High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/50775/2018dismissed

Jarnail Singh And ORS v. State Of Haryana

2023-03-20Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih,Mr. Justice Alok Jain17 pages

#$ $ $%$ $ $

$ $

& '' () *

$ +,

- #!.

$!!.

$. +,

- #!.

$, / #$

# $%"

# &

!" '"!("#)

" "*# +!" "

#(", !"# "

!("# $%"

# - !.

"( .

"# , "/""# - ! $!!.

$.* #- 1/ #&.. % "2$3- & .

#&! !%!",,* ! ." 2/ ",+ "".., %"

456++" &

789:7;:2;

++-

*.% *"*"

- )" ,/# !"-

-%!.% * 2" . !%%, "&2/ !.

#&!&

",#!" .. !.%

%"$ ,/# $

# !/!" " -- $ 2/ $,$ *",,

!"%% . !% )2 &! !/".." !&

32< " . "

!# !/!"

",,/ , -) ", $ &

")","3-

"$ !"%% -) ! *-,"&- *

!). )"3-"% * , /-* $ *-",$ %"

!")","3-

% !"%% &! !/".. ."' !# &!

%! !/ !" %, * $

, % * ) %

7=7++ ).* #&!

%! %!",,*# !" %) "%%, "

" - ! .

2 * "' "' ! ))"/ .% * %

455++#

&""-

%"&! !/& > 2.% 2/&"/-*," ", !" .

".""

%).,"

#"% ).,"

2/%

789:7;++" &

456++" 23%

:7;#2- , - !+!

- ","* #

"#- "'

*%* ?"%"*"

"'"%

"*"

!)". !.$ -%

454++2/

"" %" 2% % 2/ !2, %% - " %,- !.

!" "

"%'

).* 2/"

")" "

/.% #","

& %

456++#!" 2%)., &

! !""

-),"

# )" "

!, "., "/ > /#&!

%!!" 2 !. %"2-.% *

!)"

." -) #

" 2/!

) .

!.% *" "'

*" % 2/." ).* #

%&" !.

# !#$ ,"

!. % .,-

3".., %"

-) 2/ "," 2/ - * ! - %$

." 2/ ! ", + &!

, %$

!"%% &!"&!

, ", *&

! ! ) * $2/

+ ".%

#".

&"<. 2/ ",+ #&!

%!!"2$2"

) !. ).* !&

",3".., %"

- . ) " # !-#

! >

-" !.

!"$ *2-) 2" # ," %,- !.

!"" ).* #"." 2/ 2,&#%" " $ 2

" - " %,- ! # !!" #!"%

1%!( *) - @2,.)+ 01 .'

3) (4 $ (-$

6)'

(4 $ (-* A669:A;

+:+ ",;7BC#&!

, ", *&

! !".% -!, *"> / !.$ -%

456++#!"!, !.

%" 2-) 2/ $&

! % %

*"., "/> /# -

!-)"

-".

!& . 2,!- !%

@2,.)+ !"!, !" > 2 .$ ".#"*"

&!).% * %

456++ " &

789++" 2

, "%!"",2 .,"% ."( *) - @2,.)+ ('')$. & ( )( * :A66A;7++A94# &!

%!( *) " !.

<. !"

( *) !"2.!, 2/ !+

1%!#

.. !%

- - ).* #," %,- ! !"% !""..,

. ) " !"#

"..%

!$ %"&,," !%!",,". # .% %) " % $%%, &

!*" !"

-"%

!.% * 2

"*"

! ! % !)" "

#","

& ! " . 2/

@2,.)+ # " ,/-,,& " %)., &

!2/

",+ %",, *- -%2/ + !.

7D !"$ % ! 2) )" 2/ ! ," %,- !."

" &

! " "%#!"$* !*! ( *) - %$

- ! "%% # "*"

&!) ! ", &" % % #"." -) ).* ." 2/ ",+ ",,& *

!".., %"

456++" &

789:7;:2;+ + -

!+ -+ ",% #78B4 ".., %"2, ",, % ", .% * " % , ! .% ", ".% - " )

% % , !% ) !% / -) ,"& - !* "%- &! !/ ",&

!.""

"2, !-"

! !% /2/. !

!* , /- !% )%))

&$#

", "'%"-"

&! !%

?&!, 2-"

+ #&!

%!&, 2, !""% ",%.

