High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/8834/2016dismissed

Shitij Gaur v. State Of Haryana

2016-03-15Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh9 pages

!"#$%& '("" )( *(&

"%"( +%,%)% -(.

)/()"

"!#$!%&$'

(" & )&*+ &$$!( , !

-.,/) '

1 "2 3 !+ #

, ! !

"!'!

1 "2 4

-.,/) '

!.$,+ !

,5'

5/ 1 "2 '(()"

-%0(! (!%1/2 %"( "!(.("" )( 6 !(.(()".("" )!%4(()(/&)/( ) ' 5%)" %)" .%"

,4%"

"!(.("" )() %(

/%"(/ (5"((/ &)/( ) 67 ' %" 8 9() '

(

"%" )1" "$&5% ) :(%)(/ &)( "!(.("" )( )"()/"!%""!(.("" )( !%%(,4(()9. %"(/)"! %(1;!((%1!(;%) ")2 2(/ !(.("" )(&)9%(/1;!((%1"!( 9.%)%)"%/2 ((%)/ !%2)5%,(% //%&5"!(%;(< "!"!(.%"(;((0) ;)"

(% ! "!( "!(%"(;9 )"!!( 9.%)%)")" /& (/!((% %)&)9%(/5"

"!(.("" )(;"!%)&"( 9 "2(%)/"!((;% )2 2(9()" !(%9,9(94(% 2());!%"%..9(%5(1"!(

9.%)%)"!%!

;)!(("

4(%)&)9%(/5%)/"!(% "&9

!((%(9%%5(;%) ""

"!(.("" )(:(%)(/ &)(%

&49""!%"4 "!"!(.%"(;((!%2)50)5 (% ! "!(4&")

. 9( 9%%5(;%(2(9%/(:(%)(/ &)(!%((/&.

)"!( #&/59()" + )=4("!(.(> &")"!( %( 7 5))& & !(,&8" &

!#7&'& &9& 6 15$&9 &-8" &

!#5)&% &$ &, --9)% 1 "! &") &) .+ &*&8" &

!# .'-&+.%(/)

) 1

&-7.)&8" &

!#&*&'&.%(/)

)1 (!+5! &")859.$&9"

58"

1!# $ 52 @ 1 !

&'8" &

!# $ 5--9)%15)&$8&5,8" &

!# $ 5 --9)%%)/ < 94%,+5! &") &

&$95"

'&&',&'

8" &

!#& &&"

&9( 61)&..

" ! )"()" ) )(! %1 /2 %"( %..(% ) 4(!% "!(

9.%)%)"%)/&49""!%""!(.("" )(;%;(%;%(%4 &""!( 9%%5( "!( 9.%)%)"%)/!(/%&5!"( 9"!((%(9%%5(

" ),. 9( 9%%5(;%9%/(4&"&)/("!(.("(>" 9%%5(1 .!, %(%" );((% 9%/(;"!"!( 9.%)%)" !(.("" )( &4(A&()",4% 0(/ &" 9"!(9%%5(%)/ () (&)/( )6

'9%/( &"%!%4(()!(/4,+ )B4("!(.(> &")"!( %( &

!# 8"&."

&, +(%/"!(%5&9()"%/2%) (/4,(%)(/ &)( "!( .%"(%)/!%2(% 5 )("! &5!"!(%(5%" )(2((/)"!(

-% ;( % "!( / &9()" %2%%4( ) "!( ( ) &/)5 "!( ;!%"%..

9(%5((> !%)5(/4(";(()"!(.%"( :(%)(/ &)( "!( .("" )( !% )"()/(/ "!%" "!( .("" )(;%(%/,"

9%,;"!"!( 9.%)%)"4&"";%) ""

"!(

.("" )("!%""!( 9.%)%)";%(%(9%(/%)/%/%&5!"(;%%

) 9"!(%/;(/ 0 "% "!(%5&9()" (%)(/ &)("!%"

) . 9("

9%,;%(2(9%/("

"!( 9.%)%)"

" %..%()" 9 "!( ;!%"%.. 9(%5( (> !%)5(/ 4(";(()"!(.%"("!%""!(.("" )(;%;(%;%(%4 &""!((%( 9%%5( "!( 9.%)%)"%)/"!(/%&5!"( 9"!((%(9%%5(

;"!(A&(" ) )/(%" ) ;"!(5%/"

"!( )()" "!( 2 "9 )? '/()( )()"0) ;)"

4(52()&)/(C(% 9 ) (." )B1;! !(%/%&)/(

D? !'"

