High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/22943/2025dismissed

Raj Kumar Garg v. State Of Haryana And Another

2026-04-20Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel14 pages

;

::::"!0!0#&"

) ) %& &' &#!("

!!" #$ % ::::").#&'"&!) ) ")"

*"' #&+ ")"

*"' #&+ !" #$ !" #$ !" #$ !" #$ #& #& #& #& !" #$ ./# !" #$ ./# !" #$ ./# !" #$ ./# + + + + ")"&!

")"&!

")"&!+ + .

0/ .

0/ ;

&# &,"

"&!- &,"

"&!- &# &,"

"&!- &,"

"&!-",0)0#&+ ",0)0#&+ ",0)0#&+ ",0)0#&+ .

0/ .

0/ #'0&+ #'0&+ #'0&+ #'0&+ .

0/ .

0/ ;<3 4< ;<3 4< ;<3 4< ;<3 4< 4 4 4 43 4< 3 4< 3 4< 3 4< 4 4 4 43 4< 3 4< 3 4< 3 4<

61 :

1 1 1 1 : '@ '

)!0&" "# "3 : ( =( /023 '*#,!" $ '*#,!" &'

$# !(" ."!0!0#&"

): 0%&2 ' 3 "&0# $#

#:; A !!":

%& : ( "% #"/3 '*#,!" $#

#::

BBBBB BBBBB BBBBB BBBBB 1 1 1 13 :

3 :

")"&! ."!0!0#& () =""& $0/"

",!0#& ?D #$ !("

( !0%

2)( &(0!3 4 8("

"0&$!"

"$"

"' !# ) ) 5 67 /% %0& ,(//"&" !# !(" 0

&"' # '!"' :4:4?

8&&"9

" ?7 .))"' =% /" &"' ''0!0#& &/ "))0#&) '"3

2)("!

8("

"0&$!"

"$"

"' !# ) 5 "))0#&) '"

673 @("

"=% 0&/ "*0)0#& &

#:;;< #$ 4 4 $0/"' =% #:3 0&)! !(" # '!"' 4C:;;:4 .))"' =% !(" /" &"'

= 0*0)0#&/ 0)!

!"3 (&") 3 0)!

0,!

2)("!

8("

"0&$!"

"$"

"' !# ) 5 67 @(0,( ")!

0,!"' =#!( !("

. !0") !# 0&!

" 0& !(" )(#. 0& > ")!0#& &' ..#0&!"' ","0*"

!# !2"

.#))"))0#& #$ !(" )(#. 0& > ")!0#&3 @) //#@"' @(0/" )"!!0& )0'" !(" #

'!"' 4C:;;:4 0=0':

(" ,)" 0& (&' =" ) ,("> "' (0)!# %3 '""./% "&!

"&,("'

/ &0 #)0!% ="!@""& !(" . !0")3 @(0,( .." ) !# (*" .

#."//"'

0&!# "&0& 0& '0,0/ '*"&!

0) 3 !("

"=% "'

,0& !(" )&,!0!% #$ !(" #

! !# !(! #$ =!!/"

&'3 '

0*"& .

0/% =% '")0 " !# *0&'0,!"

)#&/ "#):

,( =,2'

#. ))

") "!"

)0&0$0,&," @(0/"

",0!0& !(" $,!

/ ,#&).",!

) &' 0& ))"))0& @("!("

!(" , 0&/

,(0&"

% () =""& )"! 0&!# #!0#& =#& $0'" #

"/% ) )!

!# )"!!/" .

0*!" *"&'"!!) 0)" #$ /"/ '0),#

)":

,,0&,!/% !(" '0).

!" ="!@""& !(" . !0") "/!") !# #&" (#.

#:3 % 2"!3 0/@% #'3

2)("!

3 %& 8("

"0&$!"

"$"

"' !# ) 50).

!"' !%67:

(" ."!0!0#&"

0) .

")0'"&!

#$ . 0!03 % !0&0'(0 =( %&3 @(# 0) !(" /&'/# ' #$ !("

)0' )(#. &' !("

#: 0) !"&&! !("

"0&: "&! ."!0!0#& =" 0& "&! "!0!0#& #:; #$ 443 ",!0#& ; #$ !("

%& "&! #&!

#/ "

/!0#& &' *0,!0#& ,!3 ;C @) $0/"' =% !(" ."!0!0#&" 3 )""20& "*0,!0#& #$ #:3 $ !(" =#*" "&!0#&"' )(#.:

(" )0' "&!

"!0!0#& @) '0) 0))"' ) @0!('

@&3 0& *0"@ #$ !(" ,# 0)" ="!@""& !(" . !0")3 ="$# " " 1#2 '/!3

2)("!

3 #& 4:;:44D:

(" % !0&0'(0 =( %&3 !( ( ."!0!0#&"

) 0!) !(# 0)"'

")"&!!0*"3 $0/"' ,0*0/ ) 0!3 ",!0#&) C E D #$ !("

.",0$0, "/0"$ ,!3 0&)!

#:3 0& !(" #

! #$ ''0!0#&/ 0*0/ '" 8 "&0# 0*0)0#&73

2)("!

8("

"0&$!"

"$"

"' !# ) 50*0/ '"673 =" 0& 0*0/ 0!

#:;;-4: F0'" # '!"' 4;:4:4 !("

/" &"' 0*0/ '"3 .))"' & 0&!"

0& &,!0#& # 0&)!

#:3 ")!