"%/ 2$ -(

%+!".

EE- !++ ",&

! !.$ "

--% "--%

! " )

- (

% %

456 +!".

EE-++ ",&

! !")" - !" /-%

!") . % ! 2,&

:7; D!#."".., %"

2!",-

!& #"/+ -.

% " > /!, 2)" "/ --%- %,":2;-23%

:7;-%

789#&!

%!".." !"$2%))

".% + #" !%")"/2# .% -"

%) . % * $ $ % ".%

+ #%!+ )"/#"- %!., "/ > /# -"/# "

'%"/#3 :"; % "- --% :2; )"'"%).,"

!- &

*F :%;

""* - !- %,"!"$ (

F : ;

"'-- %

/- !"..""%- "%% 2-%!"* # - !",,* --% 32"

,"2," '

%"/ # !"%% % / %!"* F" :; $"/. ".."" * $$ % 2-%!"* :A;

!.&%- "+ 2/23%

:7; .% -"--%)"/# "/%"&! + !"

!)" "%).,"

23%

:7; .% -

--%(% "".., %"

- !)"'

*-%!

%).,"

#2<% 2/ &!

%!%!-) + 2 "

!)" *-23%

:5;- %

789 :4; %).,"

)" %

!",,2 * #3 :"; &! )"'

!%).,"

*! + #2/%!-- %- " )"/"..

:2;

"/ !%"#2/ !.

*-- %- + :5; %

#G+ G!" !"))" *" %

789H % %

",&

!.% )

789# !-#%

789 . % ! 2,& I789%

-% ).

-,"&-," !

/-.2, $" #---%"*"

.2, %(

%" ---% ,"

%) * $ $ % :7;+ !",, "'%* ?"%3 :";:

;-"/--%. !"2, %

7BA 7CC :2 ! %, $;- ! "",+ :59-7C=6;# :

;-"/"2 ) -#"

%))

#%!--%# :

;-"/% ",%.

"%/ %))

%!--%# <%.

!%).,"

*- !.2, %$"

%% -) !.2, %$" &!)! " )

$,/2 "

:2;:

;-"/--%. !"2, "/- -,,& *%

- ! "",+ :59-7C=6;# "),/#%

784 78=:2 ! %, $;#788#A66# A69 A77:2 ! %, $;" AAC#&!%!--% ",,* !"$2%))

# ,"

#"/ .% "/+ # :

;-"/--% % 2 %

5=4#. !"2, %

5B7#%

5B9%

5B=#- !"

+ # &! %! --% ",,* !"$ 2 %))

.% -" %) . % * $ $ % ".% "/+ # :

;-"/% ",%.

"%/ %))

%))

# !"2 ) -#"/--%.% - 23 %,":

;23%,":

;#<%.

!%).,"

*- + #-) !+ &!

+ 2 "

:A; D!"%).,"

!"2)" 2/".2, %$"

%,":";-23%

:7;"/" !

/ &!

%!!

" )

$,/2 "

)"/ !&

! "&",-

!%).,"

" "%./-%! F" .

% .

2/ #- !.% *!",,2

"' !%).,"

$ %!&

! "&", !",,2 - ", -- "%!" 2%%, :4;

%," :2; - 23 %

:7;# ! )G + )""+ $ ,#$+ ",+ #" %, "

2",%

2/ "+ ",#$ % ", % - %," 2/ % 2"+ - !..-

:5; !..-%,":2;-23%

:7;#"

+ !",,2 ) 22 "

"..", " ,/, -) !"..","2, % % -%!-)+ # !%"-"+ $ ,+ -) &! %"..", " ,/, # !. % .",+

!"$ * "/ * ",% $ ,(

&!,%", (

%!+ $ ,+

$ :"; &!"..",, ) !"+ # ..,,"

+ - - (

!",, 2 + &!

%! %! + !",, 2 ) 2 2 "

F :2; &!"..",, "+ $ ," ", "$ + #%!+ !",,2 ) 22 "

!+ $ ,$+ "%% !"

!%".% %%

!&!

%! --% ",,* !"$2%))

H C !.$ -%

456++#

%,",/ )

- - !.

% "> /!, 2)" "/--%-

+,":2;-23%

:7;-%

789++&!

%! &

*" .%

-% ).

-,"&-," !

/-.2, %$" # ---%"*"

.2, %(

%" ---%,"

%) * $ $ %#" &!

