Umed Singh And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others
! "#$# %&'
('
)& *)'++)++ *)'+,-++
!"#$
% &'(" ")&"
%$
% & "(*$
% &$+ " $
$ ) + , - !(($
% &+ (!" .$
% &+ / "(0" $
% &'(" (!"!$
% & 10""$
% &+ 2 33333 +)++ .'/ 0 , "4 $"&".( (!. ,567565/ 8)" .$8) '"(&"$"'((( +( 8)"&".(."(( +:
* ,5!;'"(&" "8 (%( 8'"$ / 2$"8 (!( 5 <+ (. +"$ ( !) 8 " '"( (( (." !(.:* ,5!$" +7 * ,2!' 8. (+% / !((. !(.7*,2! +" '
=5> 8 (%( ?)8'" 2
@&(( 8'+(%& " "( "8
(%( 8) " "
(($ " ( + '"(&" ( 8(. (&
"(+ 7 "(
& "(8+ $" " (& A&"* B!(.7*,2!"8.(%
/ !((. + +(. <0 !(.7*,2!"8?) (%( 8'" !82$*(.(%('"(&(%"(" ) -
"&(! +"'" 2("
(.(( ? ")"
"%8.(%"
+(. A&"* B /"
"%8.(%"
=7> "&"*A<0B<+ (.+"$(!)8 " "A&"*B 8 . /$ '"(&""8&" + ! (*! / 1(.(%('"8 %+& (( $"(8(.(
8)8+ "(0 ("(8(. &( 2 <+ ++&(. " (( (.$ " ( (& "(? 676/565- "(!+ "( '(& ("& +"& "
+(&(."!$ '8!( 8) 676/565-$& ) +'"(&""8 @ ,/ '(""'((( $ "!(%(8.5,: +"8
*
+ " (&( $ +( (. ' & ' 8) " ( "" "&"*A<0B((" +" 2$ " "&"*'( " / "8( +"(
676/565-$"(( (.'&& (.)+(( $" ( + '"(&""% )8.(%"(8+ :
".(%&'( 8)?"( (( + 8+ ""
(($'"(&"&".'#& $ "(( ?( '+(( 8)" 8)&"(. " &(( " &"* 8.(%
/$ +(. &"* <0 8 .(% " 2(?" ' 8)"! C (...(% .("( (( (.?
(?( $'((( '+( $8(.0D 2,26 +565/8)" $'"(&"&! 8 (!( ,567565/ " (.
=-> 9 .& "+( (.'"((." ""$ '"
'"(( 8+ " .$")' " '"(&"(8(."( (."') + .(% "! (( ( 8(. " (
(."');".!( ""( "8 (8 $ ( % $*(.(%('" +" $ 676/565-""& ( +E(( "" '"(&""8.(% /(!
%8$+( (.?( &"8.(%8)" . "( &(!" 8 % &()'" " '"(&""8(( $(( A*(B$ "&(!""'
+(.'("("!*("%(. (++%$& 8&& F (...(% .("( # .! +" (. 9 . ,567565/$""8+ ,6
" ( 0 (. 8"+ +" .""8( +"(( (" +"
$ 676/565-= @ ,/>8"! '%! %(8 "!$'"(&"(&(.# (&G"(
.!$(!)8 ""( (
!*!&" +
(++&+ " "" ( +" $ '"
" ("(&( &( "($ "(!+%(( "
* "& '"(&"' 8(( $
*(.(%('"+&'"(&"&! "(* ' .$"
.""&
"!("( 676/565-$8"'% "'(+
&" &(( "8( +"+&'"(&"&! "* ' .
=/>
(."( (&( &$ (." (&( $&(+&"% 8 8)"(!"
