High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2952/2005disposed of

Brijesh Kumar v. Jagbir And ORS.

2018-07-09Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal11 pages

!"#$%&'( ))"**(+, -"#&# (./ 0%(*((+1,$"# "#)+1"+,# 23 (, +(*+#&(+4"5,1$1 ))"**(+, -"#&# !"#$%&'((+1,$"# "#)+1"+,#

!"#$ "$%

"#"+,6 5&*(, 7184(," ("#$%(&#$ 97184(," ,$"())"**(+, + (+1 "#)+1"+, + 23

%()7184(," ,$"())"**(+, + 23(+1 "#)+1"+,: + ;;; <= - 1",$ #4''+1"7 , ,*"1 !"#$%&'(-#(./ 0%(*((+1,$"#(+1 23 , ,*"1 (, +(* +#&(+4" 5,1 $1 -# !"#$ %&'( (+1,$"#("/" +.1"4 1"1,$,$"())"(*#$(8"( #"+' +"(44 1"+,7,$"""74''+(4,#("/" +.+, 4"1

$(#/""+)"""1/>4*( '(+,? !"#$%&'("+$(+4"'"+,4')"+#(, +(@(1"1/>,$"

,44 1"+,*( '# /&+(*7 +1#$,A,$" /&+(*B 8 1" !&1.'"+,1(,"1:7@$""(# 23$(# /""+ )"""1 /> ,$" +#&(+4"')(+> #""9 +. "C+"(, + ' ,$" * (/ * ,> , )(> 4')"+#(, + + ,$" .&+1 ++? )1&4, + 1 8 +. * 4"+4" "#)+1"+, D1 8"7 1"#) ," #)"4 4 ())* 4(, + '8"1 /> +#&(+4" ')(+> /"" ,$" /&+(* <:= $" (44 1"+, + E&"#, + ,9 )*(4" + 7 @$"+4*( '(+,(*+.@ ,$$ #/,$"(*(!$(1.+",F( 1+

(+1 , (,,"+1'( (." +" &9"#$7 @$ # /,$"$ # # #,"B# $&#/(+1 , (/&, 6:

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

(+1 $(1 +4&"1 '" ,$(+ #77D? ,@(1# ,"(,'"+, $" 8"$ 4*" @(# +#&"1 @ ,$ "#)+1"+, :D+#&(+4" ')(+> <3= 8"7 @+" (+1 +#&(+4" ')(+> "# #,"1 ,$" 4*( ',$"4*( '(+,+#&(+4"')(+>1 #)&,"1 ,#* (/ * ,>, )(> ,$" 4')"+#(, + + ,$" .&+1 ,$(, 1 8" ,$" & @$""*" "+1 +. 8"$ 4*"

@(# +, $(8 +. (+> 8(* 1 1 8 +. * 4"+4" <=

+1" ##&"7,$" /&+(*$"*1,$(,,$"(44 1"+, +E&"#, +,9)*(4"1&",(#$(+1+".* ."+,1 8 +.1 8" ,$"&@$""*""+1 +.8"$ 4*"

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

D# (++(1"#7("*( (+1 (+1@(#1(@ +. #ID?)"

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

$,$" ,"(,'"+,)8 1"1 +F( 1+(+1 F $,(9@(#""7 /&,,$"'"1 4 +"#$(1,/")&4$(#"1',$"'(9",(#@"** <I= $" /&+(*(,"(##"## +.,$""C)"+#"# +4&"1/> ,$"4*( '(+,(@(1"1(#&' #7D?@ ,$ +,""#,(#,$"" @(# + '(," (* "8 1"+4" ".(1 +. $ # 4+ +"'"+, , /"1 ID2 '+,$# (+1 @(+, ) ".(1 +. $ # )"'(+"+, 1 #(/ * ,> <2= $"())"(* *"1/> !"#$%&'( #"+$(+4"'"+, ("#( 1 4')"+#(, +7 @$""(# + ,$" ())"(* *"1 /> ,$" +#&(+4"')(+>7,$". "8(+4",$"+#&(+4"')(+> # ,$(,,$"1 8 +.* 4"+4"1 8",$""+1 +.