%!".." !"$2%))

".% + .% - !$ %* $ . % !.% * + # !%!+ "- %!

., "/ > /# -"/#"

'%"/)"/% "-

--% #)"'%).,"

""* --

%,"!"$ *(

!& @)"/@ %$/ !

)" "

/ %)., ,/2 )"'., "/ > /2-.% * %

456++#" .$

", % %

* - ., "/ > / .*"

$- -

'%"/ - !&

- '%"/ % % ., "/> /#

)"/ 2-.% * %

456++#2 &! !.

# ! *!)"

.% * !

% % ., "/> /#&!

,.% * %

456 + +# ! + % $ %# "' %) %

% "

%" *!

3"&"/!, * , /"/. 8 %," !# ! %

? - ! % / - !"$ - ") ", *!

# !") %., &

! 2, *"

" /

."' ! -,"&%

456" &

789- ++ - !<%.

!*",, "/.%", * "%).,"

-"--%D!"--% %))

- !

*-",$ %

"% %

784+&!

%! %$ %

789:7;:2;:

;++" !% ")"2, 2.%

"*"

456++ !2(%

$-%

456-++

"% " &! !"/--%"--%

!" )

- (

%!"2%))

% !--%!"",,* ,/"--%

.% *# &,,3).&

!% % *

% % "> /" J .%-*!)"

",% #-)

!.% * ! /> ) ,*",2, *"

%" !" !

%% "-- "/ ..

/ - !" * ! &, 2 "%% "*"

&!) "* ) *!

!.%

.% *

!"#$ %""& !"2%)" ! "/ &, * " % ",.% *"

# ) " )" 2/ ! &

# !&$ - ! " '& 2 &

#&! !/".."-

)/2- !%). +

-,"&# !/ ,-) ! ) " )"/%"# ! ) )" %

7=5-++"", , !&

,#&!

%!,

,/,"$ !

*!" / % !%"

!-,,/" !$ %> - %

!%" !"

"2 &

!%"&!

%!"- 2 &!

%!," - "% ",2 "<."/" !* %" " ,"/ %!. %/ !%

?- !% /!"$" *!

, * !%).,"

-"/--%* $"%! %" !)#

!/"", /2 ."' ! -,"& !

) *,/ "'"%

-)"'

!-", )

! + - ,"& . % ! %

? -) %"/J&" ,

!,"&#"!"2,"

&2/ @2,.)+

, ", *&

! !.$ #"% %

789:7;" 456 ++#)"'

").,/%," %

456.$ - !.%

2-,,& %")

789++ .

,"*"*-%

456#

!"2!, 2/ !.)+ # >2", *!"&"!@%":.";#"-,,& I7C$ &- !,"*"* %

456++ + 2 )"'"%).,"

*" *%)) -"--%- %

789:7;:2;#" !%

2/ ! & G+ - .

<. -(

%G !& %!"

%& ,,2" .

,/ - -(

%> " $/%"1-- , *- !%).,"

)"/!, "., "/> /" % "- --%

<. -(

% > / !, 2)" "/- !--%- %

789:

;:2; <. %/ & ,, )",,/2 ( * 2/ + 2/& *!

* !)"*

- (/-- 2/ ."--% 2/%!-*/-* %) #2 !"$ * *" !--% )."% #%!%)) ---%!" ." )

% . 2, %!-* %) -*/)"/%""$/ 2 "

(/ ". !

)"/ . $!

)-"$/ $","2,.. / !, '#2 %! %) )"/ 2( ".

%-$ %. % * $ $ % + #&!$,) $ %)"/!"$2" % "

!--% -%!.

%-$ % !2" %%.

- " )

- (

% )"/ 2 ) )", %!

%) "%# )"/ %

% )"'"%).,"

!2" $ &- %," :2;:

;# " %"$" 2/ ," %, - "..,," #&, !$

)-%!-*/-* %) ) /, / .

%! ," "

&!"$

)-"% ) ) /,#!"

2 %" 78 ! " !% "

%!!" 2'.

23%

:7; -%

456++ % ).,"

!, *-"., "/> /)",,/#" %

- - , *-"%).,"

)" !. %/- .% *2- " "

! "*&!

! .% * %%, " ! - ", ( *) %

457.$ -""..","*"

*- , *- !%).,"

!!" *" ,

% - ! "..", 2 "'

454 :A;%-" %

."+ / !%).,"

" ( !!" *- !%" -

2*!

