Reeta Devi v. Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd.(Bpcl) And ANR
!
"#$ $%&'&()*
!" # $ % & "
% ) +, - -- '
() "*+ ,(&-. "% $ /" $,(&-. % 00000 -- "## 1 " 2 % " 3$# && 4 5 (
6
7*"!" # $ %
8$& & $ .2"-""% " 7 "#& #17#.
2 &.# ## "% ##1($7"
,9" #! 1 , -:
/1 *. ;
%1 * !
..- ."- "% 7#- -2 &
5 7* " % % . %% $ . 1 # < ## # # $ $%# "%2" "/ . = * & =$-"# & " 9" # & . 7$ .
%%#- . $ # 2 % #&7> / -"&2 7 ? #*6 &&5 @ "% 7#- -" 2 %-.- . -$& @ . $ !
-"
(%% &&# 12"
"2 % (
6 "7 -"
&7*"@ & #, !" # $ &= & # $. /#- .# .
1 # &
# # # # >."!
-"
#&&2 "
#17#* - . @ && # (%%#- % "%< "% # >."7 -"
2 #&7$ #"- *" & & " # 6 -" . % & -&" '
A
! "
#$
%
%
$&$$ '( #) * '
$&$$ '( #+ # + %
#$, ) # $,#)
% - .
%#$,#)
#+
'(
% .
+
/(/%"
.
0 !
"
!
$& $$
.
"
* /*/ .'
'
/
1 2%12
" .
)$3 /(/%" 4
%
'(
> * 5
162%152
.
3 $& $$ .
'
' ! #"$
5 . " ● 7%7 -
● 8
/ %8
# ● 8
$& $$ ● % ●
# %/ # %%#&. "# ## "%. " & ##1($7"
,9" #! 1 , -:
= " /-"& #& 1 * & %%#- && / -"
%%#- 2 7$& # . ;
% 1 *7 1# .
# &$ 1
>
=-,7 1>
< > " .# &$
> =-$% & B"2 ,B" $ ,B" 45,45 ,45>,455,B > & +$7 &. "* 4 , & "#($7"
" C, C$ ,/ 79" #
5 +#,9" #! 1 , -:
=$-"# & " ("$.
7$ . " %%#- . $ % &-& " & .
1 ."# &&7 @" 7
&"" # &&2 % &. 1 7. / 7 1 +#, - :
= . % % . 1 =2 ,
-- . $-
-* ," $- #& 7 1 & " &.% 7 2 1 && 1
> &&> @ %% . -" - .- & 7*"/ 7 1 +#, -:
=$-"# & " & " "# &&2 & & & "..-./ 7 1 +# 7 " $" 1 7 1 & " $&
-- .-
-* &- ##* 1 & > %% && (
6 4# 12""% 9"% "
-& 3$# && 4 2" 7* % - %
. $&" " ""&7 &-# & -- . # "& 2.# - & -& 5 . #- ."# ## "% "#- ? "/-"& #& -1 *!* .
-"3$#% 2 -##& % .
"- &- $ # $) # - *&% @ "- ."% ""
&. # 2 & . "2" 9" . , % " -& " $% 1 &3$#&&4 5 (
6
. $ 1" "" # &&- $ 7$& #&. - & 1" - &&
;
% & -" "" 7 "#& #17#. 2 &." # ## "% 3 " 1" " $% 1 & 3$# & % " . $*< ..- -* 1 & "# &&- $ 7$&7*"
4 % "#&" #17#, "2 $ .#&
7"#.." % - % ""% - " 7 %## @ % >."2 $ " 7
&" %
# > & . " #17#* - - & " /#-
!
-"
" %%#- ;
% 2 7#1& " &- $ 7# " 12 "%.# & "&.%%#- & 2"-"2 #&# - 1 &# &&. $ $ $% &.
* $ " 9"% - - % 7"#.." %
""# && 7$&7*"% 2 . &"7
1 & > 2" " %%#- 2 7$&
9"% -" &7 . #.## 1" # -# "#17#*- - & "!
-"
.
