Sukhpal Singh v. State Of Punjab
<
<
!"#$ B9&%"%"'#&/ / ?&/, * % %&'( #) B9&, '#.&#% %&'( %&'( %&'( %&'(&+"
&+"
&+"
&+"
%&'( !'
%&'( !'
%&'( !'
%&'( !'
- - - - /&,&#%- ","'#- ,"'#- ","'#- ,"'#- /"!7 /"!7 /"!7 /"!72 2 2 2 < ' ."#$- ' ."#$- ' ."#$- ' ."#$- /"!7 /"!7 /"!7 /"!72 < 2 < 2 < 2 < 509 509 509 509 0 0 0 0 /9 / * "#$! 2.?'+ %&('
3 /&,&#+&> / &.% /'
?".&'
/&,&#+&> / &.% /'
?".&'
/&,&#+&> / &.% /'
?".&'
/&,&#+&> / &.% /'
?".&'
('/% '+'#(&/&#+"#$ +'#(&/&#+"#$ +'#(&/&#+"#$ +'#(&/&#+"#$69 @@@@@ @@@@@ @@@@@ @@@@@ 0 0 0 0293/ !6 293/ !6 293/ !6 293/ !6 & /&,&#% &%"%"'# , *&&# ("!&. #.&/ &+%"'# 8 '( % & / %"1 $ /"
/ # "% 2
3('/ , '/% 4 56 3&/,%:
"!& &+%"'#78 /9996,&& "#$,&%%"#$ ,".&A ;
"#$'(% &"> $#&.'/.&/ / . %&. 79 9 3##&= /&6 ,,&.*1 &!& /#&..."%"'# !&,,"'#, .$& 2 /"
"
%, / "* 3('/ , '/% 4 &,,"'#, '
/%562 :
&/&*1 * "!
! $/ #%&.%'%
,*&&#+ #+&!!&.
. #. ",* "!A, /&%1*'#., /& ('/(&"%&.%'% &% %&2 #.#'#* "! *!&: // / #% ,*&&#",, &. $ "#,%% & &%"%"'#&/ , !,'#'%"+&%' ",, /&%"&,:&/& ",, &.2 #.( &/('/;
"#$ $ '(, *,&;
&# #%'/.&/. %&.9 9 <3##& &= /&<6 ,,&.*1% &!& /#&.
. &,,"'#, '
/%2 :
&/&*12 (/&, #'#* "! * *!& : // #%, ?& *&&# ",, &.
. $ "#,% % &%"%"'#&/2 "# + ,& A< A 8 %"%!&. 4% %& '( #) * ?,9
!"#$ #. #'% &/52"#+ ,& 97. %&.89 9 <2/&$",%&/&.
. ('/+'>>",, "'#'('((&#+& #", *!& #.& &/&+%"'# '(% +%
3&+%"'#,< A8'(% +% ..&.! %&/'#62 %'!"+&% %"'#C'% * "2 ",%/"+%/"
%, / "*9 9 0& /#&.+'
#,&!('/% ,"%&/ %&.%
. *&&# & /!"&/ $/ #%&. % & +'#+&,,"'# '( * "! *1 !& /#&. .$&2 &+" ! '
/%2/"
%, / "*2?".&'/.&/. %&. 89 D9 <3##&= /&6 #. : ,/&$ ! /!1 & /"#$*&('/&% /%90& /#&.+'
#,&! ,( &/ "%&/ %&.% %'#79
9 2% & &%"%"'#&/+'
!.#'% & /*&('/&% &'
/% *&!': #. # !"+ %"'#,&& "#$&=&> %"'#(/'> &/,'# ! & / #+&: , !,'("!&.'#% &, ".. %&2 ,% .*&&# //&,%&.'#
9 2 "# #'% &/ *& /"#$ '97 . %&.
9 2/&$",%&/&. %'!"+&% %"'# # > #$ / 2 ) ,% #2 #. : , /&!& ,&. "# % & , ". '#!1 '#
9 <3##&= /& 690& /#&.+'
#,&! ,, *>"%%&.% %.
