← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12179/2011allowed

K.L. Johar & 22 ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2016-11-10Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan7 pages

               

!"!

#$  %% & '%(%)% *'

#

* '"

+%% !!

# '"

, '"-"

.

'/# #

* '"

++ "0 # #"

1$  #234

1'%-"!

(-4!0 .!#5*  

     

    "  #$%  %&

    !

" '



(()  

 $*!

   !

"   $  ) 

  

   !

" +,  



 

    



   

  

  

 !  

(-4!0 .!#5*6 % 7'48   ) (  !  - *  * ! ((

( - *    * )   ) )  ) .*! " +/  !)   &  01 +,,3  (! 

)   &  ) )

.*! " +/  !

")&.*& (!   4     & & + +,,2*!

  !  &

 )

 5 & )

( (  

&  

 !  ) + +,,2 !++ 5 &  4 

! 4    !" #    $ #

% &'( )

**+    *, **))  

 )   )  

&! 

! ((   

(  

) + +,,2 !) - *  $

(  7 (

 +,,'  4  ( 8 * & * 

 & + )   ( 4#    -

 

!!)  &  * !- 4

4 % 94 *!&6*     4  &  *(  (* &

- *   &  4  

!"#  - +.   

 & 5 !   !!  4) 6:" 33,//1+1 )   

   ( ) ( ) &   !   6 .*

 )

 

7* 0  

7*;)! 4

 < /'

+/ /1+1   

7*  0    4      

  !  )   (* *! 4 !   

) )   

           =(

   (   &  )   (  (          /'

;

/1++   

7*  ;    ) 4  &7&*&& (  )  

 / 3 &+ +,,>  3 ) ++  5  4  

 & + 

4 (  &! (

( 8    (

     

!" #  - + &     )

!  &!  ! ((

( ! !

" + /   &  &   

7* 0 ;

8 ) 

  ! 4 ) &! 

(  &! !!

(

    ! =(

( 5 &! !!

(

   !

  =(

   (    (   4            )        &     ( (    (

&!   5   !    =(

   (    =

 4   (21 )  

&!  *4    *( *

   (3' 5   

4 (  !!& 4 &* 

*  *& & & 



&(  !) *

! (

( &4 

  47  ! !

" +,   4 

! " /0     &  /, / +,,2 

& ( ) !4  &  4 ! 5  &     / 3   )  7  & + +,,>     3   & +,,')  )    5 ! /0

)  

 4

8        *      !         *( *(   5 !*  

& + )      !* ) )    ) )- *  8 ? %9 &6(  )   ! ((



* 

 (    3     ! ) *

 !   (

( ) + +,,2

 ++ +,,'     )        

      

@   5   &

  )    4    6*       6*   )     (  (

  ) (  3  - * 

$

( ) + +,,2 - * ) ( ! ((

( &++ +,,' )

  *  7 (

  - * ) (

(  - * ) ( !  & (  (

   (   5     )    - * ! ($

=(  

  3 ( ) + +,,2 &++

 

)     *!

!  6:" +;+''+,,, 6:" 01,2 /11+  *!

 % 94 *!&6*  

#

  / $ # %##

.

  &' $ 0

 122

**+  )  & 

   4  

6 .*

 ) () !  =

           0  



  

        

   

   

 

   $ 4 $5 '

  

 $  &+  

 $  

  5     4 $6    

   

  $  

   '

 ' $  (   7,, 

 111  &08  ()+    ' $      (   *12 

**  &08  (,+     

   98 

  $ 

       :2; 

  

 

     

<    !* !!(

 

 4  & 4#    % 94 *!& 6*   *  

  & ") )7&   )  !  !

  &(*&

  4 *  4  (     !!  A*  54*      )    !  4 ( !  )  

&4 )      !!  ( @ !"#  - +)  /11+  /1 '

/11>  8 !!   (!!  B

!!  & &  % 94 *!& 6*  * &  &  - /0 /11, 5 !    !!  /1+14 (6:" 33,/ /1+1) 

)    (  8 & ) *

  &( 4



 &   ( !



&&& &  ( ! )   !! 

 .* ( (   A*

54*      

  ! 

    4  

&!*(  

7* 0 ;

  4

 4$

 (*  )

!  )

8& )  4

  4  

 ! (

(   &!   &   4!!  &  *  &!  )  5   .* &!&

)  )  &

 4 - *   !

" '  (*  ) &&! ) )) ((

(*!  &)) ((

* =! &   

)   )) ((

(*! 

)  4  4   & )    4

  & 8& ) (*&

 4   4!  ( !!! 

))    4  * 4&!*(  

7* 0 ; 4.*  5  !

   (   ) + +,,2C 3  & 

!"#  - + $ !

& 4 * (

4 !&

-

 4! & 

& + 5  4  44   !  ) 

)) ((

(* !

5 !     4





    7&

  (

! 

)   4



 C2D!

*& (



 !"#  -  & + &+/ > /1++ )  ! 

) )   * 

%        &  * &!  7 4

!"#  - + &! )  4  

%)

  4!4&

!! 

& (  

 %% & 7(-4!0 .!#5*8 9

-5

:   ! (E 

F :  ! 4

F