Managing Director Punjab State Warehousing Corporation Ltd And Others v. Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal Bathindaand Another
!
"
# #
"
# #
"
"$$
"
$ "
"
"#
"
# "$
% & ' ' ''
#$ !
%& '( ")*$ + (!
,-./.0,12-0
) '($( ")*$ + (!
,-34-/,12-0
" ")*$ + (!
-5662$ "15.1-+12-0
7$ $")*$ + !
,1514/,12-0
$ $#8 '( ")*$ + (!
,-0526,12-0
$9$:$: ")*$ + - ,-./.0,12-0
$ ;
'<$ ")*$ + 1 ,-34-/ -5662 -0526$ "1514/+12-0$ + 3 ,-34-/ -5662 -0526 1514/+12-0 ((( ' '') &
(!
8;
*( +!
(*($<< ' (=$ " "$" -42-12-0%
>;
,4&!$
"89($8;
89=(*( (= 7# ($) 8 '
" ( 8 + +
)* =( * ;9 $ " .2? 8$*7 =$' 1 $ +$* 8 ' *"+ (*
*$!!
*$ +(
; ($ " (!;
+(!
(+$* 8 '$7 ;!+ #
-34-/+12-0 $"= ! =$ $!! " $ (<! -.20-00/ * ;" = 7 << ( )* = # $" *#8 1222 ( = "" $ $ 9 $* $'$
( ! , !$ # ;
< 112612-1 =( $ *<$# ! =$ +<" ( $" *<$# =$
" ( $8;
+ $":;"*$ $ " ;<#$<9 ( #!;'
$ "$"-42-12-0%
>;
,4&=$ !$
"=( ( # +( )* +(= 89(! ,!$ # =$ (<"88$" ('
;
"($ ( = ($" = 7" + # ($ 132 "$9 )* 8+ # + ( )* @; # + * 1.%&+( ";
$< !; * -03/ %( $+
" $ -03/ *& =$ *#!<" =( 89 ( ! , !$ # ($$ #<$ $=$ "($ $< 8 !$
" (*$ +( = 7# 89($8;
=( ( # + # )*($ 8 (<"88$" " ( 8 + +
$< ' =( * ;9 )* $ " .2? + 8$*7 =$' ($ 8 $=$ ""( $"=$ "
;
*($<< '8+ ( 89
' $ !<$ ($ ( $8;
(;<" ($) $ " (
; $+ $ ! "+-69$
= 7# "" ($)$ 9>!<$ + $!!
$*( $8;
+ "
$<+( )$ *$+ $ "($<+"*$"$!!
>#$<9 $
" *;
< + ( ! ,!$ # < ;! ( :;"'# + ( A8< ;!
# ;
+ "$ *+*, --./, $" 0 ) 1.2*1.1 3
" <" .1435/1* /36 &71 8.9:4: ;/1</+/36477= * ($+$ * #$"$+ $! "+ ) 9$
;*( * =(; :;
"* +($8;
*;
$ $ $ "$":;"*$;! 6 ! *+# B= 7# ($)$!!$ "$ ($)* ""($( # +( )* 89(! ,!$ # =$ (<" 8 8$" 7! ' )= ( )<$ + !
)
+ -03/ * $ " ( = 7# =(= $*<$
#!<9= $=$ +( '( "( + ("<$9+-69$
+< '(*<$#! ($ '(<98 * " "89$8;
;
$ !$
(#!;'
"+ (8 ++( 7# =(*(=$ (;<"8;!(<" 3 $
" *;
< + B = 7# !<$* <$ * ;! :;"'# +( A8< ;!
#;
)<!!$< 5363+12-3 "*"" -4-112-3 <" /5<4>*9 '*35< +.9:4: .3.9/, /3/5.9) /9=/3/
/1?/=:)*::/9* "($"<$9*$
*# (=$9+') ':;
* (= " 9(#*<$#(8 +(9#$98 <" . ($)($ "<$
"*;
<+ (!$ "($)' ( ;'((
* "=(( $8<$
* 4 #(+$* =(*( ($)8
$"( 8+
! ($ ( ($ 8 $ "<$9 !$ + ( ' ( * 8+ ( $8;
! ( :;"'# ;/1</+/36477=%: 2/:. :4-9/ /9$
"<$9($ 8 *
" "$ +$$<$ "=$ (<"($( * *;<" ($) 8 #$" ; ( !
*$ ( ! , !$ # "" *($<< '( * "89 , $ *($<< '(:;
"* +($8;
$ $#$ " <9 $+ (#!;'
"!$
"($"' $'$
(# (9($)$!!
$*("( ;
*($<< ' $# ('
;
"+"<$9 / ( #<$ )=($(!
< '""<$9=<<8+$$< *$ ( $# >!<$ "($ 8 $"89( A8< ;!
#;
+ "$ *+*,
--./, $ 0 ) 1.2*1.1 3 $ ) <" ;4,1..- '*35< +.9:4: 3:794@.37 .:*53 .+.,-@.37 /31 /2*,*7*.: .3>9. /31 /37<.9 $ $'
$!(1-+( $":;"'# $"
;
,
! !
" ! "
# $
% ! &
!
' !
!
&
'
( $
#
'
$ ) &
!
'
*+
, - ! '
!
' %
$ )
, .
( $ / &
!
!
!
'
!
! 0
!
' !
' !
!
1
'
! !