&%'% ('/&, "./& ,'#2% & &%"%"'#&/+'
!.#'%+ ,& & / #+&*&('/&% &'
/% *&!':2 '# 79 9 #. 79 9 <2 #. % & '
/% *&!':2 "#,%& . '( ",, "#$#'%"+&%'% & &%"%"'#&/2 ,#'%'#!1('/(&"%&. ",* "!A, /&%1*'#., %'% & &%"%"'#&/2* % !,'",, &.#'#* "! *!&: // #%, $ "#,% ">90& /#&. +'
#,&! ,, *>"%%&.% %",, #+&'(: // #%'( //&,% $ "#,%% : , /, 2.", /' '/%"'# %& #.+'#%/ /1%'% & /"#+" !&,$'?&/#"#$) ."+" ! .",+/&%"'#2 /%"+ ! /!1 :
&# *,&#+& '( % & &%"%"'#&/ : , /&!1 "# .?&/%&#%2 :
"+ : ,#&"% &/"#%&#%"'# ! #'/.&!"*&/ %&9 0& /#&. +'
#,&!
, ( &/ "%&/ %&. % % % & &%"%"'#&/ #&;
"?'+ !!1 #.&/% &, %' &#%&/ & / #+&*&('/&% /% , !,')'"#% & /'+&&."#$,"# ++'/. #+& :"% ! :2% & &%"%"'#&/, !! & /*&('/&% #.&?&/1 . %& '( & /"#$ #. !,' +'' &/ %& % &/&"#2 "# ++'/. #+& :"% ! : ('/ &= &."%"'
,+ !>"# %"'#'(% &%/" !9
'%"+&'(>'%"'#9
79 # % & ,%/&#$% '( .? #+& ,&/?"+& '( +' 1 '( &%"%"'#2 /9 .
"/ )"#$ "#.2 #) * & /, #. ++& %,#'%"+&'#*& !('( & % %& '( #) *9 & ' ',&, % & &%"%"'# "# #. *1 /$ "#$ % !!&$ %"'#, $ "#,% % & &%"%"'#&/ /& ,&/"'
, "# # % /&2 % & &%"%"'#&/ >", ,&. % & +'#+&,,"'# '( * "! & /!"&/ &=%&#.&. %' "> *1 #'% & /"#$ *&('/&% /%E#' !
,"*!&&= ! # %"'# ,*&&#*/'
%('/% ,%' :
1% & &%"%"'#&/.".#'% & /*&('/&% /%'#% & ('/&, ".. %&9 9
?& & /. !& /#&. +'
#,&! ('/ % & /"? ! /%"&, #. ?& &/ ,&.% & ? "! *!&/&+'/.9 <9 % % ", ) #+% /&2 "% :'
!. *& ',"%& %' /&(&/ &/&"# %' ) .$>&#% '( % & '#5*!& /&>& '
/% %"%!&. , ."
#%" / ,">
!
."
#%" / ,">
!
."
#%" / ,">
!
."
#%" / ,">
!
#.'% &/,?,9 *!"+/',&+ %'/2 #.'% &/,?,9 *!"+/',&+ %'/2 #.'% &/,?,9 *!"+/',&+ %'/2 #.'% &/,?,9 *!"+/',&+ %'/2"$ '
/%'(#.
/ / .&, D8 "$ '
/%'(#.
/ / .&, D8 "$ '
/%'(#.
/ / .&, D8 "$ '
/%'(#.
/ / .&, D8 7D2 7D2 7D2 7D2/&!&? #%:
&/&'(/& ., , #.&/- &,"$#"("+ #+& #.,:&& '(/%"+!& > &% &.& /"? %"'#'( !"*&/%1 > %%&/ '( $/ ?& +'#+&/# #. &/>",,"*!& '#!1 : &# % & ! :
'/","#$ "% ", /& ,'# *!&2 &?&# #.&. #. $& /&. %' % & $' !, '( +'>> #"%1 $''. #. % %& #&+&,,"%1 , &!% '
% "#/%"+!& D9 #.&&.2 % +'#,".&/ %"'#, ?&,&%'
% ,+/"%&/" /&$&/> #&%'% &+'#,%"% %"'# ! /' ',"%"'# ?&.&.
