High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13346/2020allowed

Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction Company Limited v. State Of Punjab And Others

2021-10-26Mr. Justice Rajbir Sehrawat34 pages

! "#$ % &'()'*++++'# ',-+#./,#*-012-34#& '#*#*-'. 5'.+/+ !#2#' /-6272-&#$'.+ '+1-&'-#+ 89

&'()'*++++'# ',-+#./,#*-012-34#& '#*#*-'. 5'.+/+ $*' ':'-/' -#.((*-; /#$.*#3<,/0< *-2-,*2( 00*++*-'.

':'-/' % /-6272-&2-#$'. '+1-&'-#+ =

&'()'*++++'# ',-+#./,#*-012-34#& '#*#*-'. 5'.+/+ !#2#' /-6272-&#$'.+ '+1-&'-#+ " >4 ! !

" !

%& '( ))))

! % * !

#& + ,--./ 0101#&+ 23-/ 010,#&+ ,-4/0 010,

#&+ ,--./ 0101 "

"5 "

6 " #&+ ,--./ 0101 " 5"5 & '( "" 7 "8

!+ " 9 : ; ,4/-3,2.3.<%

" "" 5

" " ; # 5 * " 5

" % 5 12 01,/= #& + ,--./ 0101 #& + 23-/ 010,> ,- 01,/ = #& + ,-4/0 010,> ?

" % 5 5 " 5 " 4 8"5

5 # 01,/ 5 01,3 * + "# 5(* "= +#(*>

9 ;5 * " = 9;*> @ ; 7 "A 58 0110 8 5

" % 5 % 5

5 "5 9

5 # ( " ,/ ,1 01,B"" ; C ; 9 " 1, 1.

01,2 ""1/ 1B 01,/" 5 7 9

5# ( "9

5# %,$+"D

: 6

,1 01,B 8

"5 + * "

9 ( ,3 ,, 01,B " : * " 5 + * "

9 "9

5# $ +"

5 9

5 # ( * ",2 ,, 01,B "5

5 "# 5 5 "9

# => ( ""

"" " 9

5 # 9 ( ?

5 A " 5 " 9

# =>( " 9

5# ( ,/ ,1 01,B " 9

5 # $

5 # ( "

,3 ,, 01,B "5 "

# (

" * 5 " " :

;*8

+ * "

9 " ; ( =A#">C ;

9 5

5 6 "" "9

5# $ E 8

+ * "

9 ,3 ,, 01,B % 5 ""

5 ; ,.232111<% 5

E % 5 + * "

9 " 1.

,0 01,B ?

5 # ( "" "

5 .3 8 ,3BB= >

8 5

5 # ( % 5

5 9

5 # " # !6 ""

* 7 " #

=; > !6 # #""

; 8 " ""

% 5:

" 5

5 ""56 "

# #""

; 5% %7 "# =; > != # #""

; 5> " :

5""

"" % 5

5 ; 9 * """5

5 5 5

+#(* 9;* * "" "" % 5

#& + ,--./ 0101 9

! # #""

; 5 5 5 !

5 5"

"" 5"

5 !

5 7 % 5 # 14 ,0 01016 # #""

; 5 5 "5 5 % 5 # #""

; 5 "5 # #""

; 5 ! ,3 ,0 0101"

5 !

5 5

2/ 7 "" #&+ 23-/ 010,

"5 ""5

#&+ ,-4/0 010,

" "" " 5 ""

5 9

5# ?

" 9

# " ""5 " 5

" 5 ?

5 55

" 5

5" "

" ""5

" 5 *

"/0=> ",%

" ! "5

5"5

5 8

5 " " 5 56 "0- ",% E " 5 " " 5 5

%; # 56 "5

"6 % 5 " " /0 => " "0- " *

" " "

7 "" ""E # !"!# $ % & '

( ))!*!+(, 8 " 5 " !

""5 E # - $ $ .! * # / . 0 1+ )2!

!! ++ )*$3$!4 5 " "5 " 5

" 6 5 "

5 * "

5 5 ""

5 " 5 "5 5 .4%

" ! 5 55 "

* " "

EF"

# % $56 # $ 5 %6' 1$ 0$ ' 3.) 77 %$0" $ , *

" " "

# #!

# % 84 ' ( ))!*!+,

* "

" ""

5 5 5

" * " "

EF"

# % ! # / 9*!' ( :)

* " " 5 " *

"" " 6 "?

