High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4379/2005allowed

Jagdish Ram v. Raj Singh & ORS.

2018-12-14Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan7 pages

!"#$

%%&& '() #*+ !" "(

#% ,(

-.*/)(0.( ( '"&1)%0. ("%%&&

( 2(3"/)$(0102(4

( +"$"(/)(0. ("(% 56 )( 7$%

9(&40"("% (:&$ !"#$ +"

(#$0%(6 %(0;$) -!("<()!"&$% ) (+ =="( '"& ! (% (% - #* + !"0 7 <&- 5(.(0(% ((1 (&,&0 2(4 0, "3)&"()!"+)%( ,&0;$) -!(5 > ( (% - - &6 )( 7$% 40 ;$) -!(5 )((*%- 2# 1

&$ !$% " ) # & )( *)( ( .&. !*%- 2# 1

( !"% (:&$ 0>">!<) 4("$& !"&$% %(6 %(0 2(4 ,&0;$) -!(01.( $ $%&4+ 2(4 0"$ "&4 $"< # 0

:%($ "?" " (. ! !" :

!"0 " % (:&$ & !>"+6@*+ !" "(%&& >(.&& *%- 2# 1

< !(. <4(% 57 <&#*+ !"?""4"&"76+;$) -!(( ! !9)(,&+ >" "*% A) (" ( 1)()>(9)(+"<0" &&) >&>()

!($& %%( ( "*%?"*%>< !(. <4(% - .(4"!"%0("&4 !&! &4 ")& (& "*%( !" $&0()& &4"*%)( )(&( " !">&> && ""(?()& &4" % (:&$ )( *)( &) ! " & 40 (" "()% (.&& "*%&) *)(?

"% (:&$ >3 !"(($>"(">()" ,16(($ "4?"% (:&$ >$ ,160 7" !("

>"(!

?"" ) (!)(!(4"&4"(0">.(0")& (.()&&4 )(%($ <&4") B0>""%($ )(?"% (:&$ &&) (($ ?"&$ " )(%($ <&4>"&"(! !"&)4 " )( " $%&4$ ? " " &$ " % $( "

: "($ &) !$ 0"%&"(!0C(40

"( !C0 .4 "(!0 C% 0%&:C(

)("$ .<4"(?""&$ "&&" ))(( !%4 2(.<$% % )( ! "(( " "% !$(

"($ ))( @"% (:&$ %(4(% "&$% !( $% "$ 0 " (% %%( & %( >( (%& ">( (%&4& <"&(% 0" "" A) "3 %& "("

!&! (. !0("(" "" > 1 "> )&("$?"$) )((<4" &$ "($ "< ($<)("$<4"$%&4(

,&%($ "&& "(.?""( & A) $"&$ @"($ !( "&$%

>( (.(

D( (%&4 & <4 (% - &$ " $&(& "(%

D"((% <4& !>( (%&43.() &!&<* &) !" 6#A)" >!(!( %"""&$ "$&> 6 %( ",& %($ .(4$)" .( >""&>3 > !"6#

(4<(( >")&$% $ <&

@"($ !( "&$% >(()

" 0 " (% %(4 ( $& "

" %& ! " %(0 &&> ! ) >( ($

D""(" >""3%& " (. ! !" :

()& *)("&$ >"()& (" !&! (. !(% >"&(. !" ! % - 2# 1

(" !&! $

(E,,

D""("&$ &$% 00>" $) ($>"$E,,

D""("&$% $ <&E,#

9""%(&. )%%("((%. &$

)%%("0"&$ "C$ $ 4 . > 27+"(#$,D0'3($+ !"0F<&"$ 7&(3: 0+)%( ,&0;$) -!( ,D 0 7 <& #* ( + !" ,D0 +6 @* + !" ,D0 &$ !"#$,D 0 > /)$(,D= #*"7"%(0 @C> (,D

""(" 0(% "C$ (% - 5#*+ !"#D -(+ !"0#!( 7&(30 +)<. &!(0 !"(#D

("( !(!)$ 0"@(<) &)-

.)("&$ ! "(% 0)- .)(

"&$ ! (% 0)- ! "(% 0 ()& &4.>(

0"(<) &) "&$ &$% # 0=0

: *)() <4"$ " (>""&&""((% >(* &4 .(&&4&<& @"&$% >&&>>" (GB%(

)$ "$% $) >(($"& ! &$ % && (&H < "%( ! 6 > <(." ((4 ($

>)& <%<4(% @"$% >(>%(& <&>

7$% ())(& $ ))( & $ C% & ) %($ %"4&<&4"C

: 7$% C% )( $&($

# : 7$%

) ( %( "(! #

: . 7$% % )( !)!(.) *)( #

: @& # 0 0= @"$) >() # 0=0

& !""$% >("$> &>( 0"&$ "&"%( %%&0 >"">!.

(% 0>"%) %%( "()!") &

6"."(&( ) &("%(<! !

"()!""((

6 " B<&40"&$ " < >($% #

:0>""6 <(

= A)<& @"%%&& :&$ < !!.( $ (. >"$ " $& C% ( ($<)(0 " < >( )$ # :< !<& "$) )&&4 )((<4"$ ($<)("$<4"1.( $ - (( >""$ &&( ( %( "(!0""< >( )$#

:0>""6 <A)<&

2>.(0 % )( !) *)( )(<4"%%&& :&$ 0""< >(#

: &4

$4.> ( !" )$<( *)()(<4"&$ 0 %("%&H )$<()(!(%(($ &4 "%%&& :&$ 0"$) >( &>( 6.(4 )& A) 4 " % )( ! ) (! <4 %(

)( ! *)(4 " .& %( " <4 (A)( ! & !

"%&H 0)(!( &&>)%($ /% .>" ()$ "06$".>"$%

>( ") &>(0>""&&( " $

@"((0"$ " #

@" %%&& :&$ " < !( $% (%& %( )( !)"4% *)( %&((&4 %(%((.(4 )$#

: >("$ ")

""&% <4"%%&& :&$ )( !"%(""%&H 0>"&! !"%&(&&> )% "3)% ( < ! &3 ( "$0 " < $% )$#

:>("$((.

@")0 " %%& ) %(&4 " $% >(<4"@(<) &.>(

0" %%&& :&$ >( )("( )$ #

: $% &<.%4<&<4&&""((% * &4 .(&&4 @"%%&& :&$ >)&< &! (GB%(

)$($" ) %%&&&" )&%4$

D")"$ 0"%%&&&>%(&4

9(*

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#