High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1278/2014disposed of

Darshan Singh v. Raj Singh

2019-10-22Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill10 pages

"# %&' %!(") "*( ++,++

- %!.!

/) "*( ,++

!0 "1 "

"# 2%+++"

% 34&15 3 ( 2%+)+)+6 44 "34 &15 &

%+ 2%+).% "1 %%*&15 &

!0 "1 "+

( %4 "*3 ( .!

1)%1

4 ) "*(& 3! %

77 "* (

0." !($4 ."1 % ) 8% 13 () "9 +.% "*( 0%

1 "*!$

% 4 .%& .!

1)%1

4 ) "*(& 1 1 "1 ! !.( (

1 "*!* "!( 7!

1$ 1+- 1 /.1*7 ""1 1 1:++&4 1(

.1 42* !% &)% 2.;!% )( $& ( 41 ( % *. 4< ."1 % ) " 8 "1 1 ( 7 ."1 %* (%

< %! "1 0<

!+9="1& "1

0<7 "

& .%( %."1 %*

%(%

7 "(!+ **% 1( * "!&( 1"00 4

1 ) !!

"! .1* & )% 2.;!% )( $+ - 1 /.1*7 " 1 1 ++& ( 1 11 "4 ) !!

"! .1* & )% 2.;!% )( $& 1 !7 !!

1 ( 00 4 1 $< ( %&( $<

%7 "*( /.1*7 ""1 %0!!

1$<

>? 1 % 4 2* !% + ) 44 **% 1& ( % (!

%% 1( 0% "% 5 !

"0 "+ ( 0% . " " ( 0% " !

3! !

" " 704 " 1$< 704 "" /) "*(&3 (( 44 * "! ( ( % 3( 4 3 %; "* ! 4@ 3% & 6;(3"34 & (1 "!0 % 1 3 ( )%1

4 ) "*( "1 ("* "% ! "( ".

%1!% *%1!( 4"17 !.% "* 8 ;"4 7%4 70% !

1 " 2.!

4 + :9& 6 44 + =AB& 2.!

4 + : 6 44 + =9A98B& 8 AB& 'A B&AB&AB&9AB& AB&:A8B& =A9B&A B&2.!

4 +96 44 +A'B&2.!

4 +:6 44 + AB& AB& 9=A9B& A'B& AB& A88B& ! . 1 " 5 44* 6;("34 +"6(!% +: "( 7$"1 &)%1

4 ) "*( 3! !( 3" ! !

;7 ) "*( " ( 5"

4.7"&3( (7 3 ( "( 0.%5 3

.4 5 "+( ! 1 "%<3!* "!( !"1( 43+;7) "*( "

7 4< 0% " 1 !% $. 1 ( 4"1 7 !.% "* 8 ;"4 7%4 " 5 .%

C;(3 "1 %) "*(&5%) "*(& 704 ""

/ ) "*( "1 .!

1 D )%1

4 ) "*( 3 ( !0

;(!% ".7$ %!+ (<! 40 !!

4"13!4!

1 4 5 1$< ;7 ) "*( ( ! !

"! "1 3! *%

1 $< ;7 ) "*( ( ( 3 .41 4!

* ( 7. " !"

("*

%!( 0+ %& " ;7 ) "*(E! (5 "* 4 1 1 !

& C;(3 "1 %) "*(&5%) "*("1 /) "*( 1!. * "! ;7 ) "*(

% 1 4% " % *%1 "* ( 4"1 7 !.% "* 8 ;"497%4

;(!%".7$ %3( ";7) "*( (1 00 % 1 "1 1 3% " ! "+ ( ! 1 !. 3!

>9?

1 " 5 .%

704 "" / ) "*(& C;(3 "1 ) "*( "1 5% ) "*( "1 ( < 3 1 4% 1 ! 3"

%! " !!

4"1 7 !.% "* 8 ;"4 9 7%4 "1 7. " 3! 4!

!" 1 " ( 5 .%+ %& ( .!

1 " % .!

3% "* .4 4 !! / ) "*(& C;(3 "1 % ) "*( "1 5% ) "*( "1 " % F "1

)%1

4) "*(& 44 *44<71 " "%< "( ".

%13 ( ."<

".( % <"1

%* "% !$< %! "*"1( .!

1(1 77 1(

!0." !($4 ."1 %) "!8=8==9 +G( ! 1 7 "

704 ""&( 00% !

( ! % $% %! $ . "1 ( %& ( < 00% ( .!

1%!(" ) "*(

%% " " ( "% !& 3( ( ( !!.% 1 !

1 .0 "(5 "*$

"0 1( 7 <+ ( .!

13 !.77 1 % 4."1 ) "8% 13 () "9 + ( 4 1% 4 .% %7 1(

3 "*0 "

"! 1 % ""11/.1 "(

# HG( % .!

1 71 74 "%< " ( ".

