Khairati Ram Rabra v. Pb State Elec. Board And ORS


  

           

  !"#"$%&%'()
 *+ %, !% - ., "!%!%'", & /",&0& 0'1 .2! !"3"$!,%$%!4 ,# '#!+",&  "&5'#"'! &

 (  67

 2 * 72  ,"&"'!(8

,2 5 '+%,9#:$ !"9,!+"5"!%!%'",

,*0' 3 03; '%9#:$ !"9,,"&5'#"'!&  +"!+",!+" "5,!",&3$ 3'";&5 5",- 4." 33;"#! &""!+"10#<-"'!=
 .","",,"#!!+" "5,!",,'! > +"!+",!+"10#<-"'!&+03#.","5,!"#%'!+"#%<"&!= 88 88 * 72 

7 +"5"!%!%'",8*+ %, !% - ., 9;+,"!%,"#,-&",:%$"'

>?
 &  +%"0#%!,90'1 .2! !"3"$!,%$%!4 ,# &%!; & !+"'9+ &%-50<'"#!+",#",# !"#
@
 ''"A0,"889:%#";+%$+ +%&$3 %-,53 $%'<+%-%'!+",":%&"#5 4&$ 3" &@8
>;%!+ ""$!  ,-  ))  "B0%: 3"'!  !  !+ !    +%"  '<%'"",9  + &  .""'

#"$3%'"#+"5"!%!%'",&""C&- '# -0&!53 $"+%-%'!+"& %#&$ 3" '# $$,#%'<34,"8$ 3$03 !"!+"$'&"B0"'!% 3."'"%!& '#5 4+%-!+"& -" 20%$"  !  & 4  !+ !  !+"  5"!%!%'",  ; &  ;,C%'<  &   0#%!,%'0'1 .2! !"3"$!,%$%!4 ,#55 ,"'!349!+"," ,"!;;%'<&D '"%&'<%'"",%'< '#!+"!+",%&$$0'!&'!+"$$0'!&;%'<9!+"," ,"0,;%'<&%"$$0'!&9%' '$"90#%! '# &!+"5"!%!%'",; & ;,C%'<'!+"$ #,"5&! &  +%"0#%!,+"5"!%!%'",$3 %-&!+ !+"

."%'<!+"&"'%,8-&!%'!+"$$0'!&, '$+&+03#."<, '!"#!+"5 4

8
8 &$ 3"9;+%$+%&<%:"'!!+" +%"!+"'<%'"",%'<%'<+"0'1 .

2! !"3"$!,%$%!4 ,#5 &&"#!+",#",# !"#
?
)) ''"A0,"88E ;+","%'!+"&"'%,8-&!" #!+""5 ,!-"'!'!+"$$0'!&&%#"

$ #," '#"A8$ #,"5&!&&+ 33."53 $"#%'!+"&$ 3" +%"'<%'"", +"5", !%:"5 ,!!+",#",%&,"5,#0$"# &0'#",(8 F+"2"'%, &!" #!+""5 ,!-"'!'!+" $$0'!& &%#"

#," '#A8 #,"&!&&+ 33."53 $"#%'!+"&$ 3" !+" +%"'<%'"",%" &) ?;+%3"!+"!+",%$",& &+ 33$'!%'0"%'!+"&$ 3" &E >+"05<, # !%'

'"5&!&+ 33'!-" ' '4%'$," &"%'!! 3'0-.", 5&!&G 20.&"B0"'!349:%#" '!+",,#",# !"#>>)) ''"A0,"8 89!+";,#&6" #&!+""5 ,!-"'!6;","&0.&!%!0!"#;%!+!+";,# %$",6+"5"!%!%'",- #" ,"5,"&"'! !%'&-";+","%'!+"4" ,


''"A0,"88@9  $3 %-%'<  !+"  ."'"%!    & %#  ,#",  # !"# 
?
))

''"A0,"88E '#$3 %-"#!+ !."%'<!+"&"'%,8-&!%'!+" $$0'!& $ #,"9+"&+03#."<, '!"#!+"&$ 3" &)8?.405<, #%'<'"

-,"5&!%'!+"$ #," !$-"&0!!+ !%'!+" ,# ""!%'<+"3#'
E
9%!

