High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14913/2023allowed

Randeep Singh v. Punjab And Haryana High Court And ORS.

2024-09-16Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma25 pages

"#"$%"

$'(') ,- "& '(

)(*"& '(

"./"01"$ 2

" #

! &

" #& # 2 %

!" #& 2 1

$$ !

% $$$

# &'

( # ,* 4*4&

) !*# ! & #4 %++,* & &&- %++ ,64 . # ).! /

& # & # &

# /

& # &

& # ! & & &

2 %*

4 ,3+ & &

2 2 1 *# & 7 # ! & && &

! 2 89((( :(1911 9;

9< 1911 & ,3+833 3/!&

/ / & & & & # ! ! & !

! # ! /

= # &!

/ # & .! # # # ! 2

19889%+ & & /#%1 9> 1918 / # >< << # / #

/ !& / / '/"& & / / ! # & / # '

& # &

& # # >

! 2 1 1 *# & 7 # ! & & && &

4 '

& # ! ! 9;

9< < 1911 # / # "

" ! # !

& & :# & "

" :# & # # '

&! # 7 ?

(

! # .! / /

& # #!

& # # &# ! ;

# & # / # ! # .! /

# /

&!:

%+ %9 9%;

, # & # ,* 4*4 4 &

) ! *# ! & #4 %++,

" #%>& &A ! & # /&

< & # # # :

&! (&& # &

19%% + & # & # & # & ! ( (&& # & ! # & # !&0

%9 & # # &

) ! *# !

! & & #4 %++, # # ! / &/

/ &

## & &

& 18 %% 1918 & 2 8 * &

4 / 2 8*&

4 2 %1(3>(19% %%=%9(%>+;;

;

19%%

" &

# # :

! & & !& # # &

.# & # # & # 2 %*

42 1 1 *# & 7 # ! & & &&

4 '

& # &

& # ! # %1 # &2 2 %*

& / & /# # ! & & #!! / # # ! # & #&

# '

#&! # &2 <+&

! & !

! # =

4 - -

5.%% 6 !" - %% %7&6% 6'7+%8%,, # # $ %&'

( ) ( (

- ## &6%

** *+'

,' , - %&'.

/ /

(

) 3 0 * / 1 +2 3 ( /0

0/ * /

( 0/

*%.9

: ; ( 9 9 +

4 4 * 4 0/ / : ; !

5.%% > .# .'

% %&'

., %% %&'.

5.%%

6 ( < < # '

%&'

, %% %&'.

& 4 - & 4 0+= 0

4 1

0 = 0 /

/ 4 / (

0 0 ( 4 0 0 6?6 4 @ %8 B # & / # & # %> ? # & # & ! 9;

9< 1919 = 5,& 6 $ $ $ ' $"

%& ;$ '

'$! (!

) *+ +* $ ! ' %

' !'7& %3 "

" & ! / # & :# & " :# & # # '

&!# 7 ( ! # .! /

& #!

& # # &#! %;

# / & & & / 2 19889% %+/ & / #%1 9> 1918/ #

& / / # & & # = 89 $ $ $ $) "

, ,---./01,-2,0./1,-234..1,- -,-0:01,-,32--1,-02423

$ , ,-00-24 $ *$ % $ '

*+ +*

! & %,

## # & # !

! ! & 0

& # # & # =

/ 3 = + A

0 / E

/ 2 5.%'

+6 B6% %& %.

5.%' - B6

- - 1 %5+87+5.% C9 9 +%7&' '

5.%%D

4 +

# # ! = &:

#" .

=,/ &

# # )(:41 )1'$&6(4/"

')$/# #/41 156#70"(/ ,"*$)6/0"(/ 4(& "("$45 '(&6/6'(# '8 "$%6*"- - )5"#3 9 # # = -'2A 9

9 B

< ? <

=> < 244/ /& < ?

> < <

89 6

@ 1 9 / / &.F F %.F 0 1 9 / @ @6 CD

$ $ $ ! + "

+ ''% '@ $$"

! "

% $ '$ ! (!

) *+ +*&7

# # 2 %1(3>(19%%=%9 9(%>+; ;

;

19%% # ! &

! & ) # # 0

- % 5+87+5.%%6%.9 +%7&' .'

