Suman Gupta v. State Of Punjab And Another
!
"#$# %&'((
)& *+) ( ,)- )
! "!#
!$ %
&&&& )- ) .( '
(
)
$ * !
++,-++.
$ /
) ! ## !
0
! !
"
!
# ! !
$%&
'
'
"
( " " '
(" ) '
'
(
!
# ! !
$%&
" (
'
%*
'
(
'
+
+
+' , -+
./ !
0$&12&3 456 ! !
! !& 7
5 , +'./ )
(
' 8
! !
'(
' (
'
' *(
' ) ** ** ** ** **9 +
(
#
% % ( $ * # !
+1 '112 !# # !% +3 '+ +224 (
( # ! #
$
#
+2 2.
+2'2 +'
2.
+2'25 6 0'7
( %
( #
24 '2 +2'4 '4 '2 +2'4 /
*# %
( # 57 +2 2+ +2+2
#
*8 15 6 0+7
( 6 # %
( # ( #
# ) 9 ( $ * # !57
# +2'.9 (
# 0
%$ 5
'
5 *:;
' '
'(
*
%
* '(
"
('"
''(
<
<
= $! 6 '
*
5 *:;
(
'(
"
(;
'* ('( "
'(
"
(;
$ 5
'( ' (%% '
(
' ( 5>6?=@A:
8 % ! :!
*
;6
<#
* %
0
0 %
0
+
(
# '22:
= !
%
( #
) !# %
(
#
* %
( $ * # !
> ?
( # +2'. *
+1 2'
+2+2 * ! 8 + "
# 9 9 9.* 9
9@* 9 (
0
$ ('
+' 1
(
$< 5
$B
5
C"! !
$! (
'
/ <D
! =
+' 1
(
$< 5
C"!
#" 5 *:"% $ 6 !" E E"
E ( E"
E ( E '' ) $ 6 " E E"
E
( E"
E*( E '' % 5C,-==6<F" ( <
+'" ?
F G ' ?
@
(
! * !
( #
+'
2.
+2+3
+?
2.
+2+35 6 0?7 #
@ *
%
( # '.
'2 +2+3
!
# ( # (
*
1 * 8 , # * * +2+' * 8 .0 ! #*
+?
+2'1
A #*
!
8 + # !
# /
'4 +2+35 6 0@7
! (
#
3'
'2 +2+3 B
#
!#
##
! * (
'3 +2+?
4%
(
# ( #
# *
! *8 '2 '.
!
*
#
,
#* * *
8
*#
%
( $ * # !
# 8 '+
0 H
'
* 2(
?
0 ! !
"
?
1
'(
! !
#
* 2(
?
#% %! !
" + ('
"
! !
+ (
8
" 0 F " 0 3 ! !
'
'
F ?' (1
<=I>C%1
' ' ' <
>("
H ( $
! !2 20 ( $
! !
3 =
<=I>C%
?' ( 1
6 1F # & 3H2 00 !2
!&
5 "
! !
)'
'
0
'
! !
H
" (
' (
& J' ( !( ' !0 & ! !2"'
/ ' * (
I
"
! !
"
'
?' (1
6 :
& 3H2 !#33 ? 3 ! !
1 I / " 5 6 " ' (
2 J
?' ( 5
C
?' ( 1
" '
+ '
" ""
+'I: " 5 6 "
%*
' (
!
"
! !
"
I: 5 6 ' (6
I:
! !
$ ' ;% E= '
4 1
( I'
C
( I'
=
''( (
I ( ( (
' (
'
B
(
4 ( '
'
(
$
?' (
+ '(
(
<
! !
20(
&
" 3 0 ! !
( ?
! % !%! !
$
" '( '+ '( + $'
"
?
1
$?1"
'+
2 B
"?1 '
'
?' (1
" ' ( ( "
' (
"
(
' (
$
' 0
"
0
! !
$
' !"
"
(
H
('"
+
( 6'(
' (
(
(
#
F ' 1
:
>
(: ?
?"'
" '
( (
' "
"
0 I "
( '
( 5
(
"
(
'
' 9 .
/ ##
#*
!
# ( # '.
'2 +2+3 A @ * 6
*
3'
'2 +2+3
24 +2+3
B ! % * $
+?
2?
+2+3
/; $ !
* ! *
?':
# ##
# #
;#*
# !
!
,2* @4* ( '2 '2 +2+3
*
21 '2 +2+3
$
#D
8!
!
*
@3: *
1 ! *
A #*
#" 8! 6
*
D3'
'2 +2+3
#" 8!
# ! * 9 9
A #* #
5
% *7
*
*
3'
'2 +2+3
!
@4* /
#* 21 +2+3 # *# %
( #
#
+2 2+ +2+2 ## !
* !
! * ! 5
7
! % # $
5% $7 #
!
# # #
( # = % #
$
! # #
*
!
*
*
A
! #
3'
'2 +2+3
3'
'2 +2+3 C
## !
'3 +2+?
6
$ #
!
'
!
# (
# '.
'2 +2+3
! ( #
3'
'2 +2+3 #* ## !# *
## A # #
#*
!
0
*
* ! * # ( #
!
* !
+'
2.
+2+3
E !
#*
!
# (
# '.
'2 +2+3 '3*
3'
'2 +2+3
*
!
# ! !
,2*
! 6
# " 8!
#
% *7
*
*
(
# ! # *
#
# '2
/
# #
''
(
$
( # '.
