High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14111/2019dismissed

Principal Dav Public School, Salwan Road, Assandh And Others v. District Judge, Educational Tribunal For Educational Institutions At Karnal And Others

2023-07-13Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil9 pages

!"#$%&%$

! " # $ ' ()* % + *+ ** ) **** % &$ '(# ( & ) ( &# & * ( +, &-## *.+/01 +,#!

- ".!/ 01 % 021 ! (* ,,34" 5 6 737/,7280 291 5 ! # . +2 ( ) /27:,729 ,222,729 ( 5 ; ) ) 5 565+/ 0,1 $ +/ < 5

# 5 ;

,:79,72/= ( ; 7,78,72/ 5 4 ) < & 4)) ; $ 9: 4- -5

( 5 //>) *5

- 2 -

) 6$ 970210(1 970,1 4- -5

65 /2?,729 4 ) & 4)) ( /2:,729 0 @1 ) 5 )( ) ( +/

5 ,222,729 +/) )( ! +/ 5

5 ! ( 737/,728) ; 4 0/1 &$ '(# ( ;

) 5 5 +/ ) 5"65 " ) 5) )()( 65 ) ) ; ) 5 ( ') ( 5 ) 5 () ) ) ) - ) ) 5 *;

' ) A ' ) 5 ) ) "

! 091 " ! 65 +/ 5 ) "65 !

- 3 -

5 5 5 ( 5 "65 ) 5)( )(" ( ;

4- -5

5 ) 0?1 < ( /220,1 5 ( 6 5 5 4) 5

5 ' 6 5)

* $ 4B ' ) "#$ $# % &'( ) * !++, - ,C

) 4 &. / #%0.# 1)2!++3

- + 031 +) ,97?,728 ) ' ) 737/,728 ) 5 0:1 A ) ,778,728 5 +/ ( ; ) ( $

5 ; 4- -5;

5 5 $ (* " ) +/ 5 ) 5 & & 4))-5;

,,0(1 4- -5;

(5)) 52? 5 6)-5;

994- 5;

- 4 - 0@1 < +/ (

,8,72/ )

+6 ( " () 5 ) ( 5 5 65 = ) 5 5 6 5 65 5 65 +/" ) 5) ( ( & 4)) 5( -5;

9:021010(1 9:0,1 081 = 0271 - ) 5 65 5+/ 565,223 42,/ "5-6"-"4 #/-.# 437 #2

5 ) 4- -5;

0221 "

! 6 ) 5(

5 5 65 ' ) )4" "65 5 '

5 5 5) 5 '

- 5 - ( ! 6) 5

5 ( 5 ) ' " 65 5 5 5 5 565 6 ( ) 5 (

)! ( 5) 4 = 5 ,7730/1$338 )4

4 0 1

( 5 ( 5 02,1 "& 5#% $#067$ 3,,

5D 5 5 65 6 ( 9, )) ;

0,1 /224"

55)4 %; "For doing away with the effect of the enquiry report or to meet the recommendations of the Inquiry Officer in the matter of imposition of punishment, furnishing a copy of the report becomes necessary and to have the proceeding completed by using some material behind the back of the delinquent is a position not countenanced by fair procedure.

- 6 -

" #$!

% & ' (

% &

% & % &

) E) F 02/1 "

65 5 65 +/ 5 5 ) 5 65 ) 6 (

- 7 - 0291 ! )))565 * 5 ) 5 5

5)! 6 ) ( 5 65 (G 5 ) ** )) 5=

))565=) 5 5 5 ( ( ) ( ( *565 ) ( 5 65 ( ) ( ) ) ) 5 5 65 ( 5 5 ) D ( ) 5 ) 5 5 = ) 5 ) ) ) )

)H 6 5 5 02?1 ! 55 )5) 5 ) 5 5) ( ( )

( ! 5 5 6 (' ( '

- 8 - )

,,34 ( ( (* 5 ) ) 5 5 5 6 ( 5 6! *

) 6 5 5 '( 5!

( ) ( ' ) ' 5 55'( 5 ( 5 6 ) * ) 5! 5 5 6 ( ' 6) ( 5 5! 5 /220,1 ( 29 ,24!4) 5 ' I' 5 ) 5 5)I 0231 " 4- -5

( 5 5 55 ( ' ) 54 *5 ) )) 5 ( $ ) .89 % 66 %:1$! !

!+;

- 9 - 02:1 ( ' ; ! 5 5 ( 5; ) ) 5 5 65 +/ 5 5) 5 02@1 !4(

5 ) 5 !

5 4 ' ,,34" 0281

5 ) 2/7:,7,/ + +

+,#!

- ".!/ 0

.!/

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No