High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2511/2025dismissed

Gurshaminder Singh And Another v. Jagtar Singh And Others

2025-05-07Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl12 pages

!" #$!!

% & '$ #$!!

(

#)*+!,-# ./0!

. )+!,-./

. !1*-./ !(

3! / ( , . , ! 4 $! 5 6 .7 %8 (1*!/,'$ ' / -9!/,# 1 $: #,;

!" #$!! &

'$ #$! ! <- 0! 1* ((, , 1* ! ( =(, 86, 0!# %!1" !,,$,! 6 .7 % (1*!> .((,, -9!0! 1*! ((,( 1*!( $! 5 6 ! ,1"

? # , !( !1"! !( -!( !/, , ! !@,, : A5

A ,,$,* 71* + +

00'$ (#$!/ : = ( : ,-B1 "!(, 11*!" 41"!!,,$!, " " :

5 / 0!! " 0 8 C !1!@,,/ :

4 ! 1"!+ + 00'$ (#$!00 ! , D ! 0 ! "! ,0 (, : =( : $ "! (,: =( :

41"!!!7 $ @,, 6 A/ (,: =( : !1D ,,$ $ @,,

A 1* ( "-"!-!@,,

A0 !/1 $ A A %

A!!" 1*/ "%@ 9! 9!!',!! + + 0"!!(,("

? # , !( ! !" ! 0!!1( %@!!$!,$!! /!!0!+ + 0 $ "/ , ,$ !(-0!B*!*( !!0"!!(,0! ! $ A 4 ! 1"!!+ + ! A -0!/* "!7! $ @,,

A! ", ,*!0!! 0 ( " $!@,, 41"! !( "0 ! 0! (!@,,

8 ( (1*! (: -!-( "/ ! (, 0 1,! 4 1" ! ! "-! (=!,!/1 " ,$!( ( *!1,/,/ !( =(,!*0, ( 1,,! ( 1,,,! ( ( * 41"! ! "($ (1*! , 0,,!> .((,, ,,$, /1! ,$!1 (,(!"( $,$,0-" ,,0!!/,1(,*! ! !"( $0!! ,*"" *( $

4!-( *!!( /(1,,0! "($ 1!((,, 86, %1,,0

3! !! , # , !( !( !(( 1B!!"($ 0!,0!/1 $!,*(!( / (1$" ,- /1" ! , !

4(!!(,=( !, , #("1 - % " *!,,$! ! $ @,,

A0!!!/17 1*+ + / : -0!( ! !$ !+ + !,,$!,1" !":

58 C !1!

A $ @,, 4!!( !! $ @,, 6 A 71* ! + + / ( :

4!0 ",1*: -- 5 7.7 %8,$0!!( /( -0 !(!!!(,0 ", "0!'$ (#$!#" + + ! 0 ,$ ($10!"-,$ ",( $0!!!1 1*(,: =( : 0!!'$ (#$! + + 0 " 40 ! ! !!+ + 0 $0!'$ #$!: !",*! E: 6- ,30%,$#!"!!! : 6- ,30-9!!: 0! , 1 '$ (#$!#" + + 40!((, !1/!

/, $ @,,07/ : -0! ! ,! !@,,0 /, ,*71*+ + -0!,(! !"0 11*) #$!-./-9!0 1* B!

E ( #$! ! )#$!-0!0 !$0 40,! % " + : 8-0!! ,$! + + - !$! $,@,,B! !!@,, 0,*( 1 !$ + + !,,* ( ! ,1 !#1$ -9! 40! "! 0,/ :

1*! /! !1! $ @,, !! $ @,,1 !(!$ (!! 7+ + ,$0!$01 !#1$ !" ,!!"1"( + +

40 ! ! !0 "!! + + !/ 0!!(,- ! !! 0!! #( 0">4: A 8 50!!0 $ 1*(,: =( : #A 0!#94%%,#+0,- 9!$+ + '$ (#$!!+ + ! B1,! ",0!! "($ / , * 4 0/ !!(, !/ /+ + ! $!! ,"! $ @,,6 A( ( 1*!(,01$1 @,,!"0,,$,* 7*1D!0! 0,! ",-0!! 00! 05 A

%,,$0!!!,((,

86,% 3! , / 5 6 ! " ! ((, 0!, $ - B ! $ @,,

A- >4 : A 8 50,,!& -%( - -4* 1*

: -,,0!!0,!0!! '$ (#$!

0,"!, 5 -0!!"0 7( !,$!!(,5 6 -1

C 0 (,,*!,,$! 3!!! 0 ", ,!(10+ + !(,0,B

.((,,1*!( 0,"1*!> .((,, 6 0!, "$ ! "- ! .((,, ! B ! ! ! 0 ,$,$ ",,$($10!(, + + -0!!( "!0!! "10!( (( ,*0 , 401 /1*!> .((,, !!(,! 1,!( "0!!0 1,!!/1,/0/ ! ( " ! ! ! @,,

A 0 $ @,,-!"!,1!1! "!!(!",0,0 ! ( ( 1,,-01 /! " $!(*!-!-!"0,1!1*! ,(!-,1!! 0,1 ( 1, ,!(, > "( ,! (1*!> .((,, - (( ! / , 0 B 1!!"( $1 ! / (!,$!/,*! $ @,,/ ! -0!, (!,$!)$"! , 3!1/ (1*! , 0,,!> .((,, 0!,00,,, *

3! @,, / : ,* $ @,,",*!,@,,!7+ +

4 ( ! ( 1* ! 5 A - ! ( !/(, (*>4: A8 5 0,, 5 A0!!!/17.7 . .0! 6844 .( ,!>40!!0 $ !* 50,!0!!"(,!0 (,: '( + !( 0!!1" 0 + + '$ (#$!

