← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/2645/2013disposed of

Ranjit Singh @ Rana v. State Of Punjab

2017-11-28Mr. Justice Arun Palli40 pages

  

 !"#"$" %""& ""$ "  

$'

$ ( )*+ ,'-./0    '' -''

 2,3  

5 '

 "6)    7#86 !

-"6 8 ""-  

     

      

         

"6 8 ""- &! !"

    $    

 &  '

( )   *+ *, -*./ 

 

   

0 '



 

 1  .2 *3 -*./

  4

 1 

 

 

-









  

  

  





"

" 

 



 -/ *- -*.-

 





 

  

 

.6 "   7 */ *3 -*.-   

   1

 

0 '



 

 1 



 

.6 "    

     '

  *2 *3 -*.-   8

  

  



.6 " 

/ 8 

  

  .,/ %  % 

"

  

 

.6 "  

   

  3:* -*.

.-*;!

8%

5   



 

0 '



 /. *, -*.-  

 2 <  



 = 

 -+ .- .662

    



  1   .6 *- -*.-

     ., " 



  "



<





8   "



> "

 

0'



 





 '

 '

  ) 

 ?





 0'

4"

4

 

 "















.6 " 





     1

8   2 <

 



"

     

"

  ) 

 

 

  

 "

 2 < 

=

1

 4

  "

   @

 

"

  A >



B  0'  @

  

   



 



   "





  

   "

 "     

A %> "

     C 

  .2 *3 -*./

 ;

 

  



&#

  4(



  

 2 <  

, .* 6:

&

1 

.2 " 



       .6 *- -*.-( :

 

  

   '

  

  *+ *, -*./ 

   "

 

 

.6 " 



   -/ *- -*.-

 

   *2 *3 -*.-

0' */ *3 -*.-      1

, 





  & (



 "







    */ *, -*.-     .+ " 

    

"

 "

     )



  

 

 



 "

 

 

"

 > "

 

0' 

  > "



%> "

   

  + ! 



  

"

2 <  *, *6 -**,



 = 

<

< ;3  4



-+ .- .662

"

 <  .2 " -*.*

<

< ;2



)  & "



) (

  "

 !1 0

!

?

1

<

< ;:  

  -+ .- .662

  





 2/6

 

  "

 !

 "

) D) 

   ! 

<

< ;,



   /--

  



> " 

 -. *. -*.3 

;

 ! @

 A    2/6

  "

 !  

  

 

 

 %#  ,6/6 -*.3 1          

"

  

  

"





-+ .- .662

< ;.* 

     *. *2 -**: 1



  "

 !  5

4 4

   &

"

 

1(

   



 

       4



 

 

-+ .- .662  " < ;..



"

  

 ./ . 62





-+ .- .662 "

& ( " ) ;5 

  "

 !  !1 0

!

?

 .* 5

 &%#  ,6/6 -*.3(

 .. */ -*.3 

   1  5  "



 



%#  6+.3 -*.3 1   

<  ;.-

;./  

  ? E  " !  .+ */ -*.3



   !

  





-+ .- .662    &



  

< ;.-( 

  1





"

4 "

 4 *- *3 -***    "

 %  3

"

/. */ -**2  

1  

 -+ */ -*.3 ..

5        

 -. .. -*.3 "     ;



 



  





 



 

 2



 





.-

  

 

>     

"

  ., */ -*.,     F8#   "

"



< < ;..  

 

-+ .- .662  

./ *. .662 8 

  

+         ? E  " ! 

 

  G 



  */ *2 -*.,

 "

 

  



*- *3 -*** 

   *

./ E  

 4

     

 

 

"

  "

  

  



  

"

 

 =

.3 7 <      .+ *2 -*.,





        

8 

 

 4       

  "

 



        



 .- &/( '

 '

 &%

 %(  -**, &  

4 4(

   "

 =< % >   &

 

(

 

   





  

 

 



  

  

*





 

"

   

  

 



 

 "D 

1   E  

 

"

%  =< % 

  =< %  

1  

 

  



.2 5 



   





; !   -2 /92 -''

: -*./ &-( #%# &% ( 6/-    

  

= 

1   

"

   .- &/( & ( &(

&(

.:

7







 

    

  "

"

  1

"

      

., 5 

>  

 



    "

 

> "

"



"

  

    ,; '

 '

 &%

 %(  -***

   > "

 

 0'

   



 "  > "

.+ 

       

  

  

 

;







" 

 <   "

&  "



 .* ,

'

< -''

!/=/55 '/ -*.3 &.( %% &%( 36*( 7

   



;

&( #=-./ -''

 2,3 -**2 &.( #%# &% (

2,:C

&( /2 -''

 2,3

-*.2 &,( #%# &% ( 3:

&( -//<> -''

  5 '/ 8# -*..