5.%%

: 4 9 2 9

$ 2 C9 9D = GG9 9'

5.% %% B 1 6 = ( " - %%7&6% 6 '7+%8% %,, #$ %&'

( ) ( ( ) ) - ## &6%

**+'

,' ,- %&'. / /

*+ +* <

3 0 *

+ 3 ( /0 0/ ) :* / + ( 0/

: ; ( + 4 * 0/ / : ; =

: H

+6= / H 9'

5.%% : - %5+87+5.%%6%9 9 +%7 7&, 9 '

5.% %% 9 B6 % 9 9 # 9 -

; : ; 9

: +6= / H @ 1%

# # # # & & ! 1> 1918".

=%%& & & & ! # = 5,& 6

4 4 ( 9 / ; 1 ; I 9 C< <

D 9 9

( ( C D

%,+.#+5.5# -

9 /

( G

( 4

; 9 9 1

) 9 ) A # !

! 9;

9< 1911

C#19%;

/ # & # #0

A # & # &# !

! 2 %1(3>(19%%=%9 9(%>+; ;

;

19%% / / # # ?

2 %1(3>(19%%=%9(%>+; ;

;

19%%&# ! ! 2 %%>+= =% 0

=;>(%3%,, 9;

%++< / # !

# '

& #

&# ! ! 2 88<+=% ..(;<,; 9,2 !%+;9/ &

#&! #

# &

# & # ! ! 2 88<+=% 0 ..

.(;<,; 9, 2 ! % +;9 '

& # ! ! 9;

1911 D $ $ $' $"

! "

%& ; $ '$! (!

) * *+ +*71 / # # # & # &

!&0

1> 2/#! ,* 4*4& &

) ! *# ! & #4 %++, / # / ! & ! '

& # '

&# / # # AAA # , * 4 *4 # & ## !

& &

& :# & " :# & # #'

&!# 7 ! # .! /

& # C#

# &! # &"! (C&& # 0 ! (! ! ! 2 88<+=% 0 ..

.(;<,; ,(%%(%+;9 & ! & ! 2 %%>+=% 0

=;>(% %3%,,8E %+;</

# & & 2 % %1(3>(19%%=%9(%>+;9 9;

19%% ,* 4 *4& ! & # # / # & #&

&! ! & 0

# ! '

# 88<+=A

# ).! /

..(;<,; 9,2 !%+;9

!/ &! ! # 2 %1(3>(19%%= %9(%>+; ;

;

19%% # / /& ! 2 88 8<+=A 0 ..(;<,; 9, 2 ! %+;9 %%>+=% 0

=;>(% %3%,, 8 E %+;

;< 2 %1(3>(19%%= %9(%>+; ;

;

19%% & #

&!!& &0

/ &2 2 2 %1(3>(19%%=%9(%>+; ;

;

19%%& & # ! ! (&& # ##

& # &

& # ! #

& / # & # & #& &! & C#

/# '

# # & ! # 9, %% %+;9 # # & & #& & ! ?

& & 2 8* &

4 / 2 %1(3>(19%%=% %9(%>+;;

;

19%% ! 2 8 * &

4 2 > & !

! 2 <& =/ # =

4 0

2 %1(3>(19%%=%9(% %>+;;

;

19%% 1

; " *

3 %5

( G0

3 %&6 6%.65.%' * 0 1 * =6% 4 * %5

3 2 %5+87+5.%%6%.9 +%7&' '

5.%% * 0 1 * =65

4 0 0 3 0

%5+87+5.% %%6%: 9 +%7&' .'

5.%% %C1 * 65D 1

; "

* * 4

* = - % 5%5

2 5.%' C * =6%D

% 5

( (

* %5

1 %5+87+5.%% %6%: 9 +%7&' .'

5.%% * =65@ 1;

& 2 %**

4 2 %1( (3>(19%%=%9(%>+; ;

;

19%% 2 <! &

! 88<+=A 0 ..(;<,; ,(%%(%+;9 %%>+=%0

=;>(%3%,, 8E %+;< &

/ # & 2 %1(3>(19%%= %9(%>+; ;

;

19%% # / 2 % *

4 . / / # &# 2 %1(3>(19%%=%9 9(%>+; ;

;

19%% # & # ! & # !( &

# '

! # '

# '

& #

88<+=A 0 ..(;<,; 9, 2 ! %+;9 &

# & ! # # ! &

!&0

&C&& # & !& &

!! !!

