Swaran Singh And Another v. Harpal Singh And Others
1-
!"#$!%&'&"()*++,
!"#$!%&'&"()*++,
-
!"#$!%&'&"()*++,
) ./
+ 0
/
!" # $
% '
()*+,(-+-. '
(*-)*(-+-. /$
% 0 )(
12 '
()*+,(-+-. '
(*-)*(-+-. /$
% '
(34)(-+-. !" # $
% '
(34)(-+-.
/1+ /
,&(
* 1 & &
2 &464 2& &
-2- 72
& ,&(
8 & (
12
% $%
822 &
%
*,2
1 & '
$ &
% 1 82 (
12
82
129 & :
&& % & 7 $%
" ;< =4$;< =- ;< =.
& '
()*+,(-+-. '
( *-)*(-+-.
8
%
2 1 1& $ $ 2 8&
& 82 (
12&
% -+-. 2$1
1
00 > &'
()*+,(-+-.$'
(*)-*(-+-. '
(34)(-+-. > & % 8 & 82 $ 8& 82
12 1 +,+,-+-- 82
-3-
1 >8$ # ? & &
@2&34( 5AB - '
(*-)*(-+-. 8& 82 1 $ 1 = 2 8
= % &( (
$
$1 1
(+,(-+-4$ % & 12 C !: 1
%
-*4--+-+ & % & 0 4 %88 0 #4.
66+3 &&
& >8 0 - %
& 0 4 $ 1
$ & 82
12 .
>8
4D$..$+++=(
1 $ & '
0 )*+, &-+-.
'
0 )*-* &-+-. 1
>8
&
$ &
12 >8 2 1 &@4)A82 "
8)4 2$ 2 8 &
$
1"
<1
-4-
)
1
2$
% ( 1 %
*
&
(1 1
&)4
)*2 &
81
8)42 %$
82
8 82<1
82 % &1 82
$ 1" $1
2 8 $
<1 &
= =8 &
8 D > >8
0
8 1
$ &;%
8$ %$
1
9
8 2
8
8 &1 8 & & ( 1 2
%
%8 &8 2 & ;% > 29
% 82
82<1
%$
82
-53 & 1 (
12
8 12$ (1 1 8 &
&
8 " %% $ (
1282 2 &
% %%
$ $ 8 1 *, 2 0 8
8
7 %
$ " 8 &21
2 %$1 %
8 "
& 1
2$
(1 1 8 " &
8 %&
1 $ " 8 *D
D+21 2
%
$ 8 2
$ $4=.
81 <& 1 1
1 2> & $1 &6 88 ,
% 9 1 82 9 1 1 82 >8
8 1 82
>8 2 " 1
86$+++=(%
-6-
111 28
" "
" 4*$+++=(& 1
"
"$ 2
4+$+++=( %$ 8 %(
1 82 # ( E(4
7 ( E(-
82 >8 1 8
82 2
2 % : &2 1 % 82 6
1 $ ( 1
12 2 &(% 1 1 82 8 <1 (%
%
(
2 " & 1
E(4(#
2 ( % 1& 1
4*$+++=( 12$7 ( E(-
2$ %8&& 821"4+$+++=(
4-$+++=(1 4+
8 <1 ( 1 2
2% =1
%$
1 1
( 1 $< 2$
%
8& 8 % 2
-7- 1:
2 & F
& 1
8 1 82
% 8
2 % =1 #
E(4 E(-
( 1 (%> 2 %
88
18 & 1 1 21
" 1 28 && %
>8
%
1 "82 " % E4 E(-> & $ "&
" 2 "$ 8 "
&& " 1 81 " "
& $ 1 "
8 4)$+++=( 1 6$+++=( "82 >8 $
1 2$ <
< &4=. %
8 &@6A 88 8
88 &*D
D+2 4+G
&
8 & 1 2 44
2$ ( " 28
( 1 1 ( & ( Income Rs.14,000/- per month Rs.14,000/- per month Future Prospects 10% (Rs.1400/-) Rs.15,400/- (14000+1400/-) Deduction 1/3rd (Rs.15400-5133) Rs.10263/- Multiplier Total loss of 10263X9X12 Rs.11,08,404/-
-8dependency Loss of Estate Rs.16,500/- (awarded by Tribunal) Rs.16,500/- Funeral Expenses Rs.16,000/- (awarded by Tribunal) Rs.16,500/- Loss of spousal and parental consortium Rs.44,000/-X 2 Rs.1,32,000/- Total Compensation awarded by the Tribunal Rs.16,33,000/- Total Compensation awarded in appeal Rs.12,73,404/- Difference of amount of compensation Rs.16,33,000/-(awarded by Tribunal) - Rs.12,73,404/- (awarded in appeal) Rs.3,59,596/- 4-
4-$3.$)+)=( ;< 1 $ & 2 $ 8 &
(
12 $ 1 8
2 8 2$'
0 34) -+-.& 82 (
12 '
0 )*+,
& -+-. '
0 *-)* & -+-. &
&8 % 1 4.
?B$&2$ & 4)
2 8 & &
/
*++, E "=
H=0
E 8 H=0