High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/2829/2013allowed

Seema v. State Of Haryana

2015-02-18Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan8 pages

!"#"$%&%'() *""+ "!%!%'", -",&.& *! !" ,/ '

"&0'#"'!

( 12

*3 2 *

,"&"'!(4

, &5%!*%'67"#%8*"'%,#9$ !"8:%!78

,*.'%;*%7 68#9$ !"8,!7"0"!%!%'",

,* !%&7* %'%8"0.!/8 ,/ ' <7"!7",!7" "0,!",&;$ ;'":&0 0",+ /=" ;;:"#!&"" !7"5.#6+"'!> =","",,"#!!7" "0,!",,'! <7"!7",!7"5.#6+"'!&7.;#=","0,!"#%'!7"#%6"&!> 44 44 2 *8 *""+ 8 $$.&"# ,"9%&%'%&!7","%'87 &%;"#!7%&,"9%&%'

6 %'&!!7",#",# !"#80 &&"#=/!7";" ,'"###%!%' ; 7! ?89%#":7%$7%!: &7";#!7 !!7"# !"=%,!7 !7" $$.&"# ,"9%&%'%&! 7","%' : & @ *%'$" !7" $$.,,"'$"!?0; $"'AB87"'$"%!: &7";#!7 !&7"

,"9%&%'%&!7","%': &+,"!7 '/" ,& 6" !!7" !%+"$++%&&%'$,%+":"9",8!7" 00;%$ !%'!7"$4 ''4,"9%&%'%&! ""!.C""!.: & ;;:"# '#&7": & 7";#!=")/" ,& '#+'!7& '# 5.9"'%;"%'$';%$!:%!7 ; :

44 ","!7";" ,'"###%!%' ;*"&&%'&.#6"8 7! ?8 !: 00;%$ !%'&:","%;"#,#"!",+%' !%' 6"D'": &%;"#=/ $$.&"# ""!.C""!. ''4,"9%&%'%&! '#!7"!7",=/ $$.&"# *""+ ,"9%&%'%&!7","%'8# .67!",&*.,"&78,"&%#"'!&9%;; 6" *.' ,% '3 ; '8%&!,%$! 7! ?8:7:","&.++'"#.'#",*"$!%'

, ! $"!,% ;,"'$" ;'6:%!7!7", $$.&"#.'#", *"$!%'&A4 '#A4 $$.&"#*""+ ,"9%&%'%&!7","%'

7 #&! !"#%'7",&! !"+"'!!7 !&7": & 5.9"'%;" !!7"!%+" $$.,,"'$"",# !"=%,!7%&BA7",","8&7"0, /"# !7 ! &7" =" #"$; ,"# 5.9"'%;" "," !7" ;" ,'"# ##%!%' ; 7! ?8=!7!7"0 ,!%"&;"#!7""9%#"'$" 7 9" 7" ,# ;" ,'"# &"'%, $.'&"; , !7" ,"9%&%'%&!7","%'8;" ,'"#"0.!/#9$ !""'", ;,!7" *! !" '#7 9" ;&$ ,".;;/6'"!7,.67!7"%;" ","!7";" ,'"###%!%' ;*"&&%'&.#6"8 7! ?8 ,"9%&%'%&!7","%'7 #"E +%'"7",+!7",*7 ?.'!; & < '# ;& 6! 0,#.$"# &$7; ,"$,# 7" .=;%$

,&"$.!, ,"&0'#"'!"E +%'"# ,&* '!&78'6 ': ,%<,?", & <8 * '!&7 3.+ ,%8 !" $7",8 9",'+"'! ,%+ ,/ *$7;8*.' ,% '3 ; '8 7! ? & < '#&+"!7",:%!'"&&"& 7" %+0.6'"# ,#", # !"# 8 0 &&"# =/ !7" ;" ,'"# ##%!%' ;*"&&%'&.#6"8 7! ?8&7:&!7 ! &0",!7"&! !"+"'!

