A S Chawla v. Union Of India & ORS
!
!!
! "#"
$ %& '( ) " * *
$ +( ) * ,,,,, " +" "
.
012 3 0 4
5 #.6 "
-3 *7( -3( 1 "
"
"2 3 "3 - 2
"
0 "
3 - % 0 3( 22 "
) "
2 8.
+" ' 22 9
2" 3
& 3 8 8.:)( 2" 3 20 *
2" 3 ; 2 + "
0 <
"= # ) 7 8> 23( 8.
0 0
"
+ 0
"
87> 2 (0 0 (2"
- 2 % 02"32 2" 3 - " 2
8 87. 8 87+"
-2 "3 0 ?
2 " ( "
3-
2 ( # $ %( " " 0 00 "
3- 7 8(
" 2
) 8
:)(0
7 8( " " ""( %" "
0-
$& "" 2 "
- "2 3 ? 0 " 0
"
" ) ) 0 ) 0 3""
3 0 2 ;
-2 "
03 "" 0 2
;
" '
''())*+,-*./0*10-2+*0(3
.4*04.)3+-
5&6! #&('
*4+*-/7)2+.
*8*0 ,- *./0*1 0-2+*0(3 89*0: .4 +39 ;: /.- )*/+8*0(28 *0*7/07/+3(.+" /4413.0!.+3."'1<*..**04 *0.)3+ 5 6 =#% '
*2)*.//7)2+.
!*07<)28*,-!.*.3 />+*8*04.)3+- 6!
$ (
""
;
*
-2 0 32" 0 - 2 -
(
) 2" 3
# < 3 3 "8.+" %
- 2
3>2
2" 3 ;
-2 0 ) ""
3 0 00 3
2 ) 2 0 + 2"
"
- - 5
) ;
'
: @-"5 !)*07*1,*+*:**/42 543*46;: -,-*7*00*.) 543*46;: -%%# 5!6=
( 04/*0*0<,- ?-!*.:*8/;3+-504/*6,. .4%%&5!6 % "
0/0 04/* *04 .)3+- ,- 8*+ !/07) $5 6 ! & " @/-)A*0.)*/11*/,-!.*.3 '3+*1**04.)3+- #5 6! (
""
: 0 2
"
) "
2 ) - 2 3(" % 0 & 3
22 9
2" 3( 20 *
2" 3; 2 +("
*
2" 3 ; 2
0 < "
"= # 23(" 0 8.
0 0
"
0#
" 0 0
2" - 2
% 02"32 2" 3+ - " 8
87. 8 87 + "
-2 "30 +" ( 2 ( # $ %( " " 0 00 "
3- " 2 +"
3 - 0 "
2
) 8 0 -33 0""(
) + "
0 1 "2 2 0 " " ;
"
-2 2"
0" " '
+" 3 8. 0
) 2 87>( (
7 88( " )
2 "2
-
;
-2 $ 0 '
" 2 )
2" 3+" % " - 1 "
;
-2 0 2
)) 3 0 2"
) )-
% - 2 - -3
- "
-3
" - " 8 87. 8 87+ 8-
) -
0 3
< 3% " 53 "8.+" 3 " >2 0 ) -
(
+ 0) 2
'-
) 3 " 0 - ) +(0
" 3
" 0 ) ""
3"
" 2 ( / (
"" " A) 0 3(
52 -" B( ) $ 0 ;= ( ) 0+"
52 -
0) " 2
( ") - " 2" -3 2 2 )+
2 ) 8
!
4 6 *
2" 3 ; 2 4
( "
""6 !
( C# # D !
EF +
0 3
- "
2 -3"" 3 1 "
"2 ) 2 ) ) -3"
-3 ) 78
(""
>
+0 2
"
- " "
% -
0 1- - 2
& #2" 3(0
" ( "3?
0"3-
3(0 3 -
( (
""
3
0 " "!
( $ 0
" 3 3 ")"2 ? = #
(
- 3(
(
2" !)*07*1,*+*:**/42 - 4
"6 " ( - ( 0"" - 3 0 0 - 0 "" ( -
" 2 ( ) 0
" ( "3 #"2 -3" 0 ( ( - 2 '
%
) 0 +" 2
% 0 ) 0 ) " 53 - "
0 2 0 -3 % 0
) 0 " 0 3 0-3
0
8*+!/07) - 4
"6(
- 3" % 2"32 " - / 22
3$)( 0 "
2 3 - - 0 ) 3 "" 2 ) 0" ( % / 3(2
2
A/ 3'
-5 " 0"" 2 -
-3"3 - )
'
: @-"5
$ 32"3 / -
2 " - A/ 3 2"
- - 2 ) /
-3"
0
'
: @- "5 @/-)A*0.)* /11*/ -
"6 $)("
-3
0 3 2
1 "
"2 -3% 0 ) +" '3 ) - " 53 -
0 - B"
0 )
" ( ) 3 3
(" --
03 4G: :!G6
H =A