D.B.Arora v. Union Of India And ORS.


 

       


     

 





    

  !  

  


  

    "#$%#$&%#$'()*$+$,%-#.(/)0$&$1.&%$)2,%#$)2*$-%3 $-



  

 

   



 





      

 

  
  

 ! 

&.&4&$%2&$)4-$,2.&()2% 5526$& 2-725$(,)$&7$,% 64%4&46%  .1$&4%2.,  72%#  &$1/46$+$,%  .5  ,%&4
$,-  

  2,  %#$ $14&%+$,%.5 1#%#4/+./.*82,   #4,)2*4&#2,%#$8$4&

$  &$6$29$)  +$)264/  &$2+0(&-$+$,%  .5 
:;<=
 %.74&)-  %#$  64%4&46% .1$&4%2.,6.,)(6%$).,#2-725$



%2-%#$*&2$94,6$.5 &.&4%#4%%#$&$-1.,)$,%-92)$/$%%$& )4%$)  >)2&$6%$)#2+%.&$148%#$$?6$--4+.(,%.5
<;=
142) %.74&)-  %#$  40.9$  +$)264/  &$2+0(&-$+$,%  72%#.(%  *292,*  #2+  4, .11.&%(,2%8.5#$4&2,*  :

#$&20(,4/&$5$&&2,*%.,,$?(&$
:)4%$) @4,) %#$6.++(,264%2.,-$,%08%#$&$-1.,)$,%-., < >#$/)%#4%%#$ &$-1.,)$,%-#49$&2*#%/8)2&$6%$) &.&4%.148%#$$?6$--4+.(,%.5



<;=
142)%.#2+%.74&)-+$)264/&$2+0(&-$+$,% @

$4&)%#$-(0+2--2.,-+4)$.,$2%#$&-2)$



&.&47#.52/$) &2*2,4/11/264%2.,0$5.&$%#$&20(,4/ #4--2,6$14--$)4748 2-/$*4/&$1&$-$,%4%29$-#49$52/$)%#$1&$-$,%7&2% 1$%2%2.,6#4//$,*2,*%#$.&)$&14--$)08%#$&20(,4/

$4&,$)6.(,-$/411$4&2,*5.&%#$7&2%1$%2%2.,$&-)&$7.(& 4%%$,%2.,%.%#$ 2&6(/4&2--($)08%#$&$-1.,)$,%-.,@  ;;7#26#&$4)- %#(-B#$46%(4/6.-%.5,%&4
6(/4& $,-2+1/4,%4%2.,4,)%#$%&$4%+$,% %#$&$%.25(,)$&%4C$,2, .9$&,+$,%.-12%4/2,5(//4,)%#$46%(4/6.-%.5
A=
7#26#$9$&2-/$--2-&$2+0(&-40/$%.%#$ .9$&,+$,%-$&94,%D

<

-1$&%#$40.9$ 2&6(/4& &.&474-$,%2%/$).,/8%.%#$ +4?2+(+  4+.(,%  .5 
A=
 %.74&)-  %#$  6.-%  .5  ,%&4  $,- 2+1/4,%4%2.,4,)%#$%&$4%+$,%%#$&$%.2,%#$ .9$&,+$,%.-12%4/

>

#$&$2-,.)2-1(%$%.%#$546%%#4% &.&4&$6$29$)4-(+.5
:;<=
%.74&)- %#$6.-% .5 ,%&4
6(/4& $,- 2+1/4,%4%2., 4,)%#$ %&$4%+$,%#2-725$#4)%4C$,2,%#$ .9$&,+$,%.-12%4/ #$&$-1.,)$,%- #49$  6/4&252$)  72%#  %#$  6.,6(&&$,6$  .5  %#$  2,4,6$  $14&%+$,%  92)$ 6.++(,264%2.,)4%$) @$9$,1&2.&%.%#$-(&*$&8(,)$&7$,%08 %#$725$.5 &.&4%#4%2,%#$+4%%$&.5&$2+0(&-$+$,%%#$6$2/2,*&4%$ 5.&5./)40/$

7.(/)0$
;.&%#$46%(4/6.-%7#26#$9$&2-/$--

;

,.(&6.,-2)$&$)92$7%#$&$-1.,)$,%-4&$$,%2%/$)%.6/4&258 %#$.&2*2,4/ 2&6(/4&2--($).,@  ;;72%#%#$6.,6(&&$,6$.5%#$2,4,6$ $14&%+$,%



.72%2-6&8-%4/6/$4&%#4% &.&474-$,%2%/$)%..,/8

:

A=
%.74&)-&$2+0(&-$+$,%5.&#2-725$E-64%4&46%.1$&4%2.,2,6/()2,* ,%&4
$,- 2+1/4,%4%2.,  

 (%  #$  #4) &$6$29$) 4  -(+ .5
:;<=
%.74&)-%#$-42).1$&4%2.,(,)$&7$,%08#2-725$ 

(%.5%#$6/42+.5
:;<=
#$+4)$%.74&)-&$2+0(&-$+$,% #$74-$,%2%/$)%.&$6$29$ 
;=
%.74&)-

+1/4,%4%2.,4,) 
A=
%.74&)-%#$$?1$,)2%(&$#$#4)0.&,$%.74&)-%&$4%+$,%4**&$*4%2,*%.
A=
-(+.5
A<;<=
#4-0$$,142)2,$?6$--%. &.&4%.74&)- &$2+0(&-$+$,%4,),.%
<;=
4-6/42+$)08%#$&$-1.,)$,%-

$4&,$)6.(,-$/411$4&2,*5.&%#$&$-1.,)$,%--(0+2%-%#4% &.&47#.*.%&$2+0(&-$+$,%.5 
:;<=
#4))2$)  .77$52,) %#4%/$*4/&$1&$-$,%4%29$-#49$6#4//$,*$)%#$.&)$&14--$)08%#$&20(,4/

:

,92$7.5%#$40.9$546%-4,)62&6(+-%4,6$-%4C2,*4/$,2$,% 92$77$)2&$6%%#$&$-1.,)$,%-,.%%.&$6.9$&%#$$?6$--148+$,%+4)$%. &.&4(,)$&,,$?(&$
4-#$#4)14--$)47484,)%#$&$6.9$&8 1&.6$--7.(/)&$-(/%2,(,%./)#4&)-#21%.%#$/$*4/&$1&$-$,%4%29$-7#. 52/$)%#$1&$-$,%7&2%1$%2%2.,

@

,%#$45.&$-42)%$&+-%#$7&2%1$%2%2.,-%4,)-)2-1.-$).5  " #     $1%$+0$& "  # (/4%2