&%(

/.*,C &( /<92-?

 -''

6  8# -*./ &%(

22/C &( "32>

 -''

@

'# . -*.- &.*( %%

3+6C &( $-23-<:5 '/  ,2'/ 2./  3 !2

 !2 '( # 55 '/ 8# -*.3

&%( .:36C &( "352 >>A -''

 '' 5

/ -*.2 &.2( %%

:/, .6 F     &  (   

  



 -* &E F % 08 I -:,.:3(;

@-* 

 "

 

 

1       

    E %

   

   

  ) 

1   

  "



 E %

  %  J



 1 ?

)    9 ;7;9







 



.+ *: .6+6  E % 

 ?

 "

   9 ;7;

 K  



    

 ? ./+- 



   

  1

  

   "



 

 .+ *: .6+6



    "

%  J  " .+ *: .6+6    

    "





.+ *: .6+6  "

 

   *3 *: -**,

 F8# *3 *: -**, A 

 .*

   

;

@.*        8



    

 <

&  (   > 



 

 <





 

 

   

 "

''

%> "  

) 



 '









 A

&E F % 08 I 3+*,/*( 5   

  

.-    "

 >    



   





 

 



  

 

 

   

 



 

1 

 



  ) 

   

 2  

 

 =   0'

 >  

 -*   

<   

     

     &   (  > 

"

  



 

    ., "  ..



-2 "   

 

 "

=  "

 

 



  





 

  /*- 8%

 -,  

  

  

   "

   

 "

 

 



 

" 



 "

 

  

 

  -.

" 



   

 







 

 

 

 -3 .* .66*



 



"

) % '



 



   

 

 

  

 -.

" 

 



  %' 

   '



 

"

  ) -.

   <  4 

 

     

"  

   



;

@-,  ,   "

1

> "



 

> "

 % %  

 ' '

 %  ''

 %     

 "

 

  > " > "



 %  >   "

1

4> "4



 > "

   ''

 F <

  ,

.-



 

  "

  

    ,

 < 4  

1

> "A 1 

 "A

@

 A



  

   

    

 



-+ .- 

  ,

  < 

  .- &-(

 < @  @

 "

 A @  

 

A .- &/(

 < @ 1 

 5 <  ; K     ,

.- "

> "



 > "





  "

" 

1

 C 



  > "

 

  4> "4



 ' '



 - &"( '

'

 "

 

<



 ' '



 % %   .6,/ &- .6,3(    "

  % A

&E F % 08 I /6-,./( -- 5   E  <    > " > " 

 

 % % 



;

@/- %> " 



 ' '

  

> "

     .- -**,         % % 

"

   

1

> "

"

   

"



< 

  ,  "

  

  % 

    > "

 %

 "

"



      

  , .- // 



 D' '

% 

 

"

1 

   .- &/( & ( &( &(  





 



"

1

      



"

 

/3 @  > "A 

  ,  .- -**,  

 1 





 >    

 

7"



"

 >    

   

 

  7"



 >  

   

 









"

 &

 

  ( >     

"

 

 "



   

 

8 < 





   



"    "



 



 

  

 "

/2 7  

    

C   

  

 

  8

 

 &2( .-   > "

 

 

 < 



"

   "



 

; &/( .-   '

'



 

 

'

"

   A &E F % 08 I /6-,./( 8  

 /,    

< 

        

   



 >  

  

 

 

)    < <  

  ;

@32 



     



   



   





  



 >

1    

   



 

 "

 "



 

" A &E F % 08 I /6-,./( ) 



  & 

 < 4 ( 

 -/ 

       < 

      &  (   

 

"



 

  

 !

