← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12227/2024allowed

Daya Nand v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-05-23Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl12 pages

 

              





!

"#$%$ &'

 ())  *

&"

)))) $ $ &+ ,+%-% .

!

 +* &

&"

/+%

)))))%0 &"& % 1 '

 23 1) .

 , 4.

3 

 

  

 

     



, 4.

36 ) 3

 ! ""#$""% & ' 

 ( 

(  )

*+ *  ",

"-"  ./    01    (           ", -2 "-""

./  21  -% -0 "-"3./  01  "

4    !+       (( ! 5 '+ &++ ", -2 "-""./  21  ( (!&  

 6

   

  ! "!   5 '+ &++(    *    + (+! !  ' !+ (  5 '+  &++! 

   *    +   *      (    +    +!   +( +!    !*

 +  

4   5          !+       5  '+ &++( +   (    (     (  !    &    

  # $ % &' /  ! !(  ++ 

7&           !8

,

7& 

#$ % &     

 

(  ! !  %    "      )     *   !     



    











   

       

!      



 

"# #

   # 

!  #  $!



 



  #"

   ! 

!  ! & 

 ""  

#   "

 !

  # !   



#

##   '   ! "# 

! ( &#%



  +,* -  .!/!0-!!!+ -(* 01%   $ &$.2&"3)  #   ****** + %  ,! #   ) 

 

! 44 

  2  2 5    '  .    ( .   '        

(

  5%

  225!

# -





"

 

     ! 4    ( . % %2

  

 ( 25  (  2 %%   22! !

    2%   .

2 

5% 2   56 

  2 7



  2 . ( .%!

!

      6   ( 82.

   5  6    !

!

   .  .

225   (    %

2 

(%  ( 8%   .% %2    2 

   5 

  2'  7



  2    . 

( . !

!

 

2     %   

  2  .   % !

  !

!





 

   

!

 

  #   

" #



 $!

"!   





 !   2.7



  2% 5

 

 

 

2.(!

-22    .   (( % %     (   5          2.

 

   .  

 .25  !  :    (%          2 #



 2.55(!

! 4   7 (  

 



25  %  5!

$ .

!







"



!  #

 /     $! 

        # $

  !   

 

     2!

 %%  (   ' 2 

  !-%   ;

 (% #  7

 .

2 ( 8% !

    

#

#

  " 





 # 



   " $!

"$

! $ 





#

 $  # #



"0% 1  % 

   1    .

  

 0234  55 (

6 ' 3334 !  7 (  (  (     

 ( 8'  7 (.

225  (%  (     %    9 %  !%022742 8(''++) +9:  :2-";  <*

) :558= - 75+) 



-

9

       (   '!    

) >

     !     #  !  



  >

   

 

!  " 

    

!     

  

   

)  

     ) 

   !!    

  

" 

>1 ?

> @** *** 7 '   "    #     

!   ( &#1 A 

  <= >  +22$&/!!  ?

5  )

 22304?6'3) ) #  ******   -

!     ! 

 /

    # ! 

!

)   # #

 

!

  

  : (  

 2   %% 2?/.2 (( 

  7

 

  2 

5    5     %%  !:     ((        (% .    (%2       % %2   2

  (  (%  .5 7

 

  2  5    .     

   

 5  %.    ( .     7      %% '7



 

5( % % 8  

   5! @! 4  :2  /!  .!  A!+!  > '   2 

 '-!4!

!B )

 $C!=!&'B A C

(!



 (!

-

::9



-

9





#

 #"



#" !  $!

  3! :  7 (             ((   57



  2

   (%     . 2 

(       %(     2   = 9 (!A!+ 8 .!

D 4 '-!4!

!BB !!B"@! 9 %     # *  #"   1 A 

 =?D 5392 22+ $?

5

+22!/!: .!  ?

5 1!&'

 "!!BB3!

3  # !  )



   E #" (! 6% !



 (! 6% ! 

    #"      

  !!

  !     (!6% ! 



    #" ! 

       !

    

   !)   

  !



  

   D : ****** 2 

 

( ! !     33    2    <)% 2  *   ) %  !   4 ( (( ) !  "

  $!

  #"  



  

% 204  % :5   -  :55+) 

#   +'

  :5::5:0-*

?4

  #

        " 

 "

    

 ) ?<

    " 

7 

#"    3"

 

 

     

!" 9 - 

 # 







 !  

) 

   

      "#

    

 )  ?<



     "           

  #"     

 3"

   

 (

 )    !

 ") 

    

 



 

 







   ! -%  2  B  :4-  2



  ' .%   2 

%% 2       2  4 (   ((        4 ( ((  ' 

 $"&' 4 ( ((  .. 2% 2  %7 %

2 

5 (%  (%2  

 52(

(% 5 % 2 %. - !% 2 '- )

   #

 <B!-%% 2!F04-"  ) 



   # 04

 04  # 04  3)

!!

#"  

?

# 

 <

% ?