+3 .,8!" $7",89",'+"'! ,%+ ,/*$7;8*.' ,% '

3 ; '8 7! ? <8 $$.&"#*""+ ,"9%&%'%&!7","%',"+ %'"#

44 #+%!!"#%'9",'+"'! ,%+ ,/*$7;8*.' ,% '3 ; '8 7! ?8 ,+B! '#&7": & #+%!!"#%''#$; &&&0",!7" &$7;,"$,#87", *""+ 1&# !"=%,!7: &BA '#!7"

& +": &%'$,0, !"#%'!7"&$7;,"$,#!.,!7",$+"&.! !7 ! !!7"!%+" #+%&&%'%''# $; &&%'!7"& %#&$7;8!7" 0 ,"'!& $$.&"#*""+ ,"9%&%'%&!7","%'#%#'!.,'%&7!7"

0,"9%.&&$7;;" 9%'6$",!%%$ !"7",0,"9%.&&$7; '#, !7",8 %# 9%! !7" !7",8 !!"&!"# ' @)B8 : & %;"# 7" &! !"+"'! +!7", !7" $$.&"# *""+ ,"9%&%'%&! 7","%'

.,!7",&7:&!7 !&7"7 &.,$7%;#,"'%"!7,""# .67!",& '#'" &'*""+ %&!7",#$7%;# '# $$,#%'6!7",8&7": &=,'' BA 7";" ,'"###%!%' ;*"&&%'&.#6"8 7! ?80; $"# 7" 9/ ,";% '$" .0' !7" &! !"+"'! + #" =/ ,& * '!&78 '6 ': ,% <,?",

<8 :7 &! !"# !7 ! &7" + %'! %'"# !7" ,"$,# =.!!7"# !"=%,!7$7%;#,"'*7 ?.'!; '#*.,"&7 $$,#%'6 ! 7",8 ,# $7%;#8 # .67!",8 : & =,' ' @8 :7"," &A!7 $7%;#8 '!7",# .67!",8*7 ?.'!; '#*.,"&7: & =,''@*7"0,#.$"#&.,9"/,"$,# E )8:7","%'

!7"' +"&!7"$7%;#,"'7 #=""'+"'!%'"# & =;% '#*'% '#%!: &&! !"#!7 ! !",!7"=%,!78!7"%,' +"&:","$7 '6"# 7"# !"=%,!7 =;%: &+"'!%'"# &@7",","8 ,";/%'6.0'!7"&.,9"/$",!%%$ !" E )8!7";" ,'"###%!%' ;

7! ?8$ +"!!7"$'$;.&%'!7 !!7"# !"

4A4 =%,!7*""+ : &@

.;"!7".9"'%;".&!%$" ," '# ,!"$!%' 7%;#,"' .;"&8 @ %' &7,! 1@ .;"&1 #" ;& :%!7 !7"

0,$"#.," ! =" ;;:"# %' #"!",+%' !%' !7" 6"8 :7%$7 %& ,"0,#.$"# &.'#",(4 F

,$"#.,"!=";;:"#%'#"!",+%' !%'6"4

' "9",/$ &" $'$",'%'6 $7%;# , 5.9"'%;" %' $';%$!:%!7; :8!7"$.,!,!7" ,#, &!7"$ &" + /="!7"++%!!"","",,"#!%',.;"!7"&" ,.;"&&7 ;;#"!",+%'"!7" 6"&.$75.9"'%;",$7%;#, 5.9"'%;"%'$';%$!:%!7; ::%!7%' 0",%#!7%,!/# /& ,+ !7" # !" + ?%'6 !7" 00;%$ !%' , !7 ! 0.,0&"

7"$.,!,!7" ,#, &!7"$ &"+ /="!7" ++%!!""&7 ;;#"$%#"!7"5.9"'%;%!/,!7",:%&"!7" 5.9"'%;",!7"$7%;#, &!7"$ &"+ /="!7"5.9"'%;"%' $';%$!:%!7; :80,%+ $%"'!7"= &%&07/&%$ ; 00" , '$",#$.+"'!&8% 9 %; =;"8 '#&"'#7%+! !7"=&",9 !%'7+",%'5 %;

' "9",/ $ &" $'$",'%'6 $7%;# , 5.9"'%;" %' $';%$!:%!7; :8!7" 6"#"!",+%' !%'%'G.%,/&7 ;;=" $'#.$!"#=/!7"$.,!,!7" ,#,8 &!7"$ &"+ / ="8!7"++%!!""=/&""?%'6"9%#"'$"=/=! %'%'6H

%!7"+ !,%$.; !%' ,"G.%9 ;"'! $",!%%$ !"&8% 9 %; =;"D '#%'!7" =&"'$":7","D

%% !7" # !" =%,!7 $",!%%$ !" ,+ !7" &$7;