  >   

  ;

@/6 ? 

  

 /6 .   

"



"



   8

  



      

"



     

"



   



  









/6 - F

1

 

"

    

  

 



 "

> "

  

"

 "

8





   

"

/6 /  

   

 "

D

  

 







   



   



   

"

    .- &/( & ( &( &(   "

 

  

>   

 > "

 .-  

  /./ %   



  "

"

  

"

 "

D



"

  1  4   

    

 

 ;

;

 "





  8 

          

   

!   "   K  

1

     

> "



 4

8   

   



     ,;



> "



>  /6 3 

    

"



 

    

"

  

 

 "



   



"

> "





  



 "

  

> "

 

>  /6 2 5  

"

   

 "



 -*** 

 



"

   -*** 



"



 





 -*** 



  

 "

 

"

   D

 



 

+   " 





 < "



 

 

    

"

/6 : % 

"

1  "

  

"

"

"



 

"



   A

&#%% % ( -3   

 

 #$  

% ! &$  !  &  (   



   

  



   '

 '

 



  

"

 

"

 8  

  

"

   

  "

8  %  



 , " 

 "



"

 



 , .- " 



"

 

"

 

 



>   

  

    

 E

  &



  

 3-



( 

;

@3- #   



    



      @  A 



 

  "

   8

* 

 



 "

  

<  

    8





"

 

 1

 



" 

  < 

 

 "

<<<<< <<<<< <<<<< <<<<< 3/ 8     "

  



    5 



"



"

 "

 "

    



.+

  D 

 

  

 

  

    



 

 "

5

  D

  "

 8

 



 "

 

 

 "



%   





      

 





   

    

   









 

"



   .3 



 8  



 .+ 

  

4





  



 .+ "

<  .3     



 "

 <

"

K !



 "

  .3  

 





 ;;;;;;;; A &E F % 08 I 2/,/6/(

;

-2 5       E 

"



 



  

   -:

)  



  

> "



"

    



  

  "





   "





"



 > "

 

-,   

  !' (   

 

 

 

  /*-

 

)   E 



#    



 

  

 





 

 



   E

#    

 

      

   "

<

  

 '

 '

 

 "

 



-+ 8  









   

  

0 '



  

 

 > "

"

  

 



 %> " 





  

> "

 -6

 )       

          

 

;

&( 5 





  

    

   " "









 "

 

"

  



 .- &-( '

 '

 &%

(  -**,C &( 5  

 



.6 " 

       

"

   C

&(      

     

    



 



  "

 

.6 "  

"







 C &(  



 

 



"

     

 



 C

" &(

%   

=  



>  

    .- &/( & ( &(  /*   



  

  

;

 &( .

50@ 

-''

 '' 5

/ -*.2 &/( < '

 &%( ,**C &( 62=3'( -''

   -*., &.( #%# &% (

.*/C &( .#/'B!2

 C'/ 2./8 . 25D '/ D-' ,#/' -''

 '' 5

/5 "

8# -*.:

&%( -3.+

&(

2 9206 2 -''

: -*.2 &:(

#%# &% ( /:

/.

5 

     



 "

 

> "

  

   > "

> 

  







   1 

   

  <

     -**, .- " 

   "







>   

 



 

   







 

% 

  "

 

"





  

1  

"

 

   

% ;H   





 

  

     

;

 &( &(

; / & (

 

 ) 

     



 %  &



"



 "

(

1



 

  





5        

"

"

 

 

  1

 

  



8 < 



 "

!* + '



 

 



 

  &  (



 "

!*+ '

     E  "

   .- &/( & ( &(

& "( 

 

@

   

"

 DA

/-   

    



  ",  &  (

    "

  



 

   

 @ 1 "









A   < 





      ;

@-:

8  

  









  





.+ "  

  "





    

  

 ''

 !