9'!(' ! + /5:

' .', # & !

)5"%!'%

5!'E )()") "& ! )()"%")"()/(/ 4,%),( " ) "! /(1"!( )()"52()4,%.( ) &)/((% )#&,1 &)/(%9 ) (." ) % "1%)/"!( .( )/ )5"!(% "0) ;1 !%(% )"

4((2(1"!%""!(

)()" ;% 52() ) )(A&() ( & ! (% 9 ) (." )F

)6 '% ((2%)")"!(.(()" %(1;! !

(%/%&)/(

4;< .'5"

) '

#!& = 8!

(2(1(> (.")"!( %(. 2/(/ 4,&4 ( " ) 1 99" %.( !% 4( .&)!(/ ;"! 9. )9()" ("!(/( ." ) %"(9;! !!%) "4(("!%)(2() ,(%4&";! !9%,4( ( %"(9;! !9%,(>"()/ "(),(%%)/!%% 4(%4("

)(&)("!(;

9() %.(/! ;);(%)/) "&)/(";(2(,(% %5(1) ;! ! %(1!(!%4(.&)!(/;"!9. )9()" ("!( /( ." ) %"(9;! !9%,(>"()/"

,(% ;"!

)( ;"!4 "!' 2/(/"!%""!( &"9%,1 %/(A&%"(%)/

.( %(% )"

4(9()" )(/)"!(#&/59()"19.

(% ()"() ( 9. )9()" %"(9 ("!%)(2(),(% 8!

(2(1G %4()5%.

( ( 99"%.(G ;"!)"!(9" "!(.

("%" )"

;! !!(%.

)"(/H )"!(.(9( %),"%" )!

&(;!("!( ) ""&%"(/ )"!(.

("%" )"

;! !!(%..

)"(/H )%;

9%))! &"

/, )"!( &"

/, %.

(

(&4 /)%"("

!9H 4 4()5 % .&4 (2%)"1 "%0( %/2%)"%5( ! % .

" )%)/ 99"%.( )%;

9%))! &"

/,%& !

.&4 (2%)" )"!( &"

/, %.&4 (2%)"&4 /)%"( !9H 4()5 )"!(9%)%5(9()" )"!("% %#%1(9%)/ !

9( "!(.% ( &"

/,("%4!(/4, &)/(%), %; "!("9(4()5) ( %;

9%)B !/()B )""&" )"%0(%/2%)"%5( ! %.

" )%)/ 99" %.( ) %), )9%"( & ! #%1 (9%)/ !

9(1 .% ( )""&" )H / 4()5 )"!(9%)%5(9()" )"!("% %!

."%1 "%0(%/2%)"%5( ! %.

" )%)/ 99"%.( )% ;

9%))"!%"!

."%H ( 99"%.( )%;

9%)0) ;)5!("

4(.(5)%)"H 99"%.( )%;

9%);!()!(&)/(";(2(,(%

%5(H 5 99" 5%)5 %.(1 !% 4( .&)!(/ ;"! 5 & 9. )9()" %"(9;! !!%) "4(("!%)"(),(%

4&";! !9%,4( (%)/!%% 4(%4( "

)( ' 2/(/"!%""!( &"9%,1 %/(A&%"(%)/.( %(% ) 4( 9()" )(/ ) "!( #&/59()"1 9.

( % ()"() ( 9. )9()" ("!(/( ." ) %"(9 ("!%)"() ,(%>.%)%" )G8!((%;

9%)%.(/4, )( ( ) % 5 &. .( ) % ")5 ) &"!(%) ( "!(

))"()" )1(% ! "!(.( )!%4(/((9(/"

!%2( 99""(/5%)5%.(;"!)"!(9(%))5 "!&4

( " ) >.%)%" ) GD8 9()B !/()B )""&" )F 9(%)%))""&" )1;!("!( %(/%) .!%)%5( %!

9( )(5( "(/;

9%) !/() %;/ ;B!

9( 4,%),

"!( )%9(1 ;! ! ("%4!(/ %)/ 9%)"%)(/ "!( ( (." ) %)/ %( ;

9%) !/() >.%)%" ) GD+ ."%F9(%)"!(.( ) " "!(!

