High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1853/2014dismissed

M/S Spacemakers & ANR v. M/S Mansi Trading Co

2017-12-13Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan6 pages

!"#$#%&'&()*

'+,!%#-!.#/'!($!("0#/ #1&'&(&'"'

2#/'3'

'!('&/!$&(4 #',($#("

) 56 +7 6 +

/#'#(")8 /-&"0!(9&:$1%!"#://#1&'&(&'"' /+ !;<!:$1%!"#://#',($#(" / 7!..!$:!/=!(! >0#"0#/"0# #,/"#/'<%!<(#?',!,#/-!=;#!<<?#$" '##"0#93$4-#("@ ;#/##//#$""0# #,/"#//(" >0#"0#/"0#93$4-#("'03<$;#/#,/"#$&("0#$&4#'"@ 88 88 6 + 0&' /#1&'&( &' $&/#%"#$ !4!&('" 93$4-#(" $!"#$ A :

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

!.#'0 73-!/: &<#$ ! %-,<!&(" 3($#/ +#%"&( "0##4"&!;<# ('"/3-#("'%"::/#!$?&"0+#%"&( :'"!"&(4"0!"!%%3'#$ &',/,/&#"/!%%3'#$%-,!(=!($&'/#',('&;<#//3((&(4 $!=8"8$!=!!&/'"0#%-,!(=%%3'#$+3(&<73-!/,<!%#$!(/$#/ $!"#$*B" '!('&/!$&(4-,!(="0/340!C-,<!&("&/- (/#%#&1&(4"0#/$#/"0/340!C:,3/%0!'#$/#D3&'&"#-!"#/&!</- '

!'03,!"&(!"0("#/(!"&(!<!4!&('"&(1&%#B:$!"#$B0# -!"#/&!<?!'"0#('3,,<&#$"!%%3'#$%-,!(=:1&$#&<< :$!"#$ B0#%!<%3<!"&(;&<<?!'!<''#(""0/340!C"!%%3'#$ &/-( B $&'%0!/4#'!&$#C&'"&(4<&!;&<&"=:!%%3'#$ &''3#$ %0#D3#;#!/&(4:$!"#$B:/ '::B* 8:$/!?(( !(.6&-&"#$: !(%0'0##< !/./!(%0:#? #<0&:&(!13/ !(4!" !- '&(%#$#%#!'#$ ?&"0"0#!''3/!(%#"0!""0#%0#D3#?&<<;# 0(3/#$%%3'#$+3(&<73-!/!<''#("!!C-#''!4#"%-,<!&(!(": '"!"&(4!;3"'#($&(4%0#D3#"%-,<!&(!("%-,!(= !(4!" !-

'&(%# $#%#!'#$ 0!$ ,/#'#("#$ "0#'!&$%0#D3#" /&#("!<!(. --#/%#: !4!$0/&: ?0&%0 ?!' $&'0(3/#$ ?&"0 "0# /#-!/.' 5 3($'

('3&%&#("5 0#/#!"#/:!(4!" !- '&(%# $#%#!'#$ &''3#$!<#4!< ("&%#$!"#$B ("0#-#!(?0&<#:!(4!" !-$&#$!($,/#'#("

%-,<!&("?!'&<#$"0/3400&'<#4!<0#&/ !.#'073-!/ 0!1# 0#!/$"0#<#!/(#$%3('#<//#1&'&(&'"':"0#<#!/(#$ %3('#<//#',($#(":"0#<#!/(#$+"!"#%3('#<!($0!1#!<'%!/#3<<= 4(#"0/340"0#&<#!'?#<<!'"0#<?#/3/"&<# 0# <#!/(#$ %3('#< / !%%3'#$8/#1&'&(&'" 0!' 1#0#-#("<= !/43#$"0!"&("0&'%!'#:"0##C&'"&(4<&!;&<&"=&'(",/1#$ 0#<#!/(#$ %3('#<0!'$/!?("0#!""#("&("0&'3/""?!/$''"!($"!.#(;=!%%3'#$

88 &( '"!"#-#("3($#/+#%"&( / ?0#/#&(0#0!' '"!"#$"0!" (#

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

0 ("#/(!"&(!<!($"0#/#!"#/(/#%#&,"'!-#:%-,<!&(!("$&',!"