! 2 ! 3 ( $ /5<4>*9'*5<%:2/:.:4-9/)8 +=$ "(= 89
* " '$+ " '($("<$9 '$ *=<< $7$=$9( '(+ (= (" !;($8;
8;($8;
($ 7! ( $""<$9 # "=(<$":;"*$ ';! (*<$#+(#!<9 5 ($<9+(* *;# * (= ($=( ("<$9 ' ( * ($ 8 >!<$ " $":;"*$ + ( * " @;$ ( " !;89($8;
8*# +$$<$ "($*+ *89( = *$ 8*($<< '" ('
;
"+("<$9$ ") +("<$9
+$$< ( "<$9 $!!
$*( ' ( $8;
($ 8 7! # " =(< $":;"*$ '(*<$# "89(= 0 * ( +$* $ " * *;# * + ( !
*$ * ( $8;
($ $< $"9$":;"*$";! ( 8= (!$ # ( !
$9 +(!
($(*<$#+( (;<"8 :*" ; '(<9 8 '$**!" -2
,>!<$ ""<$9+# ($ $"*$"($ 8 $"$ +$$<8; (#!<9 =$ @; "*($<< '( *$(+
$)$<$8<!! ;
9 *<$# <+ +*<$#" !"<$9($ 8
"(;
=( $ !
*$ '
;
"+"<$9($ 8 "$+ ;++ '$ $=$ " -- ;
( (!
*$ =(<'
<+( , = ($8;
($ '
"("<$9 '+( *(
)* +(#!<9 = # $" (9$ 1222=( $ (=$ "($ 8 !$
"$+ -09$
'(#=((8 ++
)* + 8 + +
)* $ #! 9 #!<9 =( (<" '! #$ ! ($ 8 *
" "89($8;
=(<!$
' (#!;'
" <$ ";
<
#!<9($ $ '((<"(! $ ( $"! <<> ""; +(= ""8" *($ '" ( 8 ++
)**;<" ($)8 "$ "( $# (;<" ($)8 $7 *
" 89($8;
=(<'
'(8 ++
( !
*$ ( 8 + +
)* ($ 8 '
"$+ -09$
=(*(8 +($ 8 "89($8;
=(; 9$!!<*$ +# " -1 (@; =(*($ + " # ($=($=;<"8( 8 +=(*((= *;<"8'
" ('
;
"+<<'$< # + ( )* 89 ( ! ,!$ # $ # + ( )* +
7# =$ (<"88$" <9 ('
;
"($ @; # ;
* 1.%& = *#!<" =(( $8;
$( ($ '
' (
=((8 ++
)*=(8$*7=$' * ;9 )* ( 8 + + *#!
(;<" ($) 8 '
" ( +$* "* *;# * +(!
*$ ('
+8 ++
)* $+ 12 9$
$ " ($ =( 8$*7 =$' =(< * " ' ( "<$9
*89( =(*("<$9($ ' ;
>!<$ " *;<" ($)8 " (+$* "* *;# * +(!
*$ -6 * (= (;<"($)8 "(8 ++<;#!
;# *#!
$( ($ <+=(*(($ 8 "89($8;
-3 ( ) *( + ( & $ 0 <" '46<>*9'*35<+.9:4:'7/7.0/9=/3//317<.9:)1.2*1.13$ $ ($ (<"$ ;
, 4 !
' 5 ! !
'
6 7 !
!
( $ 0
'
,
'
6!
!
,
46
/8
46
/8 !
'
'
6!
&
$
!"#$$ % 46
/8
!
& ' $ ($)
! * #$$ +"+
!
496
/8 ! , - ./ $ 0 1# - 2+ 2!#$. *
:
46
/8 ! ( - 3 (& 4
" 531 # 26 26!#$$6
!
46
/8
7 ( 0 #8# 9&
: # 9 0 2 %! #$4 %2"
5!
46
/8
'
6 ; !
C -. ( <+') (#!;'
"
#"+"(> ($ = =<< 8 <" + <;#! ;# *#!
$" +
)*$ "8$*7=$' (*#!
=<<8!$"7! ' )=(:;"'# + ( '46<>*9 '*35<%: 2/:. :4-9/ A .2 222D, + $*( *#!<" 9$
)* *$ $ #!<9($ )*# ($ 4# ( )* ( $#=<< $< 8 $" $ *#!<" 9$ + ( !;
+ *$<*;<$ ' ( $#;
+ *#!
-4 E! ' )= ( $8) 1 $<< ( = !
=<<'(+<<= '$#;
+*#!
8 + -34-/+12-0
=<< ' *#!
+ - .2 222D, + ( 6 9$
)* -./.0+12-0 ( , =<<'*#!
+ 6 22 222D,+ ( 49$
)* -5662+12-0 ( , =<<'$*#!
+ - 22 222D,+ ( 19$
)*
1514/+12-0 ( =<<'$*#!
+ - 22 222D, + ( 19$
)* 15.1-+12-0 ( , =<< '$*#!
+ - 22 222D,+ ( 19$
)* -0625+ 12-0 ( , =<< ' $ *#!
+ - 22 222D, + ( 1 9$
)* -6 ;
( $"<;#!
;#*#!
(;<"8 <$ " +$);
+ ( =( $! "+5=7 + #( *!+*!9+( *$ (*#!
" $
"$ <$ "=( (#
+ $#'
" (#!<9=<<$< 8 <"+ F5?!$ $" *#!
+ #("$+( <<($*;$<!$9# +( $# -3 "+ ($8) # -. )< *!!<*$ ! " ' +$ 9 ($<<$< "" "+ -4 !(*!9 + ( 8 !<$*" ( +< + ( *
*" !
# # ' '' @/@7/ (( !$7 'D $ " G (( ! $8< G