High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3307/2005disposed of

Radhey Shyam Gupta v. Archana & ORS

2015-08-04Mr. Justice Permod Kohli7 pages

!" #"$%&%' ( ) #*"+,*+ -./! //"00 '! 1"2&.& 2$* ' 2& "&/'#"'!&

3*"!*"2"/2!"2& 4$ 0"5&/ /"2&- +6" 005"#! &""!*"7.#8-"'!9

6"2"

"22"#!!*""/2!"2&2'!9 3*"!*"2!*"7.#8-"'!&*.0#6"2"/2!"#%'!*"%8"&!9 2"&"'!: 2%!%'+ 0#1$ !" 2 2, '7""1./! ;#1$ !" 2!*" //"00 '! 2, "* '#%2 !! ;#1$ !" 22"&/'#"'!! & '%'#"2< .2;#1$ !" 22"&/'#"'!) *%&%& ' //" 0#%2"$!"#6+ #*"+,*+ -./! //"00 '! 8 %'&!!*"5 2## !"#=

/ &&"#6+,*2%< - 0< '!;0" 2'"#

!2$$%#"'!0 %-&2%6.' 0; &!2 $>.2!;< 2' 0 1%#"5*%$* $0 %-/"!%!%'5 &/ 2!0+ $$"/!"# '#$0 %- '!&5"2"*"0#"'!%!0"#!$0 %- &;

; ?@' $$.'! #" !* #"$" &"#- 2#""/,%'8*%' -!2 1"*%$.0 2 $$%#"'!' A))

*" $!& &8 !*"2"# 2-!*"2"$2# 2"!* !' AA) #"$" &"#- 2#""/,%'8*5 &#2%1%'8 2.!% 26" 2%'82"8%&!2 !%'

@(@ (= '#5 &8%'8 2-< 2' 0!1%00 8"$* ' 5%!**%&

2%"'# 5 '<.- 25*%$*5 &'#."0"

!* '#&%#" !*"2 # '#!* !

! !'2- 0/2/"2 '#-#"2 !"&/""# '#5*"'!*" 2.!% 22" $*"# '" 2*5>'2 #;< 2' 0;%'!*"-" '5*%0"; 00 &.##"'; !2.$>6" 2%'82"8%&!2 !%'@ @)((6"%'8#2%1"'6+%!&#2%1"22 &*0+;

$ 2"0"&&0+ '#'"80%8"'!0+; $ -" 2-!*"//&%!"#%2"$!%' '#*%!!*"

2.!% 2 2-!*" 2'!&%#" '##."!%-/ $! !*" $$%#"'!#"$" &"# 2"$"%1"#&"2%.&;82%"1.& '#-.0!%/0"%'7.2%"& '##%"# !!*"&/!*" $$%#"'!%'B."&!%'!>/0 $"' $$.'! 2 &* '#'"80%8"'!#2%1%'8

!*" !2.$> 6+ 2"&/'#"'! = # !"# AA) .'#"2 ,"$!%'&

A '# (@ !*" 5 & 2"8%&!"2"# '# ' -.'!

& 0 $&5 &$0 %-"# &$-/"'& !%' "&/'#"'!5 &2"/2!"#!* 1"#%"# '#*%&0"8 0*"%2 2"&/'#"'! 5 &62.8*!'2"$2#;5* 0&/2$""#"#"C@/ 2!"'

(( 6+!*"2%6.' 0 ( "&/'#"'! 2"8%&!"2"#5'"2 !*" 2.!% 2 %0"# 52%!!"'&! !"-"'!2 %&%'8/2"0%-%' 2+67"$!%'&2"8 2#%'8- %'! %' 6%0%!+; 0$.& &! '#% '# -%&7%'#"2 '"$"&& 2+ / 2!%"& '# ''@7%'#"2

'"$"&& 2+/ 2!%"&"!$!* &6""'/0" #"#!* ! 5 '<.- 2./! * # /.2$* &"#!*" 2.!% 2 2-&* '@ '&5"2%'82"&/'#"'!') AA) '#;!*"2"