%1 ( 40 .!

1 )%1

4 ) "*( "

"!0 %<IJ % ; "* " "! 1 % " ( 5 1 1 $< ( 0% ! "1 ( % 54 "!& ( 1 % 4 .%

1( "1 "*

*. 4

3 "*

# H,( .*( "%< 3! 71 " 4.7" ".7$ % 9 3 (( ("* " 3"

%!( 0 4.7" " 704 "

)(% .1( 7 %*& )& 11 %$(&

>? $.! %!( 4.7"

.4 5 "3! %"

1 3!7 1+2 " "*( $<)%1

4 ) "*( % 7 "

1 " 0(<! 4 0 !!

!. %< ! 0 % ( 3 %1 7 1 $< 4@

3% + !"

( @.

! "( 3( ! ".4 !!

!. 0% %<& ! "4<@.

$ "

0.$4 !

%5" 3( 4 0% 0% "*& %"!4 "*& % "* (

%1 " ! 0 !!

"+ ( (17 13 %1;(.1;!( %7 " "* "7 !

/) "*(&C;(3 "1 %) "*("15% ) "*( "15 % "4<&( .41(5 ! 4<7 !C;(3 "1 %) "*(& /) "*("15%) "*(% " 0(<! 4 0 !!

" "1 ( !!

" !

" ". "* 3 ( )%1

4 ) "*(+ 6(.1;!( 3! "15 % "4< 7 1+ 1 $

" !

& ( .!

1 3! "

*. 4<

% 7; "* !.( "%<+ .

7 ( 4 <

%.7!"

!& % 4 (( (1 %4 %7 1;(.1;!(3( (( 1 $< %! "* ( 3 %1 "1 7 1 3 %1 &3( (4!

4! 7( $% %.!4

%"!% 0F+G9=& "3( (( (117 ( ( (1

7 ."

704 ""

% ( 40 "* ( 7+ 2 " "* ( $< ( (117 "*(5 "*71 . "* "(

%1 %7 " "*3 %1;(.1;!(+&(

& "1 .!

1 *. 4

% 7; "* "

%% %

1 !( ! 0.%0 "1 $< 1 !( ! 7 "! $<

>:?

% "* " "!0 %<3 ()%1

4) "*(+1( 1 ( 3 %1 ;(.1;!( 3 .41 (5

/ ) "*(& C;(3 "1 % ) "*( "1 5% ) "*( "1 % (5 "* 1 !

& ( %$ %% 4< 1 "1 7 1 ( 3 %1 1!

)%1

4 ) "*(+

% ( !;

" .41 $ 0 7 " ( ( .!

3 %1! 6(.1;!( "1 (5 *% ! *"

& .!

.41(5 ! 4<7 1( "( /.1*7 " "1 1

)(% .1( 7 %*& ( 04 "

= 704 "" 3 .41 $ " 4 1 (5

"%< "( 4.7"

%!( 0&$.( !!

4.7"3 44% 7 " " " 5 .%

)%1

4) "*(+ 5 "* "1 7; "* 4 % "=7 " "*

3 %1 "1 ( /.! < "* .%( %("* $<!

; "*7 < 7(

704 "" /.!

44 *

704 "" * "! .!

%!(" ) "*(+ (

& "1.!

1*. 4<

."1 ) "8

,++J % %

%1 "* !.( "1 "*& ( 1 % 4 2* !%

"5 1 "1 !

1 ( % ! "

1 $ + ( 00 4 1$<( %3!1 !7 !!

1+ C ."!

400 % "*

%(! "1 (( "1 "*!%

1$<( .%!$ 3% *%1 "*74

"( 0%

%% "

"$4

( " ."

44 * "%<&"

4 !!(1$

".!

>8? 704 ""!( 4

4"1(1$

"("* 1 "( "7

704 "" "1 ( ! % $% %!+ ! .%(

"1 1( .41"

$ !( 3"! $<7 " " "*(

"%<

&)%1

4) "*(&!

1"<$

+ ) 44 .%( %& (!$

"1 1($

0% .

%& 3( 3! 0.$4 !

%5"& "

!" " !

704 1 ."1 % ) " '

% 7 "4

1.% & 3! $ "

1+ & ( 5 %< 0% .

% !$1 "43+ 4 %" 5 4<& ! !.$7 1 ( ( ! "E$4 .%

! "4.!

" ( ( "5

$ "

13 (&( "( %7<$ *%"

0% $ "&!( !( "4<$% 13 ""

% "( ! 7 4< "1!

"1 "*( 7$ ( "1( $%!3 .41.!

.!(%1!( 0 7 4<7 7$ %!

%+ " ( % ("1& 4 ."!