'2 +2+3 #
*
6
%
( # '+
(
!
# ( # #* '.
'2 +2+3 A
* 6
24 +2+3
! *
+?
2?
+2+3 /; $ !
* ! *
?':
# ##
# #
;#*
# !
!
,2* @4 * ( '2 '2 +2+3
*
21 '2 +2+3
$
# D
8!
! *
@3: *
! *
# " 8! 6 *
# ! *9 9 A #*
#
5
% *7
*
*
3'
'2 +2+3 '3
( $ ! "# $ %&
'()* # +,- ! #
#
* ! /
*
%
$
#
B
!
# #
*
$
*
# 0%
# ;!
%
$ $
*
'?
(
! $ $ . # "# $ % &/ !
01 2 * 3, / # *
! #
%
$
# %
$ #*
* #
A ) *
$
*
* '@
( B9# $
! +.
''
+2+? 45 678 "0 #
& '
* 19# -', #
#*
#
*
/
#* % #
!
# $
D
(
#
$
! +1 '+ +2',
B
# # 2?
2'
+2'. *
# * 32 '+ +2', B
# ! #
! *
D !
##
( # ( # # !
#*
#*
( # ) # !
8 '
#*
#* #*
#
* #
#
! #
# #
3'
'+ +2',
* #
( ( # ## !
$# B ! $
* !
( # ( ! B !$ ## !
B9# $
# 0 3 =
'
"
(
K
1
D
'
( (
'
"
=
" ( (
1
7 # : ;7 <50 0 '
* # </ # 3,=" '
;
0 =
(
'+
6'
"
' '
'(
+ (
'
"
"
=
* " ( '(
$ ;. #> 55
) '
# 3- "
0 / 1 / 5 .
;)-- # - $ # 85# $ %)--- 3# '-"
%-: '
;
& 1
" "
'
'
"
'(7 C ("- " 0 / 1 / 5 .
; &
' ; &LL
"' ( (
' "
"
B
F 1
'(
% ( 5
&
5
H
1 "
% + (
'
( + &! 5 1 : $ # 8 5 # $ %"( 5
& 5
H$
1 =
' (
'
"
'
-
C" - 8 5 " 1 - "
, 8 "
8" 7 8 " -- "
'
!! !#; 5
& H$ ;
'
!! 5
& 5
H$ (
(
5
&
( ( ('
H$
;
' (
( D
(
(
= ' ( '(
1
$ 5
H 5
&
8
5
&
( 5
&
" E (
(E
(
(
E(
E' "
8
"
'
H $ ( (
'
D "
'E E
>
(
'E E =
' ( D '
"
'
' E E "
E E'
( (
5
H$ !# = "
' * > . 4
?>. 4 5# @ )--3 # '"
/ ?A / 5#
;
)--3 ,# (="
"
(
(
' E E
'( $
' ( ( (
"
K (
(
' E E
H$
'
'
(
' > . 4 ?>. 4 5 # @ C"
32 E! = # 7 5> 9 --#
)
# ((*"
(
' (
'
" ('
(
. 5 A 5@ 1
-- #
) # "
"
(
( ' 8
(
(
'
@ 8D)0
5# @ ) '', '# (*,"
; # K
(
'
(
' '
(
(
" '(
1
. A 5@
1
/
" ( '
8
(
' (
(
( '
'
= +
"
' +
L
0 1
(
'
( ( '
' (
' '
(
(
'
(
E $ ! =
"
6 '
"
1
/ C2&$ $
K :
C" (
(
'
("
"
' ' !
K D
6
' "
5
& H$
1 = " '
' '
('
(
1
6
'
0 "
'
1
/ "
( !! 5
' "
+
B'
("! !
'(
F 1
1
+
!H
- "!
3'(
' '
(
'( 9 ',
8 ! )
*
#*
!
#
( # '.
'2 +2+3
'3 *
! !
#
3'
'2 +2+3 % ! # #
*
! *
*
!#* 8
## !
6 #
# ! D#* # ! ( ! !
! ( #
'.
B
#
) !* ##
!
( #
#
A #*
*! $ 6
93( ', D7 5 . # 5 #
;
D 3 '=
# *%
"
$ / 9*-3 '- D# B ;
57 5. # )
1 8 /D ','- '- #*
B9# $ #/ ) 9= 3 '
' D#
;
57 5. # ) 8
8 5D '-'3 '
'
( ! 5. # E )
## * $ +.
2+ +2+? 6 3* '
'
F1!
"# B ;
E
( 0 4
/
! !
2 !
! $5
* % %!
(
'
' '
(
"8
"
'
'
(
/ " (
! 4
1
6 93( ', 7 5. # "# B ;
3 '= ) ,
"
( (
?
'
' ' '(
4
'
' ' '(
" ( '
7 5. # E )
'
' *
1
*
7 5. # E )
& 4
"
"
'
8
/
4
'
'
/ '"
'
' (
' ' *
/
"
' ' + 2 K
' "' '(
7 5. # E )
"
H =
' # / "' ' '(
(' * ( ( '(
1
" +
(' '(
" '
'
( (
1
0 7
( (
5. # E )
"
7 5 . # E )
'4
/
! ! #
( #
# * # (
#
+'
2.
+2+3 !
* !
##
3'
'2 +2+3
* ## # #
* '1
(
'(( 5)- ) * C ) !- -8 C # -8