Ramesh Kumar And Others v. State Of Haryana And Another
!
"#$%&'()&*&)+&#,' -!! !
"#$%&'(.),',"'/&#,' !! !
"#$%&'(".0,1#&#,' !! ! 2&(2&),.&)1(3+&,)4"005"#$%&'(
"00 ! &0163'.),',"'/&%&'(,44"005"#$%&'(1'#)&1*,'*7341'6
8 9:; !
< ;< ;;
: ****
!"
!# # $ <1'#&&. ,"#$307 ! %&' ()
"*
+! ",--. * / 0
" 0 &2&--3&4% 5
&.' +", + )" "+ 0 6 7+ *,
8"
8 "" *,
8"
86 % ",
0 ' !" ,&994 ) , %" "' ! -:39&99; % 5
.',0 ,,"1 ,+ <&;= %-' 7 " , + " + ! + + 8"," !0! 0 !" " %" "'
- 2 - -:39&99; 0 8 ,+ ,>%-' )+*!, !"% 0 8 (' , &9.&% &9.& ,',,,0," , !")
"
, +0,"+, 1 " " ,0+,"
0 8( 6 *,
" %:' * ,
,,0, +, 0 +1 !" +* "
!, 393.&999 + "0 ",, + !* ", +
0 ,,! , "," !" * "!" ? +"
,00+ " 0, %2' /
0 + ", !" 0 !" "
"0 ,
0 !" ,, ,,0, ! ) 0 +1 , " " )"0 ? , , ", &2&--3&4 % 5
&.'/
, ) " ,, 8 ? ,0, " -2&3-3&; % 5
&4' !, ", 8 0 "", "+ %>'
, " , + "
- 3 - + ", 0! + @ *, #!, # %$ 8*' !" , &994% &994 ,'
! ,"&9.& , 5A ,4 , B; &994 , , 1 ," 5 " 8"
8 "" 8* 1 ? 5 " 6 C 7+ ! D 5 " 8( *,
8"
8 8"
8 "" *,
8"
86 ",
0 %.' /
+ 0 6 0 + !" ," A &23.&992 # , !" , +" ,0+, % 0 ' &:3.&99. " *1 , ", B&- "! 0, )"+
!&2&--3&4% 5
8&.' , B:;! ", %4' , " , %;' 0 &2&--3&4 % 5
&.'
8# !0) ",0 &>3.&992 ", 1 5 " +&23.&99. "" " # , !" , &994/" ) 8 " , , ", 1 ! ? 5 " &99; A ","
,
- 4 -
8# +",0+, %9' /", " , !, , >%-' &9.& ,
" ,"+, ( , 0 , 0 8*!, !" 0 ", ", , ! "+ 0 " , > &9.& , , 6 8 ( 8
!
" "
# $% " # & # ! # ""
" # '
$ $ ! " " ! " " " ( %&3' ( +! ! , ! 6 ",0 8*,
,,+,0+, +)"1 ,"# , "
+ 8 "0 !88
- 5 - ! *,
,, + + " 00 *,
"+(, )0,0+, !8E8! + , 8 <)!
,!
1%&
,*( 1(&,4 ,3'3'$ ;03$3=303(6 4,) .),%,(3,' 1* **3*(1'( & ",0
&23.&992 &:3.&99. - %B&' &.3:&99: &>3:&99; : A,%B-' &33>&99: 393>&99; 2 %B:' *,
--3;&99& -&3;&99. > #! %B2' *,
3-34&99- 3&34&994 . B%B>' *,
&&&&&99& &&&&&99. 4 %B.' *,
3934&99- 3;34&994 ; %B4' &:3>&99: &-3>&99; 9
7,%B;' *,
-43.&99- -.3.&994 %&&' ( , 9 &994 , "
+
"
!" " /" 0 ,,+ "
+ *, %0' %' , ,9%'&994 , 8
# # # #
"
# )" ! * # ! # ! +( %&-' " + "
+ 0 " !" ,&&&994 , ! + !"+,0 " !" !" " ,,+ , "" 0 + "
5 "
- 6 - 0 " , 0! + ( !, "
" ", 0 *,
C8" "
", " ,&& &994 , %&:' # 5" , *,
8( %" "
, -;3--3&- 3&3&-3&3' 6 ", 0 %" "
,:334&999' , 8 ,+ 0 +0 0", ! , ,0+,, %&2' (
0 , +1 , 0,0
0 0 *
* "
!, 393.&999% 5
;' * "
"
,0* "" ,0 !"
0 "! ! " 3;34&999 % 5
9' ( ! , " , -.3>-339 ,0 00 ! , ,, 0) " " ,,
)"+ &2&--3&4 %&>'
! "
"
!, 3932-3&> * "
? 0 , >%-' &9.& , " , +
) 0 " 0 ?,
- 7 - %&.' /, 0,0*"
!, 2>&94:% 5
>' ", " " "" ! 0 , >%-' &9.& , , " 0 , 0 "6 ",0
0, 8 *,
( "" , , , 0,, " ,+ ) ) +" + , ( ,! ", " ! , 323>&94: % 5
>' 8
' "
$ , - $
- $ $ "
$,. '
" ! "
" % ! "
" " %
# / !
"$
G,H %&4' ( $! "0I
, "
", ", 0 8 !8E8! *,
- 8 - 0 ,+ ,! ! 8 6 0 8 !8E8!*,
,+ + 8C6 ",0 "! , %&;' / "
, ", " +" ,0+, "
+ "6 ", 0 ! " C*,
@ ,, " "
+
! , 88 +" ,0 !" , ,1 ," %&9' ( ) , C*,
+" ,0+, ,0, ) ",6 ", 0 ( ! ! ! , 0 " , "+0 ,0+, , ,, / ? ,",1 ,0 !"+" " , %-3' ( "
,0 5,", ,>%-' &9.& , ,&&&994 ,(+" " ,, 0 "
+ ",
,) ,+0 ,43 " ,
0 , + , + *"
, "
0 , + "
,0 + $! , ! , 393.&999 %
;'3932-3&>% 5
&>'" , ", "
- 9 - +*"
"", , + + !"
,!" %-&' A , >%-' &9.& , , && &994 , +,0 8# + " ,0 !" , ,0+, A 0 0,0 " , 0 0 , ,0 " %--' "" 0,
,, &2&--3&4 % 5
&.' + +0 " ", " , 323>&94: % 5
>' + * "
( "" ", 0 !0
, " "
, +$! "!" ) ,0 ,, "1 , + /
"
,,+ ,,0 < "
"" " %-:'
"" 0, !! ,
<1'#&&. ,"#$30
"#$&
1. Whether speaking/reasoned?
:
Yes/No
2. Whether reportable?
:
Yes/No