← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/9816/2016dismissed

Pankaj Kumar v. State Of Punjab Adn ANR

2022-05-30Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj19 pages



     



  



 

 

  

  !"#"

$  

 

 %  &' ( $ $( ) *****  

      !      



 #   ! $  % 



% #&   ' (!    '

 )%  *  ( + ,%  *  (!     

  -  *****  $( )(( ,   

   "( 

. "  /  /& (   0 " "   1//12 "

 3  4   -    5555 0

6 7 2 "(  

  - 

 "  8   ( / ! 59 0 " "   18/12 (  1:   ( :  3 % #& 1 (

 '  &&

   ;5 0

6 792<   " &      5;55 0

6 7=2  '((    7   5;559 0

6 72 



 /  -     55

 ((  

4  (      " &  *"(  "  "    (     "( "     

 " &    " >& #&     '  &    (  )&  3  

  & 0 ( "    >& #& 2  

   >& #& 7  '   '   

"    ? /      " &  '  "  



  3 % #&  0

7 2! '

   &       &  (  3 %  &   *   ! *     (     ' & )&  3  ( &     

  (( " &  "   (  &     '   &  " " ((   ( >

 "    '!

 (" "





    & 8 '   &    3 % #&  0

7 2   ( &   " >& #&  (

 '



 

      (   6 ' & ((  " &  

     & , "!  3 %   ' >& ("       ("

 '   &  ,   3 % #&     &      5      &  " &(   >& #&    " (( ( '    

  '        ""

 &   &!  '   (  (( &   3 % #&       "

   5 &    (" , 

 (

 '  && "  " &( '     (   ' >& #&  ' 

 ,(

  (( &    3 % #&  ' '   

 '   " ' "" >

   !      " >& #&  '      ((      ( *  '  ((  " &   ( 

       '     (  &   (( 

'  (((    3 % #&  '  

( "

   " >& #&  ( (!      @8 - 5   55 '     (

 

 ? *   

 8/  8  &   "      

"   !         

   =55 '

+ " "     >& #&    (    ( '( '   "  

'  (     

 "  '

 /

 '   " &   /   (   @ /( ! , ('

 

 '   "  

  (  ( "     " ""

      !    

 '     (   @ /( ! , ('

      55  & "  

7 )&  3  '  (   '  6  " 

'   

          &

" 

  " . 

  - 7 7 7( '

"    >& #&   "    &           



5555! ' '    & (   - 



"  8/ 8 7&&

  !     ' 6 & ! '

 

     & &  ! & ( 6 & 1      "    (  ( 6 & 

 ,

 A$ '  6 &   /B7 .     

"  @8  ' '

" >& #&  '  6 &   /B7  )  * #&  '  ( 6 &   /B79 "

 '

&  '  ( &   6 % ( 

"

'  &    



55 *!  " 7 7( '

"       /B7=

7

  -     /B7 >

 

"  (&   !  

 '  &&

  "   (     ;5    

6 79 ,   '   "  &&  /  

 "

  (

 " &    '        



5;55 0

6 7=2   "

& (   '  " &

, 5;55 0

6 72 ,    

   "(  ((        

 

   

'  ( "   

  - 7

  '(( , "  (  

   '  '

! !  '  

        

 &    (   

   &    ' 

. //  



( '  (( 

 

       

 (   C ( ""     (    "   <  ( ' 6 % ( 

"

"  

<  %

 

"   < 4  

 "  

  '((   & 

  !  ( 3 

  

"  &  (       " >& #&      '     (& " 

7 3 % #&    &( A !  

. //    & 9 D    (  

 ("

"  

       " &&

       &  ( &

  '  & 3  "    

      &    (  "   "  

 8  &    (( 

  4

    ( 6 &     (  "  

(

  

    >& #&      ( " (     ( '( '      ,   '    

  

      (    /  "  &  %

 8 '  &

   "  (( "

   " &   (!

   ! 

 // "

      A   "     " &   ( "  &&

!  