+&.9& ,'# *!&#&,, ',% ! %&,"#%&!!"$&#%+ /& #. /&."+ %&, % % .& /"? %"'# '( (/&&.'> *1 /&( , ! '( * "! ", #'% ('/
#"%"?& / ',&* %('/% &*"('+ !"#%&/&,%,'() ,%"+&%'% &"#."?".
! "#?'!?&. #.,'+"&%1 ((&+%&.9
G& > ,% :&"$ & +'#%/ /1 ( +%'/, %' #,:&/ % & %&,% '( /& ,'# *!&#&,,2, *)&+%%'% &#&&.('/,&+ /"#$% & /&,&#+&2'(% &* "! !"+ #%9 %> &,,&#,&%' ,, >&% % > #'#* "! , *&%%&/+ #+& %' /& /&'/ /&,&#% ",+ ,&% #'#&/&> #.&."#+ ,%'.19#."( *!"+ ) ,%"+&",%'*& /'>'%&.2>&+ #"+ !.&%&#%"'#, !.*&+!',&%''
/,2% ( #+%"'#'(* "!",!">"%&.2H+'>> #"%1/''%,H'(% &2 !"+ #% /&,%/&,,&. #.2 (%&/ % & I&/ '
#. %"'#H, # %% # "! /')&+%2 >'#&% /1 /&%1, " ",!',"#$$/'
#.9 &+'#,".&/ *!& *!"+&= &#,&"# && "#$"# ,%'.1:
&/&#'. #$&/'(.", & / #+&'/.",% /* #+&+ # /",&2",#'% #&$!"$"*!&+'#,".&/ %"'#9;
!!1"> '/% #%",% &.& !'/ *!&+'#."%"'#2 ?&/$"#$'#9% &"#
> #2'('
/, *) "!,2% #/&: /."#$+/ &!%1 #. &= &#,"?& + ,%'.1 '( ?'". *!& "#+ /+&/ %"'# > &, /&( , ! '( * "!
#/& ,'# *!& #. '!"+1( ?'
/"#$/&!& ,&) ,%!1,&#,"*!&9
9 (&:'% &/:&"$ %1( +%'/,.&,&/?&/&(&/&#+&9!!.& /"? %"'#'( !"*&/%1",? !". %&.*1,'+" !.&(&#+& #."#."?". !+'//&+%"'# !'#$ # #%"+/">"# ! ."/&+%"'#9 *!"+ ) ,%"+& ", +&#%/ ! %' % & :
'!& ,+ &>& '( * "!! :9!&&"#$) ,%"+&> ,%*&('/*"..&#* #"%"?& /, #&,,, !. *& >"#">",&.9 &,%'/ %"?& .&?"+&, %' /&.&&> % & > #2 &? % /'
+'>> #"%1 ,&/?"+&2 >&."% %"?& ./"!!2 ,% .1 +! ,,&, '/ '% &/ /&,'
/+&, !.*&"##'? %&.2 #. ! 1"#$('
!:"% *!"+ & +&*1% > &/"#$:"%
7 &?".&#+&2"#%">". %"#$:"%#&,,&,'/+'>>"%%"#$'((&#+&: "!&'#) ."+" !!1 , #+%"'#&. H(/&& &#%&/ /",&2H , !. *& /'?".&. $ "#,%9 ' ,&& &/ '( ) ,%"+& , !! ! 1 +'#(".&#+& %/"+ , '# % & +'
/% '/ +'>> #"%19
,2 +'#."%"'#,> 1*&
#$ /'
#.* "!'/.&/,2#'%%'+/" !&* %%' /'%&+%9 ",% '!",%"+) /",."+%"'# #.
> #",%"+'/"&#% %"'#"#?'