2";!*" '&5"2%'82"&/'#"'!* &'$'$"2'5%!*!*" 2.!% 2%' '+- ''"2 '#& %# 5 '<.- 2./! * #8!2"0" &"#!*"

2.!% 2'&./"2# 2%%'*%&' -" '# %'!"'!%' 00+#%#'!8"!!*"

2.!%$ 2!2 '& "22"#%'*%&' -""'+%'8!*"2 1"2-"'!& '&5"2%'8 2"&/'#"'!/2 +"# 2#%&-%&& 0 !*"$0 %-/"!%!%'

"&/'#"'!( * & %0"#&"/ 2 !"52%!!"'&! !"-"'! '# !> ./ /2"0%-%' 2+ 67"$!%' 2"8 2#%'8 - %'! %' 6%0%!+; 0$.& &! '#%; -%&7%'#"2 '#''7%'#"2 '"$"&& 2+/ 2!%"&"* &/0" #"#!* !*"%& '!!*"5'"2 !*" 2.!% 2 5"1"2;*" #-%!!"#!*" $!.-

$$%#"'! '# 00"8"#!* !!*" $$%#"'!* &! >"'/0 $"#."!2 &* '# '"80%8"'!#2%1%'8 !*"!2.$>"'+%'8!*"2 1"2-"'!&2"&/'#"'!( /2 +"# 2#%&-%&& 0 !*"$0 %-/"!%!%' = "/0%$ !%'!!*"52%!!"'&! !"-"'!&5 &'! %0"#2-!*"

/0" #%'8& !*"/ 2!%"&;!*" 005%'8%&&."&5"2" 2 -"#@ 3*"!*"2!*" $$%#"'!%'B."&!%'$ .&%'8#" !*

- 2#""/,%'8*5 &!*"2"&.0! .&" 1"*%$0"

6" 2%'8 2"8%&!2 !%' @ @)(( '#?2 1"*%$0" 6" 2%'8 2"8%&!2 !%' @(@ (= 9

%&&."%&/21"#;5*"!*"2!*"$0 %- '!& 2" "'!%!0"# ! $-/"'& !%'; % &; *5 -.$* '#

2-5*-9 3*"!*"2 !*"/"!%!%' %&'!- %'! %' 60"%'%!& /2"&"'! 2-9 (3*"!*"2!*"$0 %- '!&* 1"'0$.&&! '#%! %0"

'#- %'! %'!*"/2"&"'!/"!%!%'9

3*"!*"2 !*" /"!%!%' %& 6 # 2 -%&7%'#"2

.''"$"&& 2+ / 2!+ '# ''7%'#"2 '"$"&& 2+ / 2!+; & 00"8"#9 = "0%"

'&.//2! !*"%2$ &";$0 %- '!,-!2$* ' 5%#5 !*"

#"$" &"#*"2&"0 //" 2"# &3@ '# 0&"C -%'"# 5 '<.- 2 2"&/'#"'!( &3@ ) ' 2"6.!! 0 2"&/'#"'! * & *%-&"0 &!"//"# %'! !*"

5%!'"&&6C &3@ '#* & 0&"C -%'"#*0- # !*".2! *%"

( .#%$% 0 8%&!2 !";< 2' 0 A *"2%6.' 0;2"8 2#%'8%&&."; *"0#!* ! $$%#"'!* & ! >"'/0 $"#."!'"80%8"'!#2%1%'8 !2.$> '# 2.!% 2*" -.'!