"

       

    &   

(



-        " >& #&   &  " " !  ( "   7 & &  ! & ( 6 & 1       "    (  ( 6 & 

((  (       

  '

 

( &  ( 

  

  - 7

  6 % ( 

"

((( &  "

 /B79*

#& ! '  &&  (!   6 % ( 

"

'  & 

55!  "   (   (  & 

 , '   "(

 

  

    &   6 % (

"

"

 /B79* #&   (( '  

   (   "( *!

  6 % ( 

"

   &  "

    ' 

55!  

 

'    "  ' 

  "

 

8/

55 

& '  &    

'  

 '       "

 

8/ ,

 "  

  -  ( 

   

"   

 (  

"  

  -     4!    ( "      &  

 = A   "     ( "  "

(( '   &   '    @8  ( 

   " >& #&     

7 3 % #&    '        ( /

 

5= // '  & "  

(

"    

 , (  6  "   &          

       

      

      



 

                              !   

           "#$  %  "&  '   # 

    &  "   

   

            

       '   

     

        & "(")$

    &*"'#"+       

       

      ,  

    

        &-         



     &  

   

   '-.  *"'    ""' &           & 

  

 '  "  &                               ,  & &   "    >& #&    5;5  '  "

(( '   % . 01!&

 

   . &

*

       2&    

3  / 

14 

&

  

   *

  &     &    

3  15  &   01⁄2 0  

3   & 614 

&

  1⁄2      6&     14 

&

    0

6 

3 .   

 714 

&

0 0 -       814 



09        :&   & ; ,   "  & ( 6 &    (    

. 

6 7; ' 

(  E;'

       

& <=<> 5 , A   (  (     (     

6 75    &  

  '

  '    

& ( 8 "     %  

 !

 "   %

     & & !

"   %   

 3 !

   ( 

"   !  '((     '!

   



 (" "

 &

 (   '

 

   ( "  

  '          

(     "   %    '        & ' ""

 " (            ( (     " ((  (  " , ' 

&  "

  3 % #&  0

7 2  (  &&

" 

""      >&   3 % ' 

 "  A ! 

 '  & 55 ,  

 !  ( "     '      ( ( "  

 

 6 7% ( 

"

( &     &    3 % #&  "

 /B79* #&      

 ((( '

  & &  &  ' " &( " # & D ( 0

 - 7

  7( ' "    >& #& 2     

 

     /  " /& (     /  F8:!

  & "

   !  &   3  C 

""  8          3  C !     (( '

     /  F:

    

 //! '       (  

    '    6  %

!   ((  

   "      4

  &("

     

 &    ( ""

5 " //  '   '      ' 

 (  

   &             "  4   (  

 

   (  

  !     4        "   4   (( "

     &  " &   (

"" 

     

 8  (   " &  ( "     " "     

"    '  &   

  @8   (      ,   &  

         "      @& !   (   

    9 "   !     '      

&

"  

 '  (       

    

55 ,   (

    "      

"    ,    & &       (( "

   " &   ( "" '

 

( 

""      !

'!   

 

&(  3  '  

  (   &(    ( 5 A ( (  (

 %& "  /     

 

           / 79 5 "  

55= ' 6 &    

 //  (

5 // , (  6       &     &

 & 

    %  



&    

-  .   ! " ,  * "

 ,    !"',   ?

1%

  #

  -  

  

     &  &  

   

      & 

 

   

        &  

 @

         5 @& !  /    &     



  !  / 795;

" 5 

. 59

   % #

   

   

        -  3     

      "   08  @'@  !            &     &

  

        22    ; 0 900

      

 "   09@'@  

     

  

#

 

 &    -    

       

&  &   

         &  %    ?!  '1                 

   

 &

        



          ?!   '1     0:0

 

       5. A   " (  (

 %& "  /   &  "

  

!" #$$%&'( &" ()*$ ' !  &&

          ' 

   

    ( , (  6  "    %&  ( 

  

     ( '

09           

&           

          



 $  

   0A 999?!  '2 0:1        #

   

  

     

  

         0A9A        -   

        (

        

  '        ?!  '2 1     

     

   (                         

   



   (                  

    &  

&

    #

   %         -                         

  #

 %



           "  '  ( ( 

 %& "  /    & 

+  

   #$''&#( &" (,,# , (     ( 

  

  6    C0                       

    -   #

 %      

     

/4     &    

        &             , ?1 6!



