Prem Parkash v. State Of Punjab And Others
CWP PIL No. 133 of 2021 1
!"#$#%&'&() * +#, !+-!'. / #"&"&(#+ 0#+'1' 2"!"# 1(3!4!($".#+' #'5($#("'
+#'#(") +!61'.15"!7$8%!"#7+".#5#"&"&(#+ '!8!(6! !197''&'"!("$8%!"##(#+!97 1(3!47 +".#+#'5($#("'
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
#8#(1#7
#.!4&9&"!"&(!($&'!'"#+ !(!:#,#("78#+(,#(" 1(3!4 #!+(#$%1('#9+".#5#"&"&(#+'14,&"'".!"46&''1&(:".# &,51:(#$ &('"+1%"&(' $!"#$ C E 7 ".# !1".+&"&#' .!8#<&".$+!<(".#+#?1&+#,#("'5+#'%+&4#$46".#9#""#+'=&('"+1%"&('$!"#$
CWP PIL No. 133 of 2021 2 B *!($ *#1+".#+'14,&"'".!"46$&(:!<!6<&".".# !+#'!&$+#?1&+#,#("4"!&(&(:@ 43#%"&(#+"&&%!"#A7".#!1".+&"&#' !+#5#+,&""&(:"+!('#+59"'='&"#'&(1(!1".+&>#$%9(&#'7".!".!8#4##( +!&'#$465#+'('7<.!+#(#&".#+".#%9(&>#+'(+".#%9(&#'.!8#4##( #'"!49&'.#$&(!%%+$!(%#<&".".#5+#'%+&4#$9!< #'19"!("96,!-&(:".# #("&+# 5+%#'' "!-&(: !%"&( !:!&('" ".# 1(!1".+&>#$ %9(&>#+' +#$1($!(" " &' '14,&""#$ ".!" '#""&(: 15 !($ #'"!49&'.&(: 1(!1".+&>#$ %9(&#' &' 5+.&4&"#$ 46 ".# 5+8&'&(' ".# 1(3!4 5!+",#(" !($
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
G<.#+#&(".&'1+".!$ 15.#9$ ".# ,!($!"+6 %($&"&( 4"!&(&(: @ 43#%"&( #+"&&%!"#A 4#+#+#:&'"+!"&($%1,#("'!'+#?1&+#$46".#5+8&'&('!+6!(! #8#95,#(" !($ #:19!"&( +4!( +#!' %"7 CEF .# %("#("&( +!&'#$ 4#+# ".&' 1+" &( ".!" %!'# <!' ".!" @ 43#%"&( #+"&&%!"#A %19$("4#$#,!($#$46".#!1".+&"&#'5+&+"+#:&'"+!"&(!'".!"<19$
CWP PIL No. 133 of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
'!9#59"'!($'&"#'&'4#&(:5#+,&""#$ #!+(#$ ''&'"!(" $8%!"# #(#+!9 !55#!+&(: + ".# +#'5($#("2"!"# 1(3!4 ( &('"+1%"&(' '14,&"' ".!" ".# &,51:(#$ &('"+1%"&('$!"#$ C.!8#4##(&''1#$46".#!1".+&"&#'%(%#+(#$ !"#+4"!&(&(:!(5&(&(+,".#9!<$#5!+",#("2.#7.<#8#+7'14,&"' ".!" &( 8&#< ".# &''1#' +!&'#$ 46 ".# 5#"&"&(#+7 ".# ,!""#+ <19$ 4# +##D!,&(#$46".#!1".+&"&#'&(".#9&:."".#'"!"1"+65+8&'&('!'<#99 !'".#$#%&'&(+#($#+#$46".
G !($ ! +#'. $#%&'&( &( ".# ,!""#+ '.!99 4# "!-#( !" ".# #!+9&#'" &( !%%+$!(%#<&".9!< ('5#%&&%&('"+1%"&('7'.#1+".#+'14,&"'".!""&99 '1%. $#%&'&( &' "!-#( 46 ".# !1".+&"&#'7 ".# &,51:(#$ &('"+1%"&(' $!"#$ C E '.!99 4# -#5" &( !4#6!(%# !($ ".# !1".+&"&#' '.!99%("&(1#"!$.#+#"".#5+#8&1'&('"+1%"&('$!"#$B *!($ *
CWP PIL No. 133 of 2021 4 (8&#<".# !+#'!&$'"!"#,#(" ,!$# 46 9#!+(#$ ''&'"!(" $8%!"##(#+!97 1(3!47".#5#"&"&(&9#$46".#5#"&"&(#+&'$&'5'#$ <&". ! $&+#%"&( " ".# %(%#+(#$ !1".+&"&#' " %('&$#+ !($ $#%&$# ".# 5#"&"&(#+A' +#5+#'#("!"&( $!"#$
E B
* 7 !' #D5#$&"&1'96 !' 5''&49#7 !"#+ "!-&(: &(" %('&$#+!"&( !99 ".# &''1#' +!&'#$".#+#&(&(%91$&(:".#5+8&'&('9!<!($".#$#%&'&(+#($#+#$46 ".&'1+"&(&8&9+&" B
G465!''&(:!+#!'(#$ +$#+!($%,,1(&%!"#".#'!,#"".#5#"&"&(#+ "&',!$#%9#!+".!"".&'1+".!'("#D5+#''#$!(65&(&(( ".#,#+&"'".#%!'#!($".#,!""#+.!'4##($&'5'#$&("#+,'".# &''1#'+!&'#$46".#5#"&"&(#+!($&("#+,'".#'"!"#,#(",!$#469#!+(#$ ''&'"!("$8%!"##(#+!97 1(3!4
02H 2
* +!8&($#+ .#".#+'5#!-&(:=+#!'(#$ #'= .#".#++#5+"!49# #'=