0&0& (0 $ $

#/0)(0&- ' 0& !(" ) 0! .

!%3 ,

%0& # ! &% ,#&)!

,!0#& ,!0*0!% &' ,(&0& !(" &!

" #$ !(" )(#. 0& > ")!0#& 80).

!"' !%7:

(" )0' 0*0/ 0! @) $0&//% '0).#)"' #$ =% !(" /" &"' 0*0/ '"3 *0'" '

"&! '!"' ;:;;:43 0& *0"@ #$ !("

)!!"

"&!

'" =% #: !(! (" @0// !2" ,"

!0& &",")) % ,#&)!

,!0#& @#

2) ! !(" 0).

!"' !%3 @0!( !(" .

0# ."

0))0#& #$ "0!("

!(" "&! #&!

#//"

!(" /&'/# ' #&/%:

& !(" 0&!"

3 '

0& ."&'"&,% #$ =#*")0' 0*0/ 0!3 #& !(" ) " '%3 @("& !(" 0&!"

0& &,!0#& # @) .))"' =% !(" 0*0/ '"3 0& =#*" "&!0#&"'

0!3 0:":3 4:4:43 '0).

"/!"' @0!( " '

!# ,#&)!

,!0#& ,!0*0!% !2"& =% #: ! !(" '0).

!"'

!%3 ") /!"' 0&!# /#'0& #$ , 0&/ ,)"3 *0'" #:?C3 '!"'

4:4:4 ",!0#&) 3 C3 ?4< #$ : "

!0&"&!/%3 !(! !(" )0'

@) /#'"' ! 0&)!&," #$ #&" ( =( ,/0 0& (0 )"/$ !# =" !(" , " !2"

#$ 0).

!"' !% (*0& =""& ..#0&!"' =% !(" % !0&0'(0 =( %&3 0&)!

#::

(" ,)" 0) )!!"' !# ="

."&'0& ' '0,!0#& 0& !(" #

! #$ '0,0/ 0)!

!"3 )! /))3

2)("!

3 @("

"0& ,( ") (*" =""& $ "' 0&)!

#:3 #& 4:4:4?:

$!"

!(" 0&,0'"&! #$ 4:4:43 '0).

!" 0& = #2"

="!@""& !(" . !0") > !(" 0).

!"' !% #& 4C:4:43 &' 0& .#/0," ,# ./0&! @) /#'"' =% !(" ."!0!0#&"

(" #/0," !(0) !0 "3 0&0!0!"'

#,""'0&) )",!0#& ;? :::3 > !(" 0).

!"' !% =% $0/0& # ./0&! 8/&'

7 ="$# " !("

= 0*0)0#&/ 0)!

!"3 (&") 3 @0!( "> ")! !# ..#0&!

","0*"

)",!0#& ;< #$ !(" ::: > !("

0).

!"' !%:

& 4:;4:43 #: $0/"' 0*0/ 0! 0&)! !("

!!" #$ %& &' )# " .#/0," #$$0,"

)3 ,/0 0& ' ") &' ."

."!

/ 0& &,!0#&3 &'

")!

0&0& !(" '"$"&'&!) !("

"0& $ 0&!"

0& @0!( (0)

0(! !# "&#% "&! #$ !(" 0).

!"' !%:

& !(0) 0*0/ 0! =" 0&

#: ;? #$ 43 *0'" # '!"' 4D:;:4 .))"' =% !(" /" &"'

''0!0#&/ 0*0/ '" 8 "&0# 0*0)0#&73

2)("!

3 '",0'0& !("

../0,!0#& /") ; &' #$ 3 !(" '"$"&'&!) 8!("

"0&7 @"

")!

0&"' $ 0&!"

0& 0&!# !("

0(!) #$ #: > !("

0).

!"' !%:

")0'") !(" =#*" "&!0#&"' /0!0!0#&) ="!@""& !(" . !0")3 !("

' #$ !(" ,)"

"*"/) !(! %"! &#!("

"&! "!0!0#& =" 0& #:? #$ 4 $0/"' =% "!0!0#&"

0&)! !("

#:3 )""20& (0) "",!

"&!

$ 0).

!"' !%3 #& &') #$ &#&.% "&! #$ "&!3 ."

)#&/ &","))0!%3 & !(# 0)"'

)" &' #,, .!0#&3 0) /)# #0& #& ="!@""& !("

. !0"):

# 0& =,2 !# !(" $,!) #$ !(" 0&)!&! 0&/ 0),"// "# ) "!0!0#&3 !(" ) " () 0!) "&")0) 0& !(" # ./0&! 8/&'

7 $0/"' =% !("

.#/0," '!"' 4C:4:43 > !(" 0).

!"' !%:

= 0*0)0#&/ 0)!

!"3 (&") 3 0)!

0,!

2)("!

3 *0'" (0) # '!"' 4C:;;:43 $0&//% '",0'"' !("

!!"

3 @(0/" ..#0&!0& !(" 9", !0*" $$0,"

0)('3 (&") 3 ) ","0*"

#$ !(" 0).

!"' !%:

(0) .

.!"'

#: !# $0/" 0&/ "*0)0#& "!0!0#& ="$# " !(" ''0!0#&/ "))0#&) '"3

2)("!

=" 0& 0&/ "*0)0#& #:;;< #$ 43 @(0,( @) //#@"' #& :4:4?: 0"*"' #$ !(" '

"&! .))"' =% ''0!0#&/ "))0#&) '" '!"' :4:4?3 !(" .