> ! ( ,.7 . 0!!! (1*!', $ > ,-9! 0!,7 $!(0 !% $ -% ?B.,0, !0!! !(! ",( $!/$ 1"(/0!"( "-0!!0!/ 1 /10+ + (,: > "!1/- ( ", ! "5A-! 0 ",( $ ($ $ + + '$ ( #$! ! ", ( $0 1*'( + (,: !-!(, 1*!1/!!! 0"* 10+ + !(,1!D !(,B$ !+ + 0!!!* A,( "

4 ! !!(,!6 A- $ @,,071*!+ + / ! (, : =( : 3! $ @,, 1D!"( "5 A( "

5 (( 1 "!+ + !,!/ / *0,,7!" /! , "! ",( $1*(,: / -* - 1D! $ @,,6 A- $ @,,

A!171*!+ + / : " ,,0!1D@,, ( /,7( / $ , > "!/ " "1*!( -!,"1!/!$! + + : ! $/ ! $ @,,

A!-! ,0$!/ ! : 3!(0! (!!$! + + ,(( "1 $!@,,

A 0!!!17.7 % 0!!( /(

.,,*-! $ @,,

A01* B!

+" -F7

E (#$!

3! ""1 ! #1$ $($6!(( 1B , ! !!!!1 / !7+ + -0!!"!"1 !( ! !11* B!+" -F7

E (#$! % " + -0!!$! !+ +

!(( "-! 1 !$!,$! 3!!(,!( 5 6 ( ,!(,0,!0!!!(,! : '$ #$!! $! 5 ! ( !( ( *!: ! $!

6 ! ,8 5 !,"! ( ! ( ( * E0/ -(!,,$! =, !1"! .7 %

4! "-! (,0,,!// "!(0!! !- " -D!,0!!/ 1*! , -"1,0!! !(,,"* $! 0! (!( !, @! (!( ( 1,,-0,1 ,/!! ! (!!(,!/( "-!- * ! $!!0,( )! $! " !! $!!(, .1/- ,!, *1"( !,$!0!!!/ 1(,,*!,,$ / -* "1D! ,$!0,1!1*! ,(!-! ( , 0$! " / ! $ (= 3!1 /"1*! 0! ( 1,/,,, *

4!,$!!1/$-! $" 1* !, # , !( !!! ( " $! $ !@,,- 0,,, $!"($ !" " , F/( ,!/%@ 9! 9!!- 0!!!1!$!,$!1!,!( 0,!0! ! !$$$!+ + 0" 11,7! $ @,, %!*,(

"!",!( %@ 9! 9!!',0!7"!!(,,*! + + 0"

A 0(1, 7$! $ @,, 4! 7"-!%@! !!( -!0 ;<!1

4!,1!0'$ #$! $: 0!!,!(!,+ + 0! $ A1 !!,**!$1 !/*!(1 !0"!, 40 ! !!0(1*'$ #$!!0B0 %@!0C A!( : !""B !(*"!00 !0!(*"0"1* (,: =( : '( + -0!+ + !1 " 1* '$ #$!

#$$ 0 $/ !" ! ! 0 ($,,*!!(,:

3!-!1!/-1( " !!+ + 0" 0(1, 7$!@,,

A,,!(,$!( 0!! ! %@ 0($! (,: =( : -0,1 !" , / -(,!",/ ,,$$!+ + 7 $ @,,6 A! / !1D $ @,,!17

A,* ( 6 * "!! , $ @,,6 A !-1(( "-!+ + 0"

6 A-1

A-" -0!! / !0!+ + 0"

A 3!-! "($ (1*! , 0,,!> .((,, /1(!,

3!EG1,#( " !

(

! ! "#-!1 /!!E$! -! (!-7 (0 ( . ,

!- 0!! 1, : -7 !(0 - ((,/ ! 1,1 40,1 /! )$"! *""0! (#! /,% 0!"1E$! H (0 . , 1 ! " "- " 1 ""1 ! ! * "" ($,* 7(!E$! H) ( . ,

3!(0 !. ,1B(!""" !!0!,)"!,! ) "( (,, "(1, !$! 1, 1 !E$!

40,1 /!!(0 . , "*1 1 7 1)!$!$ ),(,

+($/0!1/ "-! ! (!!"($ ,, * 1*! 0!,7 $(0 . ,

!4 $,*-!"($ (!, !( /(1$" ,- /1" $,*-"

:,*!!1 /"!( ,* !( ($!( /(0!! !,,$! ( 86,%! 1 /"!"0,1 7( ,(!" !! , 0,! (,*!1 /"1*! - B$ !(,$-/ $" 1*!( !",! $

.,,!($",,((,-*-!,, (/0!1/ ! " "

#$%&$%'()%*+,-./'%*(0-%12 %(/0 #$%&$%''%)0'&*34%2 %(/0