'!&$4$'"!%%3'#$%-,!(= C&'"0#/$#/'#(""0/340!C C&' "0#<#""#/'"!"&(4!;3",!=-#("-!$#&(/#',('#"&(1&%# &''3#$;=%-,<!&(!(":/#4!/$&(4'3,,<=4$' 3/"0#/:#1#(&"0#'# $%3-#("'!/#(""!.#(&("%('&$#/!"&(:"0#!%"/#-!&(' "0!";"0

#'073-!/!($ !?!(73-!/ 0!1#'"!"#$"0!"/$#//!<3-&(&3- '#%"&('?!',<!%#$;=!%%3'#$8/#1&'&(&'"!($"0!"!<3-&(&3-'#%"&(' ?#/#'3,,<&#$!($(/#%#&,""0#4$':%0#D3#?!'&''3#$%%3'#$$&$ (",/$3%#/#%/$0&'%-,!(="'0?"0!"&(!%"('3%0!C?!''#(": !'%<!&-#$;=%-,<!&(!("&(0&'#1&$#(%#!($"0!"(4$'?#/#/#%#&1#$ ;="0#-!($"0!""0#<#""#//#4!/$&(4'#($&(4"0#,!=-#(""0/340%0#D3# ?!'(#1#/?/&""#(;=!%%3'#$/#1&'&(&'"0#;#'"#1&$#(%#?!'!1!&<!;<# ?&"0!%%3'#$8/#1&'&(&'":;3"&"?!'?&"00#<$/-"0#3/"0#/#/#: #1&$#(%# !.#'073-!/!($ !?!(73-!/?!'/&40"<=;#<&#1#$;="0# 3/"';#<?:0<$&(4"0!""0#'"/=,3"8/"0 ;=%-,<!&(!("/#4!/$&(4 '3,,<=-!"#/&!<!($,!=-#("&(<&#3-!"#/&!<:&'%//#%"0#<?#/ !,,#<<!"#3/"0!'

;'#/1#$"0!"!%%3'#$8/#1&'&(&'"$&$("!,,#!/&("0# ?&"(#'';C"$#(="0!"0#0!$(",<!%#!(=/$#//'3,,<=!<3-&(&3- '#%"&(' !($ "0!" 0# (#1#/ /#%#&1#$ "0# 4$' 0#/#/#: 0&' ;!<$ '344#'"&(""0#?&"(#''#'&("0&'/#4!/$%!((";#;#<&#1#$&''"/= "0!"'-#/!3$?!'%--&""#$;=(#"0#$&/#%"/'0&'%-,!(=:!<' %!((";#;#<&#1#$'&(%#&"&',/1#$"0!"%0#D3#?!'&''3#$/$&'%0!/4# <#4!<<&!;&<&"= !(=/!3$?!'%--&""#$&("0#=#!/;='!

!/-$//!!($'!&$;<!(.%0#D3#'?#/#-&'3'#$:"0#/#&'(/#!'(?0= !%%3'#$$&$("'","0#,!=-#("'!&$;<!(.%0#D3#'!($?0=0#$&$(" -!.#!(=%-,<!&("""0# ,<&%#/""0#;!(.:4&1&(4"0#(3-;#/' %0#D3#'<=&(4?&"0'!&$ !/-$//!0#/#/#:-#/#'344#'"&(""0#

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

B +3,/#-#3/"!'#': '($3'&/?!=' 1"6"$!($ "0#/'

2#/'3' '!4(3-1&!"&( 1"6"$!($!("0#/: &1&< A:+&(4<##(%0!3"0/&"=&403/"-;!= 3/!(4!;!$#(%0 &( 2&'0(3,!("+ 0!;3/!70!&/#2#/'3'7!&<!'0+ !<;0&/!$!(:

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

8A8

':: 8$#,'&"#$;=!%%3'#$;#/#"0#<#!/(#$ #4&'"/!/:#(#/!<:

;#/#<#!'#$"0&-&--#$&!"#<=

6 + * '9.' >0#"0#/',#!.&(4 /#!'(#$ ) #' >0#"0#/ #,/"!;<# )