4 00 % "*

% ( !0 "1 " 704 "" 3( 4 1

"1 "* ( /.1*7 "! "1

% 0!!

1 $< ( .%! $ 3& (! "1 1 ( ( %$ "*0.$4 !

%5"(1 "1.4* 1( 7!

" !&3( (% ."$

7 "*

0.$4 !

%5"+) 44 .%( %& ! "1 1(! "

77 1$<(

"! . 0%

( !

41. !&"

!" "3! @. %

0% .

%+ (5 ( %14 ."!

0% !"13 ( % $4 !! !"

(5 4!

* (% .*( (

>? ! % ! (

."!

% % *%1 "* "

$ " "*

!" " !

1& ( ! 1 !!.

! "

% ! " *%+ ( "E$4 ).0% .% "04 %

/.1*7 "!(!( 41(3(

77 1$<0.$4 !

%5"1

%70%

( !

41. !&"

!" " !% @. % 1+"( "!"!

& "%<

71 $<( %3!"

( !

4 1. !& !0 44< 3( " ( ".

"% ! 3 $

1!0 %"1 " %7!

/.1*7 ""11

0!!

$<( 5 4 .%+(.!& ""<!

& !"1! !$4 !( 1( "%<

KE 71 " ( ".

%1 $< ( % 3! * "! ( /.1*7 " "1 1

0!!

1 $< ( 5 4 .%!+ ( ( .%! (5 % *(4< 00% 1 (

5 1 " % *( 0 %!0 5 " ( 41 "* ( % *. 4<

."1 %) "8 + & 1 "

"1 "< *% ."1 "

3 ( (

"1 "*!%

1$<( .%!$ 3"1 %1 "*4<&.0( 41 "5

%+ 7 "* !

0%& ( 704 " " ( ! !

3! " +9++ .

4 !.$!" 5 !

1 .0 " ( %& ( (! 4% 1< ."1 %* : "(!"11<!+(.!&( %(!$

"*( * "<

% 4

4!< %!+!0 .! 1< % & ( !"

1 $ "5 1 ""< %!

%"<

1 "*!% "1 "** "!( 7+( .*(( %(! 71 "%<

" ( ".

%1& 3( ( 17 14<& 3! "

( !

4 1. !& < (

>? 7 "!(( 1 !0. 3!$ 3

"( 4$% %!"1! 44

.%( %& 00 %! ( "

"< ; "1 3! .!

704 "" 0%< $< ( ! 1 "%<& ! 17 14<& ( < (1

1! 3"

%! "( 3"

%!( 0 4.7"

%1+(

&( 0%<

4 ."!

F "1 "* $

0% $ ""$ 0 1+ ) "98%+ ++&4 5 !"

7""

1 .$( .%7.! "! 1 * &(% %"

"1 % "1 ( %.7!"

! " 3( ( (

77 1"1( "1 3( %( ! " 4 1 $ !

" 0% $

"1. % "

+ ) " 9

"1 %! & ':& .%( " 4 ! "5 !

17 " !

44! 3 ( " ( 0%7 %! !% $ 1 ( "+ ) "

! 1 0% 5 1 ! ( "

1 !@.4 "!(44( "5 " "!

"5 (!

"1 43 (."1 0% 5 !

) "9 %) "

! 1 ( "E$4 ).0% .% " ("1% !(3% )(%7-!+)

(%&AB'):&3( 4 "! 1 % "* !.(7"1 &(!( 41

3 "*

! " # $ ! ! ! % & !' !!

' & ( ! " ! !! $ " " ! ! ' &

>'? " ) &! ' " ! *+ ! & & ' , ' ! ! - !

. ! ,

! (' ! /

' ! ! & 0 ! &" ! *+ !

* *+ ! & "

*+ ! ' " &! !

. ! ! 12 3

" & ' $ ! *+

* ! ( ' " " , & ! 4$ ! ! ' " ! *+ !

) "'

! '

& *+' ' & & ! ! ' & " ! " ! 0

& ! " & 5 &!

! 6 ,'

7 ' $ ! "

! "+8

!.4"4<& 3( 4 .0( 41 "* ( "5

% ."1 % ) " 8 & ( ! !.$!" 5 !

70% !

"7 "7

1+"! 1&( ! 1 $ !

< %!.$/ ( ! . "*$ "1! ! !

(

.1 4 2* !% %"

>? ."1 %; "* ;

00 "1$

1$ (5 .%

! 1 1 "1 00 % "1 %

! "1 3( 44 1.0 " 1 !

5 4

"1 "!

$ "1!+

% ! 4!

1 % 1 0< !.7

!+ :&=! !!

4 * " $ 0 1 ) +

5 !

" 0 " !"1! 1 !0

" ( $ %7!+ !0

"( $ %7!+

! %&' 1! G( %)0 ; "*=

1# != G(

%$4 # !=