")"&! 0&/

0),"//&"# ) "!0!0#& )""20& > )(0& #$ !(" )0' '

"&! 0) $0/"' ="$# !(0) #

& ="(/$ #$ !(" !!" #$ %&3 ="0& #:;3 )". !"

"./% =% @% #$ & $$0'*0! '!"' ?:4D:4? () =""& $0/"' 0& !("

!!"

: ! 0& !(" )0'

"./% 0! 0) )0 ./% "&!0#&"' !(! !(" ,#&!"&!) #$ "!0!0#& &""' &# "./% #& ="(/$ #$ !(" !!" &' 0& !(0) &&"

!(" !!" () &#! .

! &% )"

0# ) ")0)!&," !# !(" ."!0!0#&:

:;:

#@"*"

3 #& ="(/$ #$ #: )". !" G 0!!"& !!"

"&! '!"' ;:4D:4? () =""& $0/"' @("

"0& // !(" ,#&!"&!) #$ !("

0&/ 0),"//&"# ) "!0!0#& (*" =""& "$ !"' &' 0! 0) *"

"' !(! !("

.))"' =% !(" ''0!0#&/ "))0#&) '"3 0) "&!0!/"' !# ="

0&!0&"'

.("/' ="0& @"// ")#&"' '

"&!:

& ="(/$ #$ !(" ."!0!0#&"

3 0& !&'"

@0!( !(" ./"'0& 0& !("

0&/ 0),"//&"# ) "!0!0#&3 0! () =""&

"' !(! ) ."

#*0)0#&) #$ ",!0#&) ;? &' ;< #$ !(" : :: @("&"*"

3 & 9", !0*"

0)!

!" 0) )!0)$0"' $ ".# ! #$ .#/0," #$$0,"

.#& #!("

0&$#

!0#& !(! '0).

!"3 /02"/% !# , )" = ",( #$ !(" .","3 "90)!) ,#&,"

&0& &% /&' &' ,#&)0'"

) !(" ,)" !# =" #&" #$ "

"&,%3 @0!(0&

(0) /#,/

0)'0,!0#&3 !("& (" )(// 2" & # 3 0& @ 0!0&3 &' (" ,& !!,( !(" ) =",! #$ '0).

&!0/ ,# ."!"&! ,#

! () '"!"

0&"' !("

0(!) #$ !(" . !0") !("

"!# @0!( " ' !# !(" ."

)#& "&!0!/"' !# !("

.#))"))0#& !("

"#$:

! 0)

"' $

!(! ) ."

!(" /&'

$0/"' =% !("

.#/0,"3 .. "&!/% !("

" @) = ",( #$ ."," ="!@""& !(" . !0") ,#&,"

&0& !(" 0).

!"' !%3 &' ("&,"3 ) ) ,( !(" /" &"' () 0(!/% "9"

,0)"' (0) .#@"

) ",!0#&) ;? &' ;< #$ : ::

! 0)

!(! 0& !(" 0*0/ 0! '",0'"' ="!@""& !(" . !0")3 ="$# " !(" " 1#2

< '/!3 #: *" )!!"

"&! !(! (" @0// '")0)! $

0)0& &% ,#&)!

,!0#& ! !(" 0).

!"' !% @0!(# ! )""20& ."

0))0#& $ "&!

#&!

#//"

3 = ! (" $0/"' !# '("

" !# (0) !20&:

! 0)

"' !(!

#: 0) / "'% $,0& , 0&/ .

#,""'0&) 0& #:?C '!"'

4:4:43 /#'"' 0&)! (0 0& ,#&&",!0#& @0!( !(" #$$"&,") ,#

0!!"'

=% (0 @0!( ").",! !# ,#&)!

,!0#& ! !(" 0).

!"' !%:

! 0)

!(! @("& "*"& $!"

/#'0& #$ !(" 3 #:3 ."

."!

!"' (0) 0//"/ ,!) ,#&,"

&0& !(" 0).

!"' !%3 !(" .#/0," @) /"$! @0!( &# #!("

/!"

&!0*" = ! !# 0&0!0!" .

#,""'0&) ",!0#&) ;? &' ;< #$ : ::

! 0) ) = 0!!"' !(! "))0#&) '" () @ #&/% 0&!"

"' @0!( !("

@"// ")#&"' # .))"' =% !(" /" &"' 3 @(0,( 0) &#! ) )!0&=/" 0& /@: ) ) ,( > )(0& #$ !(" 0 &"' '

"&! '!"' :4:4? .))"'

=% !(" "))0#&) '" 0) .

%"' #& ="(/$ #$ !(" ."!0!0#&"

# !(" ,#&!

%3 #& ="(/$ #$ #:3 0! 0)

"' !(!

#,""'0&) ,#&'

,!"' =% !(" /" &"' " *0!0!"' =% .

#,"'

/ 0//"/0!0"):

! 0) ) = 0!!"' !(! !(" /" &"' '",0'"' !("

!!"

@0!(# !

'0& &% "*0'"&,"3 &' @0!(# ! .

#*0'0& .

#..# !

&0!% #$ (" 0& !# !(" . !0"):

! 0)

"' !(! !(" /" &"' () "9,""'"'

0)'0,!0#& @(0/" .))0& !(" # '!"' 4C:;;:43 &' !(" /" &"' # (! &#! !# (*" 0&!"