')(+>/"",$" /&+(*1 "4, +."#)+1"+,#(+1 "1 8"(+1@+",$""+1 +.8"$ 4*",#&))*>4)> ". #,(, +4", 4(,"(+11 8 +.* 4"+4""#)+1"+,+ 8 "@ ("#( 17 *"(+"1 4&+#"* ,$" +#&(+4" ')(+> 4*( '"1,$(,+#&(+4"')(+> #"+, ,*"1,,(9"1""+4",$(, "+1 +. 8"$ 4*" @(# /" +. 1 8"+ /> &+(&,$ J"1 )"#+ $(8 +. + 8(* 1 1 8 +. * 4"+4" $" /&+(* $(# (#,"+"1 ,$" +&# + ,$" +#&(+4" ')(+> +*> + ,$" .&+1 ,$(, ,$" @+"$(#,"#, "1,$(,,$"1 8"@(#"')*>"1/>$ '+*>(," #"" +.,$" 8 +.5 4"+4"(+14+1&4, +.( 8 +."#,F +4" + 8 +.5 4"+4"@(#)1&4"1/>,$"1 8"(+1@+",$" "+1 +.8"$ 4*"7,$"""7,$"+&##$ ,"1&)+,$"+#&(+4" ')(+>4&*1+,/"1 #4$(."

1(+1+#&(+4"')(+>@(# @"**@ ,$ + ,# .$,,4*( ',$(,,$"8"$ 4*"@(#+,/" +.1 8"+ />(&,$ J"1)"#+ @+"(+11 8",$""+1 +.8"$ 4*" 1 1 +, )1&4" ,$" 1 8 +. * 4"+4"7 1"#) ," #)"4 4 ())* 4(, + '8"1/>+#&(+4"')(+>7,$"""7 ,4&*1+,/"#( 1,$(, ,$"",#'(1"/>,$"+#&(+4"')(+>/>'8 +.(#)"4 4 ())* 4(, + )1&4, + 14&'"+,# @(# +, "+&.$ F +4" ,$"1 8 +.* 4"+4"1 8",$""+1 +.8"$ 4*"$(#+,4'" ,$7 ,$"""7 , @&*1 /" ')&1"+, , "C)"4, ,$" +#&(+4" ')(+> , *"(1 &,$" "8 1"+4" , #$@ ,$(, 1 8" ,$" "+1 +. 8"$ 4*" @(# +, $(8 +. 8(* 1 1 8 +. * 4"+4" + #&4$ "8"+,&(* ,>7 ,$" +#&(+4" ')(+> $(# , /" ,(9"+ , $(8" 1 #4$(."1 ,#/&1"+)8 +.

<= $(8"$"(1*"(+"14&+#"*,$")(, "# <= *( '(+, !"#$ %&'( $(# ())"("1 (# G (+1 #,(,"1+/(1(#)"4,,$"4(#"%F& $(#())"("1 (# G : (+1 ,"#, "1 ,$(, $" @(# )#,"1 + F( 1+ + " $(1 4+1&4,"1 '"1 4 *".(* "C(' +(, + +!&"1 !"#$%&'(@$$(1 +!& "#+$ #)"#++!& "# ,H@""9"),&+1"/#"8(, +7@$ *""'( + +. +!& "# @"" 1"4*("1 , /" # ')*" # C :2DC $" )(, "+, @(# """1, F7 $,(9+,$"#('"1(> "$" +!&"1 @(# 1 #4$(."1 + :: ' F7 $,(9 $""(,"7,$" +!&"1,9,"(,'"+,'($#) ,(*(,F+")(, C # ,$" / **7 $@"8"7 4)> K?

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

$,4*(8 4*"(+>,$")(,,$"/1>, #,&",$(, )(4, 4(**> ,$" +!

