← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/49775/2017allowed

Balbir Singh v. State Of Haryana

2018-02-20Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri5 pages

Sumit Gulati 2018.02.21 11:55 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document chandigarh

  

      

   

    

 

     

     

          





 

   

 









         !"#$"% &'()(*')#+'#+%('+,  (*' -'$(./%(. /

00.&'#)0(*'&%$' %1'23)/+*3% .$!#'$' (% +*%$. 0)#1'+(*%( ) 23(4)&%$'$.

'

(*'!#'$' () '% +(*'% )(*'# 56+%('+ , 7" +'#'&(.) $67685% +56 #'/.$('#'+%()2.&'

(%(.)  .(3.$%#.$!' +. /%/%. $((*'!'(.(.) '#%$4'22%$)(*'#&) -.22%/'#$% +'9&'!((*%((*'#'.$ ))(*'#&%$'!' +. /%/%. $(*.1

*'!'(.(.) '#*%$0.2'+(*'!#'$' (%!!2.&%(.) " +'#'&(.)

0)#/#% ()0:%.2.  ;+%('+7 7" +'#'&(.) 5;

 #'/.$('#'+%()2.&'(%(.)  *% +.1% +.#.$(#.&(% &*<"2%  '%# '+&)" $'20)#(*'!'(.(.) '#&) (' +'+(*%(. .(.%223% )&&"##' &'*%+(%<' !2%&') 5 57%(-.22%/''<*!"#%'*$.2% $. .$(#.&(.$%#% +%  7" +'#'&(.) $867 66855755% +,; % +'&(.) ,)0#1$&()2.&'

(%(.) %+%#% $.4%$#'/.$('#'+%/%. $( "1:'#)0%&&"$'+. &2"+. /

 +'&'%$'+*%/4% %$$ *'#'%0('#) 6 7$%.+*%/4% %$$4%$(#% $0'##'+())2.&''%+="%#('#$%(% &*<"2%% +) , 7 %(('1!('+()&)11.($".&.+':3/" $*)(4.(**.$$'#-.&'#'-)2-'#.

00.&'#$> '$$%(% &*<"2%% +4%$&) $'="' (23%+1.(('+. 2&*'1.$( )$!.(%2% &*<"2%4*'#'*'#'1%. '+%+1.(('+(.227 7% ++.'+

*'#'%0('#(*' . (*'!#'$' (&%$'4%$#'/.$('#'+%/%. $((*'!'(.(.) '# % +  &)%&&"$'+  " +'#  '&(.)  5;    )  7 7  (  4%$  0"#(*'# &) (' +'+(*%((*'!'(.(.) '#$"##' +'#'+:'0)#'(*'2'%# '+(#.%2 )"#() ;

 7% +$. &'(*' *'.$. &"$()+3% +#'!)#(" +'#'&(.) 75

*%$%2#'%+3:'' $":1.(('+. (*.$&%$'

*'(#.%24.22(%<'%2) / (.1'% +%$$"&*(*'&"$()+3)0(*'!'(.(.) '#4.22 )2) /'#$'#-'% 3 !"#!)$'

(*')(*'#*% +2'%# '+(%('&)" $'2)!!)$'+(*':%.2) (*'/#)" +(*%((*'+'&'%$'+4%$4)#<. /%$'!"(3"!'#. (' +' ()0 )2.&'. %3#% %% +) %&&)" ()0(*'*%#%$$1' (&%"$'+:3(*'!'(.(.) '# % +)(*'#&)%&&"$'+*'&)11.(('+$".&.+'% +%$$"&* )&%$'.$1%+')"( ()/#% (:%.2()(*'!'(.(.) '#

'%# '+  &)" $'2  0)#  (*'  &)1!2%. % (  *%$  %2$)  -'*'1' (23 )!!)$'+  (*'  :%.2  )  (*'  /#)" +  (*%(  (*'  !'(.(.) '#  .$  *%-. /  &#.1. %2 :%&</#)" +% +. -.'4)0(*'0%&((*%(% )(*'#&#.1. %2&%$'.$!' +. / %/%. $(*.1*'+)'$ )(+'$'#-'(*'&) &'$$.) )0:%.2 '%# '+&)" $'2 *%$0"#(*'#%#/"'+(*%((*'$".&.+' )('+%('+, 74#.((' :3(*'

+'&'%$'+&2'%#23#'-'%2$(*%(*'&)11.(('+$".&.+') %&&)" ()0*%#%$$1' ( 1'('+)"(:3(*'!'(.(.) '#% +)(*'#&)%&&"$'+

