High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/3601/2013dismissed

Tilak Raj v. Charanjit Singh

2025-05-07Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra11 pages

!"# $#%&'&()*++ &,!- !. #"&"&(#/ 0#/'1' 2!/!(.&" &(32 #'4($#(" ) 56

!" !" 7

#!" " !$

% & !'( &) *(() $! +

" $,!( % -(

%& .

% % )"% $ & /0# %

% ( 2 0 ! & $% 3()

4!$, ! " 4 !% &( %, ))

"( !$%( !

#!" !%%

!%%& !'( &) +

" $,!( %

% 2 -( & % 4!$, ! ""% ! " ! $

)

.!5 ! ( , !" ! !%%$ "! & %) %(& ( & % 6 % !"("

"% !

" ! ! ) )"% 4

% $, ! )"% ! %%& !! ( ! &)%% 06 4

% -&2 &!7 &)48 ( 1

( !

!4 /6 4 ) & /6 444 $, 9 #! ( ! )( :5! ), )! )"% 1

8 ( "4 ,

( ! )"% -&2 &! /6 4 % ! 5" $ , & &!% 8 ( /6 4 % 4%%; % &!) )9 ( )"% 7!! )"% ( !

), *(!"

! ( ! 5 ()

/ < #!

!*( 4!" $ !

$5$,! )"% 4 ( ("

4 ! ! )5 =3(

( > ?

/ 5 & ! (

!*(4& " + 1 4&

!( #! ( % )5",) !)( !*( "

( !$, )"%% &! )"%

)"% /

&!"% ,

!% %( ()) ! ( ))

"( !$% (

0 ! !

"" ( 4 ("!

) ;"% &( %,! % ) % 1 # ($ !

! )"% 8) !

)% 7 " ( ! ) 4 $

"% & % (" () ! % !

#!) ! ( 4 ( 4! !$'( !

&( % % ) !

)% $ ; ($) !! () !!" &)%%4 &

() !*(! $ $,!

)

!& !

%&% ,

! $

( + ! & ! &() $, $! !

"" &!

" (

!% %(!% ( &( %, ))

"( !$%( 2 0 !

)( & )"% )" ) " 4 , ",

<3 (% ",)

(! ( & )"% )" ) )! .% & &&

! (

% ""%4!

) $,!""%% (

'( &) +

4 ! ! ) ! " " !$

% 0 3 &( $,% (% !" < ( !!

&& ! )"(& '( &) % $,!($%4 ( $% ! , %4 4!

% &

& !

& ! % ($%4 & ! ! $" !,&) %&%%, $%

! $8 ( $,! ( #! ( 4 %,!4 !" (%"

% *(4!

!!&)4%%& %,8 ( #! !*( *(

" !$& $,! ( 4!

&$( !*( ( , ( ! )( !%% $ "

9 8 ( &!% *( /6 4 % ( ! )"% @!4 4" !! !*( *( 4& $,!

) ! " "% 4 $%, 5 4 %( %, $, !

) #!

" ( ! $ ""%, "" #! 4 %&%%, $% $ & !

/ ( 4!

! ! 4 % $%

!& $, 4, ( !*( *( #! : % ( ""%% (

""%, ! '(

() "5 & ," " !$" $, !) 7 ! ! $ ($) &( ! ! )"(& '( &)% $%$

!" $ " !" $ *( !%%& *( ))

"( !$%( 2 0 ! ? #! " %%, "" !(&! !

(% $( ($*(%,!"" !

$!%

#! $, % (% ! " !$& ( % $

!,( ),$) !! (

& $, 4 ( ! " ! "" ! !

(8 %'(

3 4%%% ! % & !

( ("" 8 !'(

% 5""%%( ! " ! 8)%, %4 2 /0 6! , & 5 2(

! '(

!"(" , & % ! %&% , "" , ,

& "

! &(% , ,"

& (#!$' !" &!" '(

%4#!!$ 4%% ( 4!

! $ ) !)

(% 7!

& ! *( 4!! ! " '(

%4 ! % ( *( 4%%

1 %&! (" !

! !

& !

& $ ! ! $ ) $, ;A$% 2(")(

"# 4! 4!% #!4%% " ) ! % '(

&! ( , % $ 8 ( ) !(% % '( "#3

4 !

" %4 $4!! 8 %'(

) (B

6 "

& (! 4(% $"" " ( ! (, " 2 0 ! 3 4!

! % !"(" 4!

! %%4 &'2(1/ %2#81# /&('1

&%&#(%97#"%7 1($' &("2#!%%1("7!, !*( 4$," () $,!

)4 !$5 ",) , )( ), ! " ) ( ! ( !

!& 4!% " , $ ! % , ( $, ! $5 ("

! $ ( !)( ),

! ( (

!(! !*(! 8 !)(& $"

)! ( $,&)) 4 !!$5 ( !"!%%$

) ! ))

!%% 4 !( "'(

,!" !

$"( ! ! )" ) ) 4!

! ), $ 8 4 , 4 !

! ), 8 4 ! )( ! !*( 4 !$!

& !

!%%""%, (%C

! !*( ! $ " ! $5 4 !

" 8)! )! 4!

! 4 !

!" %

, 4!

! % D

$!",!!% ( ( ! !*( ! ),$ )5 ) !",)

)( ),$,&

& 4 & !

4 ! !*( 4 !

, , ! "

) $,!

) )!$5&

&!( ! !*(("

! 4 ( ! !*( %)5!",) !

)( ),!", ! ), $ !!% ( ( ! !*( 4 !

, ! " !

@8"% . ! "(" !