& 2" -" 7 . "#& 1 " % 7 #17# & & -# & "2 $ ,- # % "% " &2 .#& 7$ D@ 1&" . # - #&"7 7 &"% . 1 1"# &&
1 & "&.%%#- 9"# &&-$%# ##
%- && #* &2 % &. 1
"..-./ 71 - -
&7 " $ -- . -"
-#. #<-
-* - #& 7 1 & " $&* @ 7$& " & 7 "#&* ," $2 1 & > / -".- #% $ & & ##* .&7*"- .- &7*"/ 71 +# (
6 4 & -" " - . " % %
"#& 1"% 7 #17# -"- % #* C &
. D # & /- > & /- 5 . "
1 (-
- & " 1 . # &&
? 2 #& #7-)"&2" 2 . & #*% &.
1 7. "- -
&/ 71 & .
$"&. 1 > @ "$ #*- && "7* . -"% #2,"% ? #. "#17#* - % # >&."!
-"
@ %% . -"
- # -%#-& % C &1$ ."$./&&0/12#&( 0$'/314"2 ".&56'(7&"( &.282"#&(,#7"(7"#/$2
9!, - #
& - # % 1 " % % C . "- "#& 1"% 7 #17#7* 1 " % -$%# . $ % && " % %- %%#- "7 -"
,"%%#- 2 ? &7 7$& # &" $2 7-$%# ## %- "&.
7$ .%%#- ."%%#- "&7 7$&%
"# &. 7$ ." $ # 7$ " %
# >&."3#17#* ,"%%#- ;
% 2 % &- $ 7# " 1"2 "%.# &.. & &.%%#- -# & 1" 1 &# &&. $ $ $ % &.* $ " @ 7$&""% -
) *7 .."##1& 1 "..-."/ 71 9"# &&2 - ##* 1 & > 2"#"&.
7$ ."%%#- 2 & -""# &.. & 7*"% && $"#17#*- % 1;
% E " 7$ &7*- # 7*& 1"-%*." %%#- ""&7 7$&7*"% &%% &&
(
6 ># 12""2 % @ "-# $ # 1 . 1 . # &&<;. &&< 1 & # &&< && .
$ ,"%%#- <% "& &"& ( % # 5."%%#- . $ ) 12 7.
"& 7*-"%%#- ( % % &. $" ) 12 - & " .##2 1 $ '
A
8 ' 5
' '
% %
8 ' 5
.
% 2 @ - &&7*- #. "- % ""%
"&.
"&.# . $ 1 & "&." 1 &# && 7* $ 1 " $ 2" 2 - ##*
1 & > ( % ) 1.
"&7*"%
" #*. * . $ .
"& "%%#- . $ . &7 -
-<.# ,"- && 2 7- -##& &" %%#- 2 7&-# & #17# (- ." %
&-# 1"% #17# 1"7C .& "7 ".# . $ "&7 1 7*"% "%%#-
. $ #. "% "7 " & &"%#& 1
- &"7 % & @ 2 % #? 2" 2 #&"
1 ."# &- $ #& % 7*"% )..-F - #* -" ? -$ 7 - & & 0$'/ 314"2 ".&5+'%"'$ '182"! @ -"- "% " "& %%#&. 7 1%% & 8; 7 "-1 *.%
;
$
# /- ," ,#" 9"&- $
2 2 % # && . & 9"* 2 % &. 1 7. "- -
&/ 71
,2"#"- .-.1 /- 4 ." 1 (-
" . 7 .
& "
(-2 & > /- > & 5."
(- % & -&" '
!"#" $%&
' ' #(
)& * +& %"
- .
2 , '
-.
$%& + & $%& +)'* # '( &"
)/$
8
9
-
.
)
4 .
. .
/ :;.:&<= + /
4
!8
. - / >.
.
. . - .
?.
$&=;: $&=;
2 9"#
&/ 1#+ &1 E1 "B $ #)G - % " 16$ & $ C &1$ ."/ % $ "
&7 &" 11 " -%,$7 &
%#*./- > & /- 5 ."
(-,- ##& ".##2 1% -%# '
1 @ 0
. "
- .
@ ./ > $&=; 4 0
A
0
.
. .
8
.
9 .
@2 .
" "#& .##2 '
+<!