."%%)/) &/( "!(.( ) " %),)""&" ) "!(( (." )%)/"(%"9()"

.( ) /&)5 )2%( () ( .( ) (A&)5 9(/ %%""()" ) (!%4"%" )I

" %..%()" 9 "!( % (%/ ) "!%" ) %( "!(

)()"52()4,"!(2 "9&)/("!(9 ) (." ) "!(% "1" 2"%"(/ )"!(.(()" %("!(% &(/!%/(>&%)"( &(;"!"!( . ( &"> 4, 52)5 % %( %&%) ( 9%%5( 4&" &4(A&()", 4% 0(/ &" 9"!(%9( 9"!1"(2/()""!%""!(.("" )()(2( )"()/(/"

9%,"!( 9.%)%)"4&"!(. &(/!( )()" ), !%2)5(>&%)"( &(;"!!(!(% " "!(% &(/%A&%(, &)/("!(/()" ) %.(%!(!%/(>&%)"( &(;"!"!(2 "94,

4"%))5!( )()"&)/(%9 ) (." ) "!(% "%/()(/&)/(

)? '!(%(5(/ )()"%/"

!%2(4(() 4"%)(/4,"!( % &(/;%) "2 &)"%, )()"%)/%& !"!(% &(/)/&5(/)

(>&%)"( &(;"!"!(. ( &">4,9 )"&)5"

!(!"&( )"()" ) %9(2(;!%4(()!(/4,+ )=4("!(.(> &")"!( %(

,$&5'5:&" &!8" &

!# 6 --9)%61 ;! !(%/%&)/(

D "%..(%"!%""!()"()" ) "!( % &(/%.("!( "("9 ), '8;%15!" 9"!(4(5)))51) "!

)("

%)/ !( 0(." ) . 9)5 "!%" !( ; 9%, !(1 " !( 4( %9( .(5)%)" ! 0)/ )()" 4"%)(/ 4, "!( % &(/ %)) "4(%/"

4(%), )()"4( %&(!(;% &)/(%9 ) (." ) % ""!%""!(% &(/)"()/"

9%,!(1"!(( (1!(!%/&49""(/"

(>&%)"( &( ;"!!9!% "% %/9""(/4,"!(% &(/"!%"!(!%/

99""(/ (>&% )"( &( ;! ! %..%()" 9 "!( "("9 ), ';1%)/%)/4( ('%) !%,%" (/( "!(2%5( "9 ("!%) (%"!%""!(% &(/9%/(%%( . 9("!%"!(;

&/9%,!(!(( (1"!()"()" ) "!(% &(/5!" 9"!(4(5)))5;%) "4 )%/(%)/ "!(.

5&49""(/"

"!(&" "!(% &(/ 9.("(, 4()59(/4,"!(% &(/;!

!(/ &""!(. 9( 9%%5(!0)/ )()""%0()4,"!(% &(/;"! (% )"()" )) ""

&"!(. 9(%)/.(&%/(/"!(5"

4((2("!%"!(5 )5"

9%,!(%)/ 4"%)(/!( )()"

"!((>&%)"( &(&)/("

"%9 ) (." )1 %)) "4( "(%"(/"

4(% )()"F

&"!(1).%%6 "!(%/#&/59()"1+ )=4("!(.(> &"!%!(/%&)/(

)"!(.(()" %()2(; "!(% "%9()" )(/%4 2( ;(%(%"(/"!%""!( )()";! !!%/4(() 4"%)(/4,

6 "!(% &(/;%) "%2 &)"%, )(;! !;%52()4,!( &)/(9 ) (." ) % ""!%""!(% &(/;

&/9%,!( 4&""!) "% )()")%;!9 ((2/()" 9"!( "("9 ), '8%;(%'8;!

;%&) " ))5% '%) !%,%";!(("!(% &(/%/9""(/"!%"!(!%/ 99""(/ (>&% )"( &( %)/ . 9(/ "

9%, !( 4&" !( %4 )/(//(."("!(. 9(9%/(4( ("!('%) !%,%" !%"!

;"!%""!(% &(/!%/) )"()" )"

9%,!( 5!" 9 "!( 4(5)))5 %)/ 99""(/ (>&% )"( &( "%,&)/("!(9 ) (." ) % "4,. ( &"

"!%"!( ;

&/9%,!(F

)"!(% (%/#&/59()"1";%!(/"!%") %("!(% &(/

4"%)(/ )()" "!(. ( &">%&/&()",&)/(%9 ) (." ) "!(% ""!()!(;4(!(/5&", "!( () ( %.(+ )B4("!(.(> &" ) &."

