High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12803/2011dismissed

Dhara Singh v. The Chief Engg. Huda Panchkula & Others

2023-10-09Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger12 pages

!"# #&'('$) *++ ,!-!

.')/, ++0 #"'"'$)#- 1#-(2(

,# ,'#% )/')##-3 !-4!)!

-5!) #6#7$89#)"

2",$-'"43 !)&,:27!

$",#-(

+++0 #(8$);#)"(

< = +

. .

-#(#)" -+ 2:#(, >29!- 1#-9!3

;6$&!"# 8#"'"'$)#-+ -+ -!6##) ,!);#- $4!73

;;'"'$)!7

++ !-4!)!+ -+

(,$:

.')/, ,!2;,!-43

;6$&!"# -#(8$);#)"( $+ + + + .

+ + #"'"'$)#-

,!-!

.')/, %'7#;

')("!)"

?-'"

8#"'"'$) 2);#-

-"'&7#( @ $)("'"2"'$) );'!3 '((2!)&# ?-'"

)!"2-#

&#-"'$-!-'

A2!(,')/

?!-;

;!"#;

@++

))#B2-# 3 8!((#;

7#!-)#;

);2("-'!7 -'52)!7&29=!5$2- $2-"3 2-/!$)

,#-#')!%"#- -#%#--#;

!( C",# -'52)!7<D ?,#-#54 -#%#-#)&# ');2("-'!7 ;'(82"# -!'(#;

-#/!-;')/ "#-9')!"'$) (#-6'&#(3 ?!( !)(?#-#;

!/!')("

,'9 &7!'9 ?!( -#E#&"#;+ +

-'#%743 -!'(#;

!) ');2("-'!7 ;'(82"# -#/!-;')/ "#-9')!"'$) (#-6'&#(+

,# (!';

;'(82"# ?!( -#%#--#;

!;E2;'&!"'$) 7#!-)#;

5#7$?+

,# &7!'9#;

E$')#;

(#-6'&#( ?'", -#(8$);#)"

.25 '6'('$)!7 )/')##-3 !-4!)!

-5!) #6#7$89#)"

2",$-'"43 $,"!: !-&,3 * 8$("

!7'3

,$?#6#-3 !"

"'9# E$')')/3 )#'",#- !)4 !88$')"9#)"

7#""#- ?!( '((2#;

,'9 )$- !""#);!)&# &!-;

?!/#( (7'8( ?#-# /'6#) ,'9+

,# &7!'9#;

(#-6'&#( ?#-# "#-9')!"#;

-#(8$);#)"

++** !"

"'9#3 ?!( /#""')/ (+ +@ 8#- ;!4 !( (!7!-4+

,# &7!'9#;

(#-6'&#( ,!6# 5##) "#-9')!"#;

6'$7!"'$) .#&"'$) );2("-'!7 '(82"#(

&"3 *F@

,#-#')!%"#- -#%#--#;

!( G*F@

&"<+

&&$-;')/743 8-!4#;

-#')("!"#9#)"

?'", &$)"')2'"4 (#-6'&# !7$)/?'", !77 &$)(#A2#)"'!7 5#)#%'"(+ + ,# !%$-#(!';

&7!'9 ?!( &$)"#("#;

-#(8$);#)"( $+

,#-#')!%"#- -#%#--#;

!( G-#(8$);#)" !)!/#9#)"< %'7')/ '"( ?-'""#) ("!"#9#)"

?,#-#') 8-#7'9')!-4 $5E#&"'$) ?!( "!:#) -#(8$);#)"!)!/#9#)"

;$#( %!77 ?'",') ;#%')'"'$) G');2("-4<3 !( #)6'(!/#;

2);#- *F@

)#'",#- &$9#( ?'",') ;#%')'"'$) G?$-:9!)<3 !( 8-$6';#;

*F@

&"+

?!( (259'""#;

?$-:#;

82-#74 ;!'74 ?!/#( #98$-!-4 2("#- $77

)$ !88$')"9#)"

7#""#- $- !)4 "#-9')!"'$) 7#""#- ?!( #6#- '((2#;