 & 



             :90 99A

& D  #

  @

 

 

 

 

  &- #

 

               

    "    @   '   @    ?01  @   '  @       

& > 59  " "  '  ( &    %&    & 

 - 



 #$'.&'( &" ('*)/ 



       ' 

. //     6     "    " ( ' )    

  (   & (           & 

  (( '   

  5= D    (  

 ("

" 

  -    '

      " &&

    (     8(( 4

  " 

  6 "       "! 

     " & , " & "  %

   "    ( ' (      '((   

 "  

   6 % ( 

"

&   & "

 /B79 * #&  & 3  ""           

 , &

" 

    (  

   

  - 7

"       8  (

       

( 

" &    /  " 

( 

   

&    '

( %" 4  "    &  " & 8  " &     



 '   & 

" 

 & &

"  

         

   

  - 7

"      

5; //    3     &  ( ( 

&     '  ( ' 5 D    ( "

 

  -    "     %&  ( 

   ( "

  

 

 ( (  "  "        &    (   @ /(    (

  &

  "  

 , "!      

    (   

    &&

"  

 8  &     

5

   // 4   '       ' 

 (     &            

   (     ( 

""  '  % &  "   4!     ((         (   (( "

     &  " &   (

"" 

     

 , 4&  "

  (( "   

5 // 

( '    

  

 

  '    

(    

(  " (     

"( 8  &        ! " (    "(   ( 

       (!  ' 

 

 

   &( '   

5 // 8          '  (

   

 4     &&

 "

        

 "

    ' 

     " 

     ( " 

! ' (     , "        

   " &&

!      &        ( 

     A "     

 '  &&

            ;5       (   "

   (   @ /(  , "!    '  &&     '  " &     

5;55  , 

"

  A /  '  "(   &

 59     "  &      ( /   %     

    "6 "

  /  '   

(   &

"  5 8 

     ((    " &&

    ! " (  &   .        !  ( (    

  &

     (



+   5; 8     (    ( "

       

    (    '((   &    (

 '    "(  %&  ( 

   ( "

  

  /  FF:

"  /  " /& (    ( '  

 

  "   

& " 

"      

      (  

    '   6  %

 "  4   &  &("

   

 &     ( ""    

  3 "   ' 

   ""    "

    ,     

" (   

 

  

 ((  &  '          ""  "   ( 6((   /  

 ,     " ((    

052 //   !  ' 

 

    

 

    ( ""   '  &  

   4     &(" ( (!   & "  '    &     

  /  FF:8 "  /  " /& (    ( '  && &    "

   

5  " 

&(     "

(( ' '         (       & ""  G    

5 //  (3 "      "

(( ' '    (   

!

'!  (   " 

'     &      3 '   &  

  "

        

   (     A !

   

&  (   '

"

   '

5 //    6

502 //  ( ' 

,    

'  

5= //    &     (

""     C

     3    ! 

   ((  4 

          "      '  

 (  

502 

&(   

'    

  3  C  ""

  (  ! 

  ((   '   4   (     '   

"  /  ,!

502 // '

(   (  ' '

(  &  ( (   "  "   8

  !   " 

 

@8  

 "(    ( "    

     %&  

  //

 . // 

&(  (    

 "  %&      (     :

(&  /  8   A "   %   A  (  ) ,

    

   

 " (( '  & %&  ( (!   

