Union Of India Ad ORS. v. Cat And ORS.


 

      

 
 

    

     

     

       

 

   
  

     

     

       

 

   


     

     

       

 

  



   


!  "  !"#$"#%$"#&'()#*#+$,"-'.(/#%#0-%$#(1+$"#(1)#,$2 #,



  

3

 

  



 

 

   

  #

"#  4%1$  0#$1$1-+#%,  1+  5..  $"#  56-%#*#+$1-+#(  $"%##  4%1$ 0#$1$1-+,"57#,-')"$$-%#71#4$"#(1%#8$1-+,1,,'#(/9$"#.#5%+#(%1/'+5.


1+$"#%#,0#8$17# %1)1+5.00.185$1-+,$-)%5+$5../#+#61$,5,0%59#(6-%/9 $"#0%175$#%#,0-+(#+$,1+$#%*,-6$"#&'()#*#+$1+  

    

 



   

 -  :

;;(#81(#(-+ ;

 



"#0%175$#%#,0-+(#+$,1+1$15..9&-1+#($"##5, -+,$%'8$1-+ -5%(<6-%,"-%$= =>5,#8$1-+ 6618#%,<#8"5+185.>1+$"#9#5%;
;:1+$"#059,85.#-6

?
"#94#%#(#8.5%#(,'%0.',1+$#%*, -6$"#0%-71,1-+,-6$"#'+&5/ #-%)5+1@5$1-+8$5+(5,5%#,'.$-64"18"

$"#1%+5*#,4#%#%#6#%%#($-$"# #+$%5.'%0.',$566 #..1+#8#*/#% ;AB "#94#%#%#(#0.-9#(1+$"##05%$*#+$-6$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%,1+$"# *-+$"-659;A

"#0%175$#%#,0-+(#+$,-0$#(6-%8#+$%5.059,85.#, 0'%,'5+$  $-  $"#  -7#%+*#+$  -6  +(15  1%8'.5%  ++#C'%#  
  (5$#(   ;A

 "#1%059,85.#-6 
B
?
45,%#71,#($- 
B
:?
 ;AD -6%#,"-0$1-+45,)17#+$-$"#0%175$#%#,0-+(#+$,5+( $"#98-+$1+'#(1+8#+$%5.059,85.#5,%#71,#(-+ ;AD5+( ;;D

"#0#%,-+,,1*1.5%.9,1$'5$#(61.#(

 -  :
-6;;$1$.#(5,
 
                     /#6-%# $"#

"5+(1)5%"#+8"-6$"# #+$%5.(*1+1,$%5$17#%1/'+5.8.51*1+)%#71,#( 8#+$%5.059,85.#,-6 
DB
;4  ;AD41$"5..8-+,#E'#+$15.

/#+#61$, "#,51(500.185$1-+45,5..-4#(71(#-%(#%++#C'%#
B(5$#( ;

    !- ;;D;-661.#(/9$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%,"#%#1+5, 5)51+,$$"#,51(-%(#%45,'.$1*5$#.9(1,*1,,#(-+: 

 +  0%#6#%%#($"#%#5)51+,$45,8-+7#%$#(5, 171.00#5.5+($"#%#56$#%1$45, 5.,- (1,*1,,#( /9$"# -+=/.#'0%#*# -'%$ -+   ;

 , $"#

:
8-+$%-7#%,945,,#$5$%#,$/9$"#-+=/.#'0%#*# -'%$$"# -7#%+*#+$ -6+(15#05%$*#+$-6#%,-++#.5+(%51+1+)1,,'#()#+#%5. 1%8'.5% (5$#(  <++#C'%#
B>(1%#8$1+)$-#C$#+($"#/#+#61$-6$"# &'()#*#+$1+"5%5$"',"5+=,85,#<,'0%5>#7#+$-+-+
500.185+$,

#5%($"#,'/*1,,1-+,*5(#/9.#5%+#(8-'+,#.500#5%1+)6-% $"#  4%1$  0#$1$1-+#%,  5+(  .#5%+#(  8-'+,#.  500#5%1+)  6-%  $"#  0%175$# %#,0-+(#+$,1+5..$"#,#$"%##4%1$0#$1$1-+,

"#0%175$#%#,0-+(#+$,"5(/##+-%1)1+5..9,#%71+)5,#8$1-+

6618#%,  <#8"5+185.>  '+(#%  $"#     6$#%  $"#9  "5(  /##+  (#8.5%#( ,'%0.',$"#94#%#%#(#0.-9#(41$"$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%,1+$"#*-+$"-659 ;A

$1,5.,-+-$1+(1,0'$#$"5$$"#9"57#-0$#(6-%8#+$%5.059,85.#,

-6%#,"-0$1-+45,,-')"$6%-*$"#0%175$#%#,0-+(#+$,$"#%#56$#% +-$"#% 4-%(,$"#98-+$1+'#($-%#8#17#$"#8#+$%5.059,85.#5,%#71,#(-+ ;AD 5+( ;;D

