Mohinder Singh v. High Court Of Punjab And Haryana






  

   

!"##$%&%'()*


 





 

 

  
  





(  +,  -

-
-
 


  
! 
"

#$


%

& 
"

#$



-
-
 . 




'

"

$'

(()

   
 





 $


* 





  
 +  


,

(((-
./





*

 ,

 $


* 





  

$ 





$

,



(((((
.()/
'






,

,

(

 





*!






 

(001

$ 

$

2000
3



 '
$

, 


,

'


#

 ,
4((0256
75(6

))(


'

82



 
6 -1-

."

 , 
9
 


/
'


08
.  
:'


08:/

*
'

1


 
#'

.  

"

'/
'


0
.  
;'


0</
(

3



,

(((-
. /





*

'

''
  









3





 

 $

'
 ' '




 
$, ' 


* !
 $
((

"'


$ 


''

"


#



=  $ >

# ?$





*$
$ 


'

$# '




,

(8

3




'


,



(((((
.()/



$ 


!


 
''
(-

''






!

+


'

# 



'


'

#





$



$'

*
'

#

'$ .

/
(2

@ '
$ 


''





 !

 
,


'

#



(0


''


'

 '

8



  
'

$

'


,

 * !

$ $


*



, !
 



3

,

*

'
'

#

!


 



"




(
(0
(
9
(


  
*

:A':


"

 ((
"'

,


# *

'

88.-/


'


08

$

-2-



'$

 



 


* ''


* !

$ $


'


'$
 


#

,

(((-
. /
8

3


,




'


 :'

 
B $ 

'

#

(8((((


 
."

,   /
-


'

$

'


!
2

C


 ,


!


*

 



*!






 

(001


$

, 


,

'

#

,
4((0256
75(6

))(
.CC/


'

82

 '


08

*
'

1


'


0
3



'

# 




$



 


 
!


" 
 
$ %

" #


$"

"'(
)*

& 
 
$ #

+
# 
 &

,)*,-*.,,-


)/*).*.,,-
$ &
  0

3.
 &4*
.*

& 
+ 

%


1
# 




+&
& 
# 
" 
1
# 
.,*,)*.,,-
.)*)*.,,-
.5*,.*.,,-

./*,.*.,,-
,6*,6*.,,-

)/*,6*.,,-
,7*,8*.,,-

)6*,8*.,,-
)5*,8*.,,-

.5*,8*.,,-
,.*,7*.,,-

,9*,7*.,,-
.-*,9*.,,-

,9*,/*.,,-
..*,/*.,,-
6)*,/*.,,-
),*,-*.,,-

).*,-*.,,-
)7*,-*.,,-
.7*,-*.,,-
,9*),*.,,-

,-*),*.,,-
.,*),*.,,-

.)*),*.,,-
.-*),*.,,-

,9*))*.,,-
)5*))*.,,-

)9*))*.,,-
6,*))*.,,-
,)*).*.,,-
,6*).*.,,-

,7*).*.,,-,-*).*.,,-

),*).*.,,-
:
)8*).*.,,-

)5*).*.,,-
$  
&

+
"  0 
3--
 &4*
6*

& 1




1
2   &
"

& 
.,,-;

& 1
1



  


-3-



## 

 
..*).*)-96
 


1
 *
< *
))69
= *


 
)5*,)*.,,5*
8*

&

#


#

 




!
< *
.8-,5
*)*0**05(
 
.-*,9*.,,-
6,978
**0**05(
 
)/*-*.,,-

--85
*)*0**05(
 
6)*6*.,),*
 
& 1
#
  
1 

 &

1


 
6
#


1
2

&
3  4
 
)-55


+ 


2

&
#

 




1&
2 + 
 
 +&


#


 
$   

 2 
+  

 


2#  
#
& 
##

 &
+

"

1
1  *>
)




#

$

42-2
6C
7D.(6/

((
6 + 
E$

 


$ $

'

, '

+ 
C
$, ' $


6 + 
E$

,



(2((
.CCC/
$ $'  

