High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14165/2019dismissed

Punjab National Bank v. Debt Recovery Appellate Tribunal And ORS

2025-08-13The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Sanjiv Berry8 pages

"#$%&$'()(*+,-

./ 0$1)2)

.. . 3 3 3

. 5 3

!"#

$% &'( ) !"#

$%" ***** 30 5 +,- ,$ - % '" !

0$ ' $ 1"

% 2 '3 '

$ - $

$4'

3$""

" 0% "

6,76) #,!%%..

8 6' . -7.

5-6, 9$%" 6"."$9 ,$"$"

!: $ $ ."6,% 2

+ $., 3 %

" % %":

,'3 $$

%" " 9% . 3 "' ;" 3

"% 2$3 $. $

, -

3., " "93 3 -.. " '9- "'., 3"6, $

"%" " 9% . 3 "'

3$$

;" 3 '64'.,

' " " ! "

'" : $!)<!=1!

'" -

3"6,%":

,6,9# !)<!=1

- -#"

9 "8% 2 $ ."!$ #,$ 9' -

," "$"

9% . 3 "' "$"

" + "- ( "$"

:- "$"

7' %" , $ % "

3 6$ 76 ) #, 8 6' %" 9#"

2 3". $

9$9 ,$"$"

- "

9 "6,76 ) #,8 6' . # """

" > >!5'

8 %% .%$"6,%" - -# ..-"6,76 ) #,!%%..

8 6' . -7.

# " 9%'3"""

0 " 6

." % % : 1 $. " '.$% %" 6 3?

$%":

" "'., 5 .. .# " '9 6 .$ $

.'"

393 3"" "6 3.,%.

"6' '

.# " %%

"% 2$3 $.

.3-

9% . 3 "' % .5 '"# ' ' ," '9$ $4'

6. 93 3 #'$% + 2@ " .'3

-,- %" 5 ,% ,9 6' 3$$

,- " 3"# '" '9

.'"

3 4'

6. 93 3 $ #' $ % 2 ,% ,@ " 7)!8 -7.

# " 9%'3"

" !5' 0 "-3.,"." 9$9 ,$% '

9%'3"" '

6. ,$.

- .

6.6

" . " '.$%"

3'96, "

3 .# 9 %"

%%"6$$

$%":

, 3 ?

""'., ;" 6 .$ .3-

% . 3 "' 3 "5 '# '" '9 #'$% 2$%'%$

,@ '69 # "' 3 %" , $ . !%%.

'!%%.

> / 0 69#"6,%" - . " '.$+ 2'69 + 2- ..

#6( $ 9$% %" "."

$9 ,$% @'69 7)!8 7.

-$'.., " 9%'3"""

" 0."

3 %" 6 3 , % , @ '69 # % ..

, $%"

%'"6,+ 2 " 3"

;

,6 3 ?

.# 9 !$ " 3 "%' 3 "

%'" %":

-- .

, "$%'%$ " ;"%" 3 ?

.3- 9% . 3 "'

,5 '.# " '9$%'%$

,8. - "6, ".

' " "! "

$ ."6,% + 2 $ #,$' 3 9'6$7)8 1 - %" - 9%. "" $"$"

@9#"

6$7)8 $". $ 9$9

,$"$"

- ( "

%% .- %$"6$7)!8 -7.

"# " 9%'3"""

0 . "7)!8 -7.

""". $

9 $9 , $ "$"

33 #" 6, 9 % %$" %

<9%' .$ " 93 $

'9$ %" 3.

, %

%'"!"9 "., . 4' 2 6,%" %

, " 3"5 '"

.# " '9$ %'% %

,6'

;" $$

6 $

, 6 3 ?

.# 9=# % .$ %

.., #" %

> $

% - 5 '"6, 9% 3 "' " + "- ($

1 .

.., #" % .$ $

. -

"6,%" 6 3$$

" . " '9- .5 '

,# .

- %'" "' 3 % "

3 $ ..

' !%%.

> / 0 .!%%.

6$7)8 '.% % 2 " '$$" 9 + 2 - .. # 6( $ 9$%" "."$9 ,$ !.'3 %% . " '.$%

9" '

9- 9 "6, '.$+ 2- '

, '

-# # -$$..- 3$

"."

,3'" 0 8 %' . $ 9%'3" " "

" !5' 0% "6,7)!8 -7.

-'."# . $ %9 $

"'%6, - .% 3

""-

$+ 2 !#"' 3 '$ %% . %" %%..

93 3" ,$

% '% ,9$. 26,

%%"6?

" % 3'

,9 "$

6 $

" 9 #6, '.% 3% 2$

9" ,.

9%" '

+ 2- .. #6( $ "."$9 ,$ > 8%' .$ 9%'3""-'." .# . "'

'$% "

3$ .!%%.

9#"6,%" - . " 26,% "6 .

$- 6 3

%%" %%..

6$7)!8 ,"

-$'.., "

9 "$'+ #6(

$ 9#"$9 ,$% + "'

%"$ $

"6, 7)!8 % 9%'3""6,6# 3 +

- ' '" , '

99 "6, '.-6 + 21- .6#" # $ " % "

6-/%":

65 '"

%" 1 -9 3 %' .$ 9%'3""-'."

# . 7)!8 "% " 6 "-.. ""1 # 6#" 3 3$" '96,%" .

6 %

, '

,% , "'

, " $+ 2$. , $ % 6.

5 ' $. " '96, 9 $$

.- ,6

.."6,+ 26,

%%%

% 3 "1 9 $% ' 3"6 .6 %%%

., $3'

""# "

9%'3"" 1%

%'" .

."6,%":

, $9% + 2 8%" 6 3?

.# "6"'., ;" .3-

%%.,$.

, "5 '" ," '9 6 .$6 3?

$!"9 "., .

"$6,%" %

, ," '9

-6- % - #5 '"6,%" %

,@A6.'%9'$1"

('"39

6#" % 3

,%%% ,8.# $('"39 %"'

" '"

!!!

# # $

& '

8' 9 ' %' . $ 9%'3" " "

0-'."# . 6% " $ -$'. %%

'9 $

--- %% #6,6# 3 %" " "$ . 5 ," '9 ,% %

, '%."- '69 9 "6, '.% 3 .# $

-.. "' % "

3$ .!%%.

+ '." #6( $ 9$%" "."$9 ,$% % "

" %" "

.". 5 '" .# " '9 %

,6'

,$$$

$%":

, 7)!8- (' " 9%'3"" " 3". $ 9$9

,$% 6 3 ,% , : 8$ $9 6#"

' 6#"

9%'3"" "

" !5' 0 6 % " 6, 7)!8 -7.

- .

-6, %%

'9 %% # - $ , ..3 ,

'."66#"

..$ , $ ! 4' 6#"

' $ 39 - % 6,"

9 " !..%"

39 ..

$ , . %"$ 30 !

. !

"#$&+,-

(

% 3/ "B C/

% 6.B C/