$-/"'& !%'5 &$ 0$.0 !"# &&;

; ?@ *"2%6.' 0* &*"0# !* ! 2"&/'#"'! 6"%'8 0"8 0 *"%2 2"&/'#"'! #2%1"2 '# 2"8%&!"2"#5'"2 !*"!2.$> '#2"&/'#"'!6"%'82"8%&!"2"#5'"2

!*"$ 2 2"*"0#0% 60"!/ +!*" -.'! $-/"'& !%'*"%&&."5 & #"$%#"# $$2#%'80+ ""0%'8 #%&& !%& %"# 5%!* !*" 61" & %# 5 2# # !"# =

/ &&"#6+,*2%< - 0< '!;0" 2'"# !2$$%#"'!0 %-& 2%6.' 0; &!2 $>.2!;< 2' 0!*" //"00 '! #*"+,*+ -./! ; 2"8%&!"2"#5'"2 2.!% 26" 2%'82"8%&!2 !%'@(@ (= * & #%2"$!"#!*"/2"&"'! //" 0 * 1"*" 2#0" 2'"#$.'&"0 2!*" //"00 '! '#* 1"8'"

!*2.8*!*"2"$2#& !*"$ &" 4" 2'"#$.'&"0 2!*" //"00 '! * &&.6-%!!"#!* !%!%& /21"# 2-!*"2"$2#!* !1"*%$0"5 &&0#! 5 '<.- 2*"1"*%$0" 5 &! >"''&./"2# 2%6+ 5 '<.- 2*" 2.!% 2%'B."&!%'5 &%'

/&&"&&%' '#$'!20 5 '<.- 2 '# &&.$*!*" //"00 '!$ ''!6" *"0#0% 60"!/ +!*" -.'! $-/"'& !%' '2"/0+!!*" 61"'!"#$'!"'!%';$.'&"0 2 5 '

<.- 2* &&.//2!"#!*"5 2#!%&&.6-%!!"#!* ! //"00 '!* & %0"#! /21"&"00%'8 !*"1"*%$0" '#!*" //"00 '!* &2%8*!0+6""'*"0#0% 60"! / +!*" -.'! $-/"'& !%'

( * 1"$'&%#"2"#!*"&.6-%&&%'&- #"6+6!*!*"&%#"& '# * 1"8'"!*2.8*!*"2"$2#& !*"$ &" *"0" 2'"#2%6.' 0* &*"0#!* !&%'$" #*"+,*+ -./! %& 2"8%&!"2"# 5'"2 '# & &.$* *" %& 0% 60" ! / + !*" -.'!

$-/"'& !%'*"2%6.' 0* & 0&2"!.2'"# %'#%'8!* ! #*"+,*+ - ./! * & %0"#!/21"!* !1"*%$0"5 &&0# 5"1"2;!*"0" 2'"# 2%6.' 0* &-%&2" # '#-%&%'!"2/2"!"# !*""1%#"'$"'!*" %0" *"

2%6.' 0* &%!&"0 *"0#!* ! 5 '<.- 2* &! >"'%'!/&&"&&%'!*" 1"*%$0"'&./"2# 2%*"$ &" !*"$0 %- '!%&!* ! 5 '<.- 25 & !2 1"0%'85%!*!*"#"$" &"#%'!*"$ 2%'B."&!%' '# &&.$* 5 '<.- 2 5 &%'"

"$!%1"/&&"&&%' '#$'!20 !*"1"*%$0"!*"25%&" #*"+ ,*+ -./! * &/2#.$"#'2"$2# &./"2# 2%' - '!*" %0"%'5*%$* 5 ' <.- 2* &-"'!%'"# !* !*" * &/.2$* &"#!*"1"*%$0" 2- #*"+,*+ -./! !*2.8*

%# 1%! *%&.2!%' .!*2%!+ !"

# !"$#

% $ &'('&)('!"*+,) $-.''/" 0" "$!,.'*.',&*"0#!* !&.6&"B."'!/.2$* &"2%&*%-&"0 / 2!+#"&/%!"!2 '& "2 2"8%&!2 !%'2'!;!*"'&.6&"B."'!/.2$* &"2%' 2"&/"$! !*" $!!* !5*"2"!2 '& "2 1"*%$0"* &'!! >"'/0 $";%&0% 60"

!/ +!*" -.'! $-/"'& !%'*"0% 6%0%!+ 2"8%&!"2"#5'"25 & "22'".&%' $ &"5*"2"!*"2"5 & !2 '& "2 1"*%$0"6+#"0%1"2+!!*"

