High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18491/2009allowed

Pawan Kumar Gupta v. Financial Commissioner And ORS.

2017-04-05Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan8 pages

"#$ %$&'(')*+ , "-")./0"1/2#"

$#'#')$1( 3$1(/( 4$ ')")&'"500'((')$1")%1')&'2"56$&1$#"17#8$1)0$)#

"17")"9%/&"#') $2"1#0$)#9"17")"'8'56$&1$#"1'"#9")%#4$1( $(2)%$)#( * :; 6.; 6 1$($)#* 1."1")8'16')<4.4$4"19 %8&"#$9 1#4$2$#'#')$1 1.$(4"8/2#"9 (('(#")# %8&"#$$)$1"59"17")" 1"8$$)/2#"9 %8&"#$9 11$(2)%$)#= 1."1#'>$7"9 %8&"#$9 11$(2)%$)#+ 4$#4$1#4$$21#$1( 5&"5)$-(2"2$10"7?$"55-$%# ($$#4$@/%<0$)#A

?$1$ $11$%##4$$21#$11)# = 4$#4$1#4$@/%<0$)#(4/5%?$1$21#$%')#4$%'<$(#A .; 6 4$2$#'#')$14"(')8>$%#4$-1'#@/1'(%'&#') #4'(/1# /)%$1 1#'&5$

B #4$)(#'#/#') )%'" 1'((/')<"-1'#')#4$)"#/1$ &$1#'1"1'9C/"(4')<#4$1%$1%"#$%B ")%1%$1%"#$% +B ))$D/1$(")% 1$(2$&#'8$5798'%$-4'&41$(2)%$)#(")%

4"8$%$)'$%#4$1$#'1"5?$)$ '#('$2$)(')9<1"#/'#79218'%$)# /)%")% 5$"8$$)&"(40$)#$#& ##4$2$#'#')$1 /1#4$1"-1'#')#4$)"#/1$

0")%"0/('("5((/<4# 1%'1$&#')<1$(2)%$)#(#2"7"55#4$"?8$)#$% 1$#'1"5?$)$ '#("5)<-'#4 E')#$1$(###4$2$#'#')$1 4$ (41# "&#(9 -4'&4 "1$ 1$C/'1$% # ?$ )#'&$% 1 #4$ 2/12($ #4$%'(2("5 #4$21$($)#-1'#2$#'#')9"1$#4"##4$2$#'#')$1 4"%@')$%"("5$1>-'#46 "4'5""4"8'%7"5"9"1-")"9 '(#1'&# ')% 1$(2)%$)#=4$1$') )=, , 9"<"')(#"(")&#')$%2(#4$ ("'%55$<$-"(1$&$'8')<<1")#')"'% 10#4$6#"#$8$1)0$)# 4$ 2$#'#')$1&5"'0(#4"#-4$))$60#6")#(464"10"?$&"0$#4$

'&'"#')< 1')&'2"5 #4$("'%&55$<$9#4$(#"

4"%0"%$(0$&025"')#(")%#4$ 0")"<$0$)# #4$("'%&55$<$-"(#">$)8$1?7#4$8$1)0$)#4$ 1%$1-"(5"#$1)C/"(4$%?7#4$&02$#$)#"/#41'#74$1')&'2"5 #4$ ("'% &55$<$ ?$&"0$ ')'0'&"5 # 4'0 "( #4$ 2$#'#')$1 4"% 1$ /($% # &4")<$"5#$1#4$1$&1%4$2$#'#')$1-"((/(2$)%$% 10#4$($18'&$) B

")%4'($)#17##4$("'% &55$<$-"(?"))$% -$8$19#4$ '<4$1%/&"#')00'((')$19"17")"91$')(#"#$%4'0) 4$2$#'#')$11$@')$%)++ ")%-"("<"')(/(2$)%$%)#4$8$17 )$D# %"7 '$ B+ 4$1$"