"' 0& !("

!!"

) !(" '0).

!" ."

!0&"' !# !("

0)'0,!0#& #$ !("

0*0/ #

! # !(" "&! #&!

#//"

! 0)

"' !(! !(" 0).

!"' !%3 '

0!!"'/%3 ="0& 0& .#))"))0#& #$ #: ) !"&&!3 !("

" "90)!"'

&# '0).

!" ,#&,"

&0& 0!) .#))"))0#&: ").#&'"&!

#: ="0& 0& .

/@$ / .#))"))0#& #$ !(" )(#. 0& '0).

!"3 !(" /" &"' (' &# #,,)0#& !# 0&0!0!" .

#,""'0&) ",!0#& ;< #$ !(" : :: &' !# ..#0&! !("

","0*"

! 0) ) = 0!!"' !(! !("

#: 0) !"&&! 0& !(" '0).

!"'

)(#. )0&," /)!

" !(& %" )3 &' 0) / /% .%0& "&!3 @(0,( @) "&(&,"' #*"

!(" !0 ": & !(" )!

"&!( #$ !(")" ) = 0))0#&)3 '0) 0))/ #$ !(" ."!0!0#& 0& (&' 0) "&!

"!"' $# :

(*" (" ' !(" /" &"' ,# &)"/ $# !(" . !0") &' ."

)"' !("

,)"

' , "$ //%:

,!) #$ !(" ,)"3 ,#&)0)!0& #$ )"

0") #$ /0!0!0#& #0& #& ="!@""& !(" . !0") ,#&,"

&0& !(" 0).

!"' !%3 2" 0! ./% ,/"

!(! !("

"/ '0).

!" "90)!0& ="!@""& !(" . !0") > !(" 0).

!"' !% $/#@) $ !(" !"&&,% 0(!):

(" 1&'/# '3 !( ( ."!0!0#&"

3 .

0# !# !("

$0/0& #$ /&'

=% !(" .#/0,"3 (' / "'% $0/"' 0*0/ 0! '!"'

4:4:43 0&)!

#: 0& !(" ,#

! #$ /" &"' ''0!0#&/ 0*0/ '" 8 "&0# 0*0)0#&73

2)("!

3 =" 0& 0*0/ 0!

#:;;-4:

& !(! ) 0!3 *0'" # '!"' 4:4:4 !(" 0*0/ '"3 (' / "'% .))"' & 0&!"

0& &,!0#& # 0&)!

#:3 ")!

0&0& (0 $

#/0)(0&- ' 0& !(" ) 0! .

!%3 ,

%0& # ! &% ,#&)!

,!0#& ,!0*0!% &' ,(&0& !(" &!

" #$ !(" )(#. 0& > ")!0#& ! !("

0).

!"' !%:

& !(")" ,0 ,

)!&,")3 0$ #: ('

0)"' !("

,#&)!

,!0#& 0& *0#/!0#& #$ !(" 0*0/ '" # 3 !(" .

"'% @0!( !("

."!0!0#&"

@) !# ..

#,( !(" )0' 0*0/ #

!3 0& ,,# '&," @0!( /@3 ) () =""& 0(!/% ("/' =% !(" "))0#&) '": ! !(" /&'/# ' 0& (0) @0)'#

,(#)" !# "&!"

!(" 0).

!"' !% !# )!#.

#: $

0)0& ,#&)!

,!0#&3 '").0!" !(" 0& &,!0#& # 0& $*#

#$ !(" /&'/# ':

(" )0'

)0!

!0#& ") /!"' 0& /#'0& #$ ,)" =% !(" .#/0," 0&)!

#::

(" @) /#'"' #& 4:4:4: !0// !(" /&'/# '."!0!0#&"

*0)0!"' !(" 0).

!"' !% #& 4C:4:43 '" $ ")( .#/0," ,# ./0&!3

") /!0& 0& $0/0& #$ /&'

=% !(" .#/0,": // !(0) () (.."&"' @("&

" /0"

!(" /&'/# '."!0!0#&"

(' )# (! "*0,!0#& #$ #: $

!(" 0).

!"' !% =% $0/0& *0,!0#& "!0!0#& ="$# " !(" "&! #&!

#//"

@(0,( ") /!"' 0& '0) 0))/3 !(# ( #& !(" =)0) #$ ,# 0)":

)"> "&," #$ "*"&!) 0*") 0)" !# !(" 0&$"

"&," =# ! !(" 2""&&")) #$ !("

/&'/# '."!0!0#&"

!# # )!

#: $ !(" 0).

!"' !%:

! '"$0") /#0, &' '#") &#! ,#

&' ,,".!&," !(! !("

.#/0,"3 #& 4:4:4 (*0& )"! !(" , 0&/ /@ 0&!# #!0#& =% "0)!"

0& & 0&)! !("

#: 0& !(" =,2'

#. #$ !(" *"

% ) " '0).

@) #$ ) ,( &!

" ) !# =" /02"/% !# #,,)0#& = ",( #$ .","3 @

&!0&

)" !# .

"*"&!0*" .

#,""'0&):

,( & =

.! *#/!"$," #& !(" . ! #$ !(" .#/0," !(# 0!0")3 0& !(" =)"&," #$ &% '0),"

&0=/" ,(&" 0& ,0 ,

)!&,") # "&," #$ $ ")( !"