""..", . *"*"

! % " $ "

( ",.% * -&!

%! !)"

!"" $ & - !.$ # !%).,"

%")"/ .% "

",, - %" .% ",,/ )"

" * -% $ ,

&! % "%!",,* %% $"..,,"

-"&!

%!"

) %) * ", 2

% !

.$ -"..","*"

" ." %

454 :A;#&!2/!" *- !%" " (

, ! % - ! "..", ! .$ !& # ",

/# .% .% 2 -- , *"%).,"

2/ %!

)"/ -%

-/ !"% ", ",- !-- -" ",,/,*. ,"/ .%

-"* , /. %) !

" $" "*"&

2%),% " * $ $ % " ! $ % * , ). "

% "

" -) "%%.

* ! 2"

2.,"% .%,":2;:

; A6 ,"* .

789:7;:2;:

;# &!2/ ! 2" %"

2/ ! "

.$ &, ", ."

&! "- %)) - " "% - -*/ %) 2> ,/. % + # %"."2,- *"

) .

"%!

"" *!#"- .." *"-* %) %))

*""% --*/#"

.)"/)""* * ".%

"/% $ ,# % ", $ % #

! 2/ !

),- !*!

) .2/!

)" ).,/- , ! %) !"

.% * &, ! 2 . % -) .%

"%-". $"

." / !., %

, + #&! ! %) !"2- , #

,-%! - , "%).,"

)"/2".,*

%! ! "% ", ", - %! " . )"/ 2 ,"/

,/%!" .

&, !!

*!,/ ) ",

-% /"

,"*

A7 ",

%%"2 "'- !-"% " )",,/,% " % - , *-"% ",%).,"

" %!"% ",/" .

& ,, 2-"

" ..

* $" .

%!," "

&!". ",,* !"$%))

"--%- /.)"

%,":2;:

;

! .,"% - ","%% -3 - , *-"%).,"

-"%).,"

- , # !") %)

,* %", * *-)%!""*,& ,,2

%"% &

! ! . % ., " &'"2,

)."%

%"2, , !, 2 "$ / .

2/"% 1 :

;.""474# . % .,!"2 !-,,& *)"

!% ' "$ "% %

-""% )

. % " &'"2, )."%

%"2, , # % , ',/ !"$ 2 2/ ", ") )

) !&$# ! " $

* "-"..,/ *%!"% %

#-<")., &!

".." ", ") ",,/

",)" *G

!," " !!"- !-- , +

/+% ,$ '!

$ % :7887;7D9C"

B7#&!

&"!, "

G", ") "' !%"/ * -

"% ) 2&'"2, )."%

%"2,# % & ,,2,& - -"$-"% %

," !%>% -,,& !."

! "' 2/( * $,.

!%)),"& !%)) ,"&-*," !" ",&"/ $,. ,/ ,* %",, #" &! !,* %," &"."

2 &

!."%

%", -- %,

!% !"$

2- *!

" " ' !."*)"

& ,,2 $ ! -% /G "* $ + ) " <% +)) :78B8; A ,, 87# &!

, .

* "

.$ ! "%% #78BA# *2$

- !,

",% %

," )."%

%"2,, #

&, 2%"/ ,

," ( ) " )"' %

&'"2, !-# "$

)-"% )- -*/#"),/# !."** $ "2, <% !

%- 2/,"&

- !-- #

%"/ .,"%"

$ .

%,":2;

; AA *!$ !"",* %&" ", *&

.",.$

!, 2 ,/% " .. - ..

!!".,"% , "%."+

1%! % ,""),)",$ -1)2"/#7899 :7;+79C#&!

&"!,

&,,

, ,- % %

- .", - & . 2, " ""2,% %

%"2. .".",.$ # + ) ," &" % %

%!<).

2(% -).", /"

! !" !&!

%! )..", / "

%). - %! !)" * -<. 2/ !,* ,"

%"/

- !,* ,"

789:7;:2;:

;"-- . %

-) . $"

!, 2* $"

$ .

% ,

%.D""2, "%%.

%!2" ..

"!" 2*!

2* +"

"&:78B7 3 +!".

A7;# !. % .,*" *.",.$ !"2 "

G1 .", ) $2% "

"& !& - ! !<%, -%" &!

%! !& "/"%%.

