High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4213/2005dismissed

Karam Singh v. Ved Parkash & ORS

2018-09-14Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu8 pages

!"# $#%&'&()*+ ,!-!./&(01 233#44!(" 5#-'6' 5#$!-7!'1!($"1#-' 2#'3($#("' ) 89 /

/:9 -#'#(") -!;#'11!-$<!;=$>%!"# -"1#!33#44!(" (# --#'3($#("' - 3!4 &""!4=$>%!"# --#'3($#(" ?('6-!(%#

.3!(@ AAA BC 33#!41!'D##( &4#$!0!&('"$&'.&''!4 "1#%4!&.3#"&"&(( D@ "1# 4#!-(#$ "- %%&$#("' 4!&.' -&D6(!4= !'" -!%7

6-"=,6-67'1#"-!1#-#&(!

"#--# #--#$"!'"1# -&D6(!4<&"1!3-!@#- - '#""&(0!'&$#"1#&.360(#$!<!-$!($ -0-!(" %.3#('!"&(!'%4!&.#$ &("1#%4!&.3#"&"&(!4(0<&"1&("#-#'"&(!%%-$!(%#<&"14!< BC 9#!-(#$%6('#4%("#($#$"1!""1#4#!-(#$ -&D6(!4 !&4#$" "!7#&("!%%6(""1!""1#!33#44!("1!$!33#!-#$!':E!($3->#$"1!" -#'3($#(" 1!$ $-&>#( "1# ."-%@%4# &( F6#'"&( &( ! -!'1 !($ (#04&0#(" .!((#- $6# " <1&%1 "1# !33#44!(" '6

#-#$ .64"&34# 0-&#>6' &(;6-&#'!($"1#!&4@&!-@#3-"&# G3-$6%#$D@"1#-#'3($#("&( #>&$#(%#1!$(#>&$#("&!-@>!46#

C #- %("-!= 4#!-(#$ %6('#4 - "1# -#'3($#("E('6-!(%#

.3!(@'633-"#$"1#!<!-$!($-#&"#-!"#$"1#-#!'(&(0 -"1#$&'.&''!4 "1#%4!&.3#"&"&( BC 1!># %('&$#-#$ "1# '6D.&''&(' 4#!-(#$ %6('#4 - "1# 3!-"&#' C 1#!33#44!("1!$ &4#$!3#"&"&(%4!&.&(0%.3#('!"&(("1# !44#0!"&(' "1!" 1# 1!$ '6

#-#$ &(;6-&#' &( ! -!$ !%%&$#(" ( <1&4#1#!($ !(1!-9!4<#-#0&(0( "("1#4# "'&$# "1#-!$

-.5&44!0#.-&"/!.!(&(.-&E/!.!(&4&(7-!$!($"1!"<1#("1#@ 1!$ -#!%1#$ "1# !-#! 5&44!0# /!.!(&= ! ."-%@%4# D#!-&(0 H?*++%!.# -."1#33'&"#'&$#D#&(0$-&>#(D@-#'3($#(" &( ! -!'1 !($ (#04&0#(" .!((#- !($ 1&" "1# !33#44!("I%4!&.!(" ! "#- %.&(0 ( "1# <-(0 '&$# "1# -!$ " <!' 6-"1#- !44#0#$ "1!" "1# !33#44!("<!''1& "#$"/(& '3&"!4=,6-67'1#"-!D@ !(1!-9!4D6""1# 34&%# &( %446'&( <&"1 -#'3($#(" D@ $&'"-"&(0 "1# !%"' <-(04@ -#%-$#$ H $!"#$ H D@ '1<&(0 "1# !%%&$#(" " D# J"

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

-&01"4@ !($ %--#%"4@ #("#-#$ D6" 4!"#- "1# !33#44!("I%4!&.!(" D#%.# $&'1(#'"!($"<&'"#$"1# !%"''!'"%4!&.%.3#('!"&( BHC #'3($#(" <(#- "1# ."-%@%4# !4' "7 63 3-#4&.&(!-@D;#%"&(&(4&(#<&"1"1#'"!($ -#'3($#("!($3-!@#$

-"1#$&'.&''!4 "1#%4!&.3#"&"&( B+C #'3($#(" &#('6-!(%# .3!(@"763"1#'"!($&( &"'<-&""#('"!"#.#(""1!""1#!33#44!("I%4!&.!("1!$(

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

-..-&"/!.!(&("1#4# "'&$#!4(0<&"1 !(1!-9!4!($<1#("1#@ -#!%1#$ >&44!0# /!.!(&= ."-%@%4# D#!-&(0 HE*++ $-&>#( D@ -#'3($#("&#5#$!-7!'1-!'14@!($(#04&0#("4@1&"1&'-&01"4#0 !($1#'6

#-#$&(;6-&#'(1&'4#0!($1#!$!($"1!""1#!%%&$#("%%6--#$ $6#" !64" -#'3($#("!($!