0/ ,)!) )"

0# ) '# =! #& !("

=#& $0'") #$ !(" ,!0#& ) =)"> "&!/% !2"&:

(" )"> "&," #$ "*"&!)3 @("& *0"@"' (#/0)!0,//%3 .

$,0"3 ) ")!) /,2 #$ '

" ../0,!0#& #$ 0&'

&' ="!

%) =0!

% "9"

,0)" #$ .#@"

!("

!(& ,#&)0'"

"' &'

#=",!0*" )!0)$,!0#& ) 0) &'!# 0/% "> "'

!(" /@:

(")" $,!) (#/' // !("

" )0&0$0,&," 0& *0"@ #$ !(" 0*0/ 0! ;? #$ 43 $0/"'

=% #:3 @("

"=% !(" .#/0," #$$0,"

) @"

")!

0&"' $

0&!"

0& 0&!# !(" !"&&!"' .

0)") #$ #:3 !0// !(" '",0)0#& #$ !(! ) 0!:

& !(0) =,2'

#.3 !(" 0&0!0!0#& #$ .

#,""'0&) ",!0#& ;?

::: .." ) &#! #&/% "9,"))0*" = ! /)# /"//% &!"&=/":

! 0) !

0!" !(!

!("

0)'0,!0#& ",!0#& ;? ::: 0) "))"&!0//% .

"*"&!0*" 0& &!

"3 !# =" 0&*#2"' ). 0&/% &' #&/% .#& "& 0&" &' 0

0&"&! ..

"("&)0#& #$ = ",( #$ .","3 $# &'"' #& #=",!0*"

0/:

(" .

#*0)0#& ,&&#! ="

0!!"' !# =" "

./#%"' ) . //"/ ",(&0) !# "0!("

,0 ,

*"&! #

'0/ !" !(" "$$",! #$ # ) .))"' =% 0*0/ #

!3 &# ,& 0! =" 0&*#2"' !#

0&'0 ",!/% ,(0"*" @(! 0) "9.

"))/% .

#(0=0!"':

"$# "3 !(" 0&0!0!0#& #$ #,""'0&) ",!0#& ;? #$ !(" : :: =% !(" .#/0," 0& $,!

/ !

#$ !(" 0&)!&! ,)" 0) ,/" /% #*"

=# ' &' =0!

#&6=/"

" #

! #$ &'03 0& ,)" #$ )(#2

)(#2

*: !!" #$ !! 2(&'3 4;8;7 8 0&/7 <;

*: !!" #$ !! 2(&'3 4;8;7 8 0&/7 <;3 @(0/" '"/0& @0!( !("

),#." #$ ",!0#&) ;? &' ;< #$ !(" : :: () ("/' ) + H;:

(" 0& "'0"&!) &",")) % $# .))0& & #

",!0#& ;?

8;7 #$ !(" #'" @# /' &#! !# !0,//% !!

,! $# !(" !!,( "&! #$ !("

!%: &'"

",!0#& ;<3 0)!

!" () !# )!0)$% (0 )"/$ ) !# @("!("

"&,% "90)!) ="$# " (" .))") & # #$ !!,( "&!: ,)"

#$ "

"&,%3 ) ,#&!"

./!"'

",!0#& ;< #$ !(" #'"3 () !# ="

'0)!0& 0)("' $ " ,)" #$ ..

"("&)0#& #$ = ",( #$ !(" .",":

(" 0)!

!"3 ="$# " .))0& & #

",!0#& ;<3

)! "9./0& !(" ,0 ,

)!&,") @(% (" !(0&2) 0! !# =" ,)" #$ "

"&,%:

& #!("

@# ')3 !# 0&$"

)0!

!0#& #$ "

"&,%3 !("

)! =" !"

0/ #&

' ="$# " 0)!

!" @("& !(" ) = 0))0#& #$ !(" . !0") $0/"'3 '#,

"&!) .

,"' # "*0'"&," ''

,"':

G" $0&' $ !(0) ,)" !("

" 0) &#!(0& !# )(#@ !(! & "

"&,% "90)!) )# ) !# 0&*#2" ",!0#& ;<8;7 &' !# !!,( !(" . !% 0& > ")!0#&: ,)" #$ "

"&,%3 ) ."

",!0#& ;< #$ !(" #'" () !# ="

'0)!0& 0)("' $ " ,)" #$ ..

"("&)0#& #$ = ",( #$ .",": G("& ".# !) 0&'0,!" !(! #&" #$ !(" . !0") 0) 0& .#))"))0#&3 0(!/% #

@ #&/%3 !(" 0)!

!" ,&&#! .)) & # #$ !!,( "&! #& !("

#$ "

"&,%:

(" # ,2&#@/"'") !(" $,! !(! )(#2

() )! !"' ,#&)!

,!0#& 0& !(" .

!% 0& > ")!0#&3 !("

"$# "3 .#))"))0#& #$ !% 0) @0!( !(" .."//&! )(#2

3 @("!("

0! 0) /"/ # &#!3 0) &#! $# !(" !# '",0'":I ;4:

!0# #$ /@ /0' '#@& =% !("

#&6=/"

" #

! 0& !("

$# ")0' '

"&! 0) )> "/% ../0,=/" !# !(" $,!) #$ !(" .

")"&! ,)"

/)#:

& !(" .

")"&! ,)"3 0! 0) '

0!!"' ,)" #$ !(" . !0") !(!

#: @) 0& .#))"))0#& #$ !(" 0).

!"' !% ) !"&&!:

0) .#))"))0#& #$ !(" 0).