#$19 #4$ 2$#'#')$1 -"( ($18$% -'#4 " &4"1<$(4$$#

#$1#4$')C/'1798'%$1$(5/#')%"#$%B

94'(($18'&$(-$1$#$10')"#$%?7#4$0")"<$0$)# 1$(2)%$)#= 8$1)0$)#55$<$4$("'%1$(5/#')-"(($)###4$ '1$&#19'<4$1 %/&"#')9 "17")" )- '<4$1 %/&"#') 00'((')$19 "17")" 1$(2)%$)# 4$1$')9"(1$C/'1$%/)%$1/5$, #4$"17")"

'5'"#$% 55$<$( 6$&/1'#7 6$18'&$ &#9 , ') (41# :

&# , : $(2)%$)# ($# "('%$#4$ ("'% 1$(5/#') #4$0")"<$0$)#

1$(2)%$)#=8$1)0$)#55$<$")%1$')(#"#$%#4$2$#'#')$1-'#4 &)#')/'#7 ($18'&$")%&)($C/$)#'"5?$)$ '#(98'%$1%$1%"#$% =

= ))$D/1$= -$8$19')1$8'(')91$(2)%$)#'$ ')")&'"5 00'((')$1 ")% 1')&'2"5 6$&1$#"17 # 8$1)0$)# "17")"9 %/&"#') $2"1#0$)#9 "17")"9 "2218$% #4$ ("'% 1$(5/#') ")% #4$ ($18'&$( #4$2$#'#')$1-$1$#$10')"#$%98'%$1%$1%"#$%

4$1$"

#$19#4$2$#'#')$1"221"&4$%#4'(/1#?7-"7

'5')< == 9 #'#5$% "( "-") ./0"1 /2#" 3$1(/( ")"<')<00'##$$ 6 "4'5""4"8'%7"5"7"9"1-")"9 '(#1'&#

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

""#'"'G"%#4$2$#'#')$1?$$)%'(0'(($%9#4$)#4$-1%/($%-/5% 4"8$?$$)F"1>4"(#G #'((#"#$%#4"#/)%$1/5$ #4$"17")"

'5'"#$%55$<$(62$&'"5$)(')")%)#1'?/#17 /)%/5$(9 ') (41# :/5$( :9 #4$ '1$&#1 '( $02-$1$% # -'#445% 1 -'#4%1"-2$)(') ")$0257$$9'

4$'(</'5#7 "<1"8$0'(&)%/&# 218$% ') ") ')C/'17 &)%/&#$% ?7 #4$ 8$1)0$)# ) 1 " #$1 #4$ 1$#'1$0$)#4$1$ 1$94$'($)#'#5$%#"55#4$1$#'1"5?$)$ '#( $(2)%$)#(")% ')#4$-1'##$)(#"#$0$)##>#4$25$"

#4"##4$($18'&$ #4$2$#'#')$1-"(#$10')"#$%?7#4$&55$<$0")"<$0$)# 1$(2)%$)#=4$1$')/)%$16$&#'), #4$ &# , "##4$'1-) 5$8$5 # '( " %'(2/#$ $)#'1$57 ?$#-$$) #4$ 2$#'#')$1 ")% #4$ &55$<$ 0")"<$0$)##-"( /1#4$1(#"#$%#4"##4$2$)(')(&4$0$-"(')#1%/&$%

1#4$ '1(##'0$ 1#4$$0257$$(-1>')<)#4$"'%$%(")&#')$%2(#') #4$)8$1)0$)#1'8"#$

'5'"#$%55$<$(')#4$6#"#$ "17")"

-'#4$

$&# 10+

')5'$/ &)#1'?/#17218'%$)# /)%4$("'% 2$)(')(&4$0$'(&02/5(17')1$(2$&# ")$0257$$91$#'1')<"

#$1 =+

4$?$)$ '# &00/#"#') 2$)(')")%5$"8$$)&"(40$)#'( (2$&'

'&"557%$)'$%/)%$1#4$("'%2$)(')(&4$0$#'((#"#$%#4"#/)%$1 /5$ #4$$)(')/5$(9

9#4$2$)(')'(2"7"?5$")%#4$ 2$)(') 0$")(9

4$1$ 1$9"

#$10')"#$%$0257$$'()#$)#'#5$%#2$)(') $(2)%$)#=')#4$1$257#>#4$25$"#4"##4$1%$1

%'(0'(("5 #4$2$#'#')$1 10($18'&$4"("51$"%7?$&0$ ')"5"