E $ ! % ,E ) %&%%, $% $ ! ,>

.(! " !) ! ! ( &(! !*( *( "()" $ 4 4!

! (% !

& ! ( 2

! %, 4 "()" ! , & $% () 4 ) 4

!"()" () 2 ? ! "4!

!!% ! !*( !

!& 4!%

" , $!% , )$

!" "()" !! !*(4 4

& $,! ( !

!& $ % , 3

& !!

##!

;A$% 2(") ( ! %

4 " "% " &!"()" !( "

!()) F (

! 8 ( ! !*(

? ! ) "()" !! !*(4

!& , $!% ,

#! "()" ( 2 ? $($% "()" ! ( ! ( ! "$$% #! " $( & ! "()" ! !"" "$$

#$(!"()" " ! ( %,

% $,!

)! ( %%, !) %($) $,! )"% "$$% 3 "" "$$ $ 4 %, ) ! ) % $(&! $,!" $(%$, !

() ("4!

!!,%,

#! , ! ( ) ! $8 ("" !

2 ? )"

,$( "( $(

3 , ! ( ) ! $8(""!

/ #! (" $, ! " < )"% ! &) 0 6 4 % ! $ 8 ( $, ! ( !

(( !

/6 4 % 44 $,!

4! / 6 4 % 4 4 $, 9 ! ( ! ( 5&!% 8 ( *(!% % ! ),*( 06 4 % "!%%& ! ( ! $ $% & ! % *( / 6 4 % 8 (

( ! )"% !

!&!

% ,",$ 5! )(

/ < 4!

!45$,!

)$,4, ),

& &!% 8 ( *( /6 4 %

!! !*( *( ( ! )"% ! ) ! $

!( #!(&! !

) ( 2 ! ( ( , !*( ( ! )"%

0 !4 4!

% 8) & ! )"% $ ! % % (

, ! $5 (&& 4& !

) ! ! !*( 4 & $, !

) ! )"% ! "(" ( , )") ! 5"% $4!" ,"

( !(* 4 & !

! %

) ! &) 4% ! )"% !!! &!"! !*(#!

(&& 4 $ $,! )"% #! (

&(! !*( *( !(&! !!&)@8 4 & ()! $5$(4 ! & !*( *( ( ! "% ! $ 5 ( !

( ! % ( $%4 ! &!%, $ !!8 ( ! !*( *( $,! ( ! $

(%,"

1 .(! % ,)

! ( !

)% (&& ! )"% !! !*( *( 4 ( , !*(7 !& ( , !*( !%%% "" %4 !

( !*( % , $8 !)(!$ )%&%%, $% 2 0 ! ( ! !*(" (

& % , 3 ! !*( ! $ % , ! !*( ( , !*( 2 0 ! % !

& $ "% (" % ' (' (&

)( * + ,

- - 4! 4$ $,;A$%2(")(! !*(

( ,

% $

4!%"

""( , () G2 ( ,A (

? ! $ & ! ( ,& % )!

& & "% & ",)34$ !

& " "% & )5 ! (%

%) $% & 4!

!!" ! $(

( ! !*()( " 4

% "!) "

! *( )"% ( 2 0 ! 3 ! !" 3 4(% %%4

34 (!$ $,;A$%2(")( !$

!*( G ( ,A 4 ",) )(4 !

)" $ & "(% ",) %%! ( !( ! !*(4!

! G ( ,A $ " " !%! %))( & ",)4 4!

!( ! !*( ( ,.(! !$44(% !! " ", &!%)(( !

%% , ,! ) !)

!)( % ( ",$%!$

!& !

! & "

! !*( ( , ! $ " ;4 4! !*( !(&!G ( ,A *( %4 &! )%54! 4 ! !*(

( ! !*( "

! !% ! !*( 4(% !!" &!

& ,! %"

+ ""%, &!$

( " %4!" (%

! " $ ! ! 5 $, ! ( !

)% 4 ! ! !*( *( 4 & $, 4, ( , " ) ! &) @8

! ( !

( 58 (!% *( /6 4 % ( )"% !4 ", $ 5 ! )( ), " & ! "

$( % ! $ 8 ( & ( ! )"% ! ( ! !*( ! ! )( & "() ! )(

! !)() ! !*(! %$ ) ( ",$% 2 ! 8 ( &) @8

! )"% %,8) )& %4 $(%! 4 &

&" 8"4!($) % "

$ , !

) (% $ !5 (

" ( ,

, ! ) " ! &) @8 4 & () @ !4 ! %&%"()" ( 2 ? ! ( ! )"% ( !*($,! ( )!

$5 ( !(4! ( !4 4!"("! !*( ! $ H !( !*(

!& % , 4!

! ( % ( 8 ( % ( ! )"% %, $,!( *( ! ! !*( !4% , " & ! ( 6,5 &! "% ! ! !*( 4 ( , !*( ! ( 54% & !

,!! !*(!% ) &!(! ( ,% )

!& !

% , ( !

! &() !

!( !*(

( 2 0 ! 4) ( %, $%$'

0 3 4 !$

( )&! ! () ( !*( 4%% ! &( ! ) ! $

$,!" ! !"()" ( 2 ? 4(% () %%, ) $ &#!$( % ! %,("! "

"! !*(8 ,%&%%, $% $ % , 4!

!!! %

!&( !

(% $ ( !

& $, ! % % ( 4%% $, % ""%%( 4!

!4%% 4,

&%,

& ) ! " " ! )

)

? : ", !

%&4 ! %(A $ !% %( !"(" &""" & !"

&!) &" ! 4 $, !% %( *++

%& '

( $

) (