Jai Bhagwan v. Ravinder & ORS

  
     

 !"# $#%&'&() *

+

!& ,!-.!( //#00!(" 1#2'3' !4&($#2!($",#2' #'/($#("' 



 


2#'#(") 25!($##/ !26!',,!,!27$4%!"# 2",#!//#00!(" 21&($3/"!7$4%!"#!($ 2' !$,3 5,!28!7 $4%!"# 2 2#'/($#(" 9:('32!(%# 8/!(;






,&'!//#!0,!'<##( &0#$<;",#%0!&8!("'##6&(-#(,!(%#8#("   ",# %8/#('!"&( !.!2$#$ " ",#8 <; "2 %%&$#(" 0!&8' 2&<3(!07 ,"!6=2&<3(!0> 2',2"4&$#!.!2$$!"#$ 9

(!%%3(" ",# &(?32&#'!($$&'!<&0&";'3

#2#$<;,&8&(!8"24#,&%0#!%%&$#(".,&%,"6 /0!%#(9



2&# !%"' (#%#''!2; 2 !$?3$&%!"&(   ",# %!'# !2# ",!" ! /#"&"&( 3($#2 5#%"&(     "2 1#,&%0#' %" .!' /2# #22#$ <; ",# !//#00!(" '##6&(- %8/#('!"&( ( !%%3("   ",# &(?32&#' !($ $&'!<&0&"; '3

#2#$<;,&8&(!8"24#,&%0#!%%&$#("7.,&%,"6/0!%#(9

 ",!'<##(!4#22#$",!"",#%0!&8!(":!//#00!("!0(-.&",,&'$!3-,"#2@,&(& .#2# "2!4#00&(- &( ! ?##/ <#!2&(- @ *@  <#&(- $2&4#( <; 5!"&', A38!2 ,#; .#2# %8&(- 28 !(!32 " ,"!6 B,#( ",#; %2''#$ 1&00!-# !''&!7 ! "23%6 <#!2&(- @9 @ +* <#&(- $2&4#( <; 2#'/($#("

 @!4&($#2&(!2!',!($(#-0&-#("8!((#2%!8# 28//'&"#'&$#!($ ,&" ",# ?##/7 &( .,&%, ",# %0!&8!(" !0(-.&", ,&(& !($ 5!"&', .#2# "2!4#00&(- ' ! 2#'30" ",#2# 7 ",# %%3/!("'   ",# ?##/ '3

#2#$ 830"&/0# &(?32&#' ,# &(?32#$ .#2# "!6#( " 57 ,"!6 2 "2#!"8#(" ,# %0!&8!(" 2#8!&(#$ !$8&""#$ &( ",# ,'/&"!0 28 9

 "




  $!"#$  

7 3($#2 5#%"&(' *:99    .!' 2#-&'"#2#$ !-!&('"2#'/($#("@$2&4#2!" 0&%#5"!"&(5!$!27,"!6 ,#0#!2(#$2&<3(!0(%('&$#2!"&( ",# !%"'!($#4&$#(%# (2#%2$,#0$",!"",#!%%&$#("&(C3#'"&("6/0!%#$3#"",#2!',!($ (#-0&-#(" $2&4&(-   

#($&(- "23%6 <#!2&(- 2#-&'"2!"&( @9 @ +* <; 2#'/($#("@!4&($#2,&' &($&(- ",#0#!2(#$2&<3(!0,!'!""!&(#$

&(!0&";,#0#!2(#$2&<3(!0%(%03$#$",!"",#!//#00!("'3'"!&(#$&(?32&#' &(",&'!%%&$#("0#!$&(-"+D$&'!<&0&";!'/#2&'!<&0&";#2"& &%!"#E  ,#!//#00!(".!'!-#$*;#!2'!"",#"&8# ",#!%%&$#(",#0#!2(#$ 2&<3(!0 !.!2$#$ ! ""!0 %8/#('!"&(   '97

:@ &#7 ' 7

:@ ( !%%3(" +D/#28!(#("$&'!<&0&";!($'7

:@(!%%3(" /!&(!($ '3

#2&(-#"% F#!2(#$%3('#0 2",#!//#00!("'3<8&"'",!"$3#"",#&(?32&#' ",#!//#00!(".!'0# ".&",8!03(&( 2&-,",38#23'&( 3(%"&(!0/'&"&( .&",2#'"2&%"&4#84#8#("' ",#2&-,"',30$#2!'/#2",#$&'!<&0&";%#2"& &%!"# E  ,# %0!&8!(":!//#00!(" '3