#$1#4$ %'(0'(("5 #4$6;?7#4$):?5$6/21$0$/1# )%'" #-"( "%0'##$% #4"# #4$1$ '( " 2$)(') (&4$0$ 1 #4$ $0257$$( ) 8$1)0$)#1'8"#$

'5'"#$%55$<$(')#4$6#"#$ "17")"-'#4$

$&#

10+

/)%$1#4$1/5$(&"55$%:"17")"

'5'"#$%55$<$($)(') ")%)#1'?/#1718'%$)# /)%/5$(9

:')(41#:/5$(

: )%$1#4$("'%1/5$(9&00/#"#') 2$)(')")%5$"8$$)&"(40$)#4"( ?$$)(2$&'

'&"557%$)'$% (#4$($18'&$( #4$2$#'#')$1-$1$#$10')"#$%9 #4$1$ 1$94$'()#$)#'#5$%#2$)(')")%<1"#/'#7$<"1%')<218'%$)#

/)%9'#'((/?0'##$%#4"#)"0/)# 218'%$)# /)%'(2$)%')<-'#4#4$ &55$<$ 0")"<$0$)# 4$ &55$<$ 0")"<$0$)# 4"( %$2('#$% #4$

+ $0257$$:((4"1$ 218'%$)# /)%9"0/)#')<#(= 9

B9-'#4#4$ 8$1)0$)#98'%$4"55")= 9%"#$%B

')#4$6#"#$")>

"#'"5"9"1-")"")%%$2('#$%(,+9=B ) == ')#4$("5"17 "&&/)#')#4$1'$)#"5")> 00$1&$9"1-")"#-"( /1#4$1(#"#$% #4"# #4$ 2$#'#')$1 4"( "51$"%7 -'#4%1"-) #4$ "0/)# $8$) 10 #4$ $0257$1:((4"1$ &)#1'?/#')"&&/0/5"#$%')4'(218'%$)# /)%"&&/)# )%'

$1$)#&&"(')(9-4'&44"()#1$#/1)$%%$(2'#$($8$1"55$##$1( 4"8$4$"1%#4$5$"1)$%&/)($5( 1#4$2"1#'$(")%4"8$"5( &"1$ /557<)$#41/<4#4$ '5$ 6 "1"(#4$&)#18$1(71$<"1%')<#$10')"#') ($18'&$(

#4$2$#'#')$1'(&)&$1)$%9#4$1%$1%"#$%

9 2"(($%')#4$1$8'(')?7#4$00'((')$1")%6$&1$#"17#8$1)0$)#

"17")"9%/&"#') $2"1#0$)#9(4-(#4"##4$#$10')"#') ($18'&$(

#4$ 2$#'#')$1 -"( "2218$% -'#4 #4$ 1$(/5# #4"# #4$ 2$#'#')$1 (#% #$10')"#$% 4$ &27 #4$ @/%<0$)# ))$D/1$+9 2"(($% ?7 "

'8'(')$)&4 #4'(/1#')== 9(4-(#4"##4$ 2$#'#')$14"%&4"55$)<$%#4$1%$1 #4$00'((')$1")%6$&1$#"17# 8$1)0$)# "17")"9%/&"#') $2"1#0$)#9"2218')<#4$212("5 1 #$10')"#') 4'(($18'&$( 4$("'%-1'#2$#'#')-"(%'(0'(($%?7" '8'(') $)&4 #4'( /1# ') 5'0')$9 8'%$ 1%$1 %"#$% ))$D/1$+ /1#4$19 #4$ 6; '5$% "<"')(# #4$ ("'% 1%$1 -"( %'(0'(($%?7#4$):?5$6/21$0$/1# )%'"98'%$1%$1%"#$% , ))$D/1$B ) #4'( -"79 #4$ C/$(#') 1$<"1%')< #$10')"#')

($18'&$( #4$2$#'#')$14"(?$&0$ ')"5")%&"))#?$1$2$)$%#45% #4"#'#-"()##$10')"#') ($18'&$(9?/#1$08"5 10#4$($18'&$)#4$ 1%$1 #4$00'((')$1")%6$&1$#"17##4$8$1)0$)# "17")"9