" / >:
8
- / > - / > 8
- " A 0 9
!-
. .
+>B . - .
-
- 4
"
C -
D!
4 / >:+ $&=; .
.
9 - .
4
.
. -
$! / <=
/ <$ - / :&<=.
4
/ >:+ $&=; B
/ > $&=;
4 4 . .
..
-
. >:+ $&=;
. 0 .
/ >>:+ $&=; . . 9 0
. . 9
9" %-. #1 $ 2""- -# & 2
E1 "B $ #)G - / % (& 17-)".- ."% - ,2 #&7
.
$ " % # . " -%* . " # && %#-& - & (
6 5"" $2 - 7& 72 /" B $ ./ $# &"% " "# 9"# % &2 5* -$$ - 12. 9"&# ."% -#.# &2 -# #*$ & &"# "& 1 &
. ."# ## 1" , $ &%% - 1 & " # & ? . " # % & "# &&"& ..6&" 1 " % #.9"- .-.
1 .#- "& > ( % &3 & $ # " $% %% 2 "2 " 7 % -" &
:
& 7&#* " - .- . 1 -
*
1 > < & 1 &> "%
& # $ & > =2 ,%#-& - & (
6 4 - .- &7*/ 71 +#, -:
=$-"# & " &" # 6 -.2"-" & .##2 '
A!
/ 8
E )$$))=$;
4
8
B=&%)=$;
)$))=$;2
> ( % - .-(
6 4 &7*"- -
&/ 7 1 ,"# && ? 2 & & & "..- ."/ 71 H " $ ,% "# && 1 & " $# 12""$ 1 #2 "% -." / 71 " $&* 7 " $- #& 7
1 & " $&& #-).-
-*8 &&2 1 1 &&1 > < &&> 9" % - % " & 7&" -." - .- (
6 4 " - " . 3 . " %% % " " % "& *& 7 1 & &.% ."# &&,2 % . " % " 1".
" -# .- -" 1 & .
$"% % " -" & :
-"- - $ - ," 2 #&% -& "% $ ""&.% ."# &&7. "- -
&/ 71 2 " 1"
1 & > !*%%#* 1"&- $#&&2 0$'/ 314"2 ".&5+'%"'$ '182"! & % /- > & 5 ."
(-"# && #& % "% 2 #&)..-.
$" &2 . & #*% &. 1 7. "- -
&/ 7 1 9"&- ." % - % "#& " % #17# $ #* " - " " & .
7$ .%%#- 2 &"&. 1 .
"# && & 7 ? > -"-
9" 7$ &7*- #. " % - %
2" 1 &.# . $ " 17 .
"&7*"%
5 "%%#- . $ &" - && 7 1 1". ##* C-& $ ." ) 1.
"& 2## . &&@ ". -, $*7) .""% " 7 "#& #17#. 2 & ."# ## "%,"#- ? 7* -.
"$% 1 &$#&&4 5 (
6
#* "1 & ""# &&- $ 7$&7*" #&. - & 1"
-#$ ;
% && ."% 2 - -##&
"1 &" *.# . $ "&7 .
"&9"#&*.
$% 1 & " 7 & "7 & -# &" @2 #&
7% . " % 2&&"1 & . C- 7* . & ) " %#& 1 & 1 " - .
7$ 7 1& -& 3 " 2 7* .% .
/- 5 ."
(-," 1 &# && #& % 7*" % )..-.
$"&. % 7. "/ 7 1 - -
& @ 2."7"%%#- .
"&7*"%
"%%#- . $-
7 $& .# < -
- - -## ." - && H " - &&7,2 % ##2& 9" - ." % - % "#& 1"% 7 #17# . 2 &.&# "% ##1($7"
,9" #! 1 , - :
= "/1 * ;
% % $#&& 4 5 (
6
? "& 9" % - % & -&% -&.
" " $ % $ &- & - & "%%#- 7 -"
&7*"#& 1"% ". #.##&"- % # >
4 & &" 7* .* 1"- & .2 "%.# &7* . 1 &# &&. % & 6- .* &$ "
. "#- ? ;
% % ##2& ". & $ --!
-$8#$4:$2*;
"" %) 1< &'E < "" % 7# 'E <