High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/692/2021allowed

Hsiidc v. Narender And ORS

2021-12-22Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal22 pages

! "! !

"#$ %$&&'#$

(

#$ )$#$ "

#$ !

#$ '

$ '#%#*

+ ,' #%#* -$ " " #$ '

#$ "!#

#+ #/ '

"&. 0#

, & 12 3 4

#562/

7 562 80# * $.

/ +

* 4

0 '

$ . * 4

+* 92 ,

& .

+ $

+* .. "&. :

& ;+.

$ * "

& 4

$ & #

+ $

# + 4 & ..

$*+

* +* '

$ "&. #

< . $ "&. # $+

"&. # ! $

# * "

. # '

# $

(

& ' $ $ &

&$ '"

.+ >

$$ ..

$+ # .

$*#

"&.

&. . 2 562 #

.. >!

> , *

& ? @<

'* /

$ A? B0

& ##5 #

2 562 1

& 4 .

&1 #! >1.

$1$ & , 9 562 ' +

>11'

' 6'

19'

$ &- .+ #* , '

..!$ 4

#1# # 2>#

.!$ 4

2>#C#52D= :

& # $ "&. 19 $

.!$ 4

9##CD= '$# . $ "&. 15

!%&'()'& !*(+, -.

!/0/'

0&30(0 0() 1/,'&.

4 $ ! 54 . + ! '

' .

$ #

.! $

26##>CD= $ "&. 92 >

$ & - .+ #>>! C. #

' #>6 #< .*# + 4 .*#

252 4* '

45 ! @ ! .* 91 4* '

4 $ . E

*# . &

. > 4* #

.*#1 4*

4 $ ! '$#

# &

9. #& * >> , #

#. '

' .! $ 4 D 23 4

FGE :

* ' <

4 # .!$FE >:

$ #'

< FE 2 B

&07 -*)'(8'

2 , '

$ .!$ 4 # $ <.

& '

?. : $ ?.#' # : >.

#' # :> 2 . #. .# '

$<.

( - &' :2 $ ' ' <.

# :1/ ' <.

: > "*?.# :9 2> , # '

& . *# $ +* '

. .

@< Award dated 18.12.2010 passed in LAC case no. 131 of 2008. @< Award dated 27.2.2012 passed in LAC case no. 762 of 2009/2011 @<> Award dated 10.11.2012 passed in LAC case no. 305 of 2009/2011.

@<2 Award dated 20.1.2012 passed in LAC case no. 246 of 2007/2011.

@<1 Award dated 20.1.2012 passed in LAC case no. 248 of 2007/2011.

@<9 Order dated 21.3.2012 passed in LAC case no. 249 of 2007/2011.

@<2/

+@<C0 Copy of sale deed no. 1771 dated 2.4.2004 @<1/

+@<50 Copy of sale deed no. 1772 dated 23.4.2004 @<9/

+@<60 Copy of sale deed no . 1773. dated 23.4.2004 @<C/

+@<0 Copy of Sale Deed no. 8725 dated 20.9.1996 @<5/

+@<0 Copy of Sale Deed no. 8727 dated 20.9.1996 @<6/

+@<0 Copy of Sale Deed no.8728 dated 20.9.1996 @< Judgment dated 1.6.2018 passed by Hon'ble High Court in RFA no. 384 of 2013 @< Judgment dated 11.1.2019 passed by Hon'ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal no. 264-270 of 2019 @< Site Plan @<> Aks Shijra @<> /' &*

.+0 Copy of sale deed no. 1499 dated 27.6.2006 @<2 Notice issued by DRO-cum-LAC Gurugram to one Jai Bhagwan son of Ram Chander.

@<1 Judgment dated 17.8.2010 passed by Hon'ble Supreme Court in civil appeal no.6515 of 2009 @<9 Sale deed no. 2412 dated 5.12.2005 @<C Layout plan @<5 Judgment dated 14.1.2020 passed in LAC case no. 762 of 2009.

22 , <.

.# ' # #H*&

#%&. :# '

. *$ @< Award no. 22 dated 10.5.2006 @< Copy of sale deed no. 26 dated 6.4.2004 @< > Copy of sale deed no. 1923 dated 18.10.2005 @< Letter no. 2578 dated 3.11.2005 @< Policy of rehabilitation and resettlement @< Map of KMP Expressway @< Copy of sale deed no. 26 dated 6.4.2004 @< Copy of sale deed no. 915 dated 6.7.2005 @< Copy of sale deed no. 1923 dated 18.10.2005 @< Copy of sale deed no. 2559 dated 25.2.2005.

