← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14228/2021allowed

A.N. Buildwell Pvt Ltd v. Pr. Commissioner Cgst Gurugrm And ANR

2021-07-30Mr. Justice Ajay Tewari5 pages



         

   

  

 

    

  !



" #" "

$$"%&'(%& "

)"

$ *" 

+,  







 











! 

---- " ."

/

'* "$ %  "*,"

---- 

 "

#$%&'

0 * ,% * ,"$, 0 12 !3

4 *" )*5

"* *

) *"

" $* )" *0 " 6%*5

 * *7)*  "  * *

 * " 

"  * ,"$, "  9,* * "$,

 "   

 * ,"$  * "$, %**

 * 83 **" 80*",  "* 0 " "8"  ,*!3

"%**  "   0*   * *"

, 

(*," $, 0*" )*

"*$  "," *



)5"* "

*$"

,  "*

","$)*5

"  ", 0 " "

)*$

,"

* ")8 * * 8": *)" *" ," 

"* "

* $"

 8"  *  *5

))"  80* 5"

"%*$ 0 ,""

 2* 8 ") 80*! "   "*"$, * **

 

% 83 * "

6   ** * 5

" *

%* %*5

"*

")*","*$,

,"';*$, %<;61*" """"  * =<;6=4 ,"'6*<;6% 0 " )

," ) *$, 0

8  0**  *  "   2 *   "*" 8 ")  *  * 5

"  $, *5"

6%*

 9 "*,

 * ,","  * $, 0 

) * ")"    * $, %*" )*'*

*5

"



")  *2$, ) $5"

* 83 ," ), "

*"%8) 

* ,",   "

:

 (*! "   *

,  *

"$$

*"3  "



;

14*" "

* 8,

0 *'*

 "  80*5

"" 0$ ") "

)*>),"

* ") "  80*5

(* ,* 8

(

") %* 8"8  *5"

;

14

$ ."

 '

* 

*% '" ' )   % 2%  ."

 & , ')* .

*"

%   % ,  8*

  * ",  ! "   "*+, *      8 :

)$ $ % * % * "$ 0 " $ )

 ""



 *,"%

 %*

* 

 ,"



*2$, ) $5"

6

 1> " 4 

 * *  * "$, 0 *   8 $,

*" )*5

2 "* * *"0

 

"  * 5"

6%   **% * 5

 *   * * 7)*  " *

 * " 

"  * "$,  *  *  $ ,""*

**

 %

 %* %*

 0*5

2 $ "

*  5

"?," 

" %* *  

%   * 5

" * *  ")*    * $, 0

*," ) 

*  ")*  ", 0 *'*

 9 *"$, 0  ;

@  * )*      8 :

)$ $% *" , "0* ,"

,8)"  % ,8 0* 0 " , *,"

8 

* $"



8,"$ $ 9  ""

7 "%



* ,"  %   " "$ *     *" 8 % *" $8) " "*5

"*  "

2  " "  % 

, ",

8"  " ) )* ,"  * "$ 0 

   * ,,

  *"0%   $  * 

 *  * ,"$, 0 *" )*  5

 """ 80 " %

* 

 *"

"$ * 8 9""*  " "

)

 ,," 0  * ")  * "$, 0 *" )*  5

"% "

*

." "% 8 $ 

 * * *,"$, 0 $, 0** 3

 *"" " " ))*"

 (* % * 8   % $ ,,","     * "

 6

 1> " 4 * "  ",    % $$" "

 &  '"  ( > ,  "* "

" ) )

 ,," 0  * ,"$, *" )*  5

"  ,"    " "

) ,," 0,"

* ") 2

8,"",  ) * 

0" *5

(* "$, 0 *" )* * 5

"  "   " 8" ",     <

  

 )"

  $ ,  

 ", 0**

 2 >, *",  

 *$ " >,   0

,8 %,""

0* ," *"$*"$

  (*", , * 8 "$

'*$  * 8  %*, )  %  0%

 ,   

#

 '



# !  '



*&+ ( "

 

,%-.//0

**", 9)?"    A? **"+,"  A?