!"' !% ="0& $ //% */0' &' /"0!0 !"3 !(" /" &"' (' &# #,,)0#& !# ..#0&! !("

","0*"

",!0#& ;< #$ : :: > !(" )0' .

!%:

;;:

#*0)0#&) #$ ",!0#&) ;? &' ;< #$ : ::

2" 0!

= &'&!/% ,/" !(! 0&0!0!0#& #$ .

#,""'0&) !("

"0&3

)! '"

#&)!

)0!

!0#& 0*0& 0)" !# 0

0&"&! '&"

#$ = ",( #$ ."," #& !(" =)0) #$

;4 ;4 ;4 ;4 )# " !&0=/" )!

#& ")#&): & =)!

)" .# !

%/ #$ ) ,( ,0 ,

)!&,")3 #& !(" =)0) #$ =/' ))"

!0#&) )&) &% ) ..# !0& !"

0/3 ,&&#! $

&0)( */0'

&' #$ 0&0!0!0#& #$ .

#,""'0&) )",!0#&) 0=0':

(" /&'

$0/"' 0& !(" .

")"&! ,)" ,/" /% )."//) , $/"' ..

"("&)0#& #$ = ",( #$ ."," $# !(" .

.#)") #$ 0&0!0!0#& #$ .

#,""'0&):

(" ,!0#& !##2 =% !(" .#/0,"3 !("

"$# "3 .." ) !# (*" !

)"' ="%#&' !(" ."

0))0=/"

/0 0!) #$ )!!

!# % !(# 0!% &' . !2") !(" ,( ,!"

#$ ,#/#

=/" "9"

,0)"

#$ .#@"

(" //"!0#&) 0*0& 0)" !# $0/0& #$ 2/&'

=% .#/0,"3 ,/" /% )(#@) !(! !("

")"&!!0*") #$ !(" ."!0!0#&"

=(3 "&!"

"' !(" 0).

!"'

!%3 @(0,( 0) '

0!!"'/% !(" .#))"))0#& #$ #: ) !"&&!:

(" ,! #$ !(" ."!0!0#&"

3 0& !(0) " '3 /,2) =#& $0'")3 ) )! 4?

'%) .

0# !# !(" )0' 0&,0'"&! & (' /)# =""& /#'"' 0&)!

#: ! !(" 0&)!&," #$ ."!0!0#&"

#& !(" ) " , )": # "#*"

" @) & # .))"' =% !(" 0*0/ '" #& !(" ) =",! #$ '0).

="!@""& !(" . !0"):

! 0) !

0!" /@ !(! !(" = ",( #$ .","

"> "' ) & 0& "'0"&! #$ ",!0#& ;? #$ : :: ,&&#! =" "&"

/0)"' !"

!("

(! !# =" '",0.("

"' 0& ,#&!"9! @0!( !(" .

=/0, ! / ":

)/ #$ !(" # '!"' 4C:;;:4 .))"' =% !(" /" &"'

"*"/) !(! !(" ) " 0) ,# ,("' 0& #)! , %.!0, &' /,#&0, &&"

"$! #$ &% "&0&$ / ")#&0& # ' '0,!0#&:

(" # '#") &#!

"*0&," &% ../0,!0#& #$ 0&'3 &# '#") 0!

' &% ,#&,/ )0*" $0&'0& =)"' #& !("

0/ *0/=/" #& ':

! $//) ,#&).0, )/% )(# ! #$ !("

)"!!/"'

"> "&! !(! > )0 '0,0/ !(# 0!%

)! '("

" !# #=",!0*"

, 0!"

0 &' ))0& ,#"&!

")#&) 0& ) ..# ! #$ 0!) ,#&,/ )0#&):

(" /" &"'

3 0& !("

$ &,!# % &&"

3 () "/% '0 ",!"' !(" . !0") !# '")0)! $ 0&!"

0& @0!( !(" /&' 0& '0).

&!0/ $

) &'

;;

) =",! !# !(" # !,# " #$ !(" ,0*0/ .

#,""'0&): #3 !(" # '!"'

4C:;;:43 .))"' =% !(" /" &"' 3 &"0!("

'0),/#)") &% '0),"

&0=/"

/"/ !0#&/" &# /0&) @0!( !(" .

0&,0./") #*"

&0& !(" "9"

,0)"

0)'0,!0#& ",!0#&) ;? &' ;< #$ !(" :::

"3 0& 0!) '!"' 4C:;;:4 !(" /" &"' () $0/"' !# ' !("

"> 0)0!"

0&'"."&'"&! )!0)$,!0#& ) ,#&!"

./!"'

",!0#& ;< ::3 . !0, / /% @0!( " ' !# !(" "90)!"&," #$ & "

"&,% # !(" 0&=0/0!% !# '",0'" !(" > ")!0#& #$ .#))"))0#&:

& $,!3 !("

0/ #& ' 0&'0,!") !(! !(" ).",! #$ .#))"))0#& @) &"0!(" 0&'"!"

0&=/" &# 0&,.=/" #$ ' '0,!0#&J 0! &#! #&/% .." ) !# (*" =""& "*0'"&!3 !("

0!!"':

& ) ,( ,0 ,

)!&,")3 !(" '

)!0, ")

" #$ !!,( "&! #$ .

!% &'

..#0&!

"&! #$ ","0*"

,# /' &#! (*" =""& ")# !"' 0& !0&" #

",(&0,/ &&"

! !(0) &,!