,'9+

) 9#-'"( &7!'9 8#"'"'$)#-3 '"

?!( ("!"#;

)$ !88$')"9#)"

7#""#- $- ?!/# (7'8 ?!( /'6#) !( ?$-:#;

82-#74 ;!'74 ?!/# !( &!(2!7 7!5$2-+

?!( ("!"#;

!77 ?!/#( 8#-'$;

?,'&, ?$-:#;

!( &!(2!7 7!5$2-#- $- ;!'74 ?!/# ?$-:#-3 5##) 8!';

,'9+

?!( ("!"#;

",#-# ?!( )$ 6'$7!"'$) .#&"'$) *F@

&"+

?!( &$)"#);#;

')%!&"

7#%"

?$-:

(?##"

?'77 ;';

"2-) !/!') %!'7#;

-#8$-"

;2"4+

?!( !7($ ("!"#;

?$-:#;

F ;!4( $)# &!7#);!- 4#!-+

&&$-;')/743 8-!4#- ;'(9'((!7 &7!'9

?!( 9!;#+

#87'&!"'$) ?!( !7($ %'7#;

8#"'"'$)#-+

F+ -$9 87#!;')/( 8!-"'#(3 5#7$?

%-!9#;

%$77$?')/ '((2#( H

"#$

% & '

) $-;#- 8-$6# &7!'93 #B!9')#;

,'9(#7% !( !7($ #B!9')#;

!9#(, >29!- !( +

# !7($ "#);#-#;

;$&29#)"( B+ B+ F+

) $",#- ,!);3 -#(8$);#)"!)!/#9#)"

#B!9')#;

$)#

$/'

!9 !( "#);#-#;

;$&29#)"( B+ B+ + + 8$) &$)(';#-')/ 9!"#-'!7 #6';#)&# !6!'7!57# -#&$-;3 7#!-)#;

5#7$?3 6';# '982/)#;

?!-;

;!"#;

@++

))#B2-# 3 -#E#&"#;

&7!'9 8#"'"'$)#-+

+ ) !%$-#9#)"'$)#;

&'-&29("!)&#(3 %'7#;

')("!)"

?-'"

8#"'"'$)+ @+ =#!-)#;

&$2)(#7 (259'""#;

5#7$?

#--#;

7!?

%!&"

-#E#&"')/ &7!'9 8#"'"'$)#-+

'( (259'""#;

?$-:#;

9$-# ",!) F ;!4( &!7#);!- 4#!- 8-#&#;')/ ;!"# "#-9')!"'$) !);3 ",#-#%$-#3 ?!( #)"'"7#;

5#)#%'"

.#&"'$) *F@

&"+

'( %2-",#- (259'""#;

!7",$2/, 9!4 5# ;!'74 ?!/#-3 ("'77 8-$6'('$)( *F@

?#-# !887'&!57# ,'9 ?!( #)"'"7#;

8-$"#&"'$) ",#-#$%+

=#!-)#;

&$2)(#7 %2-",#- (259'""#;

E2;/9#)"( -#7'#;

28$) 5#7$?3 !-# !887'&!57# &!(#+

&&$-;')/743 8-!4#;

'982/)#;

?!-;

5# (#"

!(';# )#&#((!-4 -#7'#% 5# /-!)"#;

8#"'"'$)#-+

+ #- &$)"-!3 7#!-)#;

&$2)(#7 !88#!-')/ -#(8$);#)" !)!/#9#)"

$88$(#;

8-!4#- 9!;# 5#,!7% (259'""')/ 5#7$?

&$)(';#-#;

-#7#6!)"

9!"#-'!7 #6';#)&# !6!'7!57# -#&$-;

8!((#;

?#77 -#!($)#;

E2("'%'#;

?!-;3 ?,'&, ;$#( &!77 !)4 ')"#-%#-#)&# ",'( $2-"+

'( (259'""#;

)#'",#- 8-$6#;

-#&$-;

(#-6'&#( ?#-# #)/!/#;

-#/27!- 5!('( )$- 8-$6#;

-#&$-;

-#);#-#;

&$)"')2$2( (#-6'&# F ;!4( &!7#);!- 4#!- 8-#&#;')/ ;!"# "#-9')!"'$)+

'( (259'""#;

$)&# 8-$6#;

87#!;#;

&!(#3 ",#-#%$-#3 -'/,"74 5##) ;#)'#;

-#7'#% -#')("!"#9#)"

?'", &$)"')2'"4 (#-6'&# !77 &$)(#A2#)"'!7 5#)#%'"( 5#7$?+

&&$-;')/743 '"

'( (259'""#;

",#-# '( )$ 9#-'"

')("!)"

