High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/5845/2017allowed

Harmail Singh v. State Of Punjab

2017-03-23Mr. Justice Arun Palli3 pages

!"#$"%&'&#() *%+,-

*. &/ &(0+ 1"!&!&#("* 2"*'3'

! !"#$3(4 5 "'6#(7"(!

*"'"(!) *8898: /& -7;#% !" $#*!+"6"!&!&#("*8 *8 4"'+"+! -77/87;#% !""("* /-3(4 5 <<<

3*'3 (!!#!+"#*7"*#$!+&'#3*!7 !"78,8 -!+" "(&#*

36"*&(!"(7"(!#$#/&%"- (' -&'6*"'"(!&(#3*!8&' $$&7 ;&!+ ' /'# 5""($&/"75=!+"/" *("7 ! !"%#3('"/&(#3*!!#7 =-'! !&(0!+"*"&(!+ ! #(" 3>+?&(7"* &(0+'#(#$9 > &(0+-0#!*"%#*7"7+&''! !"."(!#( 8,8@-!#!+""$$"%!!+ !?+&/"+"? ''&!!&(0 ! + 5 (" * (' 9 (%+& ( #( 8,8@- !+" 6"!&!&#("*- ' /'# +&' !?# %# %%3'"7

*6&(7"* &(0+ (7A >+;&* &(0+-?"*"! />&(0 .#(0'!!+".'"/;"' (7 +">("?!+". '!+"=?"*" /'#9 5 77&6/ ="*' (7 '6"*!+"' &7 %#(;"*' !&#(-!+"=?"*"! />&(0 5#3!!+"%*&."&(B3"'!&#(8 +"#$$&%& /'#$!+"#/&%" ! !&#(37+/ 7 0#!&($#*. !&#( *"0 *7&(0!+" **"'!#$!+#'"6"*'#('$*#.!+"6#/&%"#$#/&%" ! !&#(

+"*63*-&'!*&%! (0*3*-?+"*"!+"=?"*" **"'!"7&(%#(("%!&#(?&!+

#87 !"78,8@*"0&'!"*"7$#*!+" //"0"7%#..&''&#(#$#$$"(%" 63(&'+ 5/"3(7"* "%!&#(',CC (7 (7#$!+"*.'%!8 +"*"36#(-*"%#;"*=#$!?#.#!#*%=%/"' (7 '8@-D&(% '+?"*"

'! !"7!#+ ;"5""(. 7"$*#.!+".- (7#( 6*#73%!&#(? ** (!!+"

%%3'"7?"*"6*#73%"75"$#*"!+"#3*!#(8,8@ (76#/&%"*". (7 ? '0* (!"78 !+"*!+ (!+ !-#(@8,8@-!+"%#.6/ &( (!- %++ !! *

&(0+-+&.'"/$&''! !"7!#+ ;"&7"(!&$&"7 //!+*"" %%3'"7&(!+"6#/&%" '! !&#(-!+#30+(#$#*. /&7"(!&$&% !&#(6 * 7"? '%#(73%!"78 +"'! !"."(!+ '5""( (("E"7?&!+!+" $$&7 ;&!8 A" *("7%#3('"/$#*!+"6"!&!&#("*'35.&!'!+ !!+"6"!&!&#("* + '5""(&(%3'!#7=$#*!+"6 '!#("=" *-?&!+#(/=!+"%+ *0"'+ ;&(05""( $* ."7'#$ * (76*#'"%3!&#(";&7"(%"'!&//!#%#.."(%"-?+&%+$ %!&'(#! 7"(&"75=!+"/" *("7 ! !"%#3('"/-#(&('!*3%!&#('$*#. /7"; &(0+8 6"*3' /#$!+" '+#?'!+ !!+"%#.6/ &( (!+ 7'! !"7!+ !

#("6"*'#(+ 7 !! %>"7+&. (7+ 7'( !%+"7+&'5 0%#(! &(&(0% '+ (7 + 7*3( ? =- $!"*?+&%++"+ 7$#//#?"7!+"' &76"*'#(-?+#' !7#?(#( !+".#!#*%=%/"#$+&' %%#.6/&%" (75#!+#$!+".!+"*" $!"*7*#;" ? = /#(0?&!+!+"5 0#$!+"%#.6/ &( (!8 +"%#.6/ &( (!-+#?";"*-&''""(!#+ ;"/ !"*'! !"7!+ !!+" 6"!&!&#("*- *. &/ &(0+- /'#!##> '8?+&%+? ''!#/"($*#.+&.

(7&' .".5"*#$!+"' ."0 (08 *&. $ %&"-!+"*"&'#5;&#3'/= . *>"7&.6*#;"."(!&(!+" '! !"."(!#$!+"%#.6/ &( (!&(!+" (7!+"'366/"."(! *='! !"."(!

7 !"7@8,8@F+#?";"*!+"&''3"?#3/7#5;&#3'/=5"0#("&(!#5=!+" /" *("7!*& /#3*!#(";&7"(%"5"&(0 66* &'"75=&!8"!-$#*!+"63*6#'" #$!+"5 &/ 66/&% !&#(-%#('&7"*&!'3$$&%&"(!*" '#(!# 7.&!!+"6"!&!&#("* !#5 &/8 #('"B3"(!/=-!+&'6"!&!&#(&' //#?"78+"6"!&!&#("*?#3/75" "(/ *0"7#(5 &/#(+&'$3*(&'+&(0 7"B3 !"5 &/ (7'3*"!=5#(7'!#!+"

' !&'$ %!&#(#$!+"!*& /#3*!8 ! (""7' !# 5" (#!&%"7 +"*" !+ ! #( B3"*= ' !# ?+= &7"(!&$&% !&#(6 * 7"' *"(#!% **&"7#3!&(!"*.'#$ "%!&#(*888- ";"(&$&!&' 7&'%*"!&#(0* (!"7!#!+"#$$&%"*&(%+ *0"#$!+"6#/&%"'! !&#(- !+" "(&#* 36"*&(!"(7"(!#$#/&%"+ ''! !"7!+ ! !!".6!'?#3/75". 7" !#7#!+"(""7$3/8 !&'+#6"7!+ !?+"*"% '"'? ** (! (&7"(!&$&% !&#(6 * 7"!# 5"% **&"7#3!-!+"(""7$3/?#3/75"7#("8 *%+,-

;%0 *0 370"