!7",!7 ' 0; /&$7;%,&! !!"'#"#D '#%'!7" =&"'$":7","D

%%%!7"=%,!7$",!%%$ !"6%9"'=/ $,0, !%', +.'%$%0 ; .!7,%!/, 0 '$7 / !D

4)4

= '#';/%'!7" =&"'$""%!7", %8 %%, %%% $; .&" =9"8 !7" +"#%$ ; 0%'%' :%;; =" &.67! ,+ #.;/ $'&!%!.!"# "#%$ ; ,#8 :7%$7:%;;#"$; ,"!7" 6"!7"5.9"'%;",$7%;# '$ &""E $! &&"&&+"'!!7" 6"$ ''!=" #'"8!7".,!,!7" ,#,8 &!7"$ &"+ / ="8!7"++%!!""8,!7"," &'&!=","$,#"# =/!7"+8+ /8%$'&%#","#'"$"&& ,/86%9"="'"%! !!7"$7%;#,5.9"'%;"=/$'&%#",%'67%& 7", 6"

';:",&%#":%!7%'!7"+ ,6%''"/" , '#8:7%;"0 &&%'6,#",&%'&.$7$ &"&7 ;;8 !",! ?%'6 %'!$'&%#", !%'&.$7"9%#"'$" &+ /=" 9 %; =;"8, !7"+"#%$ ;0%'%'8 &!7"$ &"+ /="8,"$,# %'#%'6 %',"&0"$!7%& 6" '#"%!7",!7""9%#"'$"&0"$%%"# %' '/!7"$; .&"&

%8 %%8 %%%,%'!7" =&"'$"

:7","8$; .&" =&7 ;;="!7"$'$;.&%9"0,!7"

6" &,"6 ,#&&.$7$7%;#,!7"5.9"'%;"%'$';%$!:%!7 ; :I

.;"!7"@ .;"&8,"0,#.$"# =9"8$;" ,;/ &7:&!7 !,#"!",+%' !%' 6"8!7",";% '$"%&!="0; $"#' + !,%$.; !%',"G.%9 ;"'!$",!%%$ !"&8% 9 %; =;" '!7"0,"&"'! $ &"8; .&"

%%&'! 00;%$ =;" &!7"+ !,%$.; !%'$",!%%$ !"%& '! 9 %; =;" *"$'#8$+"&# !"=%,!7,+!7"&$7;%,&! !!"'#"#!7",!7 ' 0; /&$7; '#%'!7" =&"'$"!7","8!7" =%,!7$",!%%$ !"%&&."#=/ ,0, !%', .'%$%0 ;.!7,%!/,

'$7 / ! $ ' =" ,";%"# .0' ' !7" 0,"&"'! $ &"8 !7" =%,!7 $",!%%$ !",+!7"&$7;,"$,#8%':7%$7*""+ 6! #+%&&%'%' !7"&"$'#$; &&8: &0,#.$"# '#!7"$",!%%$ !",+!7"&$7;

4B4 %,&! !!"'#"#=/7",: &'!0,#.$"#7"&.,9"/,"$,# E ) !7" '6 ': ,% <,?", %& '! =%,!7 $",!%%$ !"8 %&&."# =/ ,0, !%'8 .'%$%0 ;.!7,%!/, '$7 / !7",","8%'!7"

=&"'$"!7" =9"4'!"#8+"#%$ ;0%'%'%&!="&.67!,+ !7" "#%$ ; ,#,"6 ,#%'6!7" 6" 5.9"'%;", $7%;# !!7"9",/.!&"!8 +!7"9%":!7 !!7",#",!7" ;" ,'"###%!%' ;*"&&%'&.#6"8 7! ?80; $%'67" 9/,";% '$"

.0'!7"&.,9"/,"$,# E )8%&$'!, ,/!!7"0,$"#.,", #"!",+%'%'6 6" &; %##:'%' .;"!7"@ .;"& '#!7"

%+0.6'"#,#",# !"#80 &&"#=/!7";" ,'"###%!%' ; 7! ?8%&;% =;"!="&"! &%#"'!7%&&$,"';/ :8!7"G."&!%'%& &!:7"!7",!7"# !"=%,!7!7" ,"9%&%'%&! 7","%' %& ! =" $$"0!"# & @ , BA> '!7"&$7;,"$,#:7"," $$.&"#*""+ ,"9%&%'%&!