&.6&"B."'!/.2$* &"2*"!2 '& "2 5'"2&*%/ -!21"*%$0"!> /0 $"6+#"0%1"2+.'#"2,"$!%'A !*", 0"& #&$!!* &6""'

.2!*"2 6&"21"# 6+ !*%& .2! !* ! 2"8%&!2 !%' %& '0+ $%0%! !%1"

/21%&%'&/21%#"#.'#"2,"$!%' !*" !2D"*%$0"&$! '#%'

= $ &"& 5*"2" !*" &.6&"B."'! /.2$* &"2 5 & '! / 2!+; %' !* ! $ &" 2"8%&!"2"#5'"2$ '6"*"0#0% 60"6.!%'$ &"!*"&.6&"B."'!/.2$* &"2 *%-&"0 %& / 2!+;%'!* !$ &";*"$ ''!6""&$ /"# 2-!*"0% 6%0%!+! / +!*" -.'! $-/"'& !%'*2"".#8"&"'$* 'E60"/"C .2!%' .!*2%!+ 1% !2 " # !"$#

3$ "!.',+4,5 *))*"0#!* ! /"2&'5*%&%'/&&"&&%' '#$'!20 !*"1"*%$0"%&0% 60"!/ +!*" -.'! $-/"'& !%''

!*" & %# $ &"; 6 '> 5 & 2"8%&!"2"# 5'"2 6.! !*" 1"*%$0" 5 & %' /&&"&&%' '#$'!20 !*"6225"25** &'!%'&.2"#!*"1"*%$0" ,; $$"/!%'8!*" //" 0 !*"6 '>;%!5 &*"0#!* ! /"2&'%'/&&"&&%' !*"1"*%$0"%&0% 60"!/ +!*" -.'! $-/"'& !%'*" $!.-

/&&"&&%'

"'#%'8 1"*%$0" 6+ !*" //"00 '!; %' !*" &* /"

&./"2# 2%' - '# //0%$ !%' 2! >%'8!*"1"*%$0"'&./"2# 2%$0" 20+ &*5!* ! 5 '<.- 2* &*%-&"0 /0" #"#!* !*"%&!*"5'"2 !*"

1"*%$0" '#* &/.2$* &"#!*"1"*%$0"!*2.8*

%# 1%!* !!2 '& $!%'

* &! >"'/0 $"/2%2!!*" $$%#"'! *" #-%&&%'- #"6+ 5 ' <.- 2 %' !*" &* /" &./"2# 2%' - '# //0%$ !%' %& &.

%$%"'! ! $'$0.#"!* !*"%&!*"5'"2 !*"1"*%$0"*"!2% 0.2!* &%8'2"# !*"&"#$.-"'!&'!*"82.'#!* !'&/"$% %$ -.'!* &6""'-"'!%'"# *" #-%&&%'%&!*"6"&!/%"$" "1%#"'$"!*"2!* ' '"C/0 ' !%' = ,; %' !*"&" $%2$.-&! '$"&; !*" //" 0 /2" "22"# 6+ !*"

//"00 '!&! '#& $$"/!"#*"5 2#1%#"5*%$*!*" //"00 '!* &6""' *"0#0% 60"!/ +!*"$-/"'& !%' -.'!%&&"! &%#" '#%!%&*"0#!* ! 5 '<.- 25 &!*"5'"2 !*"1"*%$0" !!*"!%-" $$%#"'! '#*"

&* 00&* 2"!*"2"&/'&%6%0%!+!/ +!*" -.'! $-/"'& !%' 0'85%!* 2"&/'#"'!&; ' -"0+; - 27%!< .2;0"8 0*"%2 5'"2 !2.$>%'

B."&!%' '&"B."'!0+; !*" //" 0 &! '#& #%&/&"# %' !*" !"2-& -"'!%'"# 61" ) $/+ !*%&7.#8-"'!6"&"'!!!*"2%6.' 0 2&!2%$!

$-/0% '$" 45 16 7 '&.',+