Aruna Rani v. Veena Jagota And ORS
!"# $#%&'&()!*%+
, - *.(!!(& / 0##(! !1"!!($"+#*'
)
*#'#(") *2!(3!45!4,$/%!"# *"+#6#"&"&(#* * #+!(,$/%!"# **#'6($#("
!"# *!4) 76.1(#$ &( "+# 6*#'#(" *#/&'&( &' "+# 8.$17#(" $!"#$
6!''#$95"+# &*'"!66#44!"#%.*"3+#*#95"+#8.$17#("$!"#$
*#($#*#$95"+#43#*%.*"+!'9##('#"!'&$#!($"+#7!""#* +!'9##(*#7!($#$"&" *+#!*&(1"+#6!*"&#'(6*#:%+!*1##/&$#(%# " %7#' ." "+!" "+# *#'6($#(" &4#$ ! %*&7&(!4 %764!&("!1!&('""+#6*#'#("6#"&"&(#*!($"+#*'.($#*#%"&('
,
,
, ;, -,
:
("+#'!&$%!'#,"+#!%%.'#$3#*# '.77(#$<6*#:%+!*1##/&$#(%#3!'*#%*$#$!($! "#**#%*$&(16*#:
%+!*1##/&$#(%#!($!
"#*+#!*&(19"+"+#6!*"&#',"+#4#!*(#$!1&'"*!"# /&$#*$#*$!"#$
+#4$"+!""+#%764!&(!("7.'"+!/#9*.1+"
'.
&%&#(" #/&$#(%# ( *#%*$ 3+&%+ %.4$ 4#!$ " %(/&%"&( "+# *#'6($#("'+#4#!*(#$!1&'"*!"#+#4$"+!""+##/&$#(%#6*$.%#$95 "+#%764!&(!("&'(" *## *77!"#*&!4%("*!$&%"&(',"+#*# *#,"+#
!%%.'#$3#*#$&'%+!*1#$!($"+#%764!&("3!'$&'7&''#$ 11*&#/#$ "+# '!&$ *$#*, "+# %764!&(!(" 6*# #**#$ !
*#/&'&( 3+&%+3!' $#%&$#$ 954#!*(#$$$&"&(!4#''&(', !4!($+!* (
+#4#!*(#$$$&"&(!4#''&(' .$1#"="+#/ "+!"&(/ "+#8.$17#(" "+#6#>.*"&( !5!=/?' (".4!5, @A- (45 6*&7! !%&# %!'# 3!' " 9# '##(, "+#*# *#,"+#%!'#3!'*#7!($#$""+#!1&'"*!"#"*#:+#!*"+#6!*"&#' (6*#:%+!*1##/&$#(%# !($$#%&$#"+#%!'#&(!%%*$!(%#3&"+"+# 6!*!7#"#*'4!&$$3(95"+#6#>.*"&(!5!=B'%!'#'.6*! !7 "+#/"+!""+#!66*!%+ "+# &*'"!66#44!"#%.*"&'
3+445&44#1!4+#!1&'"*!"#+!'"!=#(!/("+#9!'&' #/&$#(%# !/!&4!94#("+#*#%*$ "+# &*'"!66#44!"#%.*" &($'"+!""+#/ "+# 43#*%.*"&'&(%**#%"!($&'4&!94#"9#'#"!'&$#,"+#(&(64!%#
*#7!($&(1"+#%!'#,"+#*$#* 4#!*(#$!1&'"*!"#%.4$+!/#9##('#"
!'&$#!
"#*$&'%.''&(1"+#7#*&"' "+#'!7# #*#4595!6645&(1(# !."+*&"5, "+# &*'" !66#44!"# %.*" %.4$ (" $&*#%" "+# !1&'"*!"# 3&"+ %#*"!&(6!*!7#"#*'("+&'/ "+#7!""#*,"+#&76.1(#$*$#*$!"#$
6!''#$95"+# &*'"!66#44!"#%.*"&''#"!'&$# +#4#!*(#$ $$&"&(!4#''&(' .$1#, !4!($+!*&'$&*#%"#$"$#%&$#"+#'!&$*#/&'&( (7#*&"'!
"#*%('&$#*&(1"+##("&*##/&$#(%#!($"+#%!'#4!3("+# 6&(" C#!*(#$ %.('#4 * "+# 6#"&"&(#* '"!"#' "+!" (# "+# !%%.'#$?*#'6($#(",(!7#45,##(!='+&D6!'!(!+!'1(#".'"*!4&! !
"#*+#*$&'%+!*1#&("+&'%!'# +#&'!443#$"!66#!*"+*.1++#* %.('#4&("+# &*'"!66#44!"#%.*" *"+#6.*6'# +#!*&(1!*1.7#("'&( "+#*#/&'&( +#6!*"&#'"+*.1+"+#&*%.('#4!*#$&*#%"#$"!66#!*9# *#
"+#'.%%#''*%.*" +*& 2 +!*7!,4#!*(#$$$&"&(!4#''&('
.$1#, !4!($+!*( ; - E
!"F !*%+
, - !