"3 !(0) #

! '""

) 0! ..#)0!" !# )# &' &#!" #$ , !0#&:

(" $,!) #$ !(" .

")"&! ,)" "9"

./0$% '0)> 0"!0& &'

)!"'0/% #@0& !"&'"&,% #&)! /0!0&!) !# 0&*#2" !(" , 0&/

0)'0,!0#&3 &#! ) =#& $0'"

)" $#

"))/ #$ /"0!0 !"

0"*&,")3 = ! ) ,#&*"&0"&! 0&)!

"&! !# )"!!/" ."

)#&/ ),# ") &'

@ "2 .

0*!" *"&"&,":

(" ,)" 0& (&' =" ) ,("> "' (0)!# %3 '""./% ="''"' @0!(

/ , #&%3 @(0,( .." ) !# (*" .

#."//"' !("

. !0") 0&!# $#

#$ '0,0/ '*"&!

0) "'

,0& !(" )#/"

& $#

#$ ' '0,!0#& 0&!# =!!/"

&' $# !(" *0&'0,!0#& #$ =

0)"' "#):

0& *00/&! !# '0),"

& @("!("

!(" .

#,")) #$ /@ 0) ="0& 0&*#2"' 0& ##' $0!( # 0) "/% ,#/#

=/" "9"

,0)"3 , $/0& &

/!"

0# '")0&:

! 0) !

0!" !(! "9 !

.0 , ) &#& # 0!

,!0#K&# ,!0#&

; ; ; ; 0)") $ & 0

/ , )"K&' "> //% !(! !(" .

#,")) #$ !(" #

)! &#! =" ."

0!!"' !# =" = )"' ) @".#& #$ ( )) "&! #

#..

"))0#&: .

#$0!=/"

"$"

"&," 0& !(0) " ' ,& ="

'" !# !("

#=)"

*!0#&) '" =% !("

#&6=/"

" #

! 0& F0)(/ #=/" 0&( F):

F0)(/ #=/" 0&( F):

!!" #$ !!

!!" #$ !! '")( &' &#!("

J 4 8;7 ;;3 '")( &' &#!("

J 4 8;7 ;;3 "/"*&! @("

"#$

"') !( )+ H21. We find that in recent years the machinery of criminal justice is being misused by certain persons for their vested interests and for achieving their oblique motives and agenda. Courts have therefore to be vigilant against such tendencies and ensure that acts of omission and commission having an adverse impact on the fabric of our society must be nipped in the bud.I

"3 *"

% ","&!/%3 @(0/"

0)0& ,#&,"

& #*"

#@0& !"&'"&,% #$ )0& , 0&/ /@ ) ./!$#

$# 0&0!0!0#& #$ *0&'0,!0*" .

#,""'0&) !# )"!!/" ),# "3 !("

#&6=/"

" #

! 0& ""! 0&( F): !!" #$ ,(/ '")( &' !("

)J ""! 0&( F): !!" #$ ,(/ '")( &' !("

)J 1 8 0&/7 1 8 0&/7 1 8 0&/7 1 8 0&/7

#: ;? #$ 4

#: ;? #$ 4 #=)"

*"' ) + H;C: 999 0&/ /@ # (! &#! =",# " ./!$#

0&0!0!0#& #$ *0&'0,!0*" .

#,""'0&) !# )"!!/" ."

)#&/ ),# ") &' *"&'"!!):

999I

(0) #

! ,&&#! /#)" )0(! #$ !(" = #'"

0&)!0!

!0#&/ ,#&,"

& !(! ) ,( 0) )" "&"&'"

(" '0,0/ )%)!"

3 / "'% =

'"&"' @0!( & #&"

) '#,2"!3 0) $

0&"' @("& 0!) !0 " &'

")#

,") " '0*"

!"'

!#@ ') ' '0,!0& '0).

!") !(! "3 0& "))"&,"3 &0$")!!0#&) #$ ."

)#&/ *"&'"!! !("

!(& "& 0&" /"/ ,#&!

#*"

)0"):

,( .

,!0,") &#! #&/% ."'" !(" "9."'0!0# ) ")#/ !0#& #$ =#& $0'" '0).

!") = ! /)# "

#'" .

=/0, ,#&$0'"&," 0& !(" )&,!0!% &' "$$0,,% #$ !(" '0,0/ .

#,")): .

#$0!=/"

"$"

"&," 0& !(0) " ' ,& ="

'" !# !(" '0,! .))"' =% !("

#&6=/"

" #

! 0& (&,(/.!0 ) F):

(" !!" #$ G")! "&/ &'

(&,(/.!0 ) F):

(" !!" #$ G")! "&/ &'

(&,(/.!0 ) F):

(" !!" #$ G")! "&/ &'

(&,(/.!0 ) F):

(" !!" #$ G")! "&/ &'

&#!("

J 4 " #

! C;3 &#!("

J 4 " #

! C;3 &#!("

J 4 " #

! C;3 &#!("

J 4 " #

! C;3 "/"*&! @("

"#$ "') ) +

; ; ; ; H4: G" @# /' /02" !# '' !(! )! ) =' ,#0&) '

0*" # ! ##' ,#0&) $

,0 , /!0#&3 =' ,)") '

0*" # ! ##' ,)") $ ="0& (" ' #& !0 ":

", )" #$ !(" .