 

  

 

 

 1 "











 

  



 

 





 

   

 

 

  





-,

 

 

  ''

 

"

"

 

  







 

 "

    



   

    



; 

 

"

     

"



  

  

  

-+ 8   

 >   

 

  

  

 





  



  )  

"



 "

 1

   





 





K ) &  (

> "



   

   A

&# F %  08 I ,:223.( // E    

 



 "



 -    &  ( 

"

 







 

"



"





  

> "



"

"



   "



 



.2 " 

 

1



 



 )

   "

"

    

.6 "     

/3 8

         "





 

  

"





 

> "



 

  

   &  ( /2 ) 

  

    '

 '

 &%

 %(  -*.2  

 -2 

 "

 

"

 

   -***  

  

 ) 



"

 

   

     

/:

8 < 



   -/ 

/ -''

525 '/  -*., &.( #%# &% ( 22:

(/ "(/:5 '/  -''

!/=/5  %# &% ( -*., -+, /, E    

  

  "

 



    /+ ) 







 

  > 

> 

  

 "  "

 "

  

 0'



 1 

 



  

"  

  

> "

   .- 

"  "

     

.6 " 

  

 > "

  

  

    



"

   > "

/6 

  >  

"

 "

  

0'

   

"  

 "

 "

 

  "

 &  



 = ( "

 "







"

5   "

< 



 -:

",  &  (

  

   1 "













  "

     

"

4 

   "

  

    .6 " 

8  1

  "



 



;

   1       

"

 

  

   





"

 "     "

 )   "

    

     





 > "

      .-  -**,



  >  

 

  

   



  

  &

 /3

F % ( 5

      



 /6 /  &%% % ( 

   "

D   

 



 



   



  

 

 

"



  @

    .- &/( & ( &( &(   "

     

>     > "

 .-A 3* 5



  > 

 

 "

  



 "



  

 "

      



> "



 

+

 

.6 "     

3.



   

 1 

  

"



"

  

 "

 



 

   " >

"

 

"



 & 

  '

 '

 &%

 %(  -*.2(

 



        

  3-  ,

,  -***

.-  -**,

   ;

@, ( 52 '

3   < 53:6. ''

 ' 4 < 525 '/

"('D&.( 

"

  < 

  











"

  & 

 (



    

"

  



 

  

"

  

&-( 

"

   



;

 &.(    > "



   "





, ( 52 '

3   < 5</ ( ,2

': 

53 

:( 2'D.(

 

"



"



  

    

1

> " 1 

 "

&

 ( 





  

  



  

 "

 

 

"



"

 

 

"

 

   

   

     



    

  



 

* &-(

8 



  



; &.(   

 

 

 

" 

 

   A

<<<<<

<<<<<

<<<<<

@.- ( 52 '

3   < 55 '

'  ".

&.( 8 "





  

%  .6     

 

  

 "

" 

1

  &-(

%   

"



 

   



 "

    

 



   

 &/( 8 "





  

 > "

 

 



 %

1 

 ;

& ( &(

 >    

 

C

 C &(

   &

 ( 

C

 C &(









"

 C & (

"

  &( &( &( 

& (

   



 

"

     

  8 < 





 

 % 





"    "



 



 D

  

 "

     

 1   

 

  

 

 

  

"



 & (&( &( &(

  

& (  

  

  8

  &3(

8

 

 

;



 .+ "  



"

   

; &/(

%    

 

 

"

  

 

"

  



   &2(



<   > "

 >  

    ,  :3 

    > "

 

 

 < 



"

   "

 

;

&/( &:(     

"

   

"



    

; &/(

 >   

  

  

   A & :3   ,;  



 



   -***( 3/ 5   , &.(   

 

"



"



1

> "

@ 1 

 "

&

 ( 



 ;;;;;;;A

5  .- &/(   "







 > "

 

  @ 1 

 ;A

 >    

 



 

   



   





 "

  )

 

 .- &/(    

> "   

 



"



"

   1 

 5

       

 /6 -

 "



1

 

"

    

  

 



 "

> "

  

"

 "

)







   

"

) 



1 >   

 "

 "

  

  "

 

 =   



 ;

 



    

 





  "

 

  5



"

"

 "

    & (

 "

 



    

 

;

 ;

  



    

 

 

 

 < 

  <

 >

 



  "



    

   

 

> "



"



  L 

 

 

 





"

  

 "

  0' 

 



 

  

 

  





 

 /6 2   

  

"

  



 -*** 

 



"

   -*** 



"

 

 





 



 ) 

"

.:

" 

- 

      "

"







 '

 '

    



  

   .- &/(  -**,        

> " 

 "

  "

<   



 ;

  3:

    "



 &  '



 ( 



 "

     &  ( 



%  .* 



1 



 



  

1  %  .* < 

 

 B   

  "

1   2

 

 > 





 

> "

   

 D  

"

   .- -**,  

 3,  "

  

C 

  

 "

 

"

   



< 

  

      

    



   "



   

&5 " 



 



   

  .+ *2 -*.,    

 

( 8

    & ! (      

 



   ., */ -*.,

   

 

  

"

  

 > "

 

3+ 8 

 

 

"

, 



  





 



1

C "

 

 



 4 "

 

> "



     

  

 ? 

