Alaknanda Cooperative Group Hou. Soc. Ltd & ANR v. Financial Commissioner , Coop. & Ps To Govt. & ORS



 

 !" #"$%&%'() * + ,"- .' '# 
/"0 !%1"02/2&%'34$%"!56!# '# '!,"0 "!%!%'"0& 7& %' '$% - 
88%&&%'"09 
/"0 !%'  '#  0%'$%/ -  4"$0"! 05  !  1!  05 '  '#!,"0& "&/'#"'!&
 ( :6 4
 44 6;

 



      

 





    !"

" 

  # 

&&&&&&&  44 6;9 6 ' 

   #   () *+ ,*(( -.
/,%0

 2"


 "





   

  1 



"

   ,( (, ,**3 -.
/,(0

 4#  

    " "# "#1" 1

5 "



 

 "

 



 1 

"

6  ,**%

 "" 1

7

 "  *% *8 ,**% -.
/(0  

"

9  1 

1# 1

  1    

"

9     *% *8 ,**% -.
/(0

  "  ,: (* ,**% -.
/,0 4   "  *3 (( ,**% -.
/%0 

"  "#  

  1 #

.
/%



$ % "    1" 

1

' 

      (8 (( ,**% -.
/+0 #

      1    

1# 1

  1

    (8 (( ,**% -.
/+0 "

 9

; " 

 

" $ %

 

"

""# 

1# 1

   ,8 (* ,**< -.
/30   

1

7 "  ,8 (* ,**< -.
/30  "   "  %( (* ,**< -.
/80  

#  

##

1# 1

<

5

  1  #      "

 

   .
/) .
/(%

2""  

## 

1

 ## 

 # "  (, *3 ,**+ " 

  4#  



# " #  # #"    "  (( *: ,**+ -.
/(<0     9   

 9   1" 

1# 1

=   

 $ % #   "  *3 (* ,**+ -.
/(+0  

 " # 1   (( *: ,**+ *3 (* ,**+

 

" 

"

 4#  

  / $ , 

.
/(3
/

"   "

 .
/()

"  > -.
/(:0 7 

"  >  "

 .
/,*   4#  

  / $ , ""

"

  #   ,( (, ,**3 -.
/ ,(0

/ ""#   ,( (, ,**3

 4#  

    //

)



 

 

   / $ ( 



 

 ((+

7   / 

  (:)< -?(:)< ?

0

# 

#



"   #  .
/,,   # " "

1

 $ (  

  #   () *+ ,*(( -.
/,%0   

  

$

   "    

" ;  

"  1"

$ ,     

"  1"

 " "

 @  "

1 

  .

"

 1 

"

1" 

 ((<

(:)<   4#  

/ $ , # "  (( *: ,**+ -.
/(<0  *3 (* ,**+ -.
/(+0 

 1 

"

"

 1" 

 ((<

(:)<  $ ,   >    "  # 

#  #   ,( (, ,**3 -.
/,(0
"#  "  " %

"

5 "   

1

1 "  "

1   1"## 



   #  

=

 "# #  "#1"

1# 1

 $ ( 1"

"

 1#

  " %

"

5 " 

   ""#""

" "#1"

1

  " .#  >  #   () *+ ,*(( -.
/,%0 





 ""#"  " 1  //"

  !

#" '   
 "

 

 

      " # # "  (8 (( ,**% -.
/+0  " 1#  1  # 

  $ ( ,    >   "1"   

 

""#

 


  " "

 1  # 

  $ ( ,   "  #    

#

  ""#" @ "

 1 $ (  #"

  " %

5 "



"#  "#1"

1

@ "

" .   

# 

"

"" 

1# 1

 1 

   

  4 (< "



    #    "   ""#

" 9 .
/+ @ "

 ""

" "

+



"

 

 #  " "

  1" "#   "

"



 ## # "

 "

    

   #  "

 

  1  #   "1"   7 

  "" 7          1#    '  



     1 #  1 .

""

 1

  .
/(<
/(+  "

" 

4    "

  " -.
/(<
/(+0    

1

1 ""#   " 

"

 $ , 

 ((<

(:)< 

'  "  

 ((<

(:)<     /




    

      

     





     !

     

 

"     

#    $  !

*

           $   %         %        

       #    #     &   

 

#   !

     $  '

  

 !

       

 (!

    $





   $  

))*!

          *!

 

      %

+*!

                   ""

   &   !

,    "!

-   #   ")!

     "!

 #   $  

"*!

    &  "(! 

      #  

>

         

 



  # '     %

 #   

    .   !

             #       .       /    %                %    0       !

 #   

                   #   #   # 



 )  $ 

 

 $%1$ ! 