B %/&"#') $2"1#0$)#%"#$%

"(-$55"(')#4$ @/%<0$)#%"#$% ))$D/1$+92"(($%?7#4$ '8'(')$)&4

#4'(/1#')== 9#4$-1%:#$10')"#'):'((2$&'

'&"557 /($%4$1$ 1$9'#4"(#?$#">$)#4"##4$($18'&$( #4$2$#'#')$1-$1$ #$10')"#$% -9#4$C/$(#')-/5%"1'($"(#-4$#4$1#4$2$#'#')$1'( $)#'#5$%#2$)(')"

#$1#4$#$10')"#') 4'(($18'&$(A 4$2$)(')'(%$ ')$%')/5$ #4$/5$(

9-4'&4 '(1$21%/&$%"(/)%$1* F/5$ F$)(')G0$")(")"0/)#-4'&4")$0257$$ (4"55<$#"(2$)(')')&5/%')<<1"#/'#7)"##"')')<#4$"<$

(/2$1"))/"#')G 4$%$ ')'#')0">$('#&5$"1#4"##4$2$)(')'(2"7"?5$)57) "##"')')<#4$"<$ (/2$1"))/"#') /5$+ #4$/5$(

218'%$( 11$#'1$0$)#?$)$ '#(9 -4'&4'(1$21%/&$%"(/)%$1* F/5$+ 4$ 55-')< 1$#'1$0$)# ?$)$ '#( (4"55 ?$ "%0'(('?5$/)%$1#4$($1/5$(9)"0$57* $)(') "6/2$1"))/"#')$)(') ?)8"5'%$)(') &02$)("#')$)(')H")% %35/)#"17$#'1$0$)#$)(') 02/5(17$#'1$0$)#$)(')

$"#4&/01$#'1$0$)#<1"#/'#7 = 6$18'&$<1"#/'#7

"0'572$)(')G )%$1/5$ #4$/5$(

9#4$0')'0/0C/"5'

7')< ($18'&$ 1 2$)(') '( 7$"1( 4$ ($18'&$ #4$ 2$#'#')$1 -"( "%0'##$%57#$10')"#$%/)%$16$&#'), #4$ &# , )&$9'#'( /)% #4"# #4$ ($18'&$( #4$ 2$#'#')$1 -$1$ #$10')"#$% ")% 4$ %'% )#

, (/2$1"))/"#$94$'()#$)#'#5$%##4$2$)(')/)%$1#4$/5$(

-9&0')<##4$C/$(#') 1$5$"($ #4$218'%$)# /)%9 "&&1%')< # #4$ (#")% 1$(2)%$)# =&55$<$ 0")"<$0$)#9 #4$ $0257$$:( (4"1$ 218'%$)# /)%9 "0/)#')< # ( = 9

B9 -"( %$2('#$% ?7 #4$0 -'#4 #4$ 8$1)0$)#9 8'%$ 4"55") = 9 %"#$% B

')#4$6#"#$")> "#'"5"9"1-")"")%(,+9=B -"( %$2('#$% ) == ') #4$ ("5"17 "&&/)# ') #4$ 1'$)#"5 ")>

00$1&$9"1-")"4$218'%$)# /)%'(#4$212$1#7 #4$2$#'#')$1 ")%$8$)"

#$1#$10')"#') 4'(($18'&$(94$'($)#'#5$%##4$("0$#'( "5((#"#$%')#4$1$257 1$(2)%$)#=&55$<$0")"<$0$)##4"##4$ 2$#'#')$1 4"( -'#4%1"-) (0$ "0/)# 10 #4$ $0257$1:( (4"1$

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

'$%&27

#4'(1%$19"5)<-'#4')#$1$(#"##4$1"#$-4'&40'<4#4"8$"&&1/$%)#4$ ("0$)"&&/)# %$2('# #4$("0$')#4$?")> .; 6 + , (@>( 4$#4$1(2$">')<1$"()$% * !$( 4$#4$1$21#"?5$ *