?-'"

8#"'"'$) 8-!4#- ;'(9'((!7 (!9# ?!( 9!;#+ *+ ,!6# ,#!-;

7#!-)#;

&$2)(#7 -#(8#&"'6# 8!-"'#( ,!6# !7($ 8#-2(#;

8!8#- 5$$:

?'", ",#'- !57# !(('("!)&#+

+ "

'( ?#77 (#""7#;

7!?

$)2( 8-$6# #B'("#)&# -#7!"'$)(,'8 #987$4#- #987$4## 5#"?##) 8!-"'#( '( 28$) ?$-:9!)+ ) ( )

* !+* ,

(

. F3 $)C57# .28-#9# $2-"

,#7;

!( 2);#- H-." /

!1 1

-2"

() 3 * ! , 4 , *

)

5 1 6 7

8.%+")%829 :

) ; <,1

1 !/ !

! 1

! !/ !

< -8"

# =

,> + ) ?

8.@+")A 1 ; <

)

! "

)

! )

< @A , B

! B

! :

) 0

! 1

'( !7($ ?#77 (#""7#;

7!?

$)2( 8-$6# ?$-:9!) -#);#-#;

&$)"')2$2( (#-6'&# "#-9( .#&"'$)

*F@

'+#+ ?$-:9!) ?$-:#;

2);#- !)!/#9#)"

F ;!4( 9$)",( 8-#&#;')/ ;!"# "#-9')!"'$) '( !7($ ?$-:9!)+

'( %2-",#- ?#77 (#""7#;

9#-# !%%';!6'"( $- (#7%(#-6')/ ("!"#9#)"( 9!;# &7!'9!)"

?$-:9!) ?'77 (2%%'&# 9!""#- ;'(&,!-/# 52-;#) 87!&#;

7!?

?$-:9!) 8-$6# ?$-:#;

F ;!4( /'6#) 4#!-+ ) ",'( -#/!-;3 -#%#-#)&# &!) 5# 9!;# &!(#

) * ( AA-D-E *),

# !

AA@D2E*)).@A + ) ')("!)"

&!(#3 !88-$!&,#;

5#7$?

?'", 87#!

?!( !88$')"#;

8$("

!7'

!-&,3 *

(#-6'&#( ?#-# '77#/!774 "#-9')!"#;

++** ;#(8'"# %!&"

?$-:#;

9$-# ",!) F ;!4( &!7#);!- 4#!- 8-#&#;')/ ;!"# "#-9')!"'$)3 ",#-#%$-#3 ?!( #)"'"7#;

8-$"#&"'$) .#&"'$) *F@

&"+ +

) $",#- ,!);3 '"

?!(

&!"#/$-'& 87#!

-#(8$);#)"!)!/#9#)"

?!( #)/!/#;

;!'74 ?!/# 5!('( )$ -#/27!- !88$')"9#)"

?!( 9!;#+

?!( %2-",#- (259'""#;

-#);#-#;

&$)"')2$2(

(#-6'&# 2);#- -#(8$);#)"!)!/#9#)"

"#-9( .#&"'$)

*F@

'+#+ F ;!4(< &$)"')2$2( (#-6'&# 9$)",( 8-#&#;')/ ;!"# "#-9')!"'$)D ",#-#%$-#3 ?!( #)"'"7#;

!)4 -#7'#%+ + ) ')("!)"

&!(#3 5#7$?3 !%"#- &$)(';#-')/ 9!"#-'!7 #6';#)&# -#&$-;3 -#"2-)#;

%$77$?')/ %');')/( H8

# *

0 /

50 /

50 / 50 /- /

82%

2@828 !