7","%' : & #+%!!"# %' !7" /" , B %" +.$7 ="," !7" $++%&&%' $,%+" %' !7" /" , B8 7", # !" =%,!7 : & +"'!%'"# &BA7"&! !"+"'! +3 ., <&7:& !7 ! $$.&"#*""+ ,"9%&%'%&!7","%': & #+%!!"#%'&"$'# $; &&')B*7".,!7",&! !"#!7 !!7" %# 9%!!7" !7", !7" $$.&"# ,"9%&%'%&!7","%' !!"&!"#'@)B,"6 ,#%'6 !7"# !"7",=%,!78: &0,#.$"# !!7"!%+" #+%&&%'7"," : &',"$,#7",7 9%'6&!.#%"#%' '/!7",&$7;7"$0/ !7" %6, !%'",!%%$ !"%&''"E.,"4 47",","8,+!7"

4@4 &! !"+"'! + 3 ., <8 %! %& 0,9"# !7 ! ! !7" !%+" #+%&&%'%'!7"&$7;'!7"= &%& %# 9%!!7" !7",# !"# @)B8*""+ ,"9%&%'%&!7","%': & #+%!!"#%'!7"

&$7;')B%'&"$'#$; && '#7",# !"=%,!7%'!7" &$7;: &,"$,#"# &BA *7": &:%!7#, :',+!7" &$7; ' 7" $0/ !7" %# 9%! !7", !7" ,"9%&%'%&!7","%'%&''"E.,"4 4A '#: &+ ,?"#=","

!7"!,% ;.,! & ,?11'!7" %# 9%!8%!%&&! !"#!7 !*""+ "9%: &'"9", &!.#"'!9",'+"'!&$7;, '/,"$6'%J"# &$7;!="%'6&8%!%&$;" ,!7 !*""+ "9%: &8,!7"%,&!!%+"8 #+%!!"#%'9",'+"'! ,%+ ,/*$7;8*.' ,% '3 ; '8 7! ?8%'

&"$'#$; &&8:7","%''!7"= &%& %# 9%!!7" !7",# !"# @)B87",# !"=%,!7: &,"$,#"# &BA%'&$7; ,"$,# '!7%&: /8!7"$ &"!7"0,"&"'! $$.&"# ,"9%&%'%&!%& $9","#.'#", .;"

%%!7"@ .;"& 7" ;;"6"# $$.,,"'$"!?0; $"'AB8:7%$7+" '&!7 ! !!7"!%+" $++%&&%'$,%+"8*""+ ,"9%&%'%&!7","%': & B/" ,&8B+'!7& '## /& '#: & 5.9"'%;""'#", 7"0"E.,!%'!7" .!7,%! !%9"0,'.'$"+"'!%'

,%+%' ;@ 7";#!7 !0,%+ ,/%+0,! '$"!!7"# !"=%,!7$",!%%$ !"%&&."#=/ !7"&$7;%,&! !!"'#"#8!7"6"'.%'"'"&&:7%$7%&'!#%&0.!"#8 %&!="6%9"'7","%&'G."&!%',";/%'6.0'!7"$",!%%$ !" %&&."#=/!7"9%;; 6"7:?%# ,7" .!7,%!/: &;;:"#; !",'

44 %'9 ,%.&$ &"&=/!7%&.,! !="%'6&8 +!7"9%":!7 !!7"%+0.6'"#,#", # !"#80 &&"#=/!7";" ,'"###%!%' ;*"&&%'&.#6"8

7! ?8%&'!&.&! %' =;"%'!7""/"&; :$$,#%'6;/8!7"& +" %& &"! &%#" '# %! %& #"$; ,"# !7 ! $$.&"# *""+ ,"9%&%'%&!

7","%' : & 5.9"'%;" ' !7" # / $++%&&%' $,%+" %" AB8 &7";# =9"7",","8 $$.&"#*""+ ,"9%&%'%&!

7","%'%&!="!," !"# & 5.9"'%;" '# $$,#%'6;/8&7"$.;#'! ="!,%"#=","!7";" ,'"###%!%' ;*"&&%'&.#6"8 7! ?8 '# %&!="!,%"#=/!7".9"'%;".&!%$" ,#$$,#%'6;/8!7"0,"&"'! ,"9%&%'%& ;;:"# 7" ;" ,'"# ##%!%' ; *"&&%'& .#6"8 7! ?8 %& #%,"$!"#!! ?"'"$"&& ,/&!"0&8%'!7";%67!!7%&,#",

2 * ) &5?&