"#-"1#!%%&$#("=-#'3($#("!($ !(1!- 9!4 #>!%6!"#$ 1&. " "1# 1'3&"!4 - /(& ( "1# '!.# ."-%@%4# #!4'3-$6%#$(-#%-$%3@ %.34!&(" G* &4#$D@ 1&. !0!&('" -#'3($#(" 6-&(0 1&' %-''E#G!.&(!"&(= 1# !$.&""#$ "1!"1#1!$.!$#!'"!"#.#("""1#34&%#D6""1!"1#1!$("'"!"#$D# -# "1# 34&%# "1!" '.# '"-!@ %!""4# %!.# - "1!" "1#-# <!' ( !64" "1#

."-%@%4&'" <#>#-=1#<!'%( -("#$<&"1"1#'"!"#.#("&("1# G=<1#-#&(&"<!'-#%-$#$"1!"1#1!$'"!"#$"1!"!'"-!@%!""4#1!$ %.#"1#-#!'!-#'64" <1&%1"1#!%%&$#(""734!%#!($"1#-#<!'(

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

!7&@!K= D6"&("1#%4!&.3#"&"&(="1#%4!&.!("1!$'#"63!""!44@$&

#-#("%!'#!($ !""-&D6"#$(#04&0#(%#"-#'3($#("="1#$-&>#- "1#."-%@%4#!($ "1!"&("1#%&-%6.'"!(%#'="1#!33#44!("%64$("D#!44<#$"$'!'1# <!'D6($D@"1#'"!"#.#(".!$#D@1&.D# -#"1#34&%#!($ -%.&(0 ""1# !

-#.#("&(#$ %(%46'&(="1#4#!-(#$ -&D6(!434!%#$ -#4&!(%#( "1#$#%&'&( "1&' 6-"&(

#$ % <1#-#&(&"1!'D##(1#4$D@-#4@&(0("1#$#%&'&(&( &'(# !))*( !"1!"<1#-#"1#%4!&.!(".!$#! '"!"#.#("D# -#"1#34&%#"1!""1#%%6--#(%#<!'!%%&$#("!4=1#%64$(" "6-(-6($!($!44#0#(#04&0#(%#".!&("!&(!%&>&4!%"&( -%.3#('!"&( "1#'!.##

#%"&' +,- ./0( $ 12/*0( $ !)%*( % -

( 3 4 !)"5 %6#$ 4&5)%7 !)"*( )

1#$#%&'&( "1#4#!-(#$/&(04#6$0#&(!33#!4!0!&('""1# !<!-$ "1# 4#!-(#$ "- %%&$#("' 4!&.' -&D6(!4 <!' 631#4$ D@ ! &>&'&(#(%1 "1&' 6-"&( !! 4 5#$ #4#>!("#G"-!%" "1#'!.#&'-#3-$6%#$ !'6($#-)E

"# $

& % "# $

' ( ")$ *++# ) '

! #+,+ - .*#/0/

"# 1 '

% '

' !

' 2

'! 3

4 $

% "# .

' 2'

) ' '

' '

% "#

' 2'

55 ' "#

6 5 '!

' '

' !

, 6

' "#

' '

! 2

7 2 '

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

($(#04&0#("$-&>&(0D@-#'3($#(" 1&'!'

>&#<#$&("1#%("#G" "1#$!"#$H 0"4$0#$D@((##4'# "1!("1#!33#44!("=0#'"#'"!D4&'1"1!"&..#$&!"#4@! "#-"1#!%%&$#("="1# 3#"&"&(#- 1!$ .!$# ! '"!"#.#(" " "1# 34&%# "1!" "1# !%%&$#(" 1!$ "!7#( 34!%#$6#"!'"-!@!(&.!4%.&(0&( -(" "1#."-%@%4&'"!($"1!""1# !%%&$#("<!'J"

!7&@!K33!-#("4@="1#!33#44!("'#"63!(#<%!'#&("1# %4!&.3#"&"&($&

#-#(" -.<1!"1!$D##('"!"#$D@1&.&("1#'4#4@ "%4!&.%.3#('!"&( B C %%-$&(04@= &($&(0 ( .#-&" &( "1# !33#!4= "1# '!.# &' $&'.&''#$ /:!4&! 6$0# *+ !.&" :1#"1#-'3#!7&(0I-#!'(#$ ) #'I :1#"1#--#3-"!D4# ) #'I