21 , . +* '

.# #. + + *

I , 3 ,

& @<=2 CC >22 >#9# 5#5#1C

@<=1 CC >22 >#9# 5#5#1C

> @<=9 CC> >22 >#9# 5#5#1C

@<=C 5C1 6669 ?=:

1 >#11# 9#2#59

@<=5 5CC 6669 ?=:

1 >#1># 9#9#6C9

@<=6 5C5 69 ?=1 1 2#9# 1#65#2

@<=> 266 C99 >6?= C6 #>#16#>C1 1## -

3.+

@<=9 2 11 9J 91 ## 26#>#CC -

3.+

29 *# . +*

+. #

.# #. + + #. * @<

I , 3

& @< = / . =C0 9 922 5?

9 >#9# 5#5#1C - 3.+

@< => / . =60 6> 51 ?=1 ##1 2## - 3.+

=5 61 9C1 2?

5 ## 2## - 3.+

= 116 11 ?=2 ##1 >#9# - 3.+

2C , # # * #

. .!$ 4 +* '

4 +* .

$ &?

0&* 1,0( 0() 1/,'&.

!/0/'

0&30(0 2:

& #

2 562

.#+ $ & "

& $ *# # & "&. 95#'

+* .

.. # # '

. .

=. "&. .* +

& "&.

+* .

/ 0'

&+ !

"&.

$* 4

# + $ )( *

+ &

#( (,-

& ,#. # (,

' & + &

$ $

& ,

&$ '

' $ '

' '

$ ' &

& '

' & '$ $ '

& '

- $

2 3 4

& /

$ $

(50 $

&$ &

(60+ & '

& 7

& ( *

' %

$ & '

& '

& (!0

' 0 $ & 0 $

$ &

' $

. 0 &

$ $

' ' $ $

' % B 25 , $

. $ & "

&# ..

+'K "&.

"0(<0& 0() 1/,'&.

!/0/'

0&30(0 0() 1/,'&.# 9

*-*7 $6E

& "&. #

1 # # + $ .+ + .

& .!$, <"&.

0(1= "%;0& -.

!/0/'

0&30(0 0() 1/,'&.

4 $ !

"&. #&

. +* $

. .+* #

.!$,

& K=952=#'

$ &? , $

< A!5 -$

& !

' 0

& +

1 '

* '

# 0 *

$ '+9

' $

' & ' $ $

& $ & +9

$ $$

' '

+9 :

%/ 9

&;& '$

' '

0 +<

$ &

<= > <

) * $

& ' &

& &

& %

& @

& $ '%&@

$ ' ' *$ + '

A#5 ,6(4 )0

%& %

$ $ $

' $ '

$ '

& $ &%&

& B !6 0

' %&

3 4 *

D2 $

. #.. &

0 $

. #..(

3 4 $

& &

' B 26 K .#

<. +* & .! $

. .+* 319E

& 1 562 #

+ .

& . .!$+' '.+* 3 $

+.!

& ' '

+* #

& $

& & '

' 4

& '

& .!$ 4

$ &? * + =

# $ +.

' E #

.!$# 4 &

$ &? # *+ =

# +* +' !!! !!

1 K. + .

29#

$ '

$ *'

@<> 9'

$ &- .+ -

2 562 , '

$ *$ $ ' $

+* <. 2#1#9#C#5# 6# /'

$ &

? 0# .+ #

@<C#5# 6< .** 2 562 #

+ *$ $ #

+* '

+ 1

'# -

+*# + . '

29 E .

<. @< C922#$ L$ L * @< #

$ <.

. 4 , #

* .$ &+

& . ,

& & .

@< 5# 6

$ &- .+ #

# .

.! $

11, .!

@< C

' @<

>#9#D= #

+ $ +* '

. .+* 3' ,

$ ' * $ $ .!$ 4

. '

+* 3.*+ '

$ &

.+ '

+* $

, '@<=

3 > 5 5'

$ & , ' 4

& $ 3 ,'

$ $ . $

+ @<=

+* '

* +

+* .

!%&'()'& !*(+,

.%>&0,

3 >1=6#

!;/ 0?;* '-* -.

!/0/'

0&30(0#

& 4

$ &- .+ , 2 562 '

C61 # .+

& # 2 562 #

+ $#

$ .+ 4

'* <

"&.

3=2=5 0&* 1,0( -.

