Ram Rattan v. Guru Nanak Dev University, Amritsar
!"#"$% &
'% ()'*+
!
" !
+,-).
!
$
%&"'(()# $
*
+, *+-.
!
/
.
"
! !
0
"
# 1 !+ /
,+-2 .
+ #
. ! 0"
! . '(+!
. '((3 / 0+4
!
0#
6
.
0
*
+, *+-# 6
4
.
0
""
"
# /
, -
7!!
"
'
, -#
"" .
+78 .
!+7." 0
5
. 7 , - !
4
!
. "
+ !:(" 4
%:;
# .
.
! " "
!!
4 . 0 "
"
6
." 3<':(=5 .
. 4
4
!
4
.
.
"
9 4
0
>
' "
.
0'(()# @?
7!!
4
4
'(() .
"
" 4"
""
@?
7!!
7 , -!
4" !
0 0
4 ! 0 .
!" A "
!"!
00 "
! B6
! 1
" 0
+ :(" " 0.
14.
.
"4"
C
* ""
"
.
% & '((
/" .
: . "
D(%:3=5
4 !
"
%
% 64
* 4. !*C D(:D !'(() 0!
" #
. 4 /
)
4
'(()
0
': 0'(()4
.
5 "
!*7* '''' !'(()# *
: & '(: .
"!
.
* .
.!
* ""
@?
7!!
'((E,4
-.
. 4
.
7!!
0'(()!
D
""
"
0!
"
0"
%E
.
" .
"
0
* " !
" * "
"
0"
%%, - .
4 .
" ,-,4-
,-
!.
"
F.
"
F
!
.
! "
4 0"
# 0"
.
""4 0 " "
"
4
?
! 0
4
C 0 4
" 0"
%%, -
4 9
"
.
0 .
8 .
.
"
!
0"
D
"
# ! .
"
!!
!
0!
"
6 " !""
"
, -, -,!-G,0-
4
!
.
""4 .
"
4"
"!7" 0"
: 4
*
0 94G
'(','- &)<
!"" .
!
A
B ".A
B !
# " 4
"
"
'',4- 94 * "
"
" 66 "
0
#
!
""
"" "
? .
* H".
0 ""
! 94)) ** ,-:(D )),'- *#%(4.
! 0" "
"4 "4
"
4 < 6 0 0
44
"
"
% + '(() .
4
4 4
0 6!
'((:!
#
"
0 4
0
1 !6 "
0 1
.
0
"
/
"" ""
! "
4 4
"
:
!!
" "
# 4
I>#
!
" #$ %& &%%'
( )
#*+%, &- %& &%%' . / 01 " 12 3) 141 2 0 5" 0 *% %% . 102
.
. . 102 02 0 )
#%%6#-*&'$# #$ %& &%%' *% %% . 02 0 " 1 2 2 1 ""
1 2
41 2 7 .1 1 " 1 02 " 0)
86*8&+&% %6 &%%$ . 02
1.
1 2 41 2 41 2 " "2 .
2&%%+ 41 2
2 / 21 ""
1
<
41 22" 0 "" . #% 2 "
12
. 2 0 "9
-# %# &%%+ 0 1 :8 #*;" .
< 2 ,9 = 3 6! + !:(" .
6 0
!
" 6! !
? "
0
# .
. !
'(( 4
"
0 ! .
.
.
!
.
0 '( "
.!
.
1 !6 .
0 +
" " .
.
"""
9
. " 4
"
0 !9
.
"
9 # 4
4"
4 4
.
4"
44
+
1. ! ""
!
1 .
. " !!
" 6
.
" !""
!!
6
"
/
3
"
4
" " 0 0"
.
E 6
. 4
!
I>6.
"""
.
! .
!" . 0
!
! 0 "
% + '(() .
!
"
4 4 0 "" 4
.
D:!
6! 4"
"
.
""
!';
!
"" /+0 & "