; &#"$%#"#.4!+"2"$,"! ,490'1 .2! !"3"$!,%$%!4 ,#9 !% 3 9!50! 05!+"- !!",.","!+" ,#9&""C%'< 55,: 3,%'$," &"%'!+"'0-.", 5&!&&"'%,8-&!+" ##"5 ,!-"'!' $$0'!&&%#",<, '!5 4 &$ 3""B0 3!!+ ! +%"'<%'"",,-'"!!;H'"" $+,$ #," 5&! '# '!+",,"A8$ #,"5&!+"& %#-"-, '#0-; & 55,:"#.4 !+" ,#%'%!&-""!%'<+"3#'


9:%#"''"A0,"88  +" ,"3": '!"A!, $!&!+"& -" ,"0'#",(8 F+" ,# 55,:"#!+" "-, '#0-%',%'$%53";":", !+" ,# 0!+,%I"#!+" "-.",  '# '# + %,- '!

8>8 #"$%#"  &  !  ;+"!+",  !+"  5&!  !  ."  <%:"'  &$ 3"    '<%'"",9&+ 33." '"A8$ #,"5&!,$ #,"5&!G +"  5"!%!%'",  !+"," !",  - #"  '!+",  ,"5,"&"'! !%'

''"A0,"889$3 %-%'<!+ !."%'<!+"&"'%,8-&!5",&'%'!+""A%&!%'< $$0'!&$ #,"9+"&+03#."<, '!"#+%<+",5 4&$ 3" &@8
> +"5"!%!%'",,"!%,"#,-&",:%$"'>?
 &  +%"0#%!, '# ''"+%&,"5,"&"'! !%'&;","#"$%#"# !$-"&0!!+ ! !",!+","!%,"-"'!!+"5"!%!%'",'" 20.+ &+,, 9 +%" &! '!,3 '# "#0$!%' %$",929 !% 3 9 ;+; &,-!+""A8$ #,"5&!9."%'<!+"&"$'#&"'%,8-&!%$",9; & <, '!"#!+"5 4&$ 3" +%"'<%'"",

&@8
>'


''"A0,"88
 334!%&&! !"#!+ !!+"," !",2+,% /+, 9;+ ; &10'%,! !+"5"!%!%'",; & 3&<, '!"#!+"& %#&$ 3" !",!+" ,"!%,"-"'!!+"5"!%!%'",9:%#"'!%'<# !"#)
> ''"A0,"88>

334!$-"&0!!+ !&%'$"!+"5"!%!%'",; &'!<, '!"#!+"& %# &$ 3"9+"%3"# ?
@8
9;+%$+; &#%&5&"#.4!+%& 0,!'

E
;%!+ #%,"$!%'!#"$%#"+%&,"5,"&"'! !%' '&"B0"'!349!+"

,#",# !"#
@
 ''"A0,"88; &5 &&"#9#"$3%'%'<!+"& %#,"3%" '  !+"  <,0'#  !+ !  !+"  5"!%!%'",  + #  3," #4  ,"!%,"#  ,- &",:%$"  ' >?
 '#!+ !!+","%&#"3 4 '#3 !$+"&%'- C%'<!+","5,"&"'! !%' '# 3&!+ !!+"%' 3#"$%&%',"< ,#%'<!+"& %#,"$--"'# !%'; &'! ! C"'#0,%'<!+"&",:%$"!+"5"!%!%'", '!+","534 3&9!+","&5'#"'!&+ :"! C"'!+"&! '#!+ !!+" %' 3#"$%&%'; &! C"'%' $!.",9
 '#!+"5"!%!%'",+ #,"!%,"#,- &",:%$"'>?
+",","9+"$03#'!."<, '!"#!+"& %#&$ 3" + :"+" ,#!+"3" ,'"#$0'&"3&,!+"5 ,!%"& '#+ :" 3& $ ,"0334<'"!+,0<+!+"%3"

8E8 +"5", !%:"5 ,!!+",#",# !"#
?
)) ''"A0,"88 E9,"5,#0$"# .:"9&+;&!+ !%!; &#"$%#"#!<, '!+%<+",&$ 3"!!+" &"'%,8-&!+" #!+"#"5 ,!-"'!'!+" $$0'!&&%#"+"5"!%!%'",+ # - #"!+"$3 %-!!+"5&!,!+"%,&!!%-"%'!+"4" ,
9$3 %-%'<!+ ! +"%&';!+"&"'%,8-&!%'!+"#"5 ,!-"'! '#&+03#."<, '!"#!+"& %# +%<+",&$ 3"! 3&$-"&0!!+ ! !",!+","!%,"-"'!!+"5"!%!%'",9!+" & -"."'"%!&;",""A!"'#"#!'"2+,%2 ,, 9;+; &%'"A8$ #,"

