← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1436/2022dismissed

Gursewak Singh v. Punjab Agriculture Development Ltd.

2022-07-13Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj17 pages



  

      

 



 !"

#$

!%&

 &'



())  *+ ,* 





 -  .-

,- )     ( / - ) *. *)

+

           . *)

+ 1 )2 -3 

     !

"#$%$ #!$#    &#' ! 

! ' 

$%$ #!$#       .*

     (  #  ) #!*+*+%*%%

($

 , #   "  ( !!

-./+**.%*0./**.%*%0 '  # ) #!   *.*.%*0.



 !!( #-%0.%*01 2 )(

 #     3!  4"  !

 5

'"  #6    

 0+.-#(7 ! 0..0($ , #    "  (7 ' '!   !,#)#(   

'



!!($   #!(     #   '      8$      ' 

!!    * 4 $   !9   (  ($ )(#   3!4" ! 4 8 &"    "  (  # 

 4 #   0+.-#(7 ! 0..0 '#  

5

'"##'  (  ,#)# !!(" #  $ !#'    ($'$  ! $( !!!:'  

 $ ! !!!    9 ( # -%+0+%0  +**;%*01  '   )(- 4"4 ! 

%+****/ #   #  ($ $ #($ 

5

'"#

(  ,#)#'     !:'  !'

         $  $!!  !9 ' 

 

'   ##(    



 0<0*%*01! 9  '  !:! 9  '     0+.-#(7 !

0..0

 

5

'"#'  $

!!  # 

'    !' # $!      #        (          , #    "  (  # #  

) #!*.*.%*0.

  

  # # 

!  !   $ $

+***/  '

%***/ '

(# ! ! ("

     ) #!        '       

' 

()! #(   

 , #  "  (( #-

.%*0.

) #!*+*+%*%%'  !

 ) #!*.*.%*0.

($ , #     "  ('  

*    #( 

     # ! #9  (  

 '  (  ,#)# $('  #  9 9  ' $  

 (    (  ,#)#  (                   

   !4" (  $  !     # 9 9  '   $9 7

    $'#   '   !4" 7     

  #  # ! ' ("

 -**   

      ) #!  

  ($      ,  #    "  ( '

,#)# : ( # '   $ 

!9  ' '



!!($ $ 

5

'"# (

!! / #  !!

  (  0+.-#(7 !  0..0      # !    (   

''   # $ ! #9 #(

!!($  

  '  ' #   9 (

!!  !!

# 7 ! $  ' #   9 !

(   

  9 (  $  # $ !    

'  

# $9 '  $'($# '9 9  (

 #(  #      $  ' $ 

 ) #!

(   # !  # !    $!    ($ )= '     # (  ($!:'      

!!# !

  ' 

     :   '  $ # ($  # 

!!#  7     # !     

    !4"

( $(  !    ($9  ($#$  (   

  $  # !  ( #!  ' 9 9  '   '       !     ($   !4"7(  $ >   > #($ 9     9      '      ($     

  $   $9  ( $ ?($("

  $!!  ($  

!  #  -#(7 ! 0..0 (! $(

  $9  $

($



    $!  > #($#$ ( (  > ) #!:@(  ! 

!   



 

    

 !

 !"



# $%



     %*%0 80**%     ('

   

 

 



 

 



   



   



!   "

 # "    $ %  & !     $ 



  

"       &

   "!    "  

" 

 #      ' ('" %)% 

  

* 



  

 

 "  &

   

 

" , - "  



  



  ""

 "

    

 



 & ,-   



 . /01 2     

 

 "  





!   



   

 # & 

 

  "  -   

 " 



     



& 



   



 



   

 

   

  "    ,

!  

 



      

,-   

   



  %&       "  -

&   

 

  - 

  3"

) 4 53  ) 4 1  2 .--%6    

   

"" 

" 

 

       



!

     



  

  " 

 7  8 !    -       9

4  

 )  4  1 2        :

;<%! ,-   

  

  &         

 



   "

 

     &

 

   "  "   

 "!      

    

 8 !     

 "

"

  "  

 

&   









 =

 "  

   "

&  

 

 "

 !  

""



 "   * 



 

   " 

7 .



 !    

,- 

 

  

 " &  !  !

> ?3

 "   



 

  



   "  



@.

 "A





   

 "

  

     "   ! 

  

'

      





   

!

  

   

 "

       

      

 

 "

  " B

    " 



 

             

    





 

 "   !  

 "   

   



 

  

   C  

!          ! 







 .

 

  9 

 

@

 "A

  "      





 " ! 

 

@

 "A 

 

           



  "  

 "8 !   

       "            ""                 "  

   

  !

 "  



&  !