   



 &  ( 

    

"

 

 .- &/( &  -**,(C   "









  =    "





 

   



)   







;

   "

"

 











> "

  

 .:

" 

 

  

  

 "

>



 



0 '





2* 5  



 

  &

 (       2 



 =   

 = 

   > 

"

 





  *+ *, -*./

.2 *3 -*./

 >



2.

! 

  



  

  -2 '

 '

 &%

 %(  -*.2

  



 &  (  

    &'

"

.2 -*.:(

 

  -*.2

  

 

 

  -*** 

5   

  



'



 

"

 .:

" 

  

    .2 -.

 -*.2 

   ;

E&.( 8

 





 









  

 



< "     

 "





" "

 

"

 >  

   

 "

 





  

 &/(  .+ 



1

  < " 

"; 1  < 0'  $1F      "



 

 "

 

 > 

  &2(    "



 



      

  

 % %   .6,/   

  





; &2(  .*.  



   

     .3 &.( % '



 % 

   

 

    "

  "

 

    > "

 

 

  &2(

  

 " "

   

 "

< 

    =<  %   E

  "   

%  )  "  "

   

  

  "

 





%  &/(  "

 



% '



 % 



0

 >

"









 ., &.( 

 > "











 

 

  

  

"

   

"  "

 

"

 

       &-( 8

   

; &.( 



  %

  *&.( 

 > "

 





  

  

  

"



 





< "  

    

"  "

 

"

 

 

       



  



  

"   1 M &(

 











 > "

 



 C

& (   

 



C

&(    "



 

  

  

  

C &!(   

  

   1 

  

"



 

 C & (  

  

  

 



"



   

   < 

  "

> 



 

N ;



"

 <  " C

&(  

  

  

 





"

 "

 



 

N ;



"

 <  " C

&"(  



   <  " 

1         1   

    "

"      

   

  

 

N      

 

    "

&2( 8

 

 

 &( &"(

; &.(

"

   M &(

 C &(



   C &(



   C &&(      > 

 

  C &&(



;

 

&3( 

  "



  .2 

 

  

 

    %N

 "



 &/( 

  "



  .2 

 

  

 

    %N

 "

 ;&.(    "

 

  .2 %O

 M &( 

  



  % %   .6,/



 

 

  

 -.       

 

 "

C &(     



 

> "



 

    .+ &2(

%N     

      



 

    



 0 %  G

 1 &/(

%N      

 

  "

 

 

"; " 

    

 

        1 

   "

 

    "

"    

      "

&3(

%N    

 

 "

"



 0 %  G

 1

>  

     "

   ;  

"

&2( 5 



; &3(  

  %O 





>  &.(   

 

";









 



  





 



 " 

"   " %O   





 0 %  G

 1



>  

 

    

 



  "

    



; &3(  .6

 

  <

1  

&2(    



; &.( %N

"M &(    

    





"

   "C &(       

  

  



 





 



+  ?    

   



 

 

 

  

     "

 

"

 

  

  8  %

"

 

  25 

  .2 &.(  



 

" "



 .:

" 

  





D

    

   .+ &/(  

  '

 '

   

  %4     

  .6 

5 

"

 

 

 

  

 .:

" 

 

 

 .:

" 



 "  

 



 )

  "

 



"

 

.:

"    

"



"

 

 "



   

 

 "



  

 / "   

  &  

 "

 

" (



"

1

  

  -*.2  "





"

 



   

 "



   -*** "

2/ ?

"  

  

 

"



"



 

*



     

"

  



B"6 8  ""  - C !

$ 

3 *&+    1 D 

BD?  #

BD?