High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4385/2005allowed

Tika Ram And Another v. Union Of India

2017-03-14Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan4 pages

!"#$#%&'&() * &+!!,!($!("-#.

//#00!(" '

1#.'2'

(&(($&!

#'/($#(" '

) 34 5 6 45 .#'#(")7 .!2055!&(&8$9%!"#8."-#!//#00!("' .52.&!($.-&"52.&8$9%!"#'8..#'/($#(" :-#"-#."-##/."#.'0%!0(#;'/!/#.,!<=#!00;#$" '##"-#>2$?,#("@

=#.##..#$""-##/."#..(" :-#"-#."-#>2$?,#("'-20$=#.#/."#$&("-#$&?#'"@ 77 77 45

4 ,/2?(#$&("-#/.#'#("&.'"!//#!0&'"-#>2$?,#("$!"#$

** 8 9&$# ;-&%- "-# %0!&, !//0&%!"&( &0#$ =< "-# !//0&%!("'

!//#00!("' ;!' $&',&''#$ =< "-# !&0;!< 0!&,' .&=2(!08

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

.,"-#/0#!$&(?'800;&(?&''2#';#.#.!,#$)7

:-#"-#.!(<2(";!.$&(%&$#("!'$#&(#$2 '

"+/0!%#8!'

!00#?#$@ :-#"-#.$#%#!'#$;!'!=(!&$#/!''#(?#.( &(".!&( 6@

:-#"-#.!//0&%!("&'"-#'0#$#/#($#(""-#$#%#!'#$@

:-#"-#.!//0&%!("'!.#%9#.#$;&"-&($#&(&"&($#/#($#("@

:-!" ;!' "-# &(!(%&!0 $#/#($#(%< "-# !//0&%!("' 2/( "-# $#%#!'#$@

;-!"!,2("%,/#('!"&(!//0&%!("'!.##("&"0#$@

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

-"$#/#($'2/("-#,#("!0&"< !/#.'(;-#"-#.-#;!("'"'##"-#%,&(?'"!"&(.,"-#$.. .,"-# ;&($; 9#(&"-#.#&'(.2'-!($('2$$#(=.!+#'!.# !//0&#$#9#("-#(;-#("-#".!&(%-!(?#'"-#0&(#;-&0#!//.!%-&(? "-#'"!"&(8"-#/''&=&0&"<>#.+&'"-#.#!($%('#C2#("0<8$2#""-#>#.+8 !,!('"!($&(?("-#$.,!<#00$;(5!.!'"-#!0!.,%-!&(&' %(%#.(#$8"-#.#&'(#9&$#(%#"-!""-#!0!.,%-!&(;!'&(;.+&(?.$#. ($$&$;.+;-#(&";!'/200#$.#9#.8"-#&.'"/.&.&"<!%-%-2 5&(?-;!'".#,9#"-#&(>2.#$""-#-'/&"!0.!"-#."-!(&(.,&(?

. "-# .!&0;!< !2"-.&"&#' -#.#.#8 "-# '!&$ #D/#%"!"&( &' 2(;!("#$ -#!%" .#,!&(' "-!" !>62,!.-!$ !00#( $;( ;-&0# ".!9#00&(?&("-#".!&(=#";##(,&(!($62.2+'-#".!(!($"-!"-#;!' .#,9#$" &9&0'/&"!0862.2+'-#".!;-#.#-#$&#$-#/'",."#, .#/."'-;'"-!""-#&(>2.&#'!.#$2#".#'20"!00.,"-#".!&(-# $&'%.#/!(%&#'/&("#$2"=<"-#.&=2(!0-!9#=##($&'%2''#$!($

77 $&'%!.$#$!=9# (9&#;"-#,!""#.8"-#&($&(?'"-#.&=2(!0( &''2#' "*!.#.#9#.'#$!($"-#'#'"!($$#%&$#$&(!92."-# !//#00!("'7!//#00!("' '!.#'20""-#.#?&(?$&'%2''&(8"-#&,/2?(#$>2$?,#(" $!"#$ ** &' '#" !'&$# !($ "-# %0!&, !//0&%!"&( &' !00;#$ #'/($#("' !.# .$#.#$ " /!< ' 88 7 %,/#('!"&( " "-# !//0&%!("'

!//#00!("';&"-&("#.#'" !""-#.!"#AE/#.!((2,.,"-# $!"#&0&(?"-#%0!&,!//0&%!"&(&#B "&00"-#$!"#!%"2!0 /!<,#("

* '>+' :-#"-#.'/#!+&(? .#!'(#$ ) #' :-#"-#.#/."!=0# ) #'