      

( 

&  " 

 8    / 

 

502 //    4   (

        /  8  (    " &   "     

   /  /& (    

 

&(   ((  "

   " &     )"" '

 

  (  

( , (   

  5 //     ( '

0 #$#1

 

0

 ?01!#

      

  

 

-  3 



 &   

   0A  

-         

    

    

              

     

 &  &    

-   &       

-           

      E  '

               

  &  22 ?1      #

          

  &  

  &    @  

F ?&1      &  &@ 

    

 ?

1 

&         99 ?

1    &2  ?01 #

  



-  - 

   

 E'

  

    #

       

 &  

& @"

     

 

      ? 1

   &2  ?01

 &       &                    

      &

@    2 2            

0   #'$  10     2  

-  -       0  0   0+

   0    0 ?01B      

     ?

        1 

    #

          &

 

 &   

 

      

 

  &. 2       &

 #

   

         

        

  ?

1 

 & 

      

  

 08     3   

- & #

     

 

    #

              



     &  

        ? 1         

    #

  -  3            

  

    &

  



 

@  5 ,  

   &      (   ( "

  

    /        (( "

   " &  8    )"" "

      A   (  !   &

' (   6 4

'    

 " &&

   ' 

   

    (   '(   &&

 8    " &  ( "  &&

   ;5 0

6 792   " "  '  &     "  

   " 

 (  

    (   

    "    "

       

7  )     "    

    (     " &&

!   & 

  



 "

 "       

 '  

     ( "  

   "     & '

(   

 " "(

 & "     ! '    &  ( 

  "        

 4&    ( '     " &&

 &  (

.

  "(

 &  & "      "

  / 

  &      "

  

 " &&

 

( 4&        "

 

 &&

 8    (   A

1( & /    &  " 31 1

"  4 

 5   ! 6

 /#$$$&#( ,#'

"    

 "    3  '( &&

 A '!  &  " 4&      3   

  (  /  " & 6 &  6 "    %" &&

 8   (!  "     &    (  

  

 

     !   & '

(  

 &   "   !

'!   &  ("

 "

& %" 

 %       ( 8  '((

'

      " 

 

" 

  (( '

 

  

!    ((

 & 6 & 

       (( "    A !     

'  %     ( & &  

 8  "

     

   

"     

         &   " 

    

 

(

 &

        &    ( 

  "        8 '

( '   &  

 /   6 &   

   '(   &&

   

  "   (  , "  "       '        



(     "

& 6 % ( 

"

( &     &    

7  &   (     "

 (&  &  '  

  - 7

     " &&

! 

   /  '((

 (

3       ( "    (   '

(

'

((     &  (       " ("  6 "       "  ""  ""    

       ( "  

   "  &  (  . ,  " &&

 &( "(     '      & (   (

 '

( 4  & "(

 &  (  3

 

 /  '(  



'!   & '

(

  (( (   '

(       

&

.95 // ,  &

( (   %  &( (    &    

 

   

 8    %&  ( 

  (    ( "

  

!  ' 

"  

    !  ( ' "!  &   '      &  '  &    /     "  A '!

 "  "       "(       C "  &

"  

     "

    "

      " &&

   

 !   

 "   ' ' 

/ !   & (   ( 

   "  

      ((   " &&

  " (!  

    &&

 

   ;5   

 "     ((       , "!        

 '  " &

5;55  ,   

    ((    " &&

 '   " "(

 59 8   (!  "( "    

 ( (      "  C "  ""      3   / 

  



 "      !      " & ,   " & "   

  &  (  "

 

  

 

&    (  " &&

 A         

  & &("     " ( ' "

  ( "

  !  



'     

  &     ((    &&

 "  (  8  (              

      /   "( "  

   59   ' 

(     5     ( /  '    %     

    "6 ,!   (   (   &&    !  '

(     7      " %      &&

    /   

       "

  (( '  / 

3  /  

   ( 6 &       "

 6 "     "

 " & "  

 8/     &&   ( ,   '

(

      ( "     "

  /     &  "

   ( /   6 &  '

"   !     

 &   (   $( )      /0+1 ""

?

1   - (    E (;  &  E (;