&.*1% ) ."+" !.",+/&%"'#+'//&! %&.%'% &? !
&,'('
/+'#,%"% %"'#9J <9 &/2 % & '#5*!& /&>& '
/% "# ) .$>&#% %"%!&. , /+ / # "#$ ?,9 % %& 3 '( &!
"6 D8 3 6
82 /+ / # "#$ ?,9 % %& 3 '( &!
"6 D8 3 6
82 /+ / # "#$ ?,9 % %& 3 '( &!
"6 D8 3 6
82 /+ / # "#$ ?,9 % %& 3 '( &!
"6 D8 3 6
82 &!. ,
#.&/- FG &/& % & $/ #%"#$ '( * "! !"&, :"% "# % & .",+/&%"'# '( % & +'
/%2 +'
/%2 +'
/%2 +'
/%2 % $/ #%"#$ '/ .&#" ! ", /&$ ! %&.2 %' ! /$& &=%&#%2 *1 % & ( +%, #. +"/+ >,% #+&,'(& + /%"+ ! /+ ,&9"#+&% &'*)&+%'(% &.&%&#%"'#'/ "> /",'#>&#%'(% & ++ ,&.",%',&+ /& ", & / #+& #., *>",,"'#%' & ) /",."+%"'# #. % & ) .$>&#% '( % & +'
/%2 +'
/%2 +'
/%2 +'
/%2 % & /"> /1 "#;
"/1 ", :
&% &/ /&+'$#"K #+&'/*'#.:'
!.&((&+%% %&#.9J <99 &/>'/&2% &'#5*!& /&>&'
/%"# ) .$>&#%%"!&. , #) 1 #./ ?,9 3 6 7 2 #) 1 #./ ?,9 3 6 7 2 #) 1 #./ ?,9 3 6 7 2 #) 1 #./ ?,9 3 6 7 2 &!. , #.&/- F
# * "! !"+ %"'#,2 $&#&/ !!12 "% , *&&# ! ". .':# (/'> % & /!"&,% %">&, % % % & '*)&+% '( * "! ", %' ,&+ /& % & & / #+& '( % ++ ,&. &/,'# % ",%/" !*1/& ,'# *!& >'
#%'(* "!9 &'*)&+%'(* "! ", #&"% &/ #"%"?& #'/ /&?&#% %"?&9 & /"? %"'# '( !"*&/%1 > ,% *& +'#,".&/&. #", >&#%2 #!&,, "% + # *& /&;
"/&. %' &#, /& % % # ++ ,&. &/,'#:"!!,% #. ",%/" !:
&#+ !!&. '#9 &+'
/%,':&>'/& # ?&/* ! /&, &+% %' % & /"#+" !& % #", >&#% *&$"#, (%&/ +'#?"+%"'#2 #.% %&?&/1> #",.&&>&.%'*&"##'+&#% #%"!.
!1%/"&. #..
!1('
#.$ "!%19 9 /'> % & & /!"&,% %">&,2 "% : , /&+" %&. % % .&%&#%"'# "# ,%'.1 &#."#$+'> !&%"'#'(%/" !+'
!.*& + ,&'( $/& % /., " 9 /'> %">& %' %">&2 #&+&,,"%1 .&> #., % % ,'>& #+'#?"+%&. &/,'#, !.*& &!."#+ ,%'.1 &#."#$%/" !%',&+ /&% &"/ %%&#. #+& %% %/" !* %"#, + ,&,2F#&+&,,"%1J",% &' &/ %"?&%&,%9 #% ",+'
#%/12"% :'
!.*&;
"%&+'#%/ /1%'% &+'#+& %'( &/,'# !!"*&/%1&#, /"#&."#% '#,%"% %"'#% % #1 &/,'#, !.*& #", &."#/&, &+%'( #1> %%&/2
'#:
"+ 2 ,#'%*&&#+'#?"+%&.'/% %"# #1+"/+ >,% #+&,2 !.*&.& /"?&.'( ",!"*&/%1 '#'#!1% &*&!"&(% &:"!!% > &/ :"% & :"%#&,,&, "(!&(% % !"*&/%12 , ?& "# % & >',% &=%/ '/."# /1 +"/+ >,% #+&,9JJJJ 9 C&& "#$"#?"&:% &&#%"/&%1'(% &( +%, #.+"/+ >,% #+&,'( &+ ,&L&, &+" !!1% &( +% >'( /">&'*)&+%'(+ #+&!! %"'#'(* "! #. ('/(&"% /& '( * "! *'#., *&"#$ ,&+ /"#$ % & /&,&#+& '( % & ++ ,&.2 % &%"%"'#&/ ++ ,&. ?"#$ +'>& ('/: /. ">,&!( %' ( +& %/" !2 :"!!"#$#&,, ':#*1% & &%"%"'#&/ ++ ,&.%' & /*&('/&% #.