$1,5+5(*1$$#(0-,1$1-+$"5$,1*1.5%.9,1$'5$#(#*0.-9##,61.#(

 $1$.#(5,"5%5$"',"5+5+(-$"#%,7,  +1-+-6+(155+($"#%#71,#( 059,85.#-6
DB
;4  ;AD41$"5..8-+,#E'#+$15./#+#61$,45, )17#+ "#*5$$#%4#+$'0$-$"#-+=/.#'0%#*# -'%$/'$'.$1*5$#.9$"# (#81,1-+$5F#+/9$"#%1/'+5.45,*51+$51+#(5,5%#,'.$-64"18"$"# #05%$*#+$-6#%,-++#.5+(%51+1+) -7#%+*#+$-6+(151,,'#(81%8'.5% (5$#(  #C$#+(1+)$"#/#+#61$-6$"#5/-7#&'()#*#+$#7#+$-+-+
500.185+$,



'%,'5+$$-$"#.#)5.0-,1$1-+,#$$.#(1+

 

<,'0%5>$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%,85++-$"57#5+9%#5,-+$-(#+9$"#/#+#61$,

B
,-')"$6-%/9$"#0%175$#%#,0-+(#+$,1+$#%*,-6$"#56-%#,51(&'()#*#+$

C
 #*0.-9##,"5(/##+(#0.-9#(1+75%1-',#05%$*#+$, 1+8.'(1+)$"##05%$*#+$-6$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%,(%541+)$"#*6%-*$"#.1,$ *51+$51+#(/9$"# #+$%5.'%0.',$566 #..

1,8%1*1+5$1-+   #C
 #*0.-9##,(#0.-9#(1+75%1-',#05%$*#+$,6-%+-65'.$-6$"#1%,1, +-$5$5..0#%*1,,1/.# ..-$"#%#05%$*#+$,4"#%##C
 #*0.-9##,"5( /##+%#(#0.-9#("5(1*0.#*#+$#($"#7#%(18$1+"5%5$"',"5+=,85,# $ 1,%#5..9,'%0%1,1+)$"5$#7#+56$#%$"#-(5.1+1,$%9-6 -7#%+*#+$-6 +(151 1+1,$%9-6#%,-++#.'/.18 %1#75+8#, #+,1-+, "5( 588#0$#(  $"#  .#)5.  0-,1$1-+  5+(  5(71,#(  $"#  #05%$*#+$,  8-+8#%+#(  $- 1*0.#*#+$$"#(#81,1-+1+"5%5$"',"5+=,85,#1+.#$$#%5+(,01%1$$"#4%1$ 0#$1$1-+#%,5%#%#.'8$5+$$-1*0.#*#+$$"#5/-7#(1%#8$1-+,1+$"#85,#-6 0%175$#%#,0-+(#+$,  ;

$45,,'/*1$$#(/9.#5%+#(8-'+,#.500#5%1+)6-%$"#4%1$ 0#$1$1-+#%,$"5$$"#1*0.#*#+$5$1-+-6$"#0%59#%,-')"$6-%/9$"#0%175$# %#,0-+(#+$,  4-'.(  057#  459  6-%  (1,8%1*1+5$1-+  5*-+),$  $"#  '+1-% +)1+##%,#*0.-9#(1+$"##05%$*#+$-6$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%,   #5%+#( 8-'+,#.  500#5%1+)  6-%  $"#  0%175$#  %#,0-+(#+$,  4-'.(  %#,1,$  $"#  5/-7# ,'/*1,,1-+-+$"#)%-'+($"5$$"#0%175$#%#,0-+(#+$,4#%#58.5,,/9 $"#*,#.7#,5,$"#9"5(/##+%#(#0.-9#(56$#%$"#9"5(/##+(#8.5%#(5, ,'%0.',1+ 



!#61+($"5$ $"#%#1,+-6-%8#1+$"#,'/*1,,1-+*5(#/9 .#5%+#(8-'+,#.500#5%1+)6-%$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%, ,%1)"$.90-1+$#(-'$/9 $"#  .#5%+#(  8-'+,#.  500#5%1+)  6-%  0%175$#  %#,0-+(#+$,  $"#  0%175$#

%#,0-+(#+$,"5(+-$/##+500-1+$#($"%-')"+-%*5.*-(#-6%#8%'1$*#+$$- -88'09$"#0-,1$1-+-6'+1-%+)1+##%,.1F#-$"#%'+1-%+)1+##%,1+$"# #05%$*#+$  -6  4%1$  0#$1$1-+#%,  +  658$  $"#9  4#%#  (#0.-9#(  $-  $"# #05%$*#+$-6$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%,56$#%$"#9"5(0'$1+9#5%,-6,#%718# 1+     5+(  (#8.5%#(  ,'%0.',  1+  $#%*,  -6  $"#  0%-71,1-+,  -6  '+&5/

#-%)5+1@5$1-+8$   +(#%,'8"81%8'*,$5+8#,$"#0%175$#%#,0-+(#+$, 8-+,$1$'$#(58.5,,/9$"#*,#.7#, "#%#6-%#1*0.#*#+$5$1-+-6$"#5/-7# (#81,1-+1+"5%5$"',"5+=,85,#4-'.(+-$(1,8%1*1+5$#5+9,1*1.5%.9 ,1$'5$#('+1-%+)1+##%1+$"##05%$*#+$-6$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%,



+71#4-6$"#5/-7#4#61+($"5$$"#%#1,+-*#%1$1+$"#,#4%1$ 0#$1$1-+,5+($"#%#6-%#$"#,5*#,$5+((1,*1,,#(

 $  %  !"   #0$#*/#%

$!  "% '.5$1  !"

D