M/S Malwa Cotton Spinning Mills Ltd. v. Punjab State Power Corp. Ltd. And Anothe4r
!
"
#
"
$ %%&
'
() *
)
) "+
,+--../
0()
!
) *
+ "+ "
,,-1/
$ %%2
() *
)
) "+
,+--../
0()
!
) *
+ "+ "
)
,,-1/ + "/ 34
55 3 556 ++
+ "/ 51189/
55
%+ + :
$+ "/ 8-.1';
155
%+ + :
&+ *4/45 1-5/'6 -5/ 78..
155 ' -5118
+ ".<= '7 <= ' -5118';
1/ --.'>.
78..
155= 51 /4517
?
@! +
) "A )! @! +
) "A "
BBB "A "= +
$ %
'
$ %2
!
"#$% "
&'
( )
) "#$% "
&'
*
+ +")) " ), ) $- #.
.$./
+" (
, 0#-.$.12 1$-.$#1 + 3 .
!
2 #
4 /% 0 # . #1# , ) $- #.
.$./
+" 1$-.$#1 5.%.67.$#6 !
, ) ./ $.
.$#1
+"
!
52 .%.67.$#6+"
2 # , + & ' .$ $8 .$#6
+" 2 . 4)+ ) 9" , + : 4)+ ) )
") " ) ) & ' ##;:"
"
" + <
) 4)+ ) .$ $8 .$#6
)
2 # " " ) ) & ') ) ))+ )+"
+")
$
4)+ ) = =)"
))+
+" , ) $- #.
.$./ , )
+"
/ <
2 # .# $6 .$.1
&'2 167%>1678 .$.1 +"<=+
) +"
)++"
"
!
?
"
2 #) "
< + )
, ) +
" + "
,
, ) $- #.
.$./ ?
"
+ , ) , ) !
, )
+" 1$-.$#1 +
!
"#
$ &'
( ( )*
+&
+,-,.-+,/
(
(
0 1 2
&
!
(
(
! !(
'
!
+ '
!
"# (
+ (
'& 2
+,,.+,/ & &
! !
"#
3 '
& (! ' & !' !(
+ ' ' '(
! "# $ &
(
' '
!
( & ! !
44"# 5 !' !(
+
&'!
! 6 !
'!
!( ( !7 !
! "#
! & & '! & ( !
8++,,9:
(
! !&
! (
&'
! ! "# 5
& (
!!
"#
0
4+,,,5 (
&' &!
7 ! !( !
( !' ! "# (
! 8++,,9 '
'(! !
& ( !
! 6
&
& ' ;
!( & <
&
+,,9 & % !5 % +8-,+-+, &
& = % ( ( ( )* & ! !
'( '
' >
(
+
!
& +,-,.-+,/ & !
(
!
&
!
& '& = ' &
' !(
+
!((
'
'
&!
0 ? &( ( &
!
!
&!
' 6 & ' (
:
& &
(
&
2 !
& ! ! !( = ' = ' ( 7 )* )* !&
! &@> :?; * 3 (
!
! A !( BC
44 "# ( ! !* : 44 "# !
!( ' ' A
(
! BC"#- 7 :- B: ! "# '
!A
44"#
5
"# !
'
!A "#- 7 ! ' !( BC ' (
44 "#
!> 7
* 44"# "#
&!A !(BC & '
- 6 ( & A
! 44 "# ( & !
"#
( 0 & (!' ?
!
"#
*5"#
! !(
&"#'
!A DB"# ! E !
!(
*? ( (
& &
!
!(
! ! * ? &
"3F!& A
? !
"#
! & A
! '
'
(
'!!& A
& ' - ) ! & A
( ! ( *
'
! ! ( (!
//-44-9+-+,,"# *5!
'
! (!'& !( -
!
& A! ?
! !
! 44"#
! ':( ! !( - & )3 6' * '
)???* ! 3 !(
A ( C ( '
( (
G + $ = !&' ( "#
! ! +,,9 & ! ( !' !(
+ +,-,.-+,/
& !(
& (! (
&
!
&! ( ! 44 "# -
?
' !
!!
! !
! & !( = 5 (
& & '& = ' ( ( )+,, *
( ( )+,, *)>
> * ( '(
!
0 1 2 ' ( )
*
' 0 1 2 (
(
!7 &
3 = '
! (+,, ( 9( 8-+-+,,9
7
!
,9-+,,9 -+,,9 ( !& (' & '(
(!7
:
'(
!: = ! ' !(
+
!
& )5 0 B>+* )+,, *-9/ ?
)+,* (
! "#
% &
' & !(
'
(
3B +9+ +,8' +,-,.-+,/ !(
+ ( 0
8-+-+,,9 !
'!
'(
-
'
(
-+,,9 (-+,/
₹ . 9, / 9-> ₹ .+ 8,,-> 5 +,/ & H .I
₹ / 9 8 9-> !( ! & H.I & (
(
44"# A '& & '
.+ . : = & & !
& & & (
!(
% +8-,+-+, & +,-,/-+,/ !(
+ &
- ( '(
?
?
/ ;' !
'
&
(% !( =
( +,-,.-+,/ !(
+>
!
!(
'(
?
?
7 ( !
? >
& : % +8++, !( = $
!(
+' +,-.-+,/7
'( $ !( ' ( ! J 6 !
(7
- !(
3B +9+ +,8 &
!
(G
) +, ) @ +"+" , ) =, )
, ) + " ) 3
+ ++" + +
;
2 # "
) , ) ?
+
") - )
&' "
"A "
"A )!
"
"
%+ + :
5 3 A 2 50 + A 2