&," %&"

1". &2 !% 4(2(/ "

"!( (>"()" "!%" % ;

9%)=4 /,) "%9%)=.%,"!)5%)/!( %)) ""%0(%/2%)"%5( "

) /("

%",!&"%)//((4,

)5%;

9%))"

)()")5 (>&% )"( &( 9., 4( %&( !( ;%)" "

)/&5( ) " !( % &(/)"! %(!% 99""(/"!(2(% " %.(%)//((2("

4( &"%4,.&)!(/ " .(&% ;!%"%.. 9(%5( (> !%)5(/ 4(";(() "!( .%"(;

&/!

;"!%""!((%((() (%4 &""!((%(9%%5(%)/

/%&5!"(%;(

9( "!(;!%"%..9(%5((> !%)5(/4(";(() "!(.%"(!

;"!%""!(.("" )(;%;(%;%(%4 &""!(/%&5!"(%)/ (%(9%%5(1;! !%((. /& (/%&)/(

DJ!(9"(0!&!9()4%!&"0!&!%%.9&#!(")%.,% 0%"(!

9&#!((04%9)(04%%/!9((")%0%4%%

5,(!

04%9&#!(!!%/0)% !%!"(!

9(4("0

4!%.)%9%))% 9&!(!%/0,( 9%!)(0%"9(4! /(/,%!%%%.4%!&"% !!(!

# 9&#!(")%%9#!%!%F D%"9%%!!

%.)4("0%%%"!F D!% %4"&9 .%5,%0!%)%0!% ("0 9%0" !() 9()#%0%0& !0!%)(0%/(0!"%!& 2(&#%%)F %%#%%"0 9((.%044%% 5(,%%/!%)%%#9%4!%

9%9%#(9%&)5%%.0 )(!%4!%%,(5F (!% .%5,%0(%"!9%0("#%)%!% %5%9%%%"

.(!(.%5,%0 9&99,0(.% !!%;% !!

/)%.%/(5%F

%9( &( ;% "!(( 4( ( "!( % &""% +5! &"1 ;!(()1 #&/59()" ,$&" %&"

1". &2 %)/ ,&* 8" &

!# 7&'& &9& - ?;((((/&.

) )"!%" %("!(% &(/ 4,52)5%&%) ("

9%,!( !%4"%"(/%)/9%/(.!, %(%" ) ;"!"!(2 "94&"&"9%"(,(&(/"

9%,!(&("!(();%%"

;!("!("!((;% )()"%)/;!("!("!(% &(/(&(/"

9%, ) "%"(!( ) (2(/%(;"!)"!(/ 9%) % "&%9%"> % (2/() ( "!(2 "9%)/"!(;")(( ) ()(/ ";%% !(/"!%"%"

.("%"%5(;!(/(%)5;"!4%%.. %" )&)/( ) 7?

'1"!( &""

)/( ),"!(%(5%" ))"!(

- ";% &"!(!(/"!%"";%%2(,.(9%"&("%5(" !

/"!%""!((;% ) "!)5"

&55(""!%"C& ! )()";% 4"%)(/B%)/4, )/()5"!( %5&9()" 4 "!"!(.%"(1";% &)/"!%"";%) "" %("

5%)"

4%%""!%""%5(%)/%.. %" ) 5%)" %)" .%"

,4%;%(#( "(/

)"!(.(()" %(% 5%)")5%)" .%"

,4% ),"!( %(5%" )%("

4((()!((2/() (;4((()/&)5"!("%%)/" %)) "4(%/"!%" )()";%52()2 &)"%,%)/"!(.("" )(;%)

? %;%( %4 &" "!( (%( 9%%5( %)/ /%&5!"( 4 ) &" "!( %/ ;(/ 02()"!(;!%"%..9(%5(%(% 9%""( (2/() (4&"

.9%% (%"(5 )5"! &5!"!(9(%5((> !%)5(/4(";(()"!( .%"(1"%..(%"!%""!(.("" )(;%;(%4 &""!((%(9%%5( %)//%&5!"( 9.,%,)5"!%""!( ) (%9()";%"!((%"!(2 "9 !%. #( "(/!(("

4(&)9%(/1 )"%,"

"!(( /%2%%4(%"

"!"%5( /)5,1 ) 2(; % " % 9()" )(/ %4 2( %)/ 4,

)/()5"!(%(5%" ))"!(

-1) 5 &)/9%/( &""

5%)"

%)" .%"

,4%"

"!(.("" )(%)/"!(.("" )4()5/(2 / %),9("

!((4,/9(/ % ! 1 1 2 .