High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1425/2015disposed of

Rohtash v. State Of Haryana

2015-07-29Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul7 pages

!""#$%&'()*

+,-.+ ,!,!#/ 0/.&.

1,-,-/(-#- .2#"#,

3+,+//2/,/.' -'#4.2-2/.5-(6-''4",.7&"85#,9 6///",/2/,/./#,9 :3+,+/,+7&"85#,.+&'"6/2/,"!#,+!8.,9

/.#,$%

/.+;//-*"< -, /,+2,!,!#/

/ -#!.+-#.-'**-/(-#-

+ 2/.#, /<!.!# 2,!,!# +-. 6# !'" 6( 2,!,!#/

+,-.+4+ 4-.#5!#-," -. -# - &." !# -. :"-,"

=)> &#"/ 1 ,!# :=> * /8!.,/" -, '! 1,-,!# ;'-#-* !.,/! ,!.-/ ?-/#",/!-'&/,<!"7&"85#,"-,"=+-"&#" ,+2,!,!#/8&!',(/,+ 55!..!## &#"/1 ,!#:=> -#"<!".2-/-,/"/"-,":.#,# "+!5,&#"/8/!8/&. !52/!.#5#,/-2/!"#(-/-#",2-(-!# .*@%/,+ 55!..!# -/.-!" # # "-&', 2-(5#, !#* ,+ 2,!,!#/4-. &/,+/ .#,# " , &#"/8 .!52' !52/!.#5#, / -

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

,+2-,/''!#8 52'-!#-#, 5 -/,-22/.#,"-#-22'! -,!#,,+ ,,+-,+!. /,!/"/5,+2.,</#5#, "! -' ! /#,+<#!#8 B)>*-',,/4/-22"!#-266'4-.&#"'(!#8!#,+ &/,(-/" +!.+&.4+/!#-"5-#" .'- .4-.5-"/5+!5-.4''-./5 +!.4!+',,/ #,-!#",+-,/-#.568!<##1&#"-(6,4# ##,25-#"!# -.,+5#(!.#,8!<#*#6"(4!''6 .-<"-#"+4!''2&,!/ #,+5/#!#8=)>*. #"-#",+!/" ',,/.4/-'.&#"'(!#8!#,+ &/,(-/"4+/!#!,4-."!/ ,",+-, /-#.568!<#,+!.2/.##-/&'.+-##,&.-!'#84+! +- ,+/-,4-.-'.8!<#,;!''+!54!,+6566'-.,3!,+,+!.!#/5-,!

52'-!#-#,2/-("/!#!,!-,!#'8-'- ,!#-8-!#.,,+2/.#4+ "5-#""/-#.5/5+!5+ /,+ 55!..!## &#"/ 1 ,!#:=> 4-./8!.,/"-#""&/!#8!#<.,!8-,!#*,+- &."4-. -//.," #,+6-.!.!#<.,!8-,!#*,++-''-#4-.2/.#,"-#" 2(-./C&!/"&#"/1 ,!#B/ 4-..&22'!",,+- &." 2/!5-%- ! -.&#"/1 ,!#:=> 4-.5-"&,-8-!#.,,+- &."

-#"- /"!#8'(* +-/84-./-5"-8-!#.,+!5<!"/"/"-,"B> 6(,+'-/#"&"! !-' -8!.,/-,.,'-..*!.-/,4+! ++"!"#,2'-" 8&!',(-#" '-!5",/!-' #/"/,2/<!,. -.*,+2/. &,!#+-.D-5!#"&/ 4!,#...! 3/ 5 -/,-2*4+!. 52'-!#-#,!#,+2/.#, -. 2/<"',,/.D ,D :<!"4+! +,+/-#.54-."5-#""

/5+!5D !.,+ 52'-!#,5<"6(+!5,,+2'! -#"#,+.-!" 52'-!#,*,+2'! +-".,-/,"!#<.,!8-,!#'',+,+/',,/.4/ ,-;#!#,2....!#6(,+2'! <!"/ </(55D D >!.,+ ',,/4+! +4-.8!<#,,+2'! 6(,+4!,+ 52'-!#-#,4+#,+ 2'! <!.!,",++&.,+ 52'-!#-#,#,+!.',,/*,+ 52'-!#-#, 4-."!/ ,",8!<5#(-,0!.+<-;-/5-+-/-5.+-'-+!.',,/4-. ,-;#!#,2....!#6(,+2'! <!"/ </(55D B #,+ -.;!#8,+2'! *,+ 52'-!#-#,2/2-/"-4+!, '&/6-8 #,-!#!#8 2-2/. !# ,+ .+-2 &//# ( #,. .@% -#" /- +" -, 0!.+<-;-/5-+-/-5.+-'-,/.5,!5*-2/.#4+4-.5&'"-

-5 , +!5 / ,-;!#8 5#( 6-8 # ,+ 5-#4+!'* ,+ 2'! -22/+#"",+-,2/.#-#"+-"#C&!/"-6&,,+!# !"#, ##C&!/(*+ "!. '."+!.#-5-. +,-.+!,+2/.#,- &."*/.!"#,#"!/- '#(* ;'-#- +/-,/* ,+ 6-8 #,-!#!#8 2-2/. 4-. ,-;# !#, 2....!#<!"/ </(55D =4+! +4-.-,,.,"6(,+4!,#.. 1!5!'-/'(* 30#-4+!.4! 52'-!#-#, 5 -/,-2 +-."2.",+-,#B)>*#.'!24-.&#"'(!#8!#,+ &/,(-/" +/+&.1+&/,+/"2.",+-,D 2,,+!.*.+"!"#,;#4-#(,+!#8 -6&,,+2/.#, -.#,+!.5-##/*,+!.4!,#..4-." '-/"+.,!'-. .+/.!'"/5+/2/<!&..,-,5#,D )/ /""6(,+2'!