#2#$ +D /#28!(#(" $&'!<&0&"; F#!2(#$ 2&<3(!0,!'!.!2$#$!8#!-2#!83(" %8/#('!"&("&'",3'/2!;#$ ",!"%8/#('!"&(!.!2$#$"",#!//#00!("<##(,!(%#$ F#!2(#$ %3('#0 2 2#'/($#(" 9G('32!(%# 8/!(; ,.#4#2/2!;'",!"",#%8/#('!"&(!.!2$#$<;",#0#!2(#$2&<3(!04&$# &8/3-(#$ !.!2$ $#' (" %!00 2 !(; #(,!(%#8#(" !' ",# '!8# &'

9 2#!'(!<0#!($?3'"& &#$&(",# !%"'!($%&2%38'"!(%#' ",#%!'#!'.#00!' #4&$#(%#(2#%2$  ,!4# ,#!2$ 0#!2(#$ %3('#0 2 ",# /!2"&#' !($ ,!4# -(# ",23-,",#2#%2$.&",",#&2!<0#!''&'"!(%# "&'("&($&'/3"#",!"",#%0!&8!(":!//#00!(".!'!4#2(8#(" #8/0;###.!'*;#!2'0$!"",#"&8# ",#!%%&$#(",#2#&'(",&(- (2#%2$"',.0'' &(%8#&(%322#$<;",#%0!&8!("7(#&",#2.#2#!(; 8#$&%!0<&00'/0!%#$(2#%2$#E%#/"&'!<&0&";#2"& &%!"#E ,#2#&' (",&(- ( 2#%2$ " &($&%!"# ",!" ",# !//#00!(" '3

#2#$ !(; '/#%& &%

3(%"&(!0$&'!<&0&";.,&%,!

#%"#$,&'#!2(&(-%!/!%&";",!'<##(!4#22#$ ",!"",#!//#00!(":%0!&8!("<#%!8#!,#!2"/!"&#("!($,!$"3($#2-<;#@ /!'''32-#2;(!%%3(" ",#&(?32&#''3

#2#$<;,&8,#2#&'(#4&$#(%# "/24#",#'!8##E%#/"!<!0$'"!"#8#(" ",#!//#00!(",&8'#0 ,#,#!2" %($&"&( '3

#2#$ <; ",# !//#00!(" &' 2&-,"0; ,#0$ <; ",# 2&<3(!0 " <# 3(%((#%"#$ .&", ",# !%%&$#(" &( C3#'"&( " ",# '!8# "&8#7 &" %!((" <# &-(2#$ ",!" ",# !//#00!(" $&$ '3

#2 ",# &(?32&#' &( ",# !%%&$#(" ( 9

7.,&%,0#$"+D/#28!(#("$&'!<&0&"; (",# !%"3!08!"2&E ",#%!'#7",#!//#00!("&'#("&"0#$"!'38  '9

:@&('"#!$ '7

:@(!%%3(" /!&(!($'3

#2&(-,# !//#00!(" &' !0' #("&"0#$ " ! '38   '

:@ ".!2$' '/#%&!0 $&#" !($ !""#($!("%,!2-#'!($!(",#2'38 '7

:@".!2$'"2!('/2"!"&(,# !83("   ' 7

:@ !.!2$#$ <; ",# 0#!2(#$ 2&<3(!0 ( !%%3("   +D /#28!(#(" $&'!<&0&"; &' 8!&("!&(#$ ,#2# 2#7 ",# !//#00!(" &' #("&"0#$ " %8/#('!"&(7.,&%,&'$#"!&0#$!'3($#2)@
 

     

!&(!($'3

#2&(- '9

:@

5/#%&!0$&#"!($!""#($!("%,!2-#'

'

:@

 9 2!('/2"!"&(%,!2-#'

'7

:@  +D #28!(#("$&'!<&0&"; ' 7

:@ 


  !"

,# !//#00!(" &'7 ",3'7 #("&"0#$ " ""!0 %8/#('!"&(  ' 7

:@ !0(- .&", &("#2#'" !" ",# 2!"#  D /#2 !((38 ( ",# #(,!(%#$!83(" 28",#$!"# &0&(- /#"&"&("&002#!0&H!"&(##$0#''" '!;7 ",# !83(" !02#!$; !.!2$#$ <; ",# 2&<3(!0 " ",# !//#00!(" 3($#2 4!2&3' ,#!$' ',!00 '"!($ $#$3%"#$ 28 ",# !83("   %8/#('!"&( 2#.26#$!'!<4# B&",",#!<4#'!&$8$& &%!"&(&(",#!83(" %8/#('!"&(7 /2#'#("!//#!0&'$&'/'#$ 












# 


$



























% 5#/"#8<#2 7

+ ',.!2 B,#",#2'/#!6&(-:2#!'(#$)@ #': B,#",#22#/2"!<0#)@ #':