'"1 4 +" )&4$(#"1 1& +. 4&"+4> ,"(,'"+, (# #'" &+"#""+ '"1 4(* "C)"+#"# (" /&+1 , /" +4&"1 + "'"."+4> <= $""@"",,(* +!& "##&""1/>,$"4*( '(+,(# )" C :2DC +!& "# , H @"" 9"), &+1" /#"8(, + (+1 4*( '(+, @(# """1 , F7 $,(9 + ,#"* 8 1"+,*>7 ,$" 4*( '(+, @(# 1 #4$(."1 '

F7 $,(9 + :: $" ("#( 1 # ,&(, + ,#"* # #&.."#, 8",$"(4,,$(,,$"4*( '(+,"'( +"1$#) ,(* J"1 (,*"(#,21(>#8"+,$&.$7,$","(,'"+,# +F( 1+(+1

F $,(9@""""7/&,,$"'"1 4 +"#$(1,/")&4$(#"1 ' ,$" '(9", (# @"**7 ,$"""7 4+#* 1(,"1 ('&+,

#7D?(#4')"+#(, +,@(1#'"1 4 +"#7$#) ,(* J(, +7 ,(+#),(, +7#)"4 (*1 ",7)( +(+1#&" +.(+1*## +4'" @&*1/",,(**>+*@"# 1" <= + 8 "@ $#) ,(* J(, + ,$" 4*( '(+,7 + '> 4+# 1""1 ) + +7 '"1 4(* / **# , ,$" ,&+" #:3 4(++,/"4+#,&"1,/"(+"C(4,('&+,#)"+,/>,$"4*( '(+, (# ,$"" @"" #'" &+"#""+ "C)"+#"# @$ 4$ $(1 , /" +4&"1/>,$"(,,"+1(+,#,$")(, "+,D +!&"1 +#&4$,>)" "'"."+4>, #(*#,&",$(,#'", '"#/ **# "C# , I 4(++*>/" ##&"1 +,$"'(++"(#)!"4,"1+"41F'" .&"##@9$(#,/"())* "1@$ *"(##"## +.,&"4')"+#(, + ,$" +!&"14*( '(+,

<:= +'>4+# 1""1) + +7,$"(@(1 #7D? (**,$"("#( 1$"(1#+""1#,/"1&/*"1+,$ #@(>7(@(1

#7D? @&*1 #& 4" , '"", ,$" $"(1 +.# '"1 4 +"#7 $#) ,(* J(, +7 ,(+#),(, +7 #)"4 (* 1 ",7 )( + (+1 #&" +.# (+1*## +4'" <3= $" "+$(+4"1 ('&+, 4')"+#(, + "

#7D?#$(**4(> +,""#,0IL',$"1(," * +. ,$"4*( ')", , +, ** +(*"(* J(, +,$"('&+, <= G ,$,$"("#( 1'1 4(, +7 #,(+1#1 #)#"1 <H=

23 $(# /""+ )"""1 /> ,$" +#&(+4"')(+>+#&(+4"')(+>$(1#)"4 4(**>'8"1 (+ ())* 4(, + 1(,"1 2I: /"" ,$" /&+(*7 1 "4, +. "#)+1"+,# (+1 " 1 8" (+1 @+" ,$" "+1 +. 8"$ 4*",#&))*>4)> (+11 8 +.* 4"+4"1 8",$" "+1 +.8"$ 4*"7/&,1"#) ,",$"#( 1())* 4(, +7+14&'"+,# @""/&.$,+"41/>,$"1 8"(+1@+",$""+1 +. 8"$ 4*" <I= ,+") +,, '"71 8"(+1@+",$""+1 +. 8"$ 4*"@"")4""1"1(.( +#,7$@"8"7*(,"+7 )4""1 +.# E&( @+" ,$" "+1 +. 8"$ 4*" @"" #", (# 1"8 1"1"1(,"1 8",$""+1 +.8"$ 4*" "'( +"1(/#"+,',$")4""1 +.#/"",$" /&+(*

