Davinder Pal Alias Binder And Others v. State Of Punjab And Another

          

 !"#"$
%&'&

 % (%)


 

            % (
)

               * +, *& - ./- -



   !"    


       

 

  







 !   



     

 

 "!

#!

#

$%&'

##### ./- -0 & *1
%
1

 *1
 1



$    "  " %&' ( (   )       )  *"  +  ,&-.'-'/

1
1

0   )    " *"   $     "12  )  

* 3      )    ) ,&-.'-'/  $ 4  "   "     )   5      * "$ !

# # ,

$   6     *    " %&' ( ( 
 
    06 

  7 7  *"             ) " 6   $   7  06 8,9%  '&,''-,.  " /-: /'/ /%, 9-; ,%&  ,%. 6 ( 1"

   " /'/ /'9 /%, 9-; ,%&  ,%. 6 (2   

 "  8
"   

 8',  '&,''-,.    " /%, /'/ 9-; ,%&  ,%. 6 ( "   " 06   * 

7 "  ) )       * "))  '&-/'-'/ 1!+

'2   *   ' < "   "  )        "))  '&-/'-'/ 1!+

'2  $   *    06 

  7    "   )  7 / 3 (  "  "  )   

11

"       6

7  = ( 1  " )$ 2  -'-;'-'/    ) "  (  * * "  $     "$   "))   "       * $ 5    "    *        (   +     % 6 "      ) $  >"   6 (   !   " " *   )   "))   *      $     *

 "  * $       " 9 3    $     $   *   "    $    06 

  7  7     ")) " *    ; ?    "         ) $  (  *  (     )   )" $   *    $  "  $  "  "))   )" $ 3      "  *   "    " ")     7  " %&'  ( ( 3 (   *  " %&'  ( (  7  06  *  "   ")  *   "   "  "   " : !   0

"  )   ( 




        

 !

"#  

  

@': 3 *   ")  "   $ "  $ " "  $) 6 "    $  "        $ +"   "  "")"    *"  (      +"  "  $   *  $    *    "

5  ")  "    " 8 )        " /'-1.2   ()

" (  $  " " ) " * *  *  " %&'   ()

" ( '& 3 "))  ) "$  
   )$   $  6     "    *  " %&'   ()

" (    " "  ")) *"   " " )$  " "    $   A   "A
 *"      )) "    ) "))"

"   " ) "  $    * $  ( $ +"  *  " %&'   ()

" (      "))      $   *  )  " " 3 "   $ "      "  +"  " * "

$   "  $ )  "  "   *"  "  " )$ *    "     '. 3  $   ""

 )   "      $    ()

" ( *" " "   *   (  " %&' 0  ) "  )  )) "     (   * *  7  "     ")  " *    " /'-   ()

" (        *   "    " /- 3 *  " %&'   ()

" (    +" B+
 > 

1 1

    "  ( 3 "    +     )     ?  (  5  +"   * 6 *

 *$    "  "")"  " " 3 *  " %&'   ()

" (   )   (     +$ " )  )  " "    $    ) )"  " " )$  

 "  $  "$      $ *$   ")) * * *

    "  ))  )    ( *"      

"   )    " "))     * ")   "$  *  )  $C & ?D   !+ (   "  $ 

        "

%

 !

#%    

@9: 3   )  )   " "  ))   *   ?  (  7  ")  06  ")   +"    "  "   )  *

   ") "  ")  "  " /'-   ( 6 *   *   *  $ )      +"  "" *       " * EF 12  "    "  12      "  $ ( 6 * " *  7  ")  ")   06 )$  +" *    ")      *     "  "")"  " "   " $ "  " ?*  +"  " *  ?  ( )         $   ") ?   "  ) $  "

5 )  "$ " "  

$ 7     ")  ")D ) $         " "          )"  "$ )  $ $ ")) *  ")        "  "  5   (

!"   " ")) $  "  * *5   ""$ "F "   $   7 ")    " "   ") "  * )

$  

)

$ "           7 "  $  "  ) "))" " )"  "   "

5 "   "    ))$    *$ "   ) $  *  *

 "

$               6  " $  " ?  ( )$ 7 ")     * "   ")) *    ")   $  ""  )   5  "  ") " *   ""     "  +) " *   "  ) $  7  ") "  

 ")   )  ")) *  ") 6  *  ?  ( ) " *  *     "$     "  " *  ")

 "   ") *  )    "  *   )  ")) *  ")  *   *  "    "     ") "         *    712   )  ?  ( 

 *

*  "  7  ") C . 3  7 "     

*    & '  

 () ! * ' "+

#

,--./ ++++++ ,' 8*     " " *  "   (   "  8   12  ) G* 12  ""   "  ) G* 12  (    " *  *  ")  " "   (  " /'- ( ( ,.:/   * "  " %&' ( ( ,.:/  7  ")

 $  ?  ( 6   "  (     ")  "  *

1'1

  ") (  "")" $   "  " /'- ( ( ,.:/   (    $  7 $ $ *       )   $  ?  (  7  ")

  ") ")   " %&' ( ( ,.:/   $  )  "   *   " *  $ " +"  *     ) "7" )$  "7  )  ") ?*   7 "   "  8   12  $ "  ) $ ""

    '.  

'.++++ '.: 4  " *  +"  *  " %&'   (   )    )  $  ""   3 " *   )    )) $   

 "))  "   )  

    ?  ( )$ 

  ""   )  7  ")

=  6  "             

    "       <5*  " *  "   )   "  $     "  

 "$    ?  ( " *  "  +"  *  $   ) " )   "")"=) )  +++H+++C ,- G  *   12  >"   6 (   !  "))  '&-/'-'/ 1!+

'2   "   *  ""   " "  

 *    $ "  "    (  * 3    

*  06 8,9%  '&,''-,.  " /-: /'/ /%, 9-; ,%&  ,%. 6 ( 1"

   " /'/ /'9 /%, 9-; ,%&  ,%. 6 (2   

 "  8
"   

 8', 

'&,''-,.    " /%, /'/ 9-; ,%&  ,%. 6 ( "   " 06   * 

 7 "  ) )  $ 7 7    $ ,,

  "  $      (./- -) 345
%0

 

 

4 5 = I=8 4  I=8