High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10767/2012dismissed

Narpal Singh v. Presiding Officer And Nar.

2015-02-02Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan4 pages

"#$"% &'()

*+&+&,'*# *#-.- #*-&/&'( 00&1*#'/.-+#&"%#&2.'"%31.43"2,.# ,.#+.#(",'"'/"',+)*#

*-$,'/*'+-

5 #*-*'+

#*-*'+

# -),67"(&/8,1"+*0,#+)*$*+&+&,'*#

# "9*-)"#( *'&,#/8,1"+*:&+)

;

"%:"%/8,1"+*0,##*-$,'/*'+ <=<=<= <=<=<= <=<=<= <=<=<= )*&'-+"'+:#&+$*+&+&,'&-/&#*1+*/"("&'-++)*":"#/ /"+*/ !

> > $"--*/ 27 +)* '/.-+#&"% #&2.'"%31.43"2,.# ,.#+ .#(",' :)*#*27 +)* #*0*#*'1* )"- 2**' "'-:*#*/ "("&'-++)*$*+&+&,'*#3:,#64"'"'/)*)"-',+2**')*%/*'+&+%*/ +,"'7#*%&*0 *"#'*/ 1,.'-*% "$$*"#&'( 0,# +)* $*+&+&,'*# :,.%/ -.24&++)"++)*$*+&+&,'*#)"/9,&'*/#*-$,'/*'+ ?,4$"'7 ,' >@ ,' +)* $,-+ ,0

,' " 4,'+)%7 -"%"#7 ,0 A!B3 &--*#8&1*-:*#*/&-$*'-*/:&+),' @ >>C"'/)* :"- ',+ (&8*' "'7 ',+&1* ,# $"7 &' %&*. ,0 ',+&1* $*#&,/ ,# #*+#*'1)4*'+1,4$*'-"+&,'"'/)*'1*+)*"1+&,':"-&'.++*# /*#,("+&,',0 *1+&,'!3,0+)*'/.-+#&"%&-$.+*-1+> D0,#

-),#+5+)*1+5E +)"-"%-,2**'"#(.*/+)"++)* "'"(*4*'+3 ,4$"'7)"-/&-$*'-*/:&+)+)*-*#8&1*-,0+)*$*+&+&,'*#27 +"6&'(-)*%+*#.'/*#&+- +"'/&'( #/*#-"'/-.1)1,.#-*,0"1+&,'

:"-',+$*#4&--&2%*:&+),.+1,'/.1+&'("/,4*-+&1*'F.&#7"- #*("#/- +)* 1)"#(* ,0 "2-*'1* 0#,4 /.+7 ,:"#/- -.1) -.24&--&,'#*%&"'1*)"-2**'$%"1*/.$,'"9./(4*'+,0+)* $*G,.#+&' ;

"/"88 B-

'/.-+#&*-+/ D>>CEC ;

"/"88 B-

'/.-+#&*-+/ D>>CEC ;

"/"88 B-

'/.-+#&*-+/ D>>CEC ;

"/"88 B-

'/.-+#&*-+/ D>>CEC

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

+"'/&'( #/*#-,0+)*,4$"'7 +)"-"%-,2**'"#(.*/+)"+ +:,#*(&-+*#*/%*++*#-)"/2**'&--.*/+,+)*:,#64"'1"%%&'( .$,')&4+,*G$%"&'"2-*'1*0#,4/.+7"'/+,:)&1)+)*#*:"-', #*-$,'-* 0,#+)1,4&'( "'/ "- -.1) +)* #*0*#*'1* )"/ 2**' #&()+0.%%7/*1%&'*/

*"#'*/1,.'-*%0,#+)*$"#+&*-)"8*2**')*"#/"+ %*'(+)"'/$%*"/&'(-,'#*1,#/)"8*2**'$*#.-*/ !

)*"2,.#,.#+ )"- #*1,#/*/ "0&'/&'( ,00"1+ "- #*("#/-+)*:,#64"')"8&'(%*0+-*#8&1*,')&-,:'"11,#/ '

+)&-#*("#/*8&/*'1*&'+)*'"+.#*,0 G)&2&+ B"'/ G)&2&+

B )"-2**'"/8*#+*/+,&'+)*&4$.('*/":"#/"'/:)&1) :*#*+:,-*$"#"+*1,44.'&1"+&,'--*'+27#*(&-+*#*/$,-++,+)* :,#64"'1"%%&'(.$,')&4+,9.-+&07+)*$*#&,/,0"2-*'1*"'/+, #*$,#+2"160,#/.+7 )*"//#*--&'+)*-*',+&1*-:"-(&8*'"- "#$"%-,',0 #&+)8&"4 .#("#).#(",'5 )*:,#64"'

:)&%*"$$*"#&'("- )"/"/4&++*/&'+)*1#,--3*G"4&'"+&,' +)"+-.1)"//#*--:"-1,##*1+ #*$,#+ G)&2&+ B:"-"%-, "//.1*/&'*8&/*'1*"-#*("#/-#*0.-"% +&-&'+)*%&()+,0/.* "$$#*1&"+&,',0*8&/*'1*+)"++)*"2,.#,.#+)"-1,'1%./*/+)"+ +)*:,#64"')"/"2"'/,'*/-*#8&1*"'/&+:"-',+"1"-*,0 +*#4&'"+&,'

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

#*$,#+"//.1*/&'*8&/*'1*+,#*0%*1+#*0.-"%,0-*#8&1*&'#*("#/

+)*#*+, ,*8&/*'1*)"/2**'%*/,'2*)"%0,0+)*$*+&+&,'*#3 :,#64"'+,/*4,'-+#"+*"'7*G$%"'"+&,')"8&'(2**',00*#*/ :&+)#*("#/ +,"2-*'1*0#,4/.+7,#"'"++*4$+)"8&'( 2**' 4"/* +, 9,&' 2"16 ,' /.+7 '/*# -.1) 1&#1.4-+"'1*- +)* 1,'+*'+&,' #"&-*/ ,' 2*)"%0 ,0 +)* $*+&+&,'*# +)"+ &+ :,.%/ 2* &4$*#"+&8*+,1,'/.1+"#*(.%"#/,4*-+&1*'F.&#7,'+)*1)"#(* ,0 "2-*'1* 0#,4 /.+7 &- :&+),.+ 4*#&+ "'/ &- #*9*1+*/ )* $#&'1&$%*-,0'"+.#"%9.-+&1*:,.%/2*+"6*'"-1,4$%&*/:&+),' "11,.'+ ,0 +)* *4$%,7*# )"8&'( 1"%%*/ .$,' "'/ (#"'+*/ ,$$,#+.'&+7+,+)*:,#64"'+,9.-+&07"2-*'1*"-"%-,+,#*$,#+ 2"16,'/.+7 ,# +)* #*"-,'- #*1,#/*/ "2,8* ', 1"-* 0,# &'+*#0*#*'1*&'+)*&4$.('*/":"#//"+*/!

> >&-4"/*,.+ @ #&+$*+&+&,'&-/&-4&--*/ D E D E D E D E ! ! ! !

,+*

)*+)*#+,2*#*0*##*/+,*$,#+*#H*-B )*+)*#+,2*#*0*##*/+,*$,#+*#H*-B )*+)*#+,2*#*0*##*/+,*$,#+*#H*-B )*+)*#+,2*#*0*##*/+,*$,#+*#H*-B