"" "

" 6" ""

" % 5 8 5"" 5 8

; 6 #""

E: 5 5 5 5 5"" 5

"5 : "

( "

"6 :

5 % ""

6 ""

"6 6 8 @""

" % ""

* ""

" " #"" " ; 501,B5 "

5 5 5

5 5 " ; 501,2%01,/ ""

" " 59

5# ( ,/ ,1 01,B " ""

5 5 ,4 ,1 01,B 8 9

5 # ( " ",/ ,1 01,B6 ""

5"5:

,4 ,1 01,B * " " "

5 ""

5 5 " 5#"" ?

5 5 " 9

5 # 5 5 ?

5 " 9

5 #

5 ; ,.232111<% * 5 ""5

5 5

5 5 ""5

5 "5 % 6 !

6 6 D 5 # #""

; 5 " !

5 "" # #""

; 5

5 5 * 5 5 "5 ""

"%% 56

""5

5 D 2/ 5 "

"5 " : 5

5#"" * # #""

; 5 5 % 5

5 5 *

@5# #""

; "

6 E #

" 5 # #""

; 5 5

5 5 8

" 5 5 5 # #""

; 5 !5 5 " 5#"" * 5 "

" 5

5 " * : "

6 !

" 5

5 ( "" " ?

5 5 # #""

; 5"

""5 " * !

"5 # #""

; 55 !

5 :

5 E : 5 ""5 "" 6 "

" ; "5 5 "

" " "

" 5 *G5F

5 0 =,1> 5 " "

" 5 #" 0 -

" "" 5 ;

"5 " "

42 " * " 6

G5F

" 5 "

G F E

5 "

G5F

" !

E 5"

"0- "/0=> ",%

" ! D?

.4% " "5 5 G %"

F 5 * 5 8 5 5 E "

* "

5 .4% :"

"" G %"

8 "

"5 *

G % "

F "5 .4% ; 6 "" 4- 5

5 5 ;

""5 " "" *5

"5 ?

5 5 " 9

# $ & " 5# #""

; 5

5 :

" 2/

" # #""

; 5 5 #""

" 5655 8 9

5# 5

5 % 5 # #""

; 5 * " # #""

; 56 "5 "5 * "5 5# #""

; 5 -2 ""# "

"5 "5 "" 6 5

" 5 " " " 5

& '( 6 "

.4% ; % 4- " 9

5# 5 % 56 ?

"5 5 #""

5 5 "5 ; " "

%% 5 " "

G "F G F G F "

" "5 55 5 "5" " "0- ",% "/0 =>

"6"

"5 G F G "F G F E 5 "/0 * "

"/0 "5 F 5

G F 5 " * 5

" % 5 E "/0 " 5" " 0- D 5

# #""

; 5 "

% -2

G""F 5 5

#"" # #""

; 5 "

# #""

; 5""

5 5 * ""

"# #""

; 5

5 5 E "5 5 # #""

; 5 "5

" ;%! $56 ;*4<

! ! "

# "

#$% & &"

#$' ("

) ;%! . $"

+ +*

)

! , + *

)

# '

.!! - / )

;%! = 22>0 1 * * $

* !

+ * !

! ! * *

) ;%! ,. $" $+4 "0!"!

!6+!*!' > 2

3 0

( !

!! !

! +

) *!

$5684

* & +

( + *

, *

6 6 + !

!! !

! +

)

* ! !

* )

! , !!

) *

7##

7778# !

! 4

9:9;

! !

! %; ;

3"!

! ! $"?6@$ !A <

+ "

= 5

* !

; ; (. $" !"0$'?+?!A <

! > ! "

* *

!; #

; ;%! =>3 $56

=>3. $" $>*+$?6+?!B #!

6 !

* ,

@ *

* .!!

@ * % :9

) .

! *

* 5

! ! ! *

* !

! ! ! !

; A

! @ * @ *

! B

@ * % :9 % 2;= ! :9

% -

" -

* !

! +

! !*

* !

* ! !

! *

* 5

! ! ! *

* !

! ! ! !

)

; C %

(

%; -C0+!$D

! + !

;

;%! ( $56

()*4 $! 0+! 0%

*! !

! $

; ;, + ' " ' ! ++!2 )*$>$!4A A

! *@

; #! *

C !

! * @

$ ; "

! !

; ;,= %" 64 ! ++!2 )*$>$!4 8!2$A A

! * @

>= "

! " ) !

! ) $

F A

! %

2 * 1 * 1

) !

% 2 #

)

&G ,

)

! *

!4 6 E ) &!

!B 2 * E

!' ; I

J *

!!!

; ;=

''60! 0!BB I

! !

* ,

* ; E " #

5 "

"5 5 ""

5 56 56 ?

.4%

" !

5 ""

5 5 * "

5 5 5 "" 5 E 5 ""

5 5

.4%

" ! " .4% " 5

"5 6

"5 .4% 6 5"

""5 5 H

"5 ?