3:11-"+& -5!.,+!#<.,!8-,!#8! /-#"++-.

2/<",+.,2.,-;#6(+!5"&/!#8,+!#<.,!8-,!#,+ -.

3A+,-1!#8+!.,+4!,#../ </(4++-" - 52-#!",+!#<.,!8-,!#8! /-.4''-.,+ 52'-!#-#,"&/!#8 !#<.,!8-,!#,+2/.#, -. -<!#8 -""& " ,+ 2/. &,!# <!"# * ,+ -. ,+ 2/. &,!#4-.2&,,,+- &."-#"+4-.D-5!#"&#"/1 ,!#:: / "#!",+2/. &,!#-''8-,!#.-#"2'-"",6!## #, 1 ,!#:=> /-".-.&#"/$

"#!

$%""& $%& %$ %&'$ (% $%!

$%"%$%"#% $ !

$%")" *

%" %++"' ,%$%" # <!4 ,+ -6< 2/<!.!#. 1 ,!# :=> * ,+

2/. &,!#4-./C&!/",2/<,+-,- &." +,-.+2&, 52'-!#-#, 5

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

'-/#" &#.'/,+1,-, -<!#86# #/#,"4!,+,+C&-'!,(<!"# -<-!'-6' # ,+ / /" 4+! + !. 8#, -#" #<!# !#8 -#" '-". , # ,+/ # '&.!#6&,,+ #<! ,!#,+2,!,!#/*'-/#" &#.'/,+ 2,!,!#/.&65!,.,+-,+4!''#,6-6',.& ..&''( +-''#8,+ #<! ,!#,+2,!,!#/ +!.&/,#+-"!..&"#,! ,,+/.2#"#,C&- C&-#,&5.#,# #'( ?-/#" &#.'/,+2,!,!#/2/-(.,+-,,+2,!,!#/+-.

-'/-"(&#"/8#.#,# /.#,# /-6&,=5#,+.-#""-(.-. -8-!#.,,+,,-'-4-/"".#,# #(-/-/8&.,+-,,+.#,# ,+2,!,!#/6.&!,-6'(/"& "-.,+!. /!5!#-',/!-'!.+-#8!#8#+!. +-"'!;-5 '.E.4/"/,+'-.,-6&,#!#(-/.-#"!,.+&'"6- .&! !#,5!,!8-,!#8 !/ &5.,-# ,,/-,+!5'#!#,'(&#.'/,+ 2,!,!#/&/,+/.&65!,.,+-,,+ &//# 2/,-!#.,,+(-/>-#" .!# ,+#-2/!"5/,+-#=(-/.+-.'-2."+2,!,!#/+-. .&/",+/"-'/-'#82/!"#.&22/,+!. #,#,!#*'-/#" &#.'/,+2,!,!#/+-.2'- "/'!-# &2#-7&"85#,,+!.&/, !#

!"#!#$%"&' , #,#",+-,!#,+.!5!'-/ !/ &5.,-# .*!#- -.&#"/1 ,!#:= * ,+!.&/,+-"/"& ",+.#,# ,+- &."/5,4(-/.,# (-/6( #.!"/!#8,+- ,,+-,,+!# !"#,4-.&/(-/.'"&/,+/ .&65!,.,+-,,+/!.#,+/ -.2#"!#8-8-!#.,,+2,!,!#/ +-< #.!"/" ,+ -/8&5#,. -"<-# " 6( ,+ '-/#" &#.'/,+2,!,!#/-.#,! "-6< /"!#8'(*',+-,7&.,! 4&'"65,,,+2,!,!#/!,+.#,# -4-/"",+!5!./"& ", ,+2/!"-'/-"(&#"/8#/"/- /"!#8'(

/,+.-;/2,!,!#*,+.#,# #(-/-4-/""6( ,+,/!-'&/,-#"-!/5"6(,+-22''-,&/,!./"& ",,+2/!" -'/-"(&#"/8#6( ,+2,!,!#/%- &."4</*,+ 2,!,!#/ !. "!/ ,",2-( .*@%-. 52#.-,!#,,+ 52'-!#-#,4!,+!## 5#,+#"-&',*,+-5&#,4!''6/ </-6'-.'-#"/<#&

3!,+,+-/.-!"5"!! -,!#!#,+/"/.#,# *,+ !52&8#"7&"85#, #<! ,!#"-,"=2-.."6(,+,/!-'&/, -#"-!/5"6(,+-22''-,&/,*!.&2+'" +2/.#,/<!.!#2,!,!#.,-#"."!.2."4!,+-"!/ ,!# ,+-,,+2,!,!#/6/'-."!55"!-,'(*!#,/C&!/"!#-#(,+/ -. -.

/#01*0234 E-8&,,E