<2= $" /&+(*(#,"+"1* (/ * ,>,)(>4')"+#(, ++ ,$"+#&(+4"')(+>#*"*>+,$".&+1,$(,@+",$" "+1 +. 8"$ 4*" @(# "C(' +"1 (# G (+1 $" $(1 ,"#, "1 ,$(,$"$(1"')*>"1(./ 0%(*((#1 8"$ #&@$""*" (,"4$"49 +.$ #1 8 +.* 4"+4"(+1,(9 +.$ #1 8 +.,"#,-"1

(* @+"

'(1" , 4*"( ,$(, (./ 0 %(*($(1@9"1 (#( 1 8" $ # 8"$ 4*" (/&, ,@ '+,$# + $ # 4## "C(' +(, +7@+"$(1,"#, "1,$(,(./ 0%(*($(1(1 8 +. * 4"+4" ##&"1/>5 4"+# +.&,$ ,>7 #, 4,F+")(,(+1@(# (+ " 4 "+, 1 8" + ,$" /(# # (, *( 1 1@+

!!"

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

./ ) *+0 12& 34(+14+,"+1"1,$(,+4"

/&1"+)@(# +,$" +#&(+4" ')(+> (+1+#&(+4" ')(+>1 #)&,"1 ,#* (/ * ,>+,$".&+1,$(,@+"(+11 8" ,$" "+1 +. 8"$ 4*" $(1 ( *"1 , )1&4" 1 8 +. * 4"+4" 1"#) ,"(#)"4 4())* 4(, +'8"1/>,$"+#&(+4"')(+> /"",$" /&+(* ##&(+4"1 "4, +#,1 8"(+1@+" ,$""+1 +.8"$ 4*",#&))*>4)>". #,(, +4", 4(," (+1 1 8 +. * 4"+4" ,$" 1 8"7 ,$"+7 + ,$" "8"+, ++? )1&4, + #&4$ 14&'"+,# /> ,$" 1 8" (+1 @+" ,$" "+1 +. 8"$ 4*"7 +#&(+4" ')(+> 4(++, /" )"#&'"1 , $(8" +, 1 #4$(."1 ,# /&1"+ )8 +. /"(4$ )* 4> 4+1 , +#$&.$,$"+#&(+4"')(+> #* (/*",#(, #>,$" (@(17/&,@ ,$( .$,,"48",$"#('"',$"@+"(+1 1 8",$""+1 +.

8"$ 4*" <= 5"(+"1 4&+#"* &,$" #&/' ,,"1 ,$(, ,$" "+1 +. 8"$ 4*" @(# /" +. 1 8"+ /> (+ &+(&,$ J"1 )"#+ $(8 +. + 8(* 1 1 8 +. * 4"+4" + , (**>7 ,$" +&# @(# #$ ,"1 + ,$" +#&(+4" ')(+> (# ,$" @+" ,$" "+1 +. 8"$ 4*" $(1 ,"#, "1 ,$(, ,$" 1 8" @(# "')*>"1 (," #"" +. $ # 1 8 +. * 4"+4"(+1,(9 +.$ #1 8 +.,"#,7/&,+4",$"14&'"+,#@"" +,)1&4"11"#) ,"#)"4 4())* 4(, +'8"1/>,$"+#&(+4" ')(+>7,$"+/>'""*>)1&4 +.8(* 1 +#&(+4"4", 4(," + "#)"4,"+1 +.8"$ 4*"@(#+,"+&.$,'(9"+#&(+4" ')(+> * (/*" , 1 #4$(." * (/ * ,> ( # +. ' (#$ (+1 +".* ."+,1 8 +.1 8",$""+1 +.

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

@ ,$ +,""#,7,$""" ,$" +#&(+4" ')(+> #$(** '(9" )(>'"+, "+$(+4"1 ('&+,(*+.@ ,$ +,""#,(+1,$"+"48",$"#('"'1 8" (+1@+",$""+1 +.

+4" !% G$",$" "(#+"1DF)"(9 +. "#D G$",$" "),(/*" "#D