   

        

   

           



 



 

  +   

 

 " &

 " 

 

 

   

  

 .

   #3

&  !

(



  

   

 

 "       

 

" 



   

 

     

 

    @   

"

A   



!  "

    

  !  



9 

       @

 "A  

      

   



 



    !  

( 

     

  

    

 "     

    

 !  "  !      

         

   

   

 

! 

 

!  



= 



 

  .

#3

 " 





    

 



 "!  





 ! 

   "  





 

  

      

 

 "   





 "

  !    



" 

     !     :@(    !         !   ) **+ ++ 

, -    ./*

0 + !

* )  2 + 3)

    '"

6 9        



   

  

             



       -       3"

  

*  .

 3



*

  <  

    " 

      ">

.

 3

9  

  +





= 

  < 

   

     ">     

   

  

 !

  "

*

  

  "

  ! .





     $ 



 

"

   <

 ">   

12 

 !   *

 

     "   



 &

"



   

 ! 

  

  

       

  " 

  = =



    



C

  

  



   

   

          

 !



  .

    3

  &

  

"   



   "   &          3"

  "

 3   "

!     

  "      

 .

! 



   

 

    "  

            "   

      

        

  D    

 

 

  " "  "

+

3 

"!  



 

(  "



 





 ! 

  3"



   

 

  

  

"       !   

  

 

   

      "  

     

  /

      



!    

  

 

   " 



        

  " 



 



<

 ">       

     " 

    3"

!    





 

   

    

 

"

 

 

 "   

   &   +



   "  .

 3



 

    *

  

     "   

     

  

 "   





  "9 

    ,-



 ! 

 "  

 

  

   

     -  : ' ' 

(       9 (

   $ 9  $'($9    $ ( ($ ! 7     # !     

  $'  '

 !  4"   !  

'

'$  

    !   ('   

' (( $      "#        0B<      -#( 7 ! 0..0:'     (  ($   

   !  (!($  

( $ ('= #

  #     #    $         $!      !

   $!('  7

 !



 # ! (   $ $#)    "



   

  '# (  $!   

) #!  (' (! #($       $ '



(!

 ($   



 $('  ($ ('    ) #!

($, #    "  ( >  ('   &    

 

 ' . /--%(?

   "

"     





"" 



            

 

      "   





 3  

 

      

6 7 * - ) # 0!

 0  $  !!(= "  "

           





76%6    

       

 

   

5

- -=C   04 !0 . 5

  .       

  

  

 

"   



            

     !   

    

        



       

* -  

 7   E3



D E     



   "  

        &

           

*  -             " 

 ? 7!



 "   

 

 

    

* -9. .!3

 0 5 !   "   F*-9(3

     

      " 

   )9          

F*-!   

     F*- !  "    

F*-!





F*-  F*-%!

"

 F*-7!

"    

 F*-?!  

"           

     

 F*-!  

"  

  

%  %F*-6!  "

 0 5 0 .F*-   "

  F*-,     

0

 .! 0 5   53



F*-3  

    

  

 F*- 

 

      .

  6  #  





3

   

  

 "   

       

   

  & ! 

 



 



 



  





  

 

     "   0  



 ,  ! 

    

    "



      "        &



* "  

 

=

*   " 

  

         "

  

    

"     

""      GGGGGGG           

          "   

    F*-7 



 F* -? 



 

   " 

,     

    3

  

  

     

    *

    "  

 

! 



  .

6 3

 

 "  

 



   





     

 

 "   "

 

,  !

  "





 &  !  - 

    

     

        "  " !  

F*-

  

   "     

     

 

 



   

   % 8  

    

   " 

 

 "

 

 

F*-  



    "    



  "      

    

 E   E  F*- &

   "



"  

F*-

"  

 

    "

    & 

!  

  



  & 

       "   

   &  !   

  



  .

 #  





3

   

                >       ) #!  

  ($  

 , #  "  (     (' <   



!  

  

"  !  

 " *" 



! *



  !

=     

 

 

 .



  -)-3  

 "  

 

" +

    !  !   

  " *" 



.!  #   



3

!

  

     .

      #  





 3

      .

 6   

#   



3

     -

 "  

 

 

  

  



  (

 > A !

(  $!

    ( $        

  $#$ !$ !  $   $) #! 

($ ('

 $!  ($ ('

  ( 

  '($ ('' 

(  # ($     -* :#!     

!  !

) #!*.*.%*0.

($ , #    "  () #!*+*+%*%% 

($

 , #  "  (  ($  ! 



    +.;  # #(

   

 # $     !    ( !

$

&     (!   

 3 !

 #(     

 C. *)

+   )) 4 

 9

 ( 

:H

(# 9

 

:H

(#