("& +"*"
$'"(&"
+&"% 8 % 8(& &8)"$!)"" + ! 8) ' .(% $'( !*!&" + (++&%(+"( ( ( 8(% + (.(%8)"
() """ '"(&"(
&( ?(( $( 8.(% "& & ( '"! ( 8#&( ( +( ""8 " ( 8'""
()'"(&"( &( ?"(( "(!+ %(( " ?( 8 "%+& ++&8((
$ +("(. +&" '( &# (&" ( % 8(& & &$ &" "(!+%(( " ?( 8 "+& +"*"
$ "''("(#( (&( &( %'("
$.(%& ( 8)"8 +("(. +" (&( $
"
'("
%(."( (& &$ # (&(&
( "(( (. ,5 "$".!'"(&""8( 8)"
( 0 + "("&)$"( +&'"(&""
' "" "&"*A<0B'( +" $'""( +&"8! "8( +"((
"( &"*"8& ?).(% " 2!)8 " &$(" (&( $*(.(%('" &(+&$ "( +( (."8.(%8)" "!"8" 8)"'
%"
((' 8)" .$"( +&& 8 ( ("4
=2>
$ ( "(( (.$ "( &"0 &" (++& &( """ (% 8)" . %"
(( ,7 %(+((! + "* +.!$" +(.
"&"*A<0B' (" +"8 "(."& ! & "
'"" &"* ' (" +" &(! (8(. +"
+"""! /" /'( +&"* " 8 (
. 8)" ("8+ "%"
(( %8+ "(0 ('(((
%(" "( +&"8& +(! 8)" ( +&%(( " &$"!
+(( '"(&""8
8)" $*(.(%('
" '"( +" 8) (++& "" +& ( (&( $"!"88(+& ("8 (8')%(8 .(%%)& "" 8(." ( (."') ,- "$+ !"('"(&""8
& (" ." 5 +"(# .!$ /( " '
+(. &"*&$".! +"(&& " " .'(" 2"
8.(%" +(.
&"* /"
8.(%" &"*<0$" /'("% && " +(.
&"* "( +&& 88 8)" ( (. 8"+ +" &$"( +& " 8*(!( 8)"
((& & " /" "%
=:> &&(8(() "( +(.(&"*$'"(&"( ' 8) / ,/
" ".!'"(&""8( 8)"
( 0 + " ( " " + .(%
/(!
%8 "
."$"!" )8 "(8+ $8 &+( (."8.(%"" &"*
8#& (( (("" +&. (!*(!8$ ( &.(8(.""(."')$ "(."& ! &
"
'" + $" .(% 2 ( +%""% +" .(% / &()'""& ""%8.(%" 8(. ( (."')$'"(&"'" & ( ( 8)" 8+ %"
((+".! +"(&& ? "% +" $"'"" (' 8'"($! .(%&'(8( 8) /"&$"( & ( & 8&& ,2
".!( 8)" ( 0 + " (" /%( .!""((" +&"* '"(&""8.(% "(!!)8 " " +" $" " &"*<0'( +"' 2 "! /( & "( ++&
!("88 ." & "
'"" H&"*
I'%(" +").(% ( +(! (
."( ! /" ( &"* ("( $'"(&"!"8&& 8)%
=C> "
()'8) . ,: "$" "8(( *(.(%('" " &(&!&'$&""" /"
"%&&
" "H&"*I'"(&"( ' 8)"(!$'"(&"'(8 (! (8(&".! +"(&& ,C "$ @ ,6$"!.(%8) ! (."'"""
8.(% 8(."( (."') '"(&"?"8&& .(% "(!"("( 8(.( "(."')'"(&"+& & & "$ /'"( (."!8+ %"
(($" " + " +(. ' " " + " 8(.
5E,E,= @ F>('(""!$'"(&"+&".
8
(& ("& (. ,F 1(. '("" () +" &(&!&$ " 8)""
(('8)" .".
8 "!" 8 % 8%(" "+&
'$ . (! + )(+&8)"(0 56
(.(&( =>$(+)$ ( + /+)++0 /,-++0 + 1 .
D""*(.E
D"" 8