&, %).! 1 &! 2*!

!& " &

# !".","% )

2% #, '"/ ! ) #"%% *

!-"

%)))" *- !,"*"* # " ! % - )"' "/ 2 ")2 *

/ !,"*"*-".", #&!%!

2 ")2 *

/&, %,",/ 2- )"

!"),"*"* "/ ! ) G ",

"","$1)2"/ "+A664:4;+:+ ",;

B=:+; A664:=;++76B >

&"<") % "2, ,"

&"!, !. % ., "

*"--% ). *".", / 2 ,/% - $",".., %"

%!)

%" ,/22$ $/%" "- - *

, !"*!"(/"$ -"!"" !"78B= +78A8# " )2"' !,"$ -"!""!

" 78BB.)+ 549#. " ))2"% -*",--"

$ -D 1*",$2" "

/ 78B8 + 76A8 " - "!""!

" $ "

&",",

") " " 78C6 + 984 !, ! .", .$ !, 2 % " )" &!

%! & ,, .. ! ) %!

- " " $"% ! 2(% &!

%! ,* ,"

!" $ & A4 "." # !%

%!&"> . ".",.$ 2 ." -".% ",,"&#"),/# + - + ", % &!

%! ,"2"

,/ * $ .% - ",-% ",%" !.$ ,/%"

" 2" "*"

* %* ?"% - " --% %

.% -

<%.

.%).,"

2/+ .", . &!

%! " "%

- .",

%" 2 2*!

2/".2, %-- %2/"."** $ " "

.","%

& %, $/ %"

*" --%"*"

! # &!"

$ ! %!""% - .", / - ! --% ! . % ., " .", !, 2 ,/ % # " .(% 2/ ! ," %,- !"..,," %"# !-#!"$".., %"

!H - ) ! "2$#

".." ! / > ) ! + !, * $ ..

/ - !" * "%% 2-- , *"%).,"

%"/ "., "/ > / 2!, )" "

,/D!"

). " ".

2-) 2/ &

!*" "> /&!

%! ") 2

/-!, *"., "/> /#.$ !.

%"2 "%! &

! %!., "/> / !%).,"

# # 2

""., %. !"2!, #"

! "* "$ "* %

456++# %

!* , %% -"." /#"*"

&!).% *" 2 "'2- !"* 2 "

"*,/% *&! !

<. # - (

%# " > /!, 2)" 2/

-"/--%"--%

* " )

%D!

, .

!.",.$ #

!" 2 !.",.$ !, 2% ")"&!

& ,,.. !) %!

-" " $"% !2(% &!

%! !,* ,"

$ &

- %"# !-#2"-,/"

!.%--)"

-".

2/ #

- "'" % &! !

!, "., "/> / " ! %!)" "

%"# !& ".

-)%!".

".." "--%#"- %

456 ++#!"2%))

# )"/.% &

! !, *"

., "/> / %".

!"2-) &

!*" --%!"$ *2%))

456++#

)"'"%).,"

*" !")!" 2 ""* -%). (

!"* !" ",&

!%!"%).,"

454++" -

""., %. -

! !2" . % .,#&&.% %

).* " %,- !.

!"*!

.(%

" - ! ".., %"

-) 2/ " - #-%!" 2)" ! -%$

." 2/ ",+ &!

, ", * &

! !. 2)

7B4++"*"

!"%% - .", - ! ( *) # &!

%! - $ "

).* #&, !& ".., %"

-) " -)"

- .

!2" - !$ %, 2/ !.%

%, . #"2)

7B4++ !2) # !-# "!"2)" 2/ !," %,- !.

,-# %" 2"%%.

- !" !)"

",,$" -%) "

%%, " -) *".

. )"3-"% "2 !--%!"$ * 2%))

#")

456++#%" 2"

! ".., %"

- .", - ).* &, !& .

".., %"

-) 2/ &!

,." !"

).*

!"" * -.% *"*"

# .

# "(

- " %" 2-", &

! *!"2.

*" !2 *"/ ! ,,*",

/ -,,& !.$ - %

456++<%.

- !#"!"$2- "2$# " ., !2" - !,"&#"!"2,"

&2/ @2, .)+ )

"2$ 7- $ &- !"2$#- *)

# ") " ) 9$!!.

$.:

9$, / #$ :

() *

.( D! !."'

*J" J D! !. "2, J