'%#+:)(*$.+'$% +!'#"$'+(*'!%!'#:))<

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

(.$%22'/'+. (*'!#'$' ( (*%( %1 "1%#'(& $"!!)#('+(*'!'(.(.) '#. (*''2'&(.) 0)#(*'!)$()0%#!% &* %/%. $(  (*'  +%"/*('#  @))?%A  )0  *%/4%  %$$  @+'&'%$'+A  4*)  4%$ $"!!)#('+:3":*%$*% +)(*'#$ *'#'0)#'(*'#''9.$('+%!)2.(.&%2#.-%2#3 :'(4'' (*'1% +(*' %1'$)0*%/4% %$$@+'&'%$'+A% +%(3% %#%3% 4'#'0%2$'23#)!'+. (*' 4*.&*2'+()% %(('1!(()&)11.($".&.+':3 *%/4% %$$) , 7% +"2(.1%('23*'+.'+) 7 7

$!'#(*'&%$')0(*'!#)$'&"(.) (*'$".&.+'4%$%(('1!('+:3 *%/4% %$$) , 7% +(*'#'%0('#*'4%$%+1.(('+()2&*'1.$( )$!.(%2% &*<"2%4*'#'*'$"&&"1:'+()*.$. ?"#3) 7 7% +%  4%$2)+/'+%/%. $((*'!'(.(.) '#% +)(*'#&)%&&"$'+" +'#'&(.) 5; 

 *'$".&.+' )('+%('+, 7 %22'/'+234#.((' :3 *%/4% %$$#'%+$%$" +'# C         

  

  

       



   

  

6    

    

     



   

     !

 

 !

 !

    "#          



$% &'$($&)D 2(*)"/*(*'-'#%&.(3)0(*'%22'/'+$".&.+' )('4.22:'$'' %( (*'(.1')0(#.%2:"('-' .0.(.$():'(%<' ) .($0%&'-%2"' ))00' &' " +'#'&(.) 5; .$1%+')"(%/%. $((*'!'(.(.) '# $!'#(*'-'#$.) . (*'!#'$' ( %$4'22%$(*' 7#'/.$('#'+%( (*'. $(% &')0% ?%3"1%#$) )0 %1"1%#%+1.(('+23%="%##'2*%+ ' $"'+:'(4'' :)(*(*'!%#(.'$. (*'.#-.22%/''<*!"#%) 5 7.

4*.&*(*#''!'#$) $+.'+% +(4)#'&'.-'+. ?"#.'$0#)1(*'$.+')0% ?%3 "1%#. &2"+. /% ?%3"1%#*.1$'20% +(*'!'(.(.) '#4%$ )4*'#'. !.&("#'

*'!'(.(.) '#4%$ '-'##'!)#('+():'(*'!%#()0(*'="%##'2(*%( ())<!2%&') 5 7 )#% 3&)1!2%. (4%$2)+/'+:3*.1%/%. $( *%/4% %$$'(&  (*'!#'$' (  &%$'(*'#'.$  '.(*'#% 3%:'(1' ( %((#.:"('+()(*'!'(.(.) '# )#% 3%22'/%(.) @$A(*%((*'!'(.(.) '#. $(./%('+ +'&'%$'+*%/4% %$$()&)11.($".&.+'

*'1"#+'#&%$'4%$#'/.$('#'+ %((*'. $(% &')0% ?%3"1%#%/%. $(*%/4% %$$% +*.$:#)(*'# '(& % +(*"$(*'!'(.(.) '#&% )(:':2%1'+0)#(*'$%1'  (4%$) 23 % ?%3  "1%#  $)  )0  %1  "1%#  4*)  2)+/'+  (*'    %1. /   *%/4% %$$. 1"#+'#&%$'% + )((*'!'(.(.) '# *'#'0)#' 

 (*.$ )"#(.$)0(*'-.'4(*%((*'. /#'+.' ($ '&'$$%#3()!#)-'(*'%:'(1' (

, ()&)11.($".&.+'%/%. $((*'!'(.(.) '#%#'2%&<. /%$(*'!#)$'&"(.) *%$ 0%.2'+  () $*)4  % 3 1%('#.%2  %/%. $(  (*' !'(.(.) '# ()  &) '&(  4.(*  (*' &)11.$$.) )0)00' &'" +'#'&(.) 5;

'!)#(" +'#'&(.) 75

*%$%2#'%+3:'' $":1.(('+  *%#/'$%#'3'(():'0#%1'+ *'(#.%2 4.22(%<'%2) /(.1'

*'#'0)#' )"$'0"2!"#!)$'4)"2+:'$'#-'+:3 <''!. /(*'!'(.(.) '#. ?%.2

  -.'4  )0  (*'  %:)-'  (*'  !#'$' (  !'(.(.)  .$  %22)4'+  (*' !'(.(.) '#.$/#% ('+(*'&) &'$$.) )0:%.2()(*'$%(.$0%&(.) )0(*' *.'0 "+.&.%2 %/.$(#%('E"(3 %/.$(#%('% &*<"2%

)(*. /$(%('+*'#'. %:)-'$*%22:'&) $(#"'+%$% '9!#'$$.) )0)!. .) ) (*'1'#.($)0(*'&%$'

 ':#"%#3 !      "

"2%(.

  F*'(*'# '!)#(%:2'

 '$ F*'(*'#!'%<. /E '%$) '+  '$