$

#

 


"'

 ,

-

   
'





* !
 $


 






, !
3




 
-


*   


$ '

 8*
 
 
#

$ %


 
2  
'
  
   
 
+
# 
 &
# 
,)*,/*)--6
.7*,/*)--6
# 
$ 

$ 
2



2 





+&
%"

1$

?+ 

 #
@  
2 
1 %


#
2 



2 

 
2

#
?
?
2 

2   *
 


" 
 
#

2   
$ 
$  $ 

1
##
# 

2 
& 
# 
"

1
$*#*
,)*,9*.,,,

)6*,9*.,,,
$ 
" "

"  
# 


2 
 *
 


" 
 
#

2   
$ 
$  $ 

1
##
# 

2 
& 
# 
$

#

+
# 
 &
$*#*
,8*,8*.,,)

)5*,8*.,,)*
 

#
 "



" 
 
$



1
##
$ 
2 
2 
2   
# 

$

#

+
# 
 &
$#*
,7*,-*.,,.

,9*,-*.,,.
)9*),*.,,.
.)*),*.,,.

./*))*.,,.

.-*))*.,,.*
-4-

 

#
?
?
$ 
2 
2 
2   
# 
 "

+
# 
 &
$**#*
,.*).*.,,8

,7*).*.,,8
)8*,)*.,,7
)9*,)*.,,7
.-*,)*.,,7

,-*,.*.,,7*
 

  ?
!
 
,7*,5*.,,9

2   
$ 
"  
= 
 &
 1
3$ 
2 &4
# 
,8*,.*.,,5
,9*,.*.,,5

$ 
$ 

 

#

# 



 
+
# 
 &*
 

#
 "
#
$
  
$ 

1
## 
2 
2 

2   
# 

"

"


2  

A&
2 
 
6,*,)*.,,-
+ 
+&
A&
## 

2 
 
./*,6*.,,-
+ 
+&

2   *
 

#
 "
#
$
  
$ 

1
## 
2 
# 
= "

=2


#
2   
# 
 "
+
# 
 &

%"
= 
1
"

2 
+ $
@ &
.,,/

2 +
.,,/*
 

#
 "
#
$ 

" 
  
$



1
##
$ 
2 
# 

"

"


2  

A&
2 
 
.,*,-*.,,/
+ 
+&
A&
## 

$


2 
 
.7*,9*.,,-
+ 
+&

2   
# 
 "
+
# 
 &
$**#*
,)*,-*.,,7

,6*,-*.,,7
,9*,-*.,,7

),*,-*.,,7

..*),*.,,7
$ &

0  *
 

#
 "

 
$


1
##
$ 
2 
# 

"

2 &
 
)7*,7*.,),


 $


 
 
.7*,6*.,,-



 
"



1
2   
 "
+
# 
 &


1

 &
# 
+ &
.,,/

!

&
.,,/*
 

#
 "
#
$
  
$


1
##
$ 
2 
# 

"

2 &
 
,-*,7*.,).


 $


 
 
,8*,.*.,).

# 
2 "
 
2

&*
 

#
 "
#
$
  
$ 

1
## 
2 
# 

"



 
2 &
 )6*,6*.,).
#

2   *
 "




& 
.,)6

2

#
 "
#
$
  
$ 

1
##
$ 
2 
# 

"



 #

2   *
 

#
 "
#
$ 

" 
  
$



1
## # 

"

2 &
 
.)*,.*.,)6

2   


 $


 
 
..*).*.,).
# 
2 "
 
2

*?

C
# *


# ? $


'


$'

$



#




,

 

 








'
'

#

!

*

,


-5-



+ #


 ,


$


6#

:

  
*

:

':


"


((
 *

F

$



$ 
 



 '

 

 
,

F





 


 



'


 1
C
# *


# 




  
?$



,

 
0

$$

 '


 


'$ .

/

 
''
'




)* 


-
-
 "

! 5 4   C  
2 %"0 

0< C  
2 +

0< -6-