# ,#$ ,1#1) 77 "2# %'$,%8%'!"%'< #+%1#'$# !33#!,%'< !<!%'&" "2# !$$.&#1:!&3."" "2#8) 2#01#'%#1"2#&!8#!'137#!1#1 !7&# %837%$!"% ') :#+#,>"2#!$$.&#11%1' "7#!1!'0#+%1#'$#%'"2#%, 1# #'$#) 2#",%!7 .,">+%1#;.1<8#'"1!"#1@)

%'1%'<'

3,%8! !$%#$!&#!<!%'&""2#!$$.&#13#,& '&>!$B.%""#1"2#8 , 8"2# $2!,<#&7#+#77#1!<!%'&""2#8)<!%'&""2!">$ 837!%'!'"*!+%"!#+% 3,# #,,#1!33#!79# ,#11%"% '!7/#&&% '&.1<#>2!;;!,>:2 !7& .32#71"2#;.1<8#'" !$B.%""!7)#'$#>"2%&$,%8%'!7,#+%&% ') 2!+#2#!,17#!,'#1$ .'&#7 ,"2#3#"%"% '#,!'13#,.&#1 "2#,#$ ,1) 5#!,'#1$ .'&#7 ,"2#3#"%"% '#,+#2#8#'"70$ '"#'1#1 "2!" "2# ",%!7 .," 2!& :, '<70 !$B.%""#1 "2# !$$.&#1 3#,& '&) .,"2#, $ '"#'1#1 "2!" 9 "2 "2# .,"& 9#7 : 2!+# &2 :' 3!"#'" %77#<!7%"0%' !$B.%""%'< "2# !$$.&#1 3#,& '& :%"2 ." $ '&%1#,%'< "2# 7#<!7!&3#$" "2#$!&#!&:#77!&#+%1#'$# ',#$ ,12!&' "9##'

$ '&%1#,#1>7#<!7%'

#,#'$#:2%$2&2 .712!+#9##'1,!:'2!&9##'

7# " ."!'1&.33 ,"%'<#+%1#'$#2!&9##'7# " ." $ '&%1#,!"% ') 2#!$B.%""!7 "2#!$$.&#1909 "2"2# .,"&9#7 :%&!,#&.7"

8%&,#!1%'<!'18%&%'"#,3,#"!"% ' "2##+%1#'$#) 2#,# ,#>"2# ;.1<8#'" 1!"#1 )

)

3!&&#1 90 7#!,'#1 11%"% '!7 /#&&% '& .1<#> 2!;;!, !'1 ;.1<8#'" 1!"#1 @)

3!&&#1 90 7#!,'#1 .1%$%!7!<%&",!"#&"7!&&>2!;;!,!,#7%!97#" 9#&#"!&%1#!&"2# &!8#!,##,, '# .&%'7!:!&:#77!&!<!%'&""2##+%1#'$# ',#$ ,1) 2!+#$ '&%1#,#1"2#$ '"#'"% '& 7#!,'#1$ .'&#7 , "2#3#"%"% '#,!'13#,.&#1"2#,#$ ,1) 2#,%!7 .,"!&:#77!&"2#7#!,'#133#77!"# .,"2!& $ '&%1#,#1"2##+%1#'$# ',#$ ,17#190"2#3, &#$."% ') "2"2# .,"&2!+#,#$ ,1#1! %'1%'<"2!""2#$ 837!%'"%&!$ .'"#,97!&"" !3#"%"% ' ,1%+ ,$# %7#1 ' F) )

)"2!&!7& $ 8# ',#$ ,1 "2!" !& 3#, "2# +#,&% ' "2# $ 837!%'!'" %' 2#, $ 837!%'"> "2# 1#8!'1 1 :,0:!&,!%&#1902#,%'7!:&%'"2#3,#&#'$# 2#,

!"2#,> "2#, ,#7!"%+#& %'$7.1%'< /8") %,8!7! #+%> 8#89#,

.'%$%3!7 .'$%7> !' %'1#3#'1#'" :%"'#&&#& !'1 !,+#&2 !'<,!> !' "2#,:%"'#&&$%"#19."9 "2"2#&#:%"'#&&#&:#,#' "#C!8%'#1" $ ,, 9 ,!"#"2%& !$") "2"2# .,"&9#7 :,#$ ,1#1!$ '$.,,#'"

%'1%'<"2!""2#$ 837!%'"%& !7&#!'1 ,%+ 7 .&!'1 "2#3, &#$."% '

2!& !%7#1" #&"!97%&2%"&$!&#!<!%'&""2#!$$.&#13#,& '&9#0 '1!'0 ,#!& '!97#1 .9") ,# +#,> !8 !

,!%1> :2%7# #C#,$%&%'< 80 ,#+%&% '!7 ;.,%&1%$"% '>$!'' ",#!33,#$%!"#"2##+%1#'$#) 2%&%&' "!$!&# :2#,# !' %83 ,"!'" 3%#$# #+%1#'$# 2!& 9##' 7# " ." , 8 $ '&%1#,!"% '90"2# .,"&9#7 ::2%7#1#$%1%'<"2#$!&#) "%&:#77&#""7#1"2!"#+#'% ": +%#:&!,#3 &&%97# '"2#

!33,#$%!"% ' #+%1#'$#!+!%7!97# ',#$ ,1>"2#+%#:"!E#'90"2# 7 :#,33#77!"# .,":2%7#!$B.%""%'<"2#!$$.&#18.&"3,#+!%7!'1 "2%& .,"&2 .71' "&.9&"%"."#%"& :'+%#: ,"2#+%#:"!E#'90"2# 7 :#, .,") ,"2#,#!& '&&"!"#1!9 +#!'1 %'1%'<' $ 83#77%'< !'1&.9&"!'"%!7<, .'1" %'"#, #,#%' %'1%'<& !$B.%""!7,#$ ,1#190 "2# .,"&9#7 :>"2%&3#"%"% '9#$ 8#&1#+ %1 !'08#,%"!'1%& 1%&8%&&#1%'7%8%'#) .70 >

) .70 >

)

/ E!'$2!'