!/0/'

0&30(0 2#

& 4

$ &? * # "&.

$ &?

0,'()'&

!*(+, .

80.'

.%>&0, # '

!! 9 $ # .*+ '

& . . 2 562 #

& 4

& #

! " # $%& ' ( @ # C# + + $ A 0

&0 = !

$ $

" * ! ) * ++< & + & &

& $

' $ &

' *

+ '

0 '

' $

# .

#..,

$.,.(#..,0

C &

.,.(#.., '

$ $

4 ,0 '

?@ A%?@-

+ '

* % E

& 8 '

F (56.@ =@,@ !,1 !

( #.5!!, 0

' &'

# *

' $

& & > 0 $

(0 & &

' &

E 0 '

$ ' >

'FG*>

& F=

$ ' E

$ &H &

E& > 2

4 = F= @& + '

& 2 ' & + '

+ '

@& F= ,

$ & H

E& $

= ,..

4 = + '

@& F= &2 ' + '

#,.

4- $ = ,..

4 0

5 0 '

$ $ &

* $ $ &

&$ $ & &> & B !0 E + '

#,,#.., '

' # #..,$ & 0

1 ,:

#..,

$ '

# @ @

#.., 0

# @ @., $

&B !0

.5.

#..6$

& + '

+ '

?@ I?-

+ '

=? 0

> : F #.#,@=@,@ #..,1 #!! # #..,

> : & >

& $ ' + '

$ ?

4 :

E& ,..

4 :

+ '

@=& F= & ' + '

= #,.

+ '

.,.. 30

4#F$

' 0 + '

$ ?

E& #...

+ '

@=& F= & ' + '

5..

+ '

= . .. (0

$ $

##(#..6

I #. *

= $ &

& > /

& >

; %% =

.,.#.#*

& / @:

@2 $ D

$ '- J$ & ( *, %- =- @6 ,.@#.

(..(#.#

& C <

&0 & = (,....1@ .,.(#.., ##.(#..6 '

'$ 0

& $

' = 5!6! ' 0

& (. '

.,.(#..,0 $ #.#..!6.$

= #.#..1@

$ $

..,#..5

&' &

$ ,#..1@ B

&*#

+ . *

!! $ C & . '

$ .

&D 4

' . * 4

' #

. *+

%& ' ( (

. / # C

' <.

$ &

. 4

. , $

< 0 & &$

$ & &

1 & $

* ' $

0$ '

& $

$ '

& 8

' #( !

& C

& &

=$ &

' ' +<

=' $ &

/:2 D

$ '

& > /

3=- @,5#.@#.(

+**>

= &

.,.#.#4

& = $ #.7 @ $

& > / +**> ' , / &

& & $

$ $ #.7

@ +$ &

' $

$ $

$ & $$

D &

'& &&

$ '

* $

$ ' ' &

/0 , '

+ .! $ 4

2#1#25D= &'

*+ . 3 4

#562 /0 , '

+ M .!$

+* . 4 '

# . * 4

# .

'. '$# .& $

+ * '

. 6

4 *# +* ' '

+* '

"! !

&D ) :

+ )

K=C= D(-%: E,@

K=962= ) ,,@ H, 3 K , H,H @ @@3E @ , E ,E 3,D@ ? E,@ >

K=96C= ) ,,@ H, 3 K , H,H @ @@3E @ , E ,E 3 ,@D E,@ 2

K=CC= DH E,@ 1

K=C= D-H ? E,@ 9

K=6= @ ? E,@ D,,@EK ) E,@ C

K=C>6= ) ,,@ H, 3 K , H,H @ @@3E @ , E ,E 3,D@ ? E,@ 5

K=61= @ ? E,@ D,,@EK ) E,@ 6

K=961= D ,/@@@0 , EH%3 E,@

K=969= D: % E,@

K=965= D H ?H E,@

K=966= D@ ? E,@ >

K=C= D EN @# @@@, EH%3 E,@ 2

K=96= D @ @ E,@ 1

K=C6= D ? E,@ 9

K=C= D @ E,@ C

K=62= @ ? E,@ D,,@EK ) E,@ 5

K=C>1= D-H ? E,@ 6

K=C>5= D % E,@

K=6>= @ ? E,@ D,,@EK ) E,@

K=C>9= D%E E,@

K=C5= D (@ E,@ >

K=>9C= % D ,,@ EK ) , EH% E33@,E %H %E E,@ 2

K=96>= D@ ? E,@

"! !