& ,

! 1 A ,

/ & 9 50 /

( 182

8.AA8 /

82% 828 / ! 50 / > /

1!3

!1!3

! 82%:

/ !

! 1

&/ 3 &

50&/

50&/ 50&/A &/

! 1

, &/ ! 1! & 50&/ 50&/A>

-A !

% + $ 4&

- "

$ 4&

&/ 1

! 1

! & 50&/ 50&/A:

50&/ 50&/A

1! $ 4&

@ + $ 4&

2AA@50 /

@AF 1 ,

50 /%

2AA@ $

G "

$ 4&

0/ 2AA@ 50 /

@AF 1 :

0/ / @%AA2: 50 / 1

8AA@50 /%

1 !

2AA@ 50 / ?

1 2AA@

0/ 1

1! ?

-A !

! ! !

1! $ 4&

! '

8#-2(!7 !%$-#(!';

%');')/( ?$27;

');'&!"# %!'7#;

8-$6# -#&$-;

-#);#-#;

&$)"')2$2( (#-6'&# F ;!4( &!7#);!- 4#!- 8-#&#;')/ ;!"# "#-9')!"'$)+

F+ =#!-)#;

&$2)(#7 %!'7#;

8$')"

$2"

!)4 9!"#-'!7 ;$&29#)"

;'(7$;/# %');')/( -#"2-)#;

-#);#-#;

(#-6'&# F ;!4( &!7#);!- 4#!- 8-#&#;')/ ;!"# "#-9')!"'$) ++**+ #"'"'$)#- (,$?) !)4 8-$$% (!7!-4 ?!/#( !%$-#(!';

8#-'$;

)$- !)4 !""#);!)&# (,##"

$- !)4 $",#- ;$&29#)"

$- -#&$-;

5##) 8-$;2&#;

(,$?

-#);#-#;

&$)"')2$2( (#-6'&# ?'", 9!)!/#9#)"

"#-9( .#&"'$)

*F@

&"+ "

'( '98-$5!57# ?$-:9!)3 ?,$ &7!'9#;

,!6# ?$-:#;

2);#- !)!/#9#)"3 ?$27;

8$((#(( !)4 ;$&29#)"!-4 #6';#)&#

8-$6# )!"2-# #)/!/#9#)"

8#-'$;

?$-:

2);#-"!:#) ?'", #987$4#-+ ,#-#%$-#3 $)&# %!'7#;

8-$6# '"( 87#!;#;

&!(#3 )$ -#7'#% &!) 5# /-!)"#;

,'9+

+ 2-",#-9$-#3 8!-!9#"#-( #B#-&'(# E2-'(;'&"'$) '/, $2-"

2);#-

-"'&7# $)("'"2"'$) );'!

&!(#( ')6$76')/ &,!77#)/# !?!-;

8!((#;

=!5$2- $2-"

);2("-'!7 $-;#-( 8!((#;

$",#- E2;'&'!7 B /

5$;'#( !-# ?#77 ;#%')#;+

?-'"

&!) 5# '((2#;

&$--#&"')/ #--$-( E2-'(;'&"'$) &$99'""#;

')%#-'$- $2-"( $- -'52)!7(+

?-'"

&!) !7($ 5# '((2#;

?,#-# #B#-&'(# E2-'(;'&"'$) &$)%#--#;

'"3 $2-"

$- !&"( '77#/!774 $- '98-$8#-74 '+#+ '"

;#&';#( A2#("'$) ?'",$2"

/'6')/ !) $88$-"2)'"4 5# ,#!-;

8!-"4 !%%#&"#;

$-;#- $- ?,#-# 8-$&#;2-# !;$8"#;

'( $88$(#;

8-')&'87#( )!"2-!7 E2("'&#+ $?#6#-3 '"

92("

5# -#9#95#-#;

E2-'(;'&"'$) '/, $2-"

'((2# ?-'"

'( (28#-6'($-4 E2-'(;'&"'$) !88#77!"# $)#+ ,'( )#&#((!-'74 9#!)( %');')/ %!&"

-#!&,#;

')%#-'$- $2-"

$- -'52)!73 !( -#(27"

!88-#&'!"'$) #6';#)&#3 &!))$"

5# -#$8#)#;

$- A2#("'$)#;

?-'"

8-$&##;')/( #B&#8"

?,#) E2;/9#)"3 $-;#- $- !?!-;

(2%%#-( %-$9 !) #--$- 7!?