&?&/1. %&"# ++'/. #+&:"% ! :2% ?"#$, *>"%%&.% !!+'' &/ %&('/ #&= &."%"'
,+ !>"# %"'#'(% &%/" !E% &/&*&"#$#' % #$"*!&> %&/" !*/'
%('/: /.%'"#."+ %&!"
&!"
''.'(% & &%"%"'#&/%' "#%&/(&/& :"% & /',&+ %"'# &?".&#+&L % ", '
/% ", '( % & +'#,".&/&. ' "#"'#% & &%"%"'#"# #..&,&/?&,%'*& !!':&.9 89
#?"&:'(% & /&?&#"&#%/ %"'+"# %"'#2"%",'/. "#&.%
,- 3"6 & /&,&#% &%"%"'#", !!':& !!':& !!':& !!':&.L 3""6 & "> $#&. '/.&/ . %&. 79 9 3##&= /& 6 #. '/.&/. %&.9 9 <3##&= /&<6 ,,&.*1% &!& /#&.&,,"'#,'
/% , :&!! , !! +'#,&;
&#%" ! /'+&&."#$, /","#$ % &/&(/'> /& ,&% ,".&2 *)&+% %' % & &%"%"'#&/ & /"#$ *&('/& % & %/" !A+'#+&/#&. '
/% '# '/ *&('/& 9 9 < 9 9 < 9 9 < 9 9 <2E, !!( /#", # #.&/% "#$% & &%"%"'#&/, !! +'#%"# &%' & /*&('/&% &%/" !A+'#+&/#&.'
#.&?&/1. %& '( & /"#$9 %",+! /"("&.% &%/" !A+'#+&/#&.'
/%, !!*& %!"*&/%1%' "> ',&, '% &/+'#."%"'#3,6 '#% & &%"%"'#&/2 ,.&&>&. /' /" %& *1"%"#% &( +%, #.+"/+ >,% #+&,'(% &+ ,&L 3"""6 & &%"%"'#&/, !!.& ',"%+',%,'( 2 A:"% % & #) * #. /1 # "$ '
/% /!&/ ,,,'+" %"'#2 #."$ / 3&$.9
'977 DD62* # .&% "!,:
&/&'(/& .,%
,- # ++'
#% '9< 7<2 % %& # '( #." 2
'.&
<2 "$ '
/%/ #+ 2 #."$ /
%",+! /"("&.% % 1>&#%'(% & ('/&, ".+',%, #. /'.
+%"'# '(/&+&" %A /''(% &/&'(*&('/&% &%/" !A+'#+&/#&.'
/%, !!*&+'#."%"'# /&+&.&#%9 # *,&#+&'(.& ',"%'(, +',%,2% & /&,&#% &%"%"'#:'
!.*& .&&>&.%'*&.",>",,&.:"% % #1( &//&(&/&#+&%'% &&#+ 9
< 3"?6 &#."#$ !"+ %"'#3,62"( #12,% #.,.", ',&.'(9 306 306 306 306 /"!7 /"!7 /"!7 /"!72 < 2 < 2 < 2 < > ?"/ &% &/, & "#$A/& ,'#&.- &,A ' &% &//& '/% *!&- &,A '