 #      %                     /   .   

    

 0          

)2   

       

      

    

     

       

         

       #       $   3

 1

"

1



" 

 ((<

(:)<  " 

"

"  1" 1   1 .

""

  1

;

     .

""#

  1 $ ,   >   

"

" # "  (( *: ,**+ -.
/(<0 *3 (* ,**+ -.
/(+0 '  #  4#  

  / $ ,   



   ,( (, ,**3 -.
/,(0  B"#

  .

""  - $ %0

 1

1

 .

"



 1   > 1"

 " C

7 1 1  $ , ""

   

"

   " 1 



"

""# 

1# 1

  

"   ""  1 ' 

    

"



1

  "   " "

 

.  1 

1

'    1    

"

# "

 $ ,  .  > " #

"

$ %    1"  #   ,( (, ,**3 -.
/,(0  

""    1# 

$ ( 



 

 ((+

(:)<   

  "

"

 



 ""

"



" #

  "

# 

"

""#"

  () *+ ,*(( -.
/,%0 4"



 # 

 $ (   /
4 $      #  5 !   62) % #

 $   62)    7

)  

  

 

  

 5 %!

 8      #-9   5  6  

      

   &     

#    3 :  #   #  $         #- 9    6    

   

 4#           #         9        #- 6        % #  

    

      5        #       6  3

=   D1

"   -?D ?

0

"



#

  (::) (< 



  "#

#

""

"  



#

 ""

 #

 " 1    "  

1# 1

 7 "  $ ,   /
;

      

 7

:  

#         

  #

    #-9   5   6  

    

 

 1<=>9<=5421569;?;+

 1;2;@75      

  #

             9        #-   9   5  6  

  

 ;A575   

 #     ' *""B  :

   9   %     #-9   5 6  

  !

 9C2  1<D:  ;?>@<C;;57  5

     9   1$ % 8 E 6  %           9    1$% 9   =$  %         1$        0    9 %5%6'8 -      6

 .$   !

$ 6;2:@  1<D:  ;?>@<C;;57  5

            6  1$ %  

6    - %=$      %. >  %8 -    3 7   1 " %

"

5 " 1  

   1 #

1 " %

5 " 







## 

1

 



#

  "     

 1#   

 #

1# 1

  



#

 

 9  1"## 

#



  "# #

"    

1# 1

'  

 



(::% 1

$#"  $ 1"#    

 

""    1 #



  "# #  "



# "  ' 

  

     

 # 1 " %

5 "

  $ (



$ % "#  "#1"

1# 1

'    1 "

  "

 

" %

5 "  

 # 1 1

"  1  1"##



<   " 



 

""  "  1 #



  "# # #  1 #"

"  1#  "



  1   " 



  " # #    

1 " %

5 " "    1>





" '  "

 "

"    

" # " '

   1 9  #  "# 

"

1

 

"    "



   # 1 9   

' #   #

 "

 " 

  9  = "



" # " 

  " "

"         # 

#

 ""#

 " "" # "



     "  

 #     1# 1" ' 

  1  1  

"   "

""

  # 

1"#  '  

"   1  " " %

 5 / " ;

   1 "

1 /"  1 /"

 "    ""

1

) 7

  # "

""# 1 /"

7 1     "

 



 >#

?1"

   4 %', &7&'#% '4! !%&!%$ - '&!%!2!"9 >< <46=  7 " 1  ?1"

  

 ,% ,<   # ""

""     / F:'&       #   2 . 2

        #

# 8 

# 

&    %$    .

   



 4   %   

   

 #  $# $  $   :51 %#$%  

# $  %    # &     #     2

. 25: -%#$%  

  

#    %$   2#    #4  

     
   

    

   

 
     

 !"

#
$%:6   7 F4  #

       $ #  '$     

      # 

    ,      

= 

$      $     $  :  #   ?/  G - &

 

!'"#()* $

#  / 7 F'$     

    

#

   , % 

     

 % $   &       %      



$:

,

$ $      $ # #



 %4  %  9  -    # 

 # #F :    # ?/ G - D

$5      

4  

6  ) +,- 

!'"#
  



& $  .



 / 0 
'

    ## !'"#
 ? #/&

$    

$     ?  /   G -  # $ 4$#  6

    

    2 

#  

# %  

#   $              $   

 2

+  %%              

#      

# 3

  $ ( , 

  ""



 "

#  #  -.
/,(
/,%0    >   " 7  #   1

 

#



 ""#" $  #  #

"

 

  1  "      

   #   "1"     #"

   # 1"     " 1"

> 1



    "

  "#   :F

 

   1 

    ""

 "#  

 

  ""



  7

 " 

"



"#   :F

  



 

 

 

  

  4""   1 1     

  ""       ? 44 6;@ (< *8 ,*(3  $