!88!-#)"

%!&# -#&$-;+ ,'( '( !5("-!&"

("!"#9#)"

7!?3 52"

6#B#;

A2#("'$) '( !( ?,!"

'( !) #--$- 7!?

!88!-#)"

%!&# -#&$-;

?,!"

&'-&29("!)&#( %');')/ %!&"

-#&$-;#;

!) ')%#-'$- $2-"

$- $- B /

!2",$-'"4 &!) 5# &$--#&"#;+

-$!;74 (8#!:')/3 !) #--$- 7!?

'( $)# ?,'&, &!) 5# ;'(&$6#-#;

5!-# -#!;')/ E2;/9#)"3 $-;#- $- !?!-;

2);#- &,!77#)/# !7$)/ ?'", ;$&29#)"( ?,'&, ,!6# 5##) -#7'#;

28$) ')%#-'$- $2-"3 $- B /

!2",$-'"4+

) #--$-3 ;'(&$6#-4 ?,'&, '( 8$(('57# $)74

!%"#- ;#"!'7#;

(&-2"')4 #6';#)&# 8-$;2&#;

8!-"'#( 7#)/",4 ;#5!"# !"

5!- &!))$"

5# -#/!-;#;

!( !) #--$- 7!?

82-8$(# ?-'"

%');')/ %!&"

-#&$-;#;

!) ')%#-'$- $2-"

$- &!) 5# &$--#&"#;

$)74 '% '"

'( (,$?) -#&$-;')/ (!';

%');')/ $2-"

$- #--$)#$2(74 -#%2(#;

!;9'"

!;9'(('57# 9!"#-'!7 #6';#)&# $- #--$)#$2(74 !;9'""#;

')!;9'(('57# #6';#)&# (!9# ')%72#)&#;

'982/)#;

%');')/+ .'9'7!-743 %');')/ %!&"

5!(#;

)$ #6';#)&# ?$27;

5# -#/!-;#;

!( !) #--$- 7!?

?,'&, &!) 5# &$--#&"#;

?-'"

+ $?#6#-3 (2%%'&'#)&4 $- !;#A2!&4 #6';#)&# -#7'#;

28$) ')%#-'$- $2-"

$- $- B /

!2",$-'"4 &!))$"

5# /$)# ')"$ '/, $2-"

?,'7# &$)(';#-')/ 8-!4#- '((2# ?-'"

+ =':#?'(#3 9#-#3 8$(('5'7'"4 %$-9')/ ;'%%#-#)"

$8')'$) -#!88-#&'!"'$) #6';#)&# 8!-"'#( '( (2%%'&'#)"

'((2# ?-'"

*!H

19*&

$"&8G-* ) -..I*

7 19 :

9 1

$"&8.A* ) GI3 *

& *?

$!?

$"&82- * ) 8.GI&**

* 1

888D-E&)& D) E@%D*)E;3,888DGE*)@A.

"$#3J

3,AAD2E*)G8 + $)(';#-')/ "$"!7'"4 &'-&29("!)&#( 7'/,"

7#/!7 8-')&'87#( ');'&!"#;

!5$6#3 ",#-# '( )$ (&$8# !)4 ')"#-%#-#)&# ",'( $2-"

%');')/(

?!-;

-#);#-#;

5#7$?3 #B#-&'(# ?-'"

E2-'(;'&"'$)+ ,#-#%$-#3 ')("!)"

?-'"

8#"'"'$) %!'7( (!9# '( !&&$-;')/74 ;'(9'((#;+

8#);')/ !887'&!"'$) (3 '% !)43 (,!77 !7($ ("!);

;'(8$(#;

$%+

*++ (E:( ,#",#- (8#!:')/ -#!($)#;

$ ,#",#- -#8$-"!57# #(