5&!+"53" + &.""'! C"'%'!+";,%!!"'&! !"-"'!!+ !'"2+,%* << ,; 39 +%"0#%!,9$ #,"5&!9; & 3," #4"'14%'<!+"5 4&$ 3" "B0%: 3"'!!!+ !!+" +%"'<%'"",+",","9!+"& -"$03#'!." <%:"'!!+"5"!%!%'",+"#"$%&%',<%:%'<!+"&$ 3" +%"'<%'"", ,-'"!!;%"'",$ #,"5&! '# '!+",,"A8$ #,"5&!; & #"$%#"#%'!+" ""!%'<!+" ,#9+"3#'


$'$30&%:" #"$%&%'; &! C"' ;":",9 !+"# !","!%,"-"'!& %#2+,%* << ,; 3; &'!-"'!%'"#%'!+","534 ',#",!&"";+"!+",!+"5"!%!%'",; &&"'%,8-&!."," +%&,"!%,"-"'!9'"%&!3C%'!!+"'!%'<# !"#
E
 ,"< ,#%'< 53 $"-"'!!+"&"'%,8-&!+" ##"5 ,!-"'!'!+" $$0'!&&%#"%"

+%"0#%!,9;+%$+%&!."<, '!"#!+"&$ 3""B0%: 3"'!!!+ ! '<%'"",+"'!%'<# !"#
E
&+;&!+ !;+"'!+"- !!",; & $'&%#","#92+,%2 ,, 9 +%" &! '!,3 '# "#0$!%' %$",9 29 !% 3 9;+; &!+""A8$ #,"5&!9; & !2",% 3 '#!+" 5"!%!%'",9;+; &'!+"$ #,"5&!9; & !2",% 3
 '!+"& -" '!%'<%!%&-"'!%'"#!+ ! !!+ !!%-"2+,%*<< ,; 39!+"!+"' 0#%!,; &;,C%'<'!+""A8$ #,"5&!9-" '%'<!+",".4!+ !!+"$ #," 5&!; & : %3 .3",<, '!&$ 3""B0%: 3"'!!!+ ! +%"'<%'"",

88 +"5"!%!%'",C"5!'- C%'<!+","5,"&"'! !%'&!%33+%&,"!%,"-"'!9;+%$+ ;","'":",#"$%#"# '#%!; &'34'!+"%'!",:"'!%'!+%& 0,!!+ !!+"

,"5,"&"'! !%'; &#"$%#"#!."%'<&9!+"5"!%!%'",9;+; &+3#%'< !+"&"'%,8-&!$ #,"5&!9; &"'!%!3"#!!+"&$ 3""B0%: 3"'!!!+ !!+"

+%"'<%'"",,-!+"# !"+"."$ -"&"'%,8-&! +%"0#%!,%'!+"

$ #,"5&!  +0&9!+"5,"&"'!;,%!5"!%!%'%& 33;"# +",#",# !"#
@
 ''"A0,"88%&+",".4B0 &+"#+","&5'#"'!& ,"#%,"$!"# !<, '!!+"5 4&$ 3" &@8
>%" +%"'<%'"",,-!+"

# !"+"."$ -"&"'%,8-&! +%"0#%!,%'!+"$ #,"5&! '&"B0"'!349 +%&,"!%, 3."'"%!& ," 3&!.",":%&"# '#,"3" &"#!+%-+"5"!%!%'", &+ 33 3&.""'!%!3"#!%'!","&! !!+", !")J5", ''0-,-!+"# !"+" ."$ -""'!%!3"#!!+"& %# ,," ,&!%33!+"# !"5 4-"'!+","&5'#"'!& ,"#%,"$!"#!5 && '"$"&& ,4,#",& '#,"3" &"!+" ,," ,&;%!+%'!; -'!+&,-!+"# !","$"%5!$",!%%"#$54!+%&,#", +"5,"&"'!;,%!5"!%!%'%& 33;"# 

* 72     )
 &1C& +"!+",&5" C%'< ," &'"# ( "& +"!+", "5,! .3"

(