! & # E C&& && # * 4

& / / & /

# # 6;7 ')$/ #/4156#70"( (/ ,..'6(/0"(/ 4(& '(&6/6'

(# '8 "$%6*"- )5"# 9 '

# # = 5@ 24?2>1 9 /

G 9 :

0 0 ?,>4 B6 9 /

9 $

4 0 9 $ *

> $ $ + "

+ '

''% ' @

$ $"

% % $ ' %

' !' ?D$

" $ '$ >&

> 4 ?

> 4 * # 0

- )/ % : %8. 9 8. E0 #

< 8. G C D

C/D 8. ? > - ( 0 * *

7.F / ##F/ ?

>2 0( 0 * 9 $ + 4

0 * * + 0 0

8./

+ ( + C: D 0 #.0

0 ) 9 9 0 + + + 0 * ( +

( + + %.F F /

> 1

/ 0 4 9 /

0 0 3 0 ( / 0

0 0/

>4 9 $ C#DA

9 $ * ( 6 C5D %& * 0

# ( 9 / 6 C5D $$ ' + "

+ + $ @ ' $

$ *+

' ! $$

& < "

" & / %+,8 /7"

"&) )*4/6'(45 =)45686*4/6'( 1'/7 6( ( 6(&6 '$ )(:416 ).

04/$6*)54/6'( ( #/4(&4$# '$ 6/# "=)6%45"(/ 6# /7"

"56;61656/?

*$6/"$64 8'$ $"*$)6/0"(/ /'

/7"

.'#/ '8 5"$>

&# #! ! F ! & A # & $ ") & $

$ $ 1 ,-,.

22./ 2 83& ! =

# #8

/ 0 0 0

J K 1 B CD 4 = / 0 0 0 = / 1 1 / = = 0 0 / 0

0 0 0 1 CDA 0 L *

0 0 1 L 0 1 L 6 0 ( 0 1 3 / 0 0

C D3 * 0 1 9 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 CD 6/0 0 I 1 0

/ J KJ

K1 6

/ J0

0 K3 + 0 9 J K C D4

@ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 +

3 * 0 CD 4 0 / J

1 K

0 0 < 0

1 0 0 CDG0 0 0 + * 3 0 I 0 0 0 * 3 0 * *

1 CD3 /0 *

1 @

&##! !&F ! &A #& !

$ & E ! % ,

2- @9 & ! =

4 0 / 0 3 0 I

0 B CD / / CD " 9 3 C D" 9 3 CD 0 * 1 C D = 0 CD )

C * 0 0 /

@ 2/#! ,* 4*4& &

) ! *# ! & #4 %++, / # / & # & & :# &"

:# &# # # #'

#&! # 7 // &! # .! / /

& # ## / D'

#F ! C &

! 2 %1(3 3>(19%%=%9(%>+; ;

;

19%%

# & # &

# # :

! & !& # &

# & #! .#& &# A &

19% %% &

# & ! # '

# ! & 0

! &

& .! &

/ &

# '

# & !

! #

! 2 88<+=% 0

..(;<,;

; , 2 ! %+;9 / &

# & ! #

A& & '

# # & # &!

! ! & ) # 0

& .! &

/ & &#'

# & #/ / &

A& &

! &# , ,* 4*4

$ $ $

! + "

+ ''% '@ $$"

! "

% $ '$ ! (!

) *+ +*

/ F

G ! 6;7 ')$/ #/4156 6#70"(/ ,..'6(/0"(/ 4(& '

'(&6/6'(# '8 "$%6*"- )5"# 9

" & ,* 4*4&

%++, / # / &:

:# &":# &# # '

#&! # 7 /# / & ! # .! /

& # ## # '

# # 8> A& & '

# & # / '

#& &

# ?

& # & # 0

# & & & / # / #'

# & # &! 0

A # & ! & ) # 0

# & # / & &# ! B # # ! &

! & ) # 0

# &

0 0

#& # 8;

C# '

# # # / ! # ! ! # & !'

& # 8, ?

) ! *# ! & #4 %++, & '

# & # # '

/ &" #%> %;& &A

8< A / & , , * 4 *4 &

) ! *# !

& #4 %++, . & # / -'

) ! *# ! & #4 %++, # & ! # .! / /

& # A /& # 2 8*&

4! & /D"=)6%45"(/F , * 4*4&

) !*# ! & #4 %++, !2 88<+=%0

.(;<,;,2 !%+;9 9/ # ! &

/ / =

CD - 9 /

; 1 ; ( I

7& >9 "

"## / / # / ! .! & 2 %*

4 # # & & & ! !& /

! "./"01"$ 2 " +-

- !

G G (