#

 < ) "

#)"  

""

 *     





        

  $    

  ?

#  

   <

 %   ?

# 

 <  "#) #

" ?

   "   *  "

   

""

    

 #"   

!    0:4=   

! 

 #"

?

#

 <

% ?

#

 < )  "#)       

"

 )

 #"     

"#  

""

 

  04-  !  # 04   ""

    



 #



" )   









  ?





 



  )  "#)"   *      ""       #"  

!    074   

?

#

 <

% ?

#

 < ) "#)!    

  

    

")  

 

 

% 

  )  "#)! #

 #!   

" 0+4" 

!) 

  

 

#  

?

#

 <

% ?

#

 < ) "#) 

  094-  # 04

# 0:4#    

""   

 *   

*!

 

""

  !  "#)

 #



! 034  



 

% 

  ) "#)##! 04  )  



 

% 

  ) "#)

04

#

$"   "#  

  

  - ) !

F 04#"

!  

 )  

 ) 

 

G 04#" ! 

?

#

 <

% ?

#

 < ) "#G 04  #"  #!  

  

  

  !

  

 G 04#"$! "!    

 )! 

G 04  #"  !   

    

!      !



 

  G 04#"

!  

  

8  0#4  # 04  7G 0#4

#

   

" 



  G 04 "   

 - G04

    024 



 

% 



 )    "#)  ! 

     )  !  "  !    )           #

" 054 



 

% 



 ) "#)  



 



"#  # % :5 '-

 )  

 

             !  "   

 )   

?

#

 < )

" # )





     # 04 % 3

"

 



  ) ) 

  

  

"  

 

 % :5 '- 

   < !   2!E$&       2  4 (  (( 4 ( (('  ( 5 '

(   5 (%2  %% 2 %  2

2 4 ( 1

 

?

#

 < ) "#))

" # )  

        

 

  

   

 

 

    # 04  3

"

 





$

!"!

)      

 !  

  

 

" 

    #



#

"

  ! 

 ) 9  

      " 

    "           



 

) 

 )



   "



*

"



 ?

  

?

#

 <

?

#  

   < )        "  #)    #  !  

#

 #! #

"  "  

9 ?

  

  #

   

!      

#"! "#  

?

#

 <

?

#

 < ) "# 0:4 =     

  

     

  % 

  ) "#)  !"

 

    

?

#

 <

?

#

 < ) "#))

" #    ")     











 

  # 04  3

"

 





$

!"!

)  

!





"

    #



#

" 

! 

 )  

  " !  

?

# 

 <

?

#

 < )  "#)  

 #  B!-    

.% %. 2      %% 2   2 5 .%'

'

  22 % '( 7 

 225 

 !4 '4 ( ((  % ' %      :4- 

(' %%%   27   8!4%

'

%(

2

.  %%  %A!$ & $ & 

 41 2 . %25' %% 2 . % 5%A!    %25    225 

 ( 

 ' 6'(% . 

 % 

   )?

#) 

 !

 

" #"    % 204

- :55+   !





" )



)



   !  

)  #"#

  

 





!    

" !  

 

"#" ! 

 

 

# * 

" ! 



#

##   

#      !

   "

  $!#

    3 

  5 H ! #  

 )

  = ?  

"

  !



 595:5:0-*

?24  

 



   )?

#

!-   7+: :5:  !!

  !

 !  

    %   

     )  ?

#)      $!

 !   #"

#

  

 



! 

   

#



   )?

#) :75:5:   )

 ) 



! "    

#  %   

     )  ?

#)        "

   :



  ! # )

 !  -  -

"I0 

 !



"  % 204J  -  -

"I0 

 !  

"  % 204J - )# ! "

  $!

  

!  #" ( &#%



 

(!

    - :55+ ) )

 !  

!   -  -

" -  -

- :55+  " "  

!  "

 !

 4   

 

! #"     /    - :55+ 4    "    

 

!  4- !

! 

 "

# 



 )   #  4)    



  

 

! 

 

!  





#  

"# "

   -  :55+



 "

)  ) 

!    !  # #"

#

  

     / )

!

   / 

 4-"

#   

"   

   #

   %  ?

#K( "  -

-

) !  



!          

!  

   

(  ! !     "      )     *   !     



   

( ! ! 

33   )% 2* ) % !

 2  4 (   ((    )    

  

    -  

 "!       ", -2 "-""./  21  !5 '+ &++ 

 !( ( 

  9/ 9*6+!+ :   7)  (+  * !!*!   

!5 '+ &++( !        '  (    +!      &++      +  *      

  +  

(+ !*

( !

( +  ) !*  + ! 7  *+ !& 

#$ % &! #

*(  (   + *       ", -2 "-""  ./    21    ( 

 !)    ; "      /  ! !(  ++    +( !  8*  ( (!& 

 #$ % &  %

'+   &  +    5 '+ &++ (  +   ( (

, 4.

3

* (6 

  $ < $ 8*= > < != >