: * """ * " "

5 "

" E ?

5 " %; "5 6 * "" "5

5 5 5

E =-> .4% ""5

" ""

H .4% =-> #""

""5 @

E .4% "5

" %"

" "" "" " 5

"" 5 *

5 G F G5F " "" .4% E "

5 .4% "

"6?

5 ""

5 .4% * #

5 5 * "

EF"

# 5 %6'1$ 0$=

# #!

> "" " * " " "

5 5 5 " 5 5 ""5 5 8 "5

E """

# * :

6 !

< 5 E " 5 "5 % 6 5 .4% G F

5 8 " # "

"5 8 #

F 8 " ""

* ""G F 5 5

5 5 "

G F " 5 % 5 .4%

5 - .4% *"

" " "

6 "

" 5 "55 5 " *"

" " "

" "5?

" "5 "55# "

E "

" : 5 !% 5# "

55 "" "

5 "

" " "" "

"5 "

" "5 " 5" (" "

G F

@ +"5

" 5 5

5 A

" ""

5 6 " "

E # /9*!=

> ""

" * !

* "

5 .4% "5

"" .4% 5 4- E ""5 " 4- # 3 " "5

6 "5 6

65#""5

5 5 5 " 5 5 " 5 5 5 * 5 5

#"" !

5 5 * "

#"" 5 5

"" 5 5" 5 5 55 5 8 #"" 5 5 " 5 5

5 5 "

D "5 #""

.4% ""5 - .4% #"" G F 5 "5

5 6" 5 * 4- " 5555 5

#"" 5 ""

5 565"

.4% ?

5 ""

"5 < 5 ;"5

5 0 =,1> 5" "5 "0- ",% 5 "/0=> " E ""5! 7 "5 "5

5 5

5 """5 5"

" "

" 5 : .4%=-> E5 5 ""5 "5

5 H

"5 " "6 * "

" " 5

" " " *

5 0 =,4> "

5 5 " *

" " 5 E

" D5G5F

" " "5" * 55

" " " " *5 "5 5 " E ?

"5" 5 5

" " " " 5 E " ""

0=,1> * #

7 "" ""E # !"!=

> !

E # - $$ .!* =

>"" " * " "5 " 5 " " "

" "" " /0 " ,%

" ! * " %"

G "F G F6 "" F " "" "/0=> 5 "

5"" 6 +" 5

5 8 8 "5 #"" %

5 E "5 G "F G F " "

" " " "

" " " 8 "5 5

" 5 E "5 "/0=> "" ?

5 " "

G5F " "

G F "" ""5 " D

G5F

5 " " "

"5 !

G5F 0 * " "

"":

G F

G5F 5 " 8 E"" :

G5F ""5 "

*:?

# 5 # #""

; 56 5 ""

" 5

5 "

"5 * : 5# #""

;

" #"""5

5 ""

5 + * " #"""""

5 " " 1.

,0 01,B & # #""

; 5 " " ""

" 5 5 " "5 1- D ""

5 "5 5 #"" 5 # #""

; 5

6 5:

" !

" ! +#(* 9;* 5 +" 56 "

" @ ""

5 " #""

5 5

A %

5 E 5

# #""

; "5 !

" 5# #""

;

" "5 "5 8 55 5 * "

"5 # #""

; 5 "

5 5 5 5

"" " " ""5 # #""

; 5 " "

5 56 E 5 "

5 # #""

; 5 "" !

" 5 !

%;% 5 +#(* 9;* " " -2

G""F?

"5""#

"5 !

# #""

; 5

" * 5 :

@ ?

" 2/ " # #""

; 5 %

5 5 5 % ""

5 5 5 " !

5 *5"5 ""5 % 5

" " "

"5 % "55 % ""

" 2/ # #""

; 5 5

5 5# #""

; 55 " ""

5 56:

5#"" # #""

; 5

* 2/ # #""

;

5 #""% 5

5 #"" * # #""

; 5 5 "

5 56 " , 2/ ""

5#"" # .2"" ! " # #""

; 5 5

5" !

5 ""

* G"F 2/ " "

6 : 5 #"" "" "

" 2/ =-> "

" 5 "

"004 # 8 " !

E # F

E # : "

# "

" ""# #""

; E # " "" !

*# #""

; 5 ?

E # 6?

5 !

"5 !

5 E #

"004 # 8 5 EF"

# " " "

" "6 8 * !

5 "

"F6 E # 6

"5G"F # #""

; E# #""

; 5!

5 ; ""5 "" "" *

"" ""

5 #$ % K

! <

,*M

3 N

2 <

@ 3 N