#/0$"

!0#& #$ $ 0*#/# ) ,)") 0& !(" ,#

!)3 !("

"/ &'

"& 0&" ,)") (*" !# !2" =,2)"! &' " &#! ="0& (" ' $# %" ) !#"!("

(" . !% @(# 0&0!0!") &' ,#&!0& ") $ 0*#/# )3 0

").#&)0=/"

&' )"&)"/")) /0!0!0#& # @(# = )") !(" .

#,")) #$ !(" ,#

)! ="

)''/"' @0!( "9"

./ % ,#)!3 )# !(! #!("

) % '"!"

!# $#//#@ ) ,( ,#

)":I

"3 0& = !

= !

= ! #% ( F): &0#& #$ &'0 &'

#% ( F): &0#& #$ &'0 &'

!("

)J 4; 8D7 C43 !("

#&6=/"

" #

! #=)"

*"' ) + H;?4:

&'0& '0,0/ )%)!"

0) #))/% $$/0,!"'3 @0!( $ 0*#/# ) /0!0!0#&: G%) &'

"&) &""' !# =" "*#/*"'3 !# '"!"

/0!0&!) $ !("0

,# /)0*" #=)"))0#&3 !#@ ') )"&)"/")) &' 0//,#&)0'"

"' ,/0 ): &"

&""') !# 2"". 0& 0&'3 !(! 0& !(" .

#,")) #$ /0!0!0#&3 !("

" 0) & 0&&#,"&!

) $$"

#& !(" #!("

)0'"3 #$ "*"

% 0

").#&)0=/" &' )"&)"/")) ,/0 :

) $$"

) /#& '

@& &90# ) ."

0#') #$ &"

*# )&")) &'

")!/"))&"))3 @(0/)!

!(" /0!0!0#& 0) ."&'0&3 @0!(# ! &% $ /! #& (0) . !:

" .%) $# /0!0!0#&3 $ ! #$ (0) )*0&) 8# ! #$ (0) =#

#@0&)73 @#

%0& !(!

!(" #!("

)0'"

% !

0,2 (0 0&!# '"$"!3 $# &# $ /! #$ (0):

" )."&') 0&*/ =/" !0 " = 0"$0& ,# &)"/ &' .

". 0& !("

(0) ,/0 :

@(0,( (" )(# /' (*" )."&! ! @# 23 # @0!( (0) $ 0/%3 0) /#)!3 $# &# $ /!

#$ (0): (# /' /0!0&! &#! =" ,# ."&)!"' $# 3 @(! (" () /#)!3 $# &# $ /!L (" ) ")!0#& !# !(" /"0)/!

" 0)3 !(! /0!0&! @(# () ) ,,""'"'3

)! =" ,# ."&)!"' =% !(" #&"3 @(# () /#)!:

(" ) ")!0#& !# !(" /"0)/!

" 0) !# $#

/!" ",(&0) 3 !(! &%#&" @(# 0&0!0!") &' ,#&!0& ") /0!0!0#& )"&)"/"))/%3 .%) $# !(" ) ":

! 0) ) ")!"'

!(! !(" /"0)/!

" )(# /' ,#&)0'"

!(" 0&!

,!0#& #$ M#'" #$ # /)# % #)!)M:I

(" .

0&,0./" 0&!"

")!

"0.

=/0,"

! )0! $0&0) /0!0

)!&')

*"/%

0&"' @("& . !0") 0&'

/" 0& $ 0*#/# ) #

#!0*!"'

#,""'0&): > //%3 !(" .( )" 5= )" #$ .

#,")) #$ /@6 0) &#! .( )" = ! ) =)!&!0*" '#,!

0&"3 #=/0!0& #

!) !# 0&!"

'0,! .

#,""'0&) !(! " 0&0!0!"' @0!( #=/0> #!0*") # $# ,#//!"

/ .

.#)"):

)!3 "$# "3 =" "

.(!0,//% "0!"

!"' !(! !(" '0,0/ .

#,")) 0) &#! $#

$# )"!!/0& ."

)#&/ &0 #)0!0") # '*&,0& .

0*!" *"&'"!!): &% !!"

!# ) =*"

! 0! $# ) ,( "9!

&"# ) .

.#)") '")"

*") !# =" '".

",!"' 0& !("

#&")! .#))0=/" !"

(0) #

! 0) ,#&)!

0&"' !# #=)"

*" !(!

!# , 0&/ /@

)! =" !"

"' @0!( ").#&)0=0/0!%3 =#& $0'")3 &'

; ; ; ; "& 0&" , )" #$ ,!0#&3 /")! !("

")!% #$ /@ =" ,# 0)"' =% 0!)

0) )":

& *0"@ #$ !(" =#*" $0&'0&) !(" '

"&! .))"' =% "))0#&) '"3 0& 0&/ "*0)0#& #:;;< #$ 43 '#") &#! ) $$"

$ &% /"/ 0&$0

0!% &' ) ) ,( 0) .("/': ") /!&!/%3 !(" .

")"&! 0&/ 0),"//&"# ) "!0!0#& 0) '0) 0))"'

'0) 0))"'

'0) 0))"':

;?:

"&'0& ../0,!0#&8)73 0$ &%3 )(// /)# )!&' '0).#)"' #$: 8 17 8 17 8 17 8 17 .

0/ .

0/ 4 4 4 43 4< 3 4< 3 4< 3 4<

(*0

G("!("